I've only tried alps a handful of times. Blue alps definitely blew me away though. I just found them really enjoyable to type on (and listen to!). They definitely feel different than Cherry MX, and I doubt a switch based on the same principle as MX could properly mimic the feel of Alps, in the same way that it can't really mimic a buckling spring.
Like with all switches though, it really comes down to preference. Lots of people like Topre too, which I'm not as big a fan of. You may try some alps and find you love them, or you may try them out and find that you're rather ambivalent. This hobby has a lot of personal preference in it -- caps and cases have a huge aesthetic component, switch types undoubtedly feel different but there's no switch that's the uncontested best, even different layouts are better for different applications and workflows. At the end of the day, you're going to get a lot of different answers here about why people like alps, or don't like alps. But none of that can tell you for sure whether you'll like alps or not, or if you'll like some varieties and not others.