[GB] Decked Out

[taylordcraig]

DISCLAIMER: I am not affiliated with this person or buy; I just saw it on PMK, wanted it, and want it to be cheaper.

This is a great color way and I haven't seen anyone promote it here yet so I'm making this thread.

DESIGNED BY: JAYFID [if you have a GH account step up. ]

http://www.pimpmykeyboard.com/deals/decked-out-keyset/



http://www.pimpmykeyboard.com/deals/decked-out-keyset/

Tons of great options.
I'll post kits and make a little banner in a bit.
You guys need to drop the price on this
by buying a lot of it
so I don't spend a fortune.

[Pyrelink]

I am not him, but I know that he designed this set over on Reddit, and all of his original creation threads are here:

One
Two
Three
Four

[taylordcraig]

I am not him, but I know that he designed this set over on Reddit, and all of his original creation threads are here:

One
Two
Three
Four

Good to know it may have some decent traction if the reddit community is interested.

[BunnyLake]

lol

[SpAmRaY]

lol

Show Image

yeah....clearly copying hyperfuse..... :facepalm:

[BunnyLake]

lol

Show Image

yeah....clearly copying hyperfuse..... :facepalm:

and using copyrighted logos in one of the packs

disgusting sp would allow this

[SpAmRaY]

lol

Show Image

yeah....clearly copying hyperfuse..... :facepalm:

and using copyrighted logos in one of the packs

disgusting sp would allow this

I'd say its all about the $$$$$$$

I realize its going off topic but whats to stop someone from taking the mockups from a group buy someone has ran here and just re-running it? OR stopping SP from just going full on production and selling the most 'popular' keysets they make for group buys?

[codyeatworld]

Yeah this is complete rip off of hyperfuse.

Not sure if github would like their logo being sold on a product either.

[BunnyLake]

lol

Show Image

yeah....clearly copying hyperfuse..... :facepalm:

and using copyrighted logos in one of the packs

disgusting sp would allow this

I'd say its all about the $$$$$$$

I realize its going off topic but whats to stop someone from taking the mockups from a group buy someone has ran here and just re-running it? OR stopping SP from just going full on production and selling the most 'popular' keysets they make for group buys?

traditionally it has been my experience that sp is pretty good about making people seek permission before using other peoples legends and stuff

the only thing he has changed from hyperfuse here is the legend colour on just the alphas, but then he even used the same purple for accent colours on the wasd packs lol

[taylordcraig]

lol

Show Image

yeah....clearly copying hyperfuse..... :facepalm:

and using copyrighted logos in one of the packs

disgusting sp would allow this

I was JUST looking at that image of hyperfuse and comparing the sets.
I already have DSA hyper so this will compliment it nicely.
Don't want to step on anyone's toes, just wanted exposure so I don't pay an arm and a leg.

Edit: I wonder if SP is aware of octocat? or if github let reddit use it?

[BunnyLake]

DESIGNED BY: JAYFID [if you have a GH account step up. ]

good one

[taylordcraig]

DESIGNED BY: JAYFID [if you have a GH account step up. ]

good one

Am I missing the joke?
A lot of users have reddit accounts and GH accounts.

[byker]

You should shoot an email to PMK/SP Bunny.

[BunnyLake]

You should shoot an email to PMK/SP Bunny.

way ahead of you on that one sir

[byker]

You should shoot an email to PMK/SP Bunny.

way ahead of you on that one sir

Thought so.. Didn't hurt to check. 

[Grendel]

Really, start a pissing match just because the color scheme is similar ?

[LechnerDE]

Really, start a pissing match just because the color scheme is similar identical?

fixed that for you

I think even the color chips are the same...


This is ridiculous! Please keep us informed about SP's response Bunny!

[yuiop]

Maybe its just me but the color scheme reminds me more of Midnight than Hyperfuse.

[BunnyLake]

Really, start a pissing match just because the color scheme is similar ?

no, but ill start a pissing match because someone has copied my original IP and run around the internet talking about how they designed it, as well as using copyright protected images that it explicitly says they cant use or even change the colour of if they even had permission

what it comes down to, is we are a small community and things tend to be done on a level of respect, or with a wink  and a handshake, with the understanding that although we may not legally protect ourselves, we dont just rip each other off, huge amounts of time and money goes in to this stuff

[taylordcraig]

I think the green is more green than teal, and I think the gray is darker.
I'll concede it is very similar. I've asked for color codes on PMK.
However, the mods between hyper, midnight, and this are all one shade off as far as I'm concerned.
Two-tone gray and a third accent color is a whole lot of sets.
I think it is very similar, but not identical.
Waiting on color codes to find out.

edit: still want to know what my joke was.

[Grendel]

Nope, alpha colors are different. As far as I can tell both use SP's of-the-shelf font & colors, can the combination be (c) ? If so, I see a lot of problems coming up in the future..

[Edit] Ah, thanks for the clarification Bunny. Going to check the reddit links, curious how that was unfolding.

[jdcarpe]

I wasn't interested anyway, but I hope nobody buys this and it dies.

What a joke.

[SpAmRaY]

I wasn't interested anyway, but I hope nobody buys this and it dies.

What a joke.

come on jd.....tell us how you really feel about it

[LechnerDE]

I wasn't interested anyway, but I hope nobody buys this and it dies.

What a joke.

come on jd.....tell us how you really feel about it

Yeah! Everybody knows JD loves DSA

[JaccoW]

no, but ill start a pissing match because someone has copied my original IP and run around the internet talking about how they designed it, as well as using copyright protected images that it explicitly says they cant use or even change the colour of if they even had permission

Which images are you talking about Bunny?

[BunnyLake]

no, but ill start a pissing match because someone has copied my original IP and run around the internet talking about how they designed it, as well as using copyright protected images that it explicitly says they cant use or even change the colour of if they even had permission

Which images are you talking about Bunny?

the github logo

details here

https://github.com/logos

[lightsout714]

Looks like midnight with white alphas to me. I honestly don't much of a relation to hyperfuse as far as colors go.

[GSimon]

Probably best I stay out of this, I don't play on getting this (DSA ew) and BunnyLake has been awesome to me as far as customer service/hooking me up with keysets. Although I will say I think it has enough of a variation in color that it is not a clear rip-off of Hyperfuse (more of a homage to keysets like it) and is distinct enough to where I believe it's not a copy. Perhaps the WASD add-ons and GitHub logo crossed the line however, and that's worth bringing attention to.

edit: still want to know what my joke was.

I think he's mocking how it was 'DESIGNED BY: JAYFID'

[strict]

I actually thought it was HyperFuse at first, I had to do a double take.

[BunnyLake]

Probably best I stay out of this, I don't play on getting this (DSA ew) and BunnyLake has been awesome to me as far as customer service/hooking me up with keysets. Although I will say I think it has enough of a variation in color that it is not a clear rip-off of Hyperfuse (more of a homage to keysets like it) and is distinct enough to where I believe it's not a copy. Perhaps the WASD add-ons and GitHub logo crossed the line however, and that's worth bringing attention to.

edit: still want to know what my joke was.

I think he's mocking how it was 'DESIGNED BY: JAYFID'

[byker]

To me, it looks like a ****tier version of Hyperfuse..

[BunnyLake]

To me, it looks like a ****tier version of Hyperfuse..

dont let our mockups fool you in to thinking they are different colours, we go for a washed out look on our graphics, look at the actual picture of the keys

[GSimon]

Show Image

Show Image

Show Image

Show Image

Show Image

Show Image

Show Image

Show Image

Show Image

Show Image

Show Image

Show Image

Ugh guess I bit the hand that feeds

It's hard to determine the exact color used with just a color picker, but as others mentioned it seems like a slightly different tint/shade for all colors. The inspiration for the set was clearly Hyperfuse, GMK Dolch and maybe Calm Depths/Midnight and from my perhaps naive perspective it seems like this set was just trying to pick and choose the best from all those, to create a 'decked out' version, which I don't know if that can be considered a direct copy based on those similarities. I can understand it being an infringement of your designs, enough people have stated they thought it was Hyperfuse that it could very well be deemed a ripoff and not something SP should have allowed.

[heedpantsnow]

Meh, somebody pass the popcorn. I love drama.

[Elrick]

To me, it looks like a ****tier version of Hyperfuse..

dont let our mockups fool you in to thinking they are different colours, we go for a washed out look on our graphics, look at the actual picture of the keys

If it's a lame copy of your edition, then what is the attraction for this latest version?

[tbc]

what was the thrme supposed to be?

i was under the impression it was 'retro command line'

[ntw]

i thought of the same thing when i first saw the interest check over at reddit too. but he clarified that it was "heavily influenced by hyperfuse, dolch, granite, and similar sets"

[Harrowed]

I hope he had named it as Hypermerge. No point doing obvious rip-offs if you don't have obvious rip-off name for it.

[limitz]

In the original reddit thread, he comments several times that he was influenced by:

"It's definitely based on some of my favorite DSA keysets, including hyperfuse, dolch, etc"

http://www.reddit.com/r/MechanicalKeyboards/comments/27xnxt/interest_check_for_a_sp_dsa_groupbuy_design/ci5dz5u

He also mentions that:

"It's basically what you said. Dolch and hyperfuse are my favorite keysets and I heavily based this on those."

http://www.reddit.com/r/MechanicalKeyboards/comments/27xnxt/interest_check_for_a_sp_dsa_groupbuy_design/ci5foio

Even more:

"There's really more influence from Dolch/Granite/Hyperfuse. However, when you're laying out a 4 color set with large centered legends, there's going to be some similarity with most existing sets."

http://www.reddit.com/r/MechanicalKeyboards/comments/28w5fw/update_the_keyset_i_posted_a_few_days_ago_is_back/cif7wle

And lastly, in response to this comment:

"looks too much like hyperfuse for it to really take off."

He acknowledges and comments on the similarity:

"I actually disagree. I really like hyperfuse, and it was one of the keysets that inspired me to put this together, but the hyperfuse set just isn't readily available anymore. One of my goals was to make something for people who like certain things like hyperfuse/DSA/high contrast designs but can't actually get anything like that."

http://www.reddit.com/r/MechanicalKeyboards/comments/287jh0/interest_check_group_buy_got_a_good_response_a/ci86kd3

---

Personally, I don't think it's a knockoff of Hyperfuse. Rather, I see it as a hybrid of Hyperfuse and Dolch. I like the green color (my suggestion in the original thread!), which I feel reminds me of the old "terminal green" on Linux machines.

Lastly, it's hilarious that people are emailing Github for "copyright" issues, when seemingly, nobody has a problem with the Darth Vader Clacks. Bunnylake, have you snitched on ClackFactory to 20th Century Fox/Disney for copyright violations of the Darth Vader design? Have you written an email to Nintendo regarding the aluminum Pokemon keycaps? To Warner Bros regarding the V for Vendetta caps? If you haven't... then why do you take such umbrage here? To me, using the Github logo isn't much different than any of the other instances of keycaps inspired by popular culture. If you're going to peeved about this, than why not be peeved at the other instances?

http://geekhack.org/index.php?topic=59993.0

People seem really salty today, but personally, I think it's a nice set.

[absyrd]

when you're laying out a 4 color set with large centered legends, there's going to be some similarity with most existing sets."

This is the part I agree with. Only so many variations when you like a certain look.

[BunnyLake]

In the original reddit thread, he comments several times that he was influenced by:

"It's definitely based on some of my favorite DSA keysets, including hyperfuse, dolch, etc"

http://www.reddit.com/r/MechanicalKeyboards/comments/27xnxt/interest_check_for_a_sp_dsa_groupbuy_design/ci5dz5u

He also mentions that:

"It's basically what you said. Dolch and hyperfuse are my favorite keysets and I heavily based this on those."

http://www.reddit.com/r/MechanicalKeyboards/comments/27xnxt/interest_check_for_a_sp_dsa_groupbuy_design/ci5foio

Even more:

"There's really more influence from Dolch/Granite/Hyperfuse. However, when you're laying out a 4 color set with large centered legends, there's going to be some similarity with most existing sets."

http://www.reddit.com/r/MechanicalKeyboards/comments/28w5fw/update_the_keyset_i_posted_a_few_days_ago_is_back/cif7wle

And lastly, in response to this comment:

"looks too much like hyperfuse for it to really take off."

He acknowledges and comments on the similarity:

"I actually disagree. I really like hyperfuse, and it was one of the keysets that inspired me to put this together, but the hyperfuse set just isn't readily available anymore. One of my goals was to make something for people who like certain things like hyperfuse/DSA/high contrast designs but can't actually get anything like that."

http://www.reddit.com/r/MechanicalKeyboards/comments/287jh0/interest_check_group_buy_got_a_good_response_a/ci86kd3

---

Personally, I don't think it's a knockoff of Hyperfuse. Rather, I see it as a hybrid of Hyperfuse and Dolch. I like the green color (my suggestion in the original thread!), which I feel reminds me of the old "terminal green" on Linux machines.

Lastly, it's hilarious that people are emailing Github for "copyright" issues, when seemingly, nobody has a problem with the Darth Vader Clacks. Bunnylake, have you snitched on ClackFactory to 20th Century Fox/Disney for copyright violations of the Darth Vader design? Have you written an email to Nintendo regarding the aluminum Pokemon keycaps? To Warner Bros regarding the V for Vendetta caps? If you haven't... then why do you take such umbrage here? To me, using the Github logo isn't much different than any of the other instances of keycaps inspired by popular culture. If you're going to peeved about this, than why not be peeved at the other instances?

http://geekhack.org/index.php?topic=59993.0

People seem really salty today, but personally, I think it's a nice set.

i think you interpret that very differently to me, the way i feel, saying you are inspired by something, doesnt give you free reign to mimic it, the fact is, he is in breach of our community unregistered design rights and claiming he designed something he didnt

with regards to the github logo, much like he ripped me off, he has done the same to them, and its just another reason this buy shouldnt exist, i dont know why you bring up other makers, if they wanna use copyrighted work, that is up to them, if those companies wish to pursue the issue, that is also up to them, those companies have the right to pursue their properties, but we our simply taking a stand with ours

this happening, legitimately hurts [CTRL]ALTS future plans, we are about to launch hyperfuse with gmk as well as having plans to do another round of hyperfuse with sp shortly, as has been commented in other sections of this subforum, its hard enough getting buys to moq as it is, without people taking our designs and claiming it as their own

[absyrd]

this happening, legitimately hurts [CTRL]ALTS future plans, we are about to launch hyperfuse with gmk as well as having plans to do another round of hyperfuse with sp shortly, as has been commented in other sections of this subforum, its hard enough getting buys to moq as it is, without people taking our designs and claiming it as their own

Ugh. That definitely will hurt [CTRL]ALT's buys. However, if we can keep this peaceful, I'm sure the much larger GH community will rally around you rather than this dude's set.

[limitz]

>i dont know why you bring up other makers, if they wanna use copyrighted work, that is up to them, if those companies wish to pursue the issue, that is also up to them, those companies have the right to pursue their properties, but we our simply taking a stand with ours

Because you are not associated with Github, yet went out of your way to inform them. Yet, I don't see you expending the same effort with the other companies. That's my point. It doesn't seem like you really care about copyright at all, but simply being vindictive here.

This set is similar to Hyperfuse as Pepsi is to Coke, as Mr. Pibb is to Dr. Pepper. That is to say, I really don't think he stole any of your work. Maybe inspired by it, but I see enough difference. Like another user said, the green reminds me of a retro command line. My opinion is that he did not mimic Hyperfuse, but formed somewhat of a hybrid with Dolch.

That said, I don't think I'll change your opinion. I guess the market will decide.

[JaccoW]

>i dont know why you bring up other makers, if they wanna use copyrighted work, that is up to them, if those companies wish to pursue the issue, that is also up to them, those companies have the right to pursue their properties, but we our simply taking a stand with ours

Because you are not associated with Github, yet went out of your way to inform them. Yet, I don't see you expending the same effort with the other companies. That's my point. It doesn't seem like you really care about copyright at all, but simply being vindictive here.

This set is similar to Hyperfuse as Pepsi is to Coke, as Mr. Pibb is to Dr. Pepper. That is to say, I really don't think he stole any of your work. Maybe inspired by it, but I see enough difference. Like another user said, the green reminds me of a retro command line. My opinion is that he did not mimic Hyperfuse, but formed somewhat of a hybrid with Dolch.

Bunny went through the trouble to ask Github for permission and use it in a set. Then some twat comes along and uses it because "this is the internet".
As he has told you before, Marvel never came down on the Ironman caps because they either didn't know or didn't care.
But why do you think there are no Batman keysets? Because somebody did ask and the owner of that logo said NO.
Notice how the Apple logo is missing from the OS pack?

Bunny runs a business. And as [CTRL]ALT he has the right to press the issue.
A Pepsi and Coke comparison is wrong because they you cannot copyright a recipe. They could have patented it but that would have meant all the ingredients were available for all to see after 25 years. But rest assured if another Cola company would come along and use their logo that they would and have cracked down on them.

In the end part of this issue is solved, because the Github logo and Code key has disappeared from the set.
It is still bad form and hurts Bunny's business, especially when he had plans to do a rerun of the set in the near future. Spin it whatever way you want multiple similar sets running at the same time means MOQ is harder to meet.

[LechnerDE]

this happening, legitimately hurts [CTRL]ALTS future plans, we are about to launch hyperfuse with gmk as well as having plans to do another round of hyperfuse with sp shortly

Which profile will it be?

Last time I only ordered DCS, but right now I also kinda want a DSA version.

Not to mention that I already put money aside for Hyperfuse GMK

[BunnyLake]

this happening, legitimately hurts [CTRL]ALTS future plans, we are about to launch hyperfuse with gmk as well as having plans to do another round of hyperfuse with sp shortly

Which profile will it be?

Last time I only ordered DCS, but right now I also kinda want a DSA version.

Not to mention that I already put money aside for Hyperfuse GMK

sp version will be dsa
gmk version will replace dcs

[EpicSNES]

"...but the hyperfuse set just isn't readily available anymore..."

this happening, legitimately hurts [CTRL]ALTS future plans, we are about to launch hyperfuse with gmk as well as having plans to do another round of hyperfuse with sp shortly...

Yeah but was this announced previously? Seems as though it was made as a type of tribute since they weren't being made anymore.

[BunnyLake]

"...but the hyperfuse set just isn't readily available anymore..."

this happening, legitimately hurts [CTRL]ALTS future plans, we are about to launch hyperfuse with gmk as well as having plans to do another round of hyperfuse with sp shortly...

Yeah but was this announced previously? Seems as though it was made as a type of tribute since they weren't being made anymore.

well, plenty of poeple have been aware im rerunning hyperfuse for a long time, basically anybody who has contacted me about it i let know it was coming again soon, it was also officially announced prior to this thread, also i dont feel i should have to announce my work just so somebody else wont rip it off, as stated before, this community is based on trust and respect, and as this person showed zero respect, he shouldnt be trusted

at no point did he contact me to ask about purchasing hyperfuse, rerunning hyperfuse or using our design

[Spopepro]

... doesnt give you free reign to mimic it, the fact is, he is in breach of our community unregistered design rights ...

Help me out... I'm having a hard time understanding this part.  You picked 4 colors out of a ring of 150, no?  Would you take all the paint at the paint store as well, because, hey, it's your design?  This seems petty, and a little immature.

The github thing (assuming this other guy did not get permission), that's different.  But colors don't make for "design rights", especially stock ones.

[LechnerDE]

From a legal point of view you're probably right, but this is about morality within the community.

Bunny - a community member - came up with this color combination and that's why he should have the "right" to this set.

At least that's my opinion on the matter...