See, I'm always torn when art attempts to recreate reality in a controlled way. It's too contrived and fake, in that it's far too close to an actual desktop a messy individual would have or you'd see in a workspace. I've seen some interesting desks in academia, art studios, and even kitchens. Had I just snapped a pic of each cluttered surface would it hold the same intrinsic value as opposed to one painstakingly setup to look the same way?