I can't thank you guys enough for the feedback. After giving all the feedback some thought, I think I've settled on the need for 3 types of keyboards.
1) The custom keyboard (long-term)
Purpose: When it makes financial sense to do this, and I've learned more about boards in general, this will be the goal, to build my first custom board. Note Keyboard #2 & #3 below come first.
- At the time I'll be all over the forums and doing research I'm sure of it.
- Is KPrepublic a good place to buy Korea kits?
Budget: $400-$600 (for the first build)
2) A pre-built niche quality good value keyboard
Purpose:
- To get introduced to important keyboard brands right now. To get a great typing experience for good value. (i.e. the mentioned Filco, Royal Kludge, Red Dragon etc)
-To possibly try out a 65% board, I never have tried anything other than full length, and wonder what it's like.
- I'd also love a couple of board recommendations. I'd be excited to pick one up right now! I wonder if one of the Filco's with a specialized KOBO frame would be a good place to start?
- I'd also really like a recommendation on switches. The options are overwhelming. In my mind I want the best typing experience. I wonder if Cherry MX brown is a good option to try with this board?
Budget: $50-$200
3) The Gamer/Collector "new enthusiast" keyboard
The idea for this keyboard can be summed up in this youtube unboxing therapy video of the Drop Ctrl (1:15 mark and 3:30 mark for rgb) -
Purpose:
- A better alternative for gamers, good construction. An aluminum frame is a very tangible improvement that I think gamers would appreciate immediately.
- A board that would look great with artisan key caps, probably with RGB lighting behind them. I would like to start gift exchanges at holidays, birthdays of artisan key caps. I think they woudl always be thoughtful, personal, and original. I LOVE the idea.
- Hot swap is nice for this target board, because gamers won't need to be expected to solder, but if you tell them they can buy switches and change them easily. Believe me it will help get gamers more into the community.
- Budget $100-$250 (Artisan key caps separate)
- It might be nice to have two options at this category. One on the higher end, and one slightly more budget concious.
- If anything, this may be more of a keyboard closer to "sentimental/to enjoy having", with personalized added key caps and such. But overall the choice is approved in principle by the community. And a good "entry" point to the community
One of the appeals of this board, is that it allows gamers to get the board near a price they're used to, and you can slowly add to the board over time with the artisan key caps. (For example I just picked up a Dota 2 anodized cnc machine key cap, a Dwarf factory resin key caps, and a spinner which I thought was so cool).
The effect of this keyboard is that the owners will gain an appreciation for the better aspects of keyboards. Later they would branch out into non-RGB. They would also have the benefit of taking their artisan key caps and any additional switches with them. Bottom line this board may not have 1000% seal of approval, but it will be able to be "showy", and still have a good aluminum construction with removeable parts.
* About numpads, I'm a lefty. I've always used my right hand for integrated keyboards, which I'm totally used to. I've never tried with my left hand. If I bought a separate numpad, would it have to be compatible with the keyboard? I'm not sure how that works. Where might I find a good separate numpad?
* Understood on hot swaps. I think it's more of an appeal for keyboard #3, or new comers in general willing to try different switches at the early stages
* Understood on RGB. Again, this is all keyboard #3 for me at this point.
* On blue switches - that is really interesting, that makes a lot of sense for FPS gamers to avoid them. My crowd is more casual in gaming, but still like overwatch and apex which may push them more towards the quickly double tap or nudge switches. For me personally, I only care about typing experience. I think there's a time to enjoy clicky sounds (like at home), and a time for quiet typing (like at the office).
Anyway, in general I am very excited to get into keyboards, with keyboard #2 as a starting point. I am also pretty stoked about keyboard #3 style like in the linked video and the concept of getting friends/family into keyboards who already are gamers, gifting personalized artisan key caps
Really looking forward to any recommendations to get me started on keyboard 2 & 3. And thanks so much again for the feedback to a newcomer.