Sounds like you may like the Das then, but the controller issue will hose you.
I have a PS3 too. Its on the shelf and I don't actually touch the shiny parts. I dust it occasionaly.
Shiny is personal pref., its all good.
All in all, I like the filco better mostly because its not shiny. The letters wearing off of the keys can be a show stopper for some people, I don't really care so much.
The filco is also cleaner looking to me. But all of that is just my personal opinion.