There are silicones that can withstand the heat of molten pewter (tin, lead, alloys) but not aluminium.
That could then be plated afterwards if you would want another finish.
If all you want is a specific look and not the durability then you could look at "cold-casting", which is mixing metal powders into resin, cast in a silicone mould.
The result could be polished, but not nearly as well as solid metal.