[IC] JTK new PC Plastic keycaps trays MAX

[JT Keycaps]

2020-01-04 Updates:
Some pics from customers:
_________________________________________________________________

Here is the link: https://www.jtkeycaps.com/page1001?article_id=50

New PC trays MAX will be used as HSA package in the future. And it will support SA profiles.

[laserbeamspewpew]

When and how much?

[JT Keycaps]

When and how much?

Currently only in support of China because the shipping problem. If western customers want to buy some, it is better to organize some GB and ship together.

[romevi]

Wow, that's nice.

[iaman]

Wow, I would love to get in on some polycarb trays like this as more display-oriented containers than the foam trays I've used for storage. Extremely here for this if anybody runs it as a western GB

[mrkantz]

Super interested in some of these, I was about to pull the trigger on the older small model

[growler]

Would prob be in for 3 or 4 of these....

growler

[nasp]

Nice! Looks like it could hold a base kit plus 2 or 3 other child kits depending on size.

[Puddsy]

I'll get a small GB together soon, methinks.

I'll keep updates in this thread.

[growler]

I'll get a small GB together soon, methinks.

I'll keep updates in this thread.

growler

[Waffle0508]

Since it would support SA profiles, would it also support MT3 profiles? No trays have been made for those

Sent from my SM-N960F using Tapatalk

[Puddsy]

Since it would support SA profiles, would it also support MT3 profiles? No trays have been made for those

Sent from my SM-N960F using Tapatalk

MT3 is shorter than SA so yes.

[Mcnos]

Since it would support SA profiles, would it also support MT3 profiles? No trays have been made for those

Sent from my SM-N960F using Tapatalk

MT3 is shorter than SA so yes.

But does it come with a Puddsy

[Woovie]

I've noticed that DSA caps larger than 1u fit VERY tightly and I have to store them upside down in existing trays. Do these solve that?

Thank you for making this product, it's awesome and much nicer than GMK's flimsy trays.

[Rob27shred]

I'll get a small GB together soon, methinks.

I'll keep updates in this thread.

Please & thank you Mr. Puddsy! I could use at least three of these to get my SA Godspeed & SA Pulse Rd1 sets out bags. I'll be keeping an eye in this thread fr sure!

[baye12928]

 

I just want to highlight its cheap price....

one box costs only no more than 9 US dollars....

[IOVERCALLHISTIOCYTES]

Thanks puddsy. I’d buy a few.

[user 18]

Would buy a few of these I think

[Puddsy]

I just want to highlight its cheap price....

one box costs only no more than 9 US dollars....

plus shipping, which is expensive and slow because of the volume of these trays

i've asked for price quotes and i am looking for available vendors to try and run these ASAP

likely it'll be switchmod, since krelbit and i have worked together on other stuff and he's the homie

[Sigil]

I would definitely buy several of these.

[DuellM]

Me too I'd definitely be in for a few.

Sent from my Pixel 3a using Tapatalk

[Puddsy]

talked with JTK and he says he wants to release them on his site with HSA first so it'll be a minute

[JT Keycaps]

more renders

[Theswetiyeti]

I am very interested in this. Depending on pricing after shipping cost I might buy 10 or more of them. It would be awesome if switchmod ran these.

[riterdando]

Also very interested in at least 2 or 3 boxes.
Delivery to EU has to be considered.


Gesendet von iPhone mit Tapatalk

[PiotrMKG]

Count me in, EU group buy must be launched.

[KeyCap75]

Count me in, EU group buy must be launched.

I'm in! 

[fuzzybaffy]

Sorry for the noob question, but it seems like there are only spaces for 1u keys? How would space bars fit in there?

[JT Keycaps]

Sorry for the noob question, but it seems like there are only spaces for 1u keys? How would space bars fit in there?

No sir, it just show how many keys can they put.

[Puddsy]

Sorry for the noob question, but it seems like there are only spaces for 1u keys? How would space bars fit in there?

it's not 1u boxes, it's long rows

[fuzzybaffy]

I'm a goddamn noob.

[thornkin]

Fuzzy, I had exactly the same question. It wasnt obvious to me.  The render should have some spacebars in them.

Laser ALT sporting red Sky Pandas

[82d28a]

Does it have a cover? Is it vacuum formed or something else? 

Would there be a rectangular version?  It seems that this is an awkward shape to ship.

I am interested and willing to try 5 or 6.

[82d28a]

Does it have a cover? Is it vacuum formed or something else? 

Would there be a rectangular version?  It seems that this is an awkward shape to ship.

I am interested and willing to try 5 or 6.

Never mind I see the hinges. How sturdy is it?  Will it stack?

[Puddsy]

Does it have a cover? Is it vacuum formed or something else? 

Would there be a rectangular version?  It seems that this is an awkward shape to ship.

I am interested and willing to try 5 or 6.

Never mind I see the hinges. How sturdy is it?  Will it stack?

it's injection molded

if the current trays are anything to go by, they'll be sturdy and will stack

[82d28a]

Does it have a cover? Is it vacuum formed or something else? 

Would there be a rectangular version?  It seems that this is an awkward shape to ship.

I am interested and willing to try 5 or 6.

Never mind I see the hinges. How sturdy is it?  Will it stack?

it's injection molded

if the current trays are anything to go by, they'll be sturdy and will stack

Links to pics of current trays?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Puddsy]

Does it have a cover? Is it vacuum formed or something else? 

Would there be a rectangular version?  It seems that this is an awkward shape to ship.

I am interested and willing to try 5 or 6.

Never mind I see the hinges. How sturdy is it?  Will it stack?

it's injection molded

if the current trays are anything to go by, they'll be sturdy and will stack

Links to pics of current trays?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

https://dailyclack.com/products/jtk-trays

[growler]

Count me in, EU group buy must be launched.

Agree!

growler

[jdefontes]

In for a handful of these.

[eskimojo]

In for a handful of these.

unless your hands are exceptionally large, i don't think you'll be able to get many of these in a handful

[thornkin]

Any idea what the price will be like? I am interested, but price will make the decision.

[Hawkstar]

I'd be in for ten or so. I've been looking for these

[Puddsy]

Any idea what the price will be like? I am interested, but price will make the decision.

very cheap, like $10 each or so probably

the real barrier is shipping price

[King4477]

Any idea what the price will be like? I am interested, but price will make the decision.

very cheap, like $10 each or so probably

the real barrier is shipping price

Puddsy prides himself on personally picking up shipments from the manufacturer and hand-delivering each order to its purchaser. Really amazing service.

[Hawkstar]

I check this thread everyday. Any news on this?

[JPVann]

Just got two trays with my order of JTK Hyperfuse - very nice!  Don't think I would pay more than $10 each though.  They are solid and well made plastic, sliding locks on the front, plenty of space for even SA kits.

[ullr]

At $10 each I'll buy like a dozen, seriously. Combined shipping should be relatively inexpensive per unit, right?

[JT Keycaps]

At $10 each I'll buy like a dozen, seriously. Combined shipping should be relatively inexpensive per unit, right?

Ocean shipping is cheap. But the GB is closed

[YiZZo]

Dang I missed it. When did it start?

[growler]

Closed?? What the.... I've been waiting for it to start!

growler

[IOVERCALLHISTIOCYTES]

I'm on this site, mk, and mm multiple times a day, and I never saw the GB happen. If they wished to sell to end users, i figure i would have seen it. Perhaps we can buy them from resellers.

[nasp]

I think some Chinese sites had them available, but they required a specific number before you could place the order. Don't quote me on that though

Edit: NM. Those were for non-max trays

[Hawkstar]

Ocean shipping is cheap. But the GB is closed

What?! When did it even start?!

[senryo]

I'm on this site, mk, and mm multiple times a day, and I never saw the GB happen. If they wished to sell to end users, i figure i would have seen it. Perhaps we can buy them from resellers.

Same. Pretty stoked for this, sad that this is not gonna be a thing.

[growler]

@JT Keycaps

Can this... happen?

growler

[JT Keycaps]

Dang I missed it. When did it start?

Only in China. International shipping is quite expensive so we did not run in other place.

[JT Keycaps]

Closed?? What the.... I've been waiting for it to start!

growler

This will be in stock always in the future. Do worry, maybe you can buy them from other vendors if someone order them.

[JT Keycaps]

@JT Keycaps

Can this... happen?

growler

Will be in stock always.

[JT Keycaps]

Ocean shipping is cheap. But the GB is closed

What?! When did it even start?!

It will be in stock in the future. And it will be JTK HSA standard package also. Dont worry sir.

[ullr]

Is Puddsy still going to run a group buy? Any chance of getting these in America?

[JT Keycaps]

Is Puddsy still going to run a group buy? Any chance of getting these in America?

They will finish in the next month.

[piit79]

They will finish in the next month.

What do you mean by that?

[IOVERCALLHISTIOCYTES]

They didn't want to sell any to end users. No advertising on here or reddit or any discord I follow.

[JT Keycaps]

They didn't want to sell any to end users. No advertising on here or reddit or any discord I follow.

The international shipping fee will be over $20 for one unit. The cheapest shipping is ocean shipping, but the weight should be more than 100KG. That is why I dont want to sell to end users because of the so expensive shipping fee.

[IOVERCALLHISTIOCYTES]

That totally makes sense! Wish we could've gotten together with a distributor over here to get a bulk order. If I could get 10 of them for ~125 shipped inside the US I'd have done it. Perhaps in the future.

[growler]

At 12 USD per tray, I'd be in for 10. Am in the UK, but I could make US delivery work if push came to shove.

growler

[JT Keycaps]

some pics from customers

[ddnomad]

Sooo... international GB ... any plans?

[growler]

Yes please!

growler

[thornkin]

Would be in for a few

[wil]

yeah make this happen please!

[IOVERCALLHISTIOCYTES]

If we got distributors on each continent I'm sure a bunch could be sold.

[wholypantalones]

[US-MI] [H] Mucho Monies [W] Thicc boi JTK trays to replace ****ty GMK trays

[IOVERCALLHISTIOCYTES]

I've probably got 6 sets of mechmarket GMK caps without trays. even those trays would be a step up...

[hammerbrotha]

I'd buy a few of these for sure

Sent from my SM-G965W using Tapatalk

[sent-by-an-iPerson]

I’ll buy 8-10 at least


Sent-by-an-iPerson using Tapatalk

[ddnomad]

I’ll buy 8-10 at least


Sent-by-an-iPerson using Tapatalk

Double that. Unless they are really expensive I’ll buy probably like 10 of them or something. I need these trays

[menuhin]

I really want to afford this for all my keycap sets.
However they're relatively quite expensive compared to other food boxes even when dor the highend ones, which costs only from 1-5€.
What are the factors for pricing?

[ddnomad]

I really want to afford this for all my keycap sets.
However they're relatively quite expensive compared to other food boxes even when dor the highend ones, which costs only from 1-5€.
What are the factors for pricing?

Is there even any info on official pricing? I assume comments above mentioning $10 for a single tray are guesses. Or am I wrong?

And imo $10 for a tray is fine, what I’m worried about is 1). Shipping prices 2). The fact that OP is not into answering our prayers just yet

[wholypantalones]

Just got confirmation that 1upkeyboards will be stocking these in CONUS.

[IOVERCALLHISTIOCYTES]

I'm pretty sure they don't want to sell to end users on different continents for a variety of reasons, one of which is shipping. My hope of posting in here is that vendors in North America (and EU) buy in bulk and sell to us. Even then, shipping (JTK to North America, vendor to end users) is going to account for a significant cost.

Menuhin-which boxes do you use now?

EDIT: 1up works for me that's great. Thanks wholy!

[ddnomad]

Just got confirmation that 1upkeyboards will be stocking these in CONUS.

Show Image

Dang, wondering whether Candy Keys or MyKeyboard would want to stock these in EU.

[growler]

Just got confirmation that 1upkeyboards will be stocking these in CONUS.

Show Image

Dang, wondering whether Candy Keys or MyKeyboard would want to stock these in EU.

\o/

growler

[riterdando]

Yes hopefully they are available in the EU...



Gesendet von iPad mit Tapatalk

[thornkin]

Excited for 1up...

[hiddensong]

Really? I just read this entire thread to get all the info cause of shipping nonsense.....only to read “GB closed”. WTCF!?!?
Soooooooo salteeeeee

[ddnomad]

So I’ve contacted CandyKeys and David said they are planning to stock the trays in the nearest future.

They should be listed on their website soon (tm) so we can subscribe for “back in stock notifications”.

So yeah, now I wait

[menuhin]

...
Menuhin-which boxes do you use now?

EDIT: 1up works for me that's great. Thanks wholy!

Just carton boxes lol, and those that come with some of the sets.
It takes energy and time to be get away from the chaotic tendency of the entropy.

[JT Keycaps]

Some vendors have contacted to us, some will order directly and some will run GB soon. I will keep updating when I confirm those information.

[SolidCactus]

In for a bunch once CandyKeys has them!

[ddnomad]

^______^ Niiiiice

[phinix]

Uuu, I'm in for couple. Perfect, I hope eu shops will have them as well.

[norb]

candykeys better get a bunch of these babies

[growler]

Damn straight!

growler

[snarfel]

They're now on Drop for 7 days at $21. Whether or not vendors will sell them for cheaper will be TBD I guess?

[DuellM]

I Think the ones on Drop are the smaller ones

[rockydbull]

I Think the ones on Drop are the smaller ones

Drop has the smaller ones for 16 and the max for 21. I am curious if 1up will end up being the same price or cheaper. I would prefer to give them my money over Drop.

[snarfel]

I Think the ones on Drop are the smaller ones

It's both standard and MAX.  The screenshot im the newsletter only shows standard so understandable why one might think that, but I have MAX in my shopping cart waiting for me to decide if I think vendors will sell it cheaper

[DuellM]

I Think the ones on Drop are the smaller ones

It's both standard and MAX.  The screenshot im the newsletter only shows standard so understandable why one might think that, but I have MAX in my shopping cart waiting for me to decide if I think vendors will sell it cheaper

Will **** your right, my bad

[sent-by-an-iPerson]

The ones on Drop are the ones in this thread or different ones? Link please? I can’t seem to find them.


Sent-by-an-iPerson using Tapatalk

[DuellM]

Drop.com/buy/93381

[sent-by-an-iPerson]

Thx!


Sent-by-an-iPerson using Tapatalk

[pcire]

They're now on Drop for 7 days at $21. Whether or not vendors will sell them for cheaper will be TBD I guess?

I think if you run something on drop they want you to make sure than no one else will sell for cheaper.
Hopefully I’m wrong

[DuellM]

They're now on Drop for 7 days at $21. Whether or not vendors will sell them for cheaper will be TBD I guess?

I think if you run something on drop they want you to make sure than no one else will sell for cheaper.
Hopefully I’m wrong

Get the hell out of here 3RiC

[sent-by-an-iPerson]

On 1up the smaller tray is $18. On Drop it’s $16. My guess is that Drop will undercut all other vendors.

Also, don’t forget: it’s $16 for two (or $21 for ONE for the MAX)

Edit: $21 for ONE Max


Sent-by-an-iPerson using Tapatalk

[eskimojo]

On 1up the smaller tray is $18. On Drop it’s $16. My guess is that Drop will undercut all other vendors.

Also, don’t forget: it’s $16 for two (or $21 for two for the MAX)


Sent-by-an-iPerson using Tapatalk

I believe it is $16 for two standard, or $21 for one MAX.

[pcire]

On 1up the smaller tray is $18. On Drop it’s $16. My guess is that Drop will undercut all other vendors.

Also, don’t forget: it’s $16 for two (or $21 for two for the MAX)


Sent-by-an-iPerson using Tapatalk

Drop being drop 😪

[sent-by-an-iPerson]

On 1up the smaller tray is $18. On Drop it’s $16. My guess is that Drop will undercut all other vendors.

Also, don’t forget: it’s $16 for two (or $21 for two for the MAX)


Sent-by-an-iPerson using Tapatalk

I believe it is $16 for two standard, or $21 for one MAX.

Sorry, correct.


Sent-by-an-iPerson using Tapatalk

[rockydbull]

On 1up the smaller tray is $18. On Drop it’s $16. My guess is that Drop will undercut all other vendors.

Also, don’t forget: it’s $16 for two (or $21 for two for the MAX)


Sent-by-an-iPerson using Tapatalk

Thats what I am starting to think. I could 1up selling the max for slightly below the cost of 1 max tray shipped from Drop. Maybe 27 shipped? But, Drop will scale better with shipping costs since 1up doesnt scale their shipping and just builds into the price of their items.

[sent-by-an-iPerson]

Welcome to capitalism. :-) If ppl want to support small sellers they’ll just have to pay more. Redistribute more $$ in their hands upfront so later they can afford to cut margins by increasing volume. That’s how Drop did it.


Sent-by-an-iPerson using Tapatalk

[rockydbull]

Redistribute more $$ in their hands upfront so later they can afford to cut margins by increasing volume.


Sent-by-an-iPerson using Tapatalk

Oh is that how Zeal did it? /s

[DukeEsquire]

Drop has them for preorder:

https://drop.com/buy/jtk-polycarbonate-keycap-storage-trays

I got like 10.

[KingOfMemes]

Welcome to capitalism. :-) If ppl want to support small sellers they’ll just have to pay more. Redistribute more $$ in their hands upfront so later they can afford to cut margins by increasing volume. That’s how Drop did it.


Sent-by-an-iPerson using Tapatalk

God bless capitalism, the system that puts the consumer first

[wholypantalones]

On 1up the smaller tray is $18. On Drop it’s $16. My guess is that Drop will undercut all other vendors.

Also, don’t forget: it’s $16 for two (or $21 for ONE for the MAX)

Edit: $21 for ONE Max


Sent-by-an-iPerson using Tapatalk

Standard - $25-ish for two shipping and tax..

Max - $30-ish for one shipping and tax..

Was interested, but $30 for a keycap tray is a no go. 

I'll wait and see what 1up pricing is

[phinix]

$21? I thought they were $9?

[dto10000]

Interested but $21 for one MAX case is a bit pricy

[DukeEsquire]

Interested but $21 for one MAX case is a bit pricy

Just buy more!

[rockydbull]

On 1up the smaller tray is $18. On Drop it’s $16. My guess is that Drop will undercut all other vendors.

Also, don’t forget: it’s $16 for two (or $21 for ONE for the MAX)

Edit: $21 for ONE Max


Sent-by-an-iPerson using Tapatalk

Standard - $25-ish for two shipping and tax..

Max - $30-ish for one shipping and tax..

Was interested, but $30 for a keycap tray is a no go. 

I'll wait and see what 1up pricing is

Currently two shipped from 1up is 36. I highly doubt they come in under Drop's price on the max

[barihunk]

On the off chance anyone here is from Chicago I’d be happy to combine orders to save on shipping

[wodahS]

On 1up the smaller tray is $18. On Drop it’s $16. My guess is that Drop will undercut all other vendors.

Also, don’t forget: it’s $16 for two (or $21 for ONE for the MAX)

Edit: $21 for ONE Max


Sent-by-an-iPerson using Tapatalk

Standard - $25-ish for two shipping and tax..

Max - $30-ish for one shipping and tax..

Was interested, but $30 for a keycap tray is a no go. 

I'll wait and see what 1up pricing is

Currently two shipped from 1up is 36. I highly doubt they come in under Drop's price on the max

For some additional context, 1up factors shipping in with their base pricing (for US), 1 for $18. Drop will have shipping added after (~$8 for me in Midwest) so 2 for $24. It's probably the same price to ship 1 as 2 so we may find 1up priced competively if you only need one MAX tray since they seem to be pricing the OG tray ~$10 per (though that is 125% Drop's $8).

If you need multiples then Drop is the move (duh statement) but I wouldn't be surprised to see vendor's pricing around the price of 1 MAX plus shipping from Drop

/fingerscrossed

I haven't seen other storage solutions where you can keep caps in place and display/store easily besides these (and was bummed when found GB was non-US originally), I enjoy my OG tray for some keys as is but MAX would be nice for full sets









Sent from my Pixel 2 XL using Tapatalk

[wholypantalones]

On 1up the smaller tray is $18. On Drop it’s $16. My guess is that Drop will undercut all other vendors.

Also, don’t forget: it’s $16 for two (or $21 for ONE for the MAX)

Edit: $21 for ONE Max


Sent-by-an-iPerson using Tapatalk

Standard - $25-ish for two shipping and tax..

Max - $30-ish for one shipping and tax..

Was interested, but $30 for a keycap tray is a no go. 

I'll wait and see what 1up pricing is

Currently two shipped from 1up is 36. I highly doubt they come in under Drop's price on the max

Right, which is why I'll wait instead of giving drop money now. I'm still not paying $30 for a keycap tray regardless.

[rockydbull]

On 1up the smaller tray is $18. On Drop it’s $16. My guess is that Drop will undercut all other vendors.

Also, don’t forget: it’s $16 for two (or $21 for ONE for the MAX)

Edit: $21 for ONE Max


Sent-by-an-iPerson using Tapatalk

Standard - $25-ish for two shipping and tax..

Max - $30-ish for one shipping and tax..

Was interested, but $30 for a keycap tray is a no go. 

I'll wait and see what 1up pricing is

Currently two shipped from 1up is 36. I highly doubt they come in under Drop's price on the max

For some additional context, 1up factors shipping in with their base pricing (for US), 1 for $18. Drop will have shipping added after (~$8 for me in Midwest) so 2 for $24. It's probably the same price to ship 1 as 2 so we may find 1up priced competively if you only need one MAX tray since they seem to be pricing the OG tray ~$10 per (though that is 125% Drop's $8).

If you need multiples then Drop is the move (duh statement) but I wouldn't be surprised to see vendor's pricing around the price of 1 MAX plus shipping from Drop

/fingerscrossed

I haven't seen other storage solutions where you can keep caps in place and display/store easily besides these (and was bummed when found GB was non-US originally), I enjoy my OG tray for some keys as is but MAX would be nice for full sets









Sent from my Pixel 2 XL using Tapatalk

I think the drop price will still be lower BUT there will be the time factor so it will be worth it to pay maybe 2 or 3 dollars more (on the one set). It would be nice if someone like 1up would discount multiples instead of charging full shipping on orders of 2 or more. Time will tell.

[sent-by-an-iPerson]

I just bought 10x MAX. $243 with tax + shipping. Shipping was $14.50. To me, totally worth it.


Sent-by-an-iPerson using Tapatalk

[IOVERCALLHISTIOCYTES]

Anyone else in boston wanna combine for shipping? Ill pay up front.

[phinix]

Well, I bought 5x Max boxes....

[thelaughingman]

Got the boxes today. They are well-made and give MT3 a snug fit. Really happy about this purchase.

[Zeelobby]

Damn. How did I not find this sooner. Is there any update on when 1up might stock these?

[alanskiii]

I thought 1up was going to sell these


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[growler]

Anyone selling in UK/EU ?

growler

[dmatx1]

Anyone selling in UK/EU ?

growler

MyKeyboard does, but first batch sold almost immediately.

[growler]

Anyone selling in UK/EU ?

growler

MyKeyboard does, but first batch sold almost immediately.

Cool, thanks

growler

[Zeelobby]

Yeah. I def want max. If/when they stock. Nice to have a full base set in one case.

[fantasyrunner]

Does anyone know how Cherry profile caps fit in the MAX? Would love to pick some of these up. I'm assuming it's either 2 of the regular size or 1 MAX to fit a GMK base kit?

[JT Keycaps]

Does anyone know how Cherry profile caps fit in the MAX? Would love to pick some of these up. I'm assuming it's either 2 of the regular size or 1 MAX to fit a GMK base kit?

If you don't move the trays often, there won't be a problem. If there is a big vibration, it may be scattered.

[fantasyrunner]

Awesome thanks for the reply! I will maybe try and figure a way to make the larger tray fit cherry profile with a snug fit. Honest'y with the way GMK's new packaging has gone, I'm in the market for a lot of these and I think many people will be too.

[DuellM]

Am I the only one who would love to have a cherry profile version of the max? Basically the smaller ones with more slots  )

[IOVERCALLHISTIOCYTES]

They could rerun these right now with every top saying ‘IOVERCALLHISTIOCYTES is a s******y pathologist and I would buy 10 because new GMK trays are terrible

[Puddsy]

They could rerun these right now with every top saying ‘IOVERCALLHISTIOCYTES is a s******y pathologist and I would buy 10 because new GMK trays are terrible

working on it i think

[DuellM]

They would make so much money if they made a bigger version of the cherry profile case. GMK’s new container are horrible


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[fantasyrunner]

Yea I would love a slightly larger size than the smaller one that could fit a full kit of GMK. Once I saw how bad the new GMK trays were I paid a ton getting the older style trays. They aren't so great either though. Until then I'm waiting to source a bunch of the smaller JTK small size. I saw a video on showing the max trays with cherry profile, I don't think it's the best match.