had to make an april fools joke huh? you should focus on the other april fools joke you have currently running. just an after thought ;)Said it like a champ.
had to make an april fools joke huh? you should focus on the other april fools joke you have currently running. just an after thought ;)Jelly delights set isn't my design and technically im not running it. This one is mine
i love curious georgeHuh really looks like him xd
Not gonna comment on much cuz I知 sure others have mentioned it but have you made and/or licensed those novelties? The scaling seems stretched which slightly raises a red flag.Novelties are made by me , the size got me dumb , i agree it needs some revision. Thanks for your feedback !
This is a great april fools joke
as a parent i feel entitled to suggest renaming as GMK Dirty Diaper
nsfws*MoreMod Edit: Removed the nasty diaper pic (you can use your imagination if you like)
*not safe for weak stomachs
It's a real shame seeing the comments on this thread. Especially from those of you who would call yourselves fellow designers. If you're unable to give constructive criticism for keycaps then you probably shouldn't be looking at IC's period. Unwarranted negative remarks are not something that we need in this space.
OP, my thoughts on the set. First of all you have kitting, colors, and renders which is a great start for your IC so you're on the right track!
I do see some artifacting on the novelty renders. I am not sure where thats coming from but perhaps a revisiting those would be beneficial. I know of some talented SVG people in the community that could lend their hand in polishing those for you.
I am not a huge fan of the colors. I do like the idea of brown yellow and white but I think these shades don't work that well together. Perhaps something a bit more "dusty" to help set the mood.
I do like the theme but I am hoping you develop it a bit more. I would love to see some more "grit" in the theme maybe.
Good luck working on your set! the Keycap Designer Discord is a great place to get more help and resources as you plan your direction for the set. You can also reach out to me on my Discord if you need guidance on some of the process's and meta.
It's a real shame seeing the comments on this thread. Especially from those of you who would call yourselves fellow designers. If you're unable to give constructive criticism for keycaps then you probably shouldn't be looking at IC's period. Unwarranted negative remarks are not something that we need in this space.
OP, my thoughts on the set. First of all you have kitting, colors, and renders which is a great start for your IC so you're on the right track!
I do see some artifacting on the novelty renders. I am not sure where thats coming from but perhaps a revisiting those would be beneficial. I know of some talented SVG people in the community that could lend their hand in polishing those for you.
I am not a huge fan of the colors. I do like the idea of brown yellow and white but I think these shades don't work that well together. Perhaps something a bit more "dusty" to help set the mood.
I do like the theme but I am hoping you develop it a bit more. I would love to see some more "grit" in the theme maybe.
Good luck working on your set! the Keycap Designer Discord is a great place to get more help and resources as you plan your direction for the set. You can also reach out to me on my Discord if you need guidance on some of the process's and meta.
I do agree that the community should strive towards constructive criticism, but OP did 2 alarming things:
1.- Created a project on behalf of another creator who got banned from Geekhack which is already shady, and we can't even corroborate that story he said, nor we can confirm this is not his second account.
2.- Did other IC's which failed and deleted the post.
I don't recall if he was called before because of stolen art for novelties, so I can't add that to the list, but there is a faint memory of it as well.
Also...as a fellow parent, those colors look like poop :blank:
It's a real shame seeing the comments on this thread. Especially from those of you who would call yourselves fellow designers. If you're unable to give constructive criticism for keycaps then you probably shouldn't be looking at IC's period. Unwarranted negative remarks are not something that we need in this space.I agree with everything you said in terms of recommendations, but i don't think you know the whole backstory.
OP, my thoughts on the set. First of all you have kitting, colors, and renders which is a great start for your IC so you're on the right track!
I do see some artifacting on the novelty renders. I am not sure where thats coming from but perhaps a revisiting those would be beneficial. I know of some talented SVG people in the community that could lend their hand in polishing those for you.
I am not a huge fan of the colors. I do like the idea of brown yellow and white but I think these shades don't work that well together. Perhaps something a bit more "dusty" to help set the mood.
I do like the theme but I am hoping you develop it a bit more. I would love to see some more "grit" in the theme maybe.
Good luck working on your set! the Keycap Designer Discord is a great place to get more help and resources as you plan your direction for the set. You can also reach out to me on my Discord if you need guidance on some of the process's and meta.
set itself, color-wise is not even as bad as many are making it to be. no comment on the IC quality or kitting, but really the set colorway is far from the worst thing I've seen. does indeed remind me of curious george. i'd continue pursuing if you'd really like to make thisi really agree that the realisation is bad , working on it , thanks for the kind words :thumb:
2x2.75u shifts. sickA very stupid mistake , fixed it .Thanks a lot for your feedback
God, please be an April Fools set.it's not a fool (((
It's a real shame seeing the comments on this thread. Especially from those of you who would call yourselves fellow designers. If you're unable to give constructive criticism for keycaps then you probably shouldn't be looking at IC's period. Unwarranted negative remarks are not something that we need in this space.Great to see such thoughts , thanks for the kind words , i'll try my best
OP, my thoughts on the set. First of all you have kitting, colors, and renders which is a great start for your IC so you're on the right track!
I do see some artifacting on the novelty renders. I am not sure where thats coming from but perhaps a revisiting those would be beneficial. I know of some talented SVG people in the community that could lend their hand in polishing those for you.
I am not a huge fan of the colors. I do like the idea of brown yellow and white but I think these shades don't work that well together. Perhaps something a bit more "dusty" to help set the mood.
I do like the theme but I am hoping you develop it a bit more. I would love to see some more "grit" in the theme maybe.
Good luck working on your set! the Keycap Designer Discord is a great place to get more help and resources as you plan your direction for the set. You can also reach out to me on my Discord if you need guidance on some of the process's and meta.
It's a real shame seeing the comments on this thread. Especially from those of you who would call yourselves fellow designers. If you're unable to give constructive criticism for keycaps then you probably shouldn't be looking at IC's period. Unwarranted negative remarks are not something that we need in this space.I agree with everything you said in terms of recommendations, but i don't think you know the whole backstory.
OP, my thoughts on the set. First of all you have kitting, colors, and renders which is a great start for your IC so you're on the right track!
I do see some artifacting on the novelty renders. I am not sure where thats coming from but perhaps a revisiting those would be beneficial. I know of some talented SVG people in the community that could lend their hand in polishing those for you.
I am not a huge fan of the colors. I do like the idea of brown yellow and white but I think these shades don't work that well together. Perhaps something a bit more "dusty" to help set the mood.
I do like the theme but I am hoping you develop it a bit more. I would love to see some more "grit" in the theme maybe.
Good luck working on your set! the Keycap Designer Discord is a great place to get more help and resources as you plan your direction for the set. You can also reach out to me on my Discord if you need guidance on some of the process's and meta.
He has been to the keycap deisgner discord, and rushed the set. I know this for a fact, and I can/will provide screen shots
He knew about how scuffed his novelties and renders were, and did nothingShow Image(https://i.gyazo.com/8a78e58e4dcfbb04b89b3d92d9904b5d.png)
He also acknowledges that he rushed, and he will "change" things. They have not, he just posted anywayShow Image(https://i.gyazo.com/1edd127df57a6d53eb2d62a1cf747227.png)
He was still asking about how good was the concept, TODAYShow Image(https://i.gyazo.com/56e2f8868eba52951ba87c7d2be268af.png)
And what the hell is this? He contradicted himself in the same screenshot lol. He said he won't rush and won't post until it's ready, but here we are.Show Image(https://i.gyazo.com/1cf7ccd8430d2f7394fd24c60eb5b2a0.png)
I'll attempt to find more stuff later, but i think this speaks for itself so far.
You can contact me at iinko#3028 on discord if you'd like a fast response over geekhack. You can also check the keycap designer discord if you want to verify anything, it is in the #off-topic-lounge channel.
It's a real shame seeing the comments on this thread. Especially from those of you who would call yourselves fellow designers. If you're unable to give constructive criticism for keycaps then you probably shouldn't be looking at IC's period. Unwarranted negative remarks are not something that we need in this space.
OP, my thoughts on the set. First of all you have kitting, colors, and renders which is a great start for your IC so you're on the right track!
I do see some artifacting on the novelty renders. I am not sure where thats coming from but perhaps a revisiting those would be beneficial. I know of some talented SVG people in the community that could lend their hand in polishing those for you.
I am not a huge fan of the colors. I do like the idea of brown yellow and white but I think these shades don't work that well together. Perhaps something a bit more "dusty" to help set the mood.
I do like the theme but I am hoping you develop it a bit more. I would love to see some more "grit" in the theme maybe.
Good luck working on your set! the Keycap Designer Discord is a great place to get more help and resources as you plan your direction for the set. You can also reach out to me on my Discord if you need guidance on some of the process's and meta.
I do agree that the community should strive towards constructive criticism, but OP did 2 alarming things:
1.- Created a project on behalf of another creator who got banned from Geekhack which is already shady, and we can't even corroborate that story he said, nor we can confirm this is not his second account.
2.- Did other IC's which failed and deleted the post.
I don't recall if he was called before because of stolen art for novelties, so I can't add that to the list, but there is a faint memory of it as well.
Also...as a fellow parent, those colors look like poop :blank:
Yes, Jelly Delights OP was called out for stock image novelties. There have also been more shady instances other than just the GH ban, including the extremely poor communication about the situation and other questions, though, I'll give them the benefit of the doubt because Kaysoo is only the middleman. However, I still feel as though we should get a better explanation than OP being banned for having multiple accounts, and as to why OP would post an IC on an alternate account rather than their main account, unless they were trying to hide their previous posts. Kozify (Jelly Delights OP) was accused of being behind the GMK Witch frenzy (I can link more info if needed), which seems to stand strong because 1, both designers were called out for using stock images, and 2, that would give an explanation for the ban of Kozify (got a bad rep, created an alternate account to clear their name, which was later banned for being an alternate account). THOUGH KEEP IN MIND, all of this is speculation, and none of this is proven. Though, to further support this, we still don't know what Kozify's main account is, and why he decided to post on an alt account and not his main.
This topic is irrelevant to this thread anyways because it's designed by Kaysoo, who yes, manages the Jelly Delights IC, but that shouldn't be held against him for sets he creates alone.
It's a real shame seeing the comments on this thread. Especially from those of you who would call yourselves fellow designers. If you're unable to give constructive criticism for keycaps then you probably shouldn't be looking at IC's period. Unwarranted negative remarks are not something that we need in this space.
OP, my thoughts on the set. First of all you have kitting, colors, and renders which is a great start for your IC so you're on the right track!
I do see some artifacting on the novelty renders. I am not sure where thats coming from but perhaps a revisiting those would be beneficial. I know of some talented SVG people in the community that could lend their hand in polishing those for you.
I am not a huge fan of the colors. I do like the idea of brown yellow and white but I think these shades don't work that well together. Perhaps something a bit more "dusty" to help set the mood.
I do like the theme but I am hoping you develop it a bit more. I would love to see some more "grit" in the theme maybe.
Good luck working on your set! the Keycap Designer Discord is a great place to get more help and resources as you plan your direction for the set. You can also reach out to me on my Discord if you need guidance on some of the process's and meta.
I do agree that the community should strive towards constructive criticism, but OP did 2 alarming things:
1.- Created a project on behalf of another creator who got banned from Geekhack which is already shady, and we can't even corroborate that story he said, nor we can confirm this is not his second account.
2.- Did other IC's which failed and deleted the post.
I don't recall if he was called before because of stolen art for novelties, so I can't add that to the list, but there is a faint memory of it as well.
Also...as a fellow parent, those colors look like poop :blank:
Yes, Jelly Delights OP was called out for stock image novelties. There have also been more shady instances other than just the GH ban, including the extremely poor communication about the situation and other questions, though, I'll give them the benefit of the doubt because Kaysoo is only the middleman. However, I still feel as though we should get a better explanation than OP being banned for having multiple accounts, and as to why OP would post an IC on an alternate account rather than their main account, unless they were trying to hide their previous posts. Kozify (Jelly Delights OP) was accused of being behind the GMK Witch frenzy (I can link more info if needed), which seems to stand strong because 1, both designers were called out for using stock images, and 2, that would give an explanation for the ban of Kozify (got a bad rep, created an alternate account to clear their name, which was later banned for being an alternate account). THOUGH KEEP IN MIND, all of this is speculation, and none of this is proven. Though, to further support this, we still don't know what Kozify's main account is, and why he decided to post on an alt account and not his main.
This topic is irrelevant to this thread anyways because it's designed by Kaysoo, who yes, manages the Jelly Delights IC, but that shouldn't be held against him for sets he creates alone.
Can you remind me again what the whole GMK Witch fiasco was about? Slips my mind atm.
It's a real shame seeing the comments on this thread. Especially from those of you who would call yourselves fellow designers. If you're unable to give constructive criticism for keycaps then you probably shouldn't be looking at IC's period. Unwarranted negative remarks are not something that we need in this space.I agree with everything you said in terms of recommendations, but i don't think you know the whole backstory.
OP, my thoughts on the set. First of all you have kitting, colors, and renders which is a great start for your IC so you're on the right track!
I do see some artifacting on the novelty renders. I am not sure where thats coming from but perhaps a revisiting those would be beneficial. I know of some talented SVG people in the community that could lend their hand in polishing those for you.
I am not a huge fan of the colors. I do like the idea of brown yellow and white but I think these shades don't work that well together. Perhaps something a bit more "dusty" to help set the mood.
I do like the theme but I am hoping you develop it a bit more. I would love to see some more "grit" in the theme maybe.
Good luck working on your set! the Keycap Designer Discord is a great place to get more help and resources as you plan your direction for the set. You can also reach out to me on my Discord if you need guidance on some of the process's and meta.
He has been to the keycap deisgner discord, and rushed the set. I know this for a fact, and I can/will provide screen shots
He knew about how scuffed his novelties and renders were, and did nothingShow Image(https://i.gyazo.com/8a78e58e4dcfbb04b89b3d92d9904b5d.png)
He also acknowledges that he rushed, and he will "change" things. They have not, he just posted anywayShow Image(https://i.gyazo.com/1edd127df57a6d53eb2d62a1cf747227.png)
He was still asking about how good was the concept, TODAYShow Image(https://i.gyazo.com/56e2f8868eba52951ba87c7d2be268af.png)
And what the hell is this? He contradicted himself in the same screenshot lol. He said he won't rush and won't post until it's ready, but here we are.Show Image(https://i.gyazo.com/1cf7ccd8430d2f7394fd24c60eb5b2a0.png)
I'll attempt to find more stuff later, but i think this speaks for itself so far.
You can contact me at iinko#3028 on discord if you'd like a fast response over geekhack. You can also check the keycap designer discord if you want to verify anything, it is in the #off-topic-lounge channel.
Yeah I wasn't aware of all this in the background. I should be more active in the Discord for as much as I recommend it to people lol.
That being said, to OP, I am not entirely sure of what your history and situation is but I sympathize with feeling the urge and excitement to get the set out there and get feedback. Every set I have ever done, one of the most exciting parts is making that first IC post. But realize that that is just the first step of a journey. You don't have to complete a set in record time. Some people are able to get sets to GB in a months time after IC. But that's not an expectation. Take your time nurturing your ideas and developing them. Being able to sit with your ideas for awhile is a good sign that you will be able to follow through with changes and challenges along the way. And this is good not only for you as a designer who will have to handle those challenges in stride, but it's also good for your customers to see that you will stick through with it to the end for them to make sure they get a great experience. This set is an opportunity for you to make something great so I still look forward to the development.
wow internal keyset designer drama is so boring
wow internal keyset designer drama is so boring
take out that knife
It's a real shame seeing the comments on this thread. Especially from those of you who would call yourselves fellow designers. If you're unable to give constructive criticism for keycaps then you probably shouldn't be looking at IC's period. Unwarranted negative remarks are not something that we need in this space.I agree with everything you said in terms of recommendations, but i don't think you know the whole backstory.
OP, my thoughts on the set. First of all you have kitting, colors, and renders which is a great start for your IC so you're on the right track!
I do see some artifacting on the novelty renders. I am not sure where thats coming from but perhaps a revisiting those would be beneficial. I know of some talented SVG people in the community that could lend their hand in polishing those for you.
I am not a huge fan of the colors. I do like the idea of brown yellow and white but I think these shades don't work that well together. Perhaps something a bit more "dusty" to help set the mood.
I do like the theme but I am hoping you develop it a bit more. I would love to see some more "grit" in the theme maybe.
Good luck working on your set! the Keycap Designer Discord is a great place to get more help and resources as you plan your direction for the set. You can also reach out to me on my Discord if you need guidance on some of the process's and meta.
He has been to the keycap deisgner discord, and rushed the set. I know this for a fact, and I can/will provide screen shots
He knew about how scuffed his novelties and renders were, and did nothingShow Image(https://i.gyazo.com/8a78e58e4dcfbb04b89b3d92d9904b5d.png)
He also acknowledges that he rushed, and he will "change" things. They have not, he just posted anywayShow Image(https://i.gyazo.com/1edd127df57a6d53eb2d62a1cf747227.png)
He was still asking about how good was the concept, TODAYShow Image(https://i.gyazo.com/56e2f8868eba52951ba87c7d2be268af.png)
And what the hell is this? He contradicted himself in the same screenshot lol. He said he won't rush and won't post until it's ready, but here we are.Show Image(https://i.gyazo.com/1cf7ccd8430d2f7394fd24c60eb5b2a0.png)
I'll attempt to find more stuff later, but i think this speaks for itself so far.
You can contact me at iinko#3028 on discord if you'd like a fast response over geekhack. You can also check the keycap designer discord if you want to verify anything, it is in the #off-topic-lounge channel.
Yeah I wasn't aware of all this in the background. I should be more active in the Discord for as much as I recommend it to people lol.
That being said, to OP, I am not entirely sure of what your history and situation is but I sympathize with feeling the urge and excitement to get the set out there and get feedback. Every set I have ever done, one of the most exciting parts is making that first IC post. But realize that that is just the first step of a journey. You don't have to complete a set in record time. Some people are able to get sets to GB in a months time after IC. But that's not an expectation. Take your time nurturing your ideas and developing them. Being able to sit with your ideas for awhile is a good sign that you will be able to follow through with changes and challenges along the way. And this is good not only for you as a designer who will have to handle those challenges in stride, but it's also good for your customers to see that you will stick through with it to the end for them to make sure they get a great experience. This set is an opportunity for you to make something great so I still look forward to the development.
So I decided to look a bit deeper into the kozify/ester situation and found some interesting things. To begin with this, there is a screenshot of a render Ester was trying to make that looks exactly like one of the old jelly delights novelties shown here, https://imgur.com/a/AXeBLLk and also the fact that kozify the discord account was made very recently and joined KDD the day after the gmk witch debacle, which is extremely suspicious if you ask me. This is also shown here, https://imgur.com/a/kjFlvMi. Now this on its own really would have meant nothing to me, but the fact that this was hidden feels odd to me as a whole. If we could have a direct response from Ester that would be great, because sure he messed up GMK Witch but he could have fixed it up and redeemed himself or scrapped it as a whole like he did but redeemed himself with jelly delights instead of causing the confusion and distrust because of this.
AgreedIt's a real shame seeing the comments on this thread. Especially from those of you who would call yourselves fellow designers. If you're unable to give constructive criticism for keycaps then you probably shouldn't be looking at IC's period. Unwarranted negative remarks are not something that we need in this space.I agree with everything you said in terms of recommendations, but i don't think you know the whole backstory.
OP, my thoughts on the set. First of all you have kitting, colors, and renders which is a great start for your IC so you're on the right track!
I do see some artifacting on the novelty renders. I am not sure where thats coming from but perhaps a revisiting those would be beneficial. I know of some talented SVG people in the community that could lend their hand in polishing those for you.
I am not a huge fan of the colors. I do like the idea of brown yellow and white but I think these shades don't work that well together. Perhaps something a bit more "dusty" to help set the mood.
I do like the theme but I am hoping you develop it a bit more. I would love to see some more "grit" in the theme maybe.
Good luck working on your set! the Keycap Designer Discord is a great place to get more help and resources as you plan your direction for the set. You can also reach out to me on my Discord if you need guidance on some of the process's and meta.
He has been to the keycap deisgner discord, and rushed the set. I know this for a fact, and I can/will provide screen shots
He knew about how scuffed his novelties and renders were, and did nothingShow Image(https://i.gyazo.com/8a78e58e4dcfbb04b89b3d92d9904b5d.png)
He also acknowledges that he rushed, and he will "change" things. They have not, he just posted anywayShow Image(https://i.gyazo.com/1edd127df57a6d53eb2d62a1cf747227.png)
He was still asking about how good was the concept, TODAYShow Image(https://i.gyazo.com/56e2f8868eba52951ba87c7d2be268af.png)
And what the hell is this? He contradicted himself in the same screenshot lol. He said he won't rush and won't post until it's ready, but here we are.Show Image(https://i.gyazo.com/1cf7ccd8430d2f7394fd24c60eb5b2a0.png)
I'll attempt to find more stuff later, but i think this speaks for itself so far.
You can contact me at iinko#3028 on discord if you'd like a fast response over geekhack. You can also check the keycap designer discord if you want to verify anything, it is in the #off-topic-lounge channel.
Yeah I wasn't aware of all this in the background. I should be more active in the Discord for as much as I recommend it to people lol.
That being said, to OP, I am not entirely sure of what your history and situation is but I sympathize with feeling the urge and excitement to get the set out there and get feedback. Every set I have ever done, one of the most exciting parts is making that first IC post. But realize that that is just the first step of a journey. You don't have to complete a set in record time. Some people are able to get sets to GB in a months time after IC. But that's not an expectation. Take your time nurturing your ideas and developing them. Being able to sit with your ideas for awhile is a good sign that you will be able to follow through with changes and challenges along the way. And this is good not only for you as a designer who will have to handle those challenges in stride, but it's also good for your customers to see that you will stick through with it to the end for them to make sure they get a great experience. This set is an opportunity for you to make something great so I still look forward to the development.
owl speaks many languages, and one of them is the language of the gods. I agree with everything you said.
Lets try to keep this thread about this set. Even if accusations are true, there really is no point in having them here.yes please
Truth be told the ad hominem arguments are too heavy on this thread. I like the idea of a cowboy key set, but will have to sit this one out for I don't trust OP enough. Hopefully, I am mistaken.
Have a good day lads.
Truth be told the ad hominem arguments are too heavy on this thread. I like the idea of a cowboy key set, but will have to sit this one out for I don't trust OP enough. Hopefully, I am mistaken.I知 a complete different person from Kozify... if there is a way to confirm this i would be really happy
Have a good day lads.
If this gives something , my account is way older than those 2Truth be told the ad hominem arguments are too heavy on this thread. I like the idea of a cowboy key set, but will have to sit this one out for I don't trust OP enough. Hopefully, I am mistaken.I知 a complete different person from Kozify... if there is a way to confirm this i would be really happy
Have a good day lads.
If this gives something , my account is way older than those 2Truth be told the ad hominem arguments are too heavy on this thread. I like the idea of a cowboy key set, but will have to sit this one out for I don't trust OP enough. Hopefully, I am mistaken.I知 a complete different person from Kozify... if there is a way to confirm this i would be really happy
Have a good day lads.Show Image(https://i.imgur.com/DJU4WE2.png)
wow internal keyset designer drama is so boring
had to make an april fools joke huh? you should focus on the other april fools joke you have currently running. just an after thought ;)Jelly delights set isn't my design and technically im not running it. This one is mine
If you have any constructive criticism i'm really happy to read it...
I really wish to start geathering feedback about the set ,and move on from this things...If this gives something , my account is way older than those 2Truth be told the ad hominem arguments are too heavy on this thread. I like the idea of a cowboy key set, but will have to sit this one out for I don't trust OP enough. Hopefully, I am mistaken.I知 a complete different person from Kozify... if there is a way to confirm this i would be really happy
Have a good day lads.Show Image(https://i.imgur.com/DJU4WE2.png)
I've trusted from the start that you are a different person, I just feel bad that kozify has twisted you into his mess and now your image will be affected by his actions.
Kozify is the one who gives me the IC updates and other stuff i just post them because he got banned , as you can see in the IC he even states his nickname , not mine ,i'm just a midlle man helping him...had to make an april fools joke huh? you should focus on the other april fools joke you have currently running. just an after thought ;)Jelly delights set isn't my design and technically im not running it. This one is mine
If you have any constructive criticism i'm really happy to read it...
You literally posted this...
https://geekhack.org/index.php?topic=111390.0
You could call it:Thank you for the sugestion ,if i will plan any changes i think i will use something from your list :thumb:
Old West
Tumbleweed
"Howdy" - hello in cowboy
Saloons
Buckaroo
Wow! Colors are much better this time around, looking forward to the new novelties :thumb:Thanks a lot ,i like them more too :D
Thanks for pointing out this big mistake, hope everyone can leave advices, in order to make the design better )It's a real shame seeing the comments on this thread. Especially from those of you who would call yourselves fellow designers. If you're unable to give constructive criticism for keycaps then you probably shouldn't be looking at IC's period. Unwarranted negative remarks are not something that we need in this space.I agree with everything you said in terms of recommendations, but i don't think you know the whole backstory.
OP, my thoughts on the set. First of all you have kitting, colors, and renders which is a great start for your IC so you're on the right track!
I do see some artifacting on the novelty renders. I am not sure where thats coming from but perhaps a revisiting those would be beneficial. I know of some talented SVG people in the community that could lend their hand in polishing those for you.
I am not a huge fan of the colors. I do like the idea of brown yellow and white but I think these shades don't work that well together. Perhaps something a bit more "dusty" to help set the mood.
I do like the theme but I am hoping you develop it a bit more. I would love to see some more "grit" in the theme maybe.
Good luck working on your set! the Keycap Designer Discord is a great place to get more help and resources as you plan your direction for the set. You can also reach out to me on my Discord if you need guidance on some of the process's and meta.
He has been to the keycap deisgner discord, and rushed the set. I know this for a fact, and I can/will provide screen shots
He knew about how scuffed his novelties and renders were, and did nothingShow Image(https://i.gyazo.com/8a78e58e4dcfbb04b89b3d92d9904b5d.png)
He also acknowledges that he rushed, and he will "change" things. They have not, he just posted anywayShow Image(https://i.gyazo.com/1edd127df57a6d53eb2d62a1cf747227.png)
He was still asking about how good was the concept, TODAYShow Image(https://i.gyazo.com/56e2f8868eba52951ba87c7d2be268af.png)
And what the hell is this? He contradicted himself in the same screenshot lol. He said he won't rush and won't post until it's ready, but here we are.Show Image(https://i.gyazo.com/1cf7ccd8430d2f7394fd24c60eb5b2a0.png)
I'll attempt to find more stuff later, but i think this speaks for itself so far.
You can contact me at iinko#3028 on discord if you'd like a fast response over geekhack. You can also check the keycap designer discord if you want to verify anything, it is in the #off-topic-lounge channel.
Waiting for the new novelties :)Means a lot to me :D
Not my favorite, but still looks really good :thumb:Apreciate it :D
I wish the comment Hoffman added on the Jelly Delights wil help getting over this messwow internal keyset designer drama is so boring
Totally cannot understand the key cap designer drama. most do not even do any designing themselves and pay others to draw novelties and deskmats, somehow they feel qualified to call others out. Not everyone of course but I feel in keyboards this is a frequent thing where they take themselves and their design" skills" too seriously. Though there are some special talented folks who really know how to bring an idea to life.
New colors look very good. I have some feedback about your kitting:Added the changes that reffered to the base and bars, thank you very much for your feedback !
_ Base: F13 should be in mod color due to color sequence: F9-F12 are in alpha. The second 5 in numpad looks like it's barred too which is the same to the first 5, it may be render mistake or my computer is dead...I don't know.
_ Novelty: Can you consider making 1u novelties to cover the nav colomn on 65/75s layouts and adding iso enter novelties (Like the novelty kit of GMK Earth Tones and Lavender)?
_ Bar kit: I think mod color for space bar is not a good idea, please consider changing these 2 mod bars (6u I believe) to alpha color.
looks similiar to GMK Lucky CatIn fact the colors are pretty different
this is developing so well!Thanks for your support ! :D
wow internal keyset designer drama is so boring
Totally cannot understand the key cap designer drama. most do not even do any designing themselves and pay others to draw novelties and deskmats, somehow they feel qualified to call others out. Not everyone of course but I feel in keyboards this is a frequent thing where they take themselves and their design" skills" too seriously. Though there are some special talented folks who really know how to bring an idea to life.
I love cowboys and i'm super interested in this set.novelties are still redesigned :thumb:
The novelties look a bit bland though. I'm not sure the bag translates very well.
You have a cowboy hat and cactus on your deskmat, maybe you can pull something from those instead
The line inside the sheriff badge seems very thin as well.
I would of been down if the entire kit was the color of the mod keys. That tan color is unique among keysets. I don't care for the alpha keys colors though, at all.Thanks for your feedback ,interesting point.