Check out what I got on eBay

[xsphat]

For $37 American:

[Waves77]

Very nice find for that price

What type of alps are in these? Are they all black?

[xsphat]

No, there are all white.

[Waves77]

No, there are all white.

How would you compare them to the black ones? Are all Northgates equiped with white alps?

Funny thing is I was actually watching this item There's also a Lexmark model M NIB being auctioned BTW...

[xsphat]

The white ones are very similar to the black one except for two differences I know of - for one thing, the white switches are clicky and the other thing is that they feel a bit cleaner because the blacks have a bumper at the bottom, a stop, that they whites don't have. When they are next to each other, I can feel that difference ...

And AFAIK, Northgates all had white Alps switches.

[Waves77]

The white ones are very similar to the black one except for two differences I know of - for one thing, the white switches are clicky and the other thing is that they feel a bit cleaner because the blacks have a bumper at the bottom, a stop, that they whites don't have. When they are next to each other, I can feel that difference ...

And AFAIK, Northgates all had white Alps switches.

Thanks for the info. I asked b/c I find the black alps that are in my Dell AT101W to feel incredibly different than the white Alps in my Apple Extended II. I might have to get one of these to compare one of these days

[xsphat]

I thought the Apple Extended II had pink sliders (VERY similar to the blacks). And I also have heard that old school black Alps switches are more linear than modern ones. Do you have any thoughts on that?

[lowpoly]

For $37 American: ...

That looks pretty clean. Congrats.

The sliders in my Extended II look white. Some say it's supposed to be beige. I think it's white. Pinks are in the Extended I, which in the pics look orange to me. I think.

I'm still puzzeled how the white Alps in the Extended II are supposed to feel. If you press a key slowly it goes through at least two minor resistances, none of which qualify as tactile, IMO. Then, on its way up the key slightly clicks. I also think the rubber that is supposed to make bottoming out more quiet is too soft. It is also not durable, on my Ext. II it has desintegrated on Enter and Delete. Obviously, I don't like these switches too much.

My old laptop keyboard however also has white Alps switches which are perfectly smooth and ... linear. I love these.

Color is not a good indicator with Alps switches, I guess.

[xsphat]

The white Alps in the MK96 I'm using right now are great - they're responsive as hell, the click happens on the way down at the same time the keystroke registers and there is resistance going down and pushing on the way up. They bottom hard and loud, Just how I like it.

And I agree, I don't think color is a reliable way to judge what you'll get with Alps, but thank whatever I never got any like you're talking about.

[lowpoly]

Didn't you say somewhere that you always bottom out? Why do you care about click/tactile then? That's two confirmations per key press.

Linear switches would be perfect for you.

[iMav]

I might have to get one of these to compare one of these days

If you want to try white Alps, why not pick up one if the Macally 'boards up on eBay?

[xsphat]

Didn't you say somewhere that you always bottom out? Why do you care about click/tactile then? That's two confirmations per key press.

... um, OK.

[iMav]

Didn't you say somewhere that you always bottom out? Why do you care about click/tactile then? That's two confirmations per key press.

Sofa King makes a good point.

The true advantage of tactile feedback is that you receive confirmation that a key has actuated, so you don't have to slam your fingers down to the bottom.  With the blue cherries, I found that I was able to "flick" my fingers at the keys and not bottom out much at all.

More importantly, with all keyboards I've used that provide decent tactile feedback, I am, at the very least, decelerating my keystroke if/when I hit bottom.  So I am saving myself from that abuse that comes from slamming, full force, to the bottom of the keystroke over and over.

[bhtooefr]

Exactly - when I bottomed out all the time, I was faster on a laptop keyboard, ignoring the tactile sensation... but now I'm even faster on a Model M, because I don't bottom out.

Anyway, congrats on the find - that's the only Northgate board I'd use, too - I hate L-shaped enters with a passion, and IIRC, that's the only one without one. (Although, if for some reason I had to have an ergonomic keyboard, and couldn't source a Model M15, I'd probably get an OmniKey Evolution, L-shaped enter and all.)

[Waves77]

If you want to try white Alps, why not pick up one if the Macally 'boards up on eBay?

I actually got #498 of that MK96 lot - I'll let you guys know how I like it.

As far as for the Alps, the ones in the extended II are definitely white, but I've only tried this one and the blacks on the AT101W - I'd definitely say the white ones are a lot rounder and softer than the black ones. It could be an age thing as well, I've been keeping my eye on a spanish NIB extended II. There's someone on ebay selling them one at a time, but they keep getting sniped away from me (I'm not willing to spend that much on it, and don't have the time to do any sniping myself). We'll see also how the Macally compares to the old Dell. At some point I'll try a Northgate and a Focus, as they're often on ebay.

Black Alps we're definitely a close #2 for me against the buckling springs, but the blue cherries will probably will take that spot. I'll have to get a hold of a board that I can use long enough before I make up my mind though

xsphat - I bottom out most of the time too, and different keyswitches still make a huge difference to me feel wise.

[xsphat]

xsphat - I bottom out most of the time too, and different keyswitches still make a huge difference to me feel wise.

Word.

[bhtooefr]

You know, if you don't feel like doing it by hand, there are free tools that will do the sniping for you...

(I prefer doing it by hand. Winning an item with 2 seconds to go with a sniping tool isn't fun. Winning an item with 7 seconds to go, sniping on a cell phone, using Opera Mini? That is fun. )

[iMav]

As far as eBay is concerned, there is rarely anything that I absolutely HAVE to have.  I simply put in the max I am willing to pay.  If someone comes along and outbids me, good for them...it was worth more to them.

[bhtooefr]

I find that, due to psychological effects on other people, seeing bids on an item before it ends, I get things for cheaper due to sniping.

[xsphat]

The Northgate 101 came today and my god, these things really aren't made for Macs. I had a ***** of a time just getting it to work, and when I did, every time I hit the Cap Lock key, the board would enter into some sort of programming mode or something and all the LEDs blinked and no input was recorded. I finally got it to work by turning on Dip switch 1 & 3 and leaving the rest off, and using OS X to remap the Caps Lock to control, control to option and alt to command. But in any case it works now, but there is a dead key - the x - but that isn't a big deal. I'm thinking about having the Nothgate Repair guy do a cleaning and fix that switch, and the M key feels close to the end of it's life as well, so I'll have him switch that one out too.

Oh, and BTW, this keyboard has clicky white Alps switches but a different feel than the Macally, it almost feels a bit more forgiving somehow, but all in all I like the 'board so far. It's not a hulk like the Model M, but it is a big assed full size keyboard, and I am getting into big 'boards lately.

i'm gonna call back the Northgate Repair guy (he helped me get it working just now) and make arrangements to send this puppy in to him, but I don't think I will ship it until my other new keyboard arrives. And I should spend a stretch on this 'board to see if I like it enough to repair it. Miss the x key, as you can see by the amount of times I've typed it in this post, doesn't really affect me since I rarely use it and I have the MacBook keyboard, like, right there in front of me when I need an x. The m key on the other hand, that would hurt me.

So stay tunned sports racers, more on the Northgate saga at a later date.

[xsphat]

I showed my wife my proud new purchase and the first thing she said is, "oh my god is that ugly." Just thought you'd get a kick out of that.

[meltie]

Hehe, low WAF (wife acceptance factor) :-)

[iMav]

I showed my wife my proud new purchase and the first thing she said is, "oh my god is that ugly." Just thought you'd get a kick out of that.

Are you sure she was talking about the keyboard??

[xsphat]

Are you sure she was talking about the keyboard??

Now that you mention, it your chat icon was displayed in Adium at the time ...

[bhtooefr]

Now that you mention, it your chat icon was displayed in Adium at the time ...

[Jaydoublem]

You can try to clean the alps switch yourself to get x to work again. Worked for me on my apple extended which should have the exact same switches.

[xsphat]

This Northgate rules, but it is a really tricky keyboard to operate. I had a little trouble earlier after I restarted, I couldn't get my computer to recognize the keyboard. So I did the first thing you do when that **** happens, I tried it on my wife's computer and it was recognized, but it wouldn't type the correct characters. So I messed with the dip switches a bit while I reinstalled my OS on my computer and now I'm typing on it. I don't know if this''ll last past my next restart, but for now it's grand.

BTW, how did you clean your Alps switch? I'll give it a shot.

[Jaydoublem]

All I did was use a Q-Tip with water and a little all surface cleaner. I cleaned around the switch, and clicked it a few times. If that doesn't work you can use contact cleaner (available at the Hardware store), and spray it inside the switch. A lot of people have done this when Alps were still omnipresent, and it worked for a lot of them.

[xsphat]

Hey, I tried to clean the switch and I am typing this post on the Northgate right now xxxxxxXXXXXxxXxXXxxxX!

Thank you so muchfor the tip Jaydoublem, that worked like a charm. Now the only thing I don't like about this keyboard is it has to "warm up" for almost 4 minutes after I start my computer.  It just sits there with the LEDs blinking intermittently and won't register any input. After that, it's golden. My model M does the same thing but the LEDs only flash a few times, not for 4 entire minutes.

[bhtooefr]

Hmm, is it only on that computer, or on all computers?

If it's on all computers, I'm going to suspect that there's a chip not seated properly, or maybe even weak traces on the PCB or bad caps something.