Exactly - the folks who need ISO/numpad support pay for it, rather than everyone in the entire buy subsidizing the additional cost for caps they will never use.
This might the slippery slope toward Alpha, Modifiers, Extension kits and SA pricing.
I don't think this is an issue to be decided sorely based on short term factors.
We all benefited from broad base set coverage and volume pricing. Why we risk shooting ourselves in the foot?
With how gmk pricing works, SA style kits arent feasible. All this is doing is reducing the size of the base kit to fit the needs of the majority of people who use more standard layouts tkl and smaller. There is nothing SA stylized about that, not even remotely.
Nope, there have been many instances of alphas, novelties, adapters, etc. on GMK.
I wouldn't jump into conclusion based on historic pricing policies and kitting trends.
If the problem is price inflation, we should look at that holistically rather that going for easy fix of compromising coverage.
Someone earlier blamed price inflation on base set bloat which is unfounded - all the popular base sets have had 140-150+ keys.
Hate to pick on Jamon (design I like), but if I put some essential kits in the Cart, I'm very close to $200. It sure feels like SA shopping experience. I honestly don't know splitting off numpad will hasten us there, but really don't want that to happen.
We collectively buy far more sets each year, but the price keeps going up. On top of that get less coverage? I don't think so.
What kits are essential? How are they costing 200 USD? Let's say jamon stays at 250 MOQ price (it'll prob make it to 500 due to MD buying up sets, vendors, etc) and that you buy both the split/40s kit and the numpad kit. That is ~202 USD. But who is going to buy both? You might as well buy another base kit at that point as well.
Let's say you consider "essential" to be base + novelties and spacebar kit. Lets say that because you like novelties so much, you buy all the kits. Assume the base kit still has a 250 MOQ price. Thats around 228 USD for base plus 4 other kits. GMK red samurai base with novelties and spacebars costed around 215 USD. Keep in mind that GMK samurai's base kit hit its 500 MOQ price drop point, while jamon has not yet.
Since jamon will probably make it to 500 MOQ, minus all of my jamon price calculations by 15 USD. There is nothing crazy about those numbers considering what you are paying for.
If GMK pricing and kitting was going to become like SP, it would have happened a long time ago with all the additional add-on alpha and mod kits. Except it hasn't.
Another point I want to make that a lot of people seem to miss is that more coverage = better. It's not about the amount of coverage a kit has, it's about how much of it is really used. How many boards does the average enthusiast have that make use of a numpad? Or 40's/split? The vast number of people use standard layouts ranging from 60-tkl. Out of all those standard users, they might have some boards bigger than a tkl like an 1800, but they can only put one numpad on it. So the numpad from one set they bought gets used while the others collect dust or eventually replace the current set on the 1800, which just starts the process over again. That is a lot of wasted keys, and even more so money wise. Same deal with including ISO in base kits, hell, not even Nautilus was able to reach the minimum MOQ for ISO, and it reached 1900 base sets which got it a low price of 100 USD. In the past when the community was smaller and had less crazy layouts, people were arguing over if 65% support should be included in the base kit of sets and now it's a common occurrence. Now I think we are at the point of too much coverage as the norm. Why do people need 6U spacebars in base kits? Why is ISO included? Why are there numpads sitting around being wasted by the majority of users?
Its funny because people said that adding more keys to sets in the past would make their pricing too expensive. Funny where we have ended up now, I guess people just don't like change.
Exactly - the folks who need ISO/numpad support pay for it, rather than everyone in the entire buy subsidizing the additional cost for caps they will never use.
ISO needs 4 keys. That's 2.5 USD.
There are also 4 people who would ever use ISO.