I like shorter reviews, specially when comparing things. 5 pages long when you are going to read 4 reviews gets tiresome.
I think that if you made 'sections' like 'feel', 'key caps' and the like would be better.
Good review
I don't like short reviews because I feel like you just get what amounts to a forum post without anything substantial. As someone who writes for a hobby, I despise the TL:DR ****. I'm not saying this about *THIS* article, just responding to your post.
Related to this article, I feel like it was a nice summary but could've had way more information/opinion in it. Definitely a good start if you're going to build on it or post other reviews though.