Author Topic: Flat, low and spaced! But why?  (Read 2091 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline Busty

  • Thread Starter
  • Posts: 30
Flat, low and spaced! But why?
« on: Wed, 24 September 2008, 03:33:43 »
There seems to be trend to produce keyboards with flat, low and spaced keys. Sony and Apple use it in there notebook and desktop keyboards (http://reviews.cnet.com/sc/33240536-2-300-DT1_RAW.jpg or http://images.apple.com/keyboard/images/wired_keyboard20070813.gif). Now, this is not something new. A lot of computers on the early days of the PC used it, eg. the Sinclar or a prominent failure, the PCjr from IBM (http://images.pcworld.com/reviews/graphics/139100-ibmPCjr.jpg).
I've got a MacBook with this kind of keyboard and it is ok but not great; especially after tying for a while the hard stop is unpleasent. So why did companies dug out this old design. Is it just for looks? Or even cheaper to produce? Lower hight in laptops? New findings on ergonomics?
Any opinions or insights in this new trend?

Offline lowpoly

  • Posts: 1749
Flat, low and spaced! But why?
« Reply #1 on: Wed, 24 September 2008, 05:30:05 »
Quote
Is it just for looks?
In desktop keyboards yes. However, people seem to like the snappy response which is of course bought at the price of bottoming out way too early. I'd guess the rubber domes are slower when they are pressed beyond their tactile phase. So if you avoid that they're snappy.

Quote
Or even cheaper to produce?
Not than std. rubber domes but cheaper than mechanical.

Quote
Lower hight in laptops?
That's where it started. These are still rubber dome with membrane boards but the mechanism that leads the key folds together under the keycap allowing for a  flatter design.

Quote
New findings on ergonomics?
No. Ergonomics are worse because the keycaps are not angled. So you have to reach farther for the upper row, for example. However, you can push the keycaps at the edge and they will go down perfectly because of the scissors (the opposite edge is pulled down). If this whole scenario is desirable though, I don't know.

Miniguru thread at GH // The Apple M0110 Today

Offline madmaxmedia

  • Posts: 27
Flat, low and spaced! But why?
« Reply #2 on: Thu, 25 September 2008, 15:36:37 »
I prefer these low scissor keyboards to rubber domes (not saying a lot, but hey.)

I used to have a MacBook and didn't like the keyboard. I do have an Apple aluminum keyboard at home (for low noise), and like it a LOT better. The MacBook keyboard feels cheap and the keys have a lot of wiggle. The aluminum keyboard is pretty stiff and the keys feel much better.