geekhack

geekhack Marketplace => Interest Checks => Topic started by: Krakob on Sat, 18 February 2017, 17:09:05

Title: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans [GB started]
Post by: Krakob on Sat, 18 February 2017, 17:09:05
GROUP BUY HERE (https://geekhack.org/index.php?topic=88361)

[attachimg=1]

GMK NorDeUK is simply put an effort to bring GMK caps to a large portion of the European community. I am aiming for a minimal price by cutting out (almost) all of that unnecessary American rabble, shipping from Sweden, and minimising profits. Combined with having a single unified set, MOQ should be easy to reach!

Compatibility:

Covered languages:

Pricing:
The MOQ is 150 at most, but I have asked GMK if they are willing to go lower given that it’s a community effort.
Pricing will be per kit from GMK + VAT + shipping + €10 as a safety margin. I’m hoping for it to be closer to €100 than €150 but I can’t really say yet.
Shipping will be insured and tracked packages sent through PostNord.

About me:
I can imagine this post looks a bit fishy given my low post count, hence an introduction is in order. I am primarily a user of /r/mk and a mod of the accompanying Discord. I started out with keyboards way back when my sister called me from DreamHack, saying that SteelSeries was selling mechanical keyboards (6Gv2) for cheap and offered to buy one for me. Of course I said yes and roughly a year later I entered the community looking for a better keyboard which lead me to a Ducky Shine 2. From there on it was just a hazy sequence of poor choices and failed rehabilitation.

The set was developed with the help of friends on the MechKeys Discord and after a bit of reiterating, we got the set as seen in this thread.
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: Ball-o-tron on Sat, 18 February 2017, 17:43:49
Yes

Edit: Isn't the dot usually a tilde?
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: ehmlis on Sat, 18 February 2017, 17:47:03
Well, this sounds interesting :thumb:
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: Burt Macklin on Sat, 18 February 2017, 18:13:21
Sounds great  ;D

Any ETA?
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: vegs on Sat, 18 February 2017, 18:40:17
Interested :D
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: TalkingTree on Sat, 18 February 2017, 19:21:51
Wouldn't be worth replacing ANSI keys with NorDe equivalents rather than having both?
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: longtran1568 on Sun, 19 February 2017, 01:23:53
Hi,

Thanks for the effort! A cheap and universal ISO kit like this is very much needed!

I just want to ask for the addition of 3 R1 keys: Del, End and Page Down.

I am currently using a custom 96 keys layout, similar to ZZ96 and RS96. Leopold 1800 layout is also quite similar. For those layouts you would need to have those 3 keys on the top of the numpad (R1).

If this kit could also have it, you would have a buyer!
Thanks.
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: longtran1568 on Sun, 19 February 2017, 01:25:51
Wouldn't be worth replacing ANSI keys with NorDe equivalents rather than having both?

This. This set is meant for ISO users so we can omit those ANSI keys
Title: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: pattulus on Sun, 19 February 2017, 02:10:59
My thoughts:

I really like the idea. But I'm not sold because of the color choice. The classic black and white look is the epitome of simplicity. I get that. But why not go all-in with a more interesting color story.

I'd also love to see the Planck and Ergodox typed out in the compatibility list rather than "lots of customs" — this would give me a warm feeling of being included. I'd know that I'm on the safe side keycap-wise.
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: twk on Sun, 19 February 2017, 02:15:58
Good idea! I might be interested, depending on the price.
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: diiiP on Sun, 19 February 2017, 02:44:42
Interested, but would love to see some other colors than black & white 
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: Krakob on Sun, 19 February 2017, 03:31:04
Super glad to wake up to this reception!

Yes

Edit: Isn't the dot usually a tilde?
It's different for all covered languages, meaning we'd need to add 5 caps, which is more cost than it's worth. As such I want to replace it with a generic key, or possibly a blank.

Sounds great  ;D

Any ETA?
None yet! Hopefully we'll be finalise the design within a week or two and submit to GMK, after which it's just a matter of sorting out logistics and getting the GB running!

Hi,

Thanks for the effort! A cheap and universal ISO kit like this is very much needed!

I just want to ask for the addition of 3 R1 keys: Del, End and Page Down.

I am currently using a custom 96 keys layout, similar to ZZ96 and RS96. Leopold 1800 layout is also quite similar. For those layouts you would need to have those 3 keys on the top of the numpad (R1).

If this kit could also have it, you would have a buyer!
Thanks.
This is something I've considered. However, I'm not keen on introducing three more keys. What I do wonder is if it would be reasonable to change the mentioned keys to R1 instead, as it'll make the kit better for a lot of non-standard layouts while still being pretty much the same for TKL, considering that they're not part of the main cluster anyway.

Wouldn't be worth replacing ANSI keys with NorDe equivalents rather than having both?
The only ANSI caps included are left shift, enter, and pipe (blank). This is to make the set compatible with HHKB as well as ANSI, for the Eu users who prefer ANSI as well as any buyers who might just want a cheap WoB GMK set. The keys shown in the main cluster are ISO UK with all Nordic/DE caps shown below.

My thoughts:

I really like the idea. But I'm not sold because of the color choice. The classic black and white look is the epitome of simplicity. I get that. But why not go all-in with a more interesting color story.

I'd also love to see the Planck and Ergodox typed out in the compatibility list rather than "lots of customs" — this would give me a warm feeling of being included. I'd know that I'm on the safe side keycap-wise.
I chose white on black in order to make it a simple set that can appeal to a wide audience, even if it's not their preferred colourway. The intention of the set is to make it appeal to as many Nordic/German/UK users as possible in order to make sure we can reach MOQ. While it's not a super interesting set design wise, this isn't really the place for innovation.

Sadly, Ergodox and Planck will not be covered. They add too many keys and will raise the price too much, making MOQ harder to hit.
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: dorf on Sun, 19 February 2017, 03:51:33
You got my attention.
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: TalkingTree on Sun, 19 February 2017, 03:56:16
Wouldn't be worth replacing ANSI keys with NorDe equivalents rather than having both?
The only ANSI caps included are left shift, enter, and pipe (blank).
Not those. I mean the number strip and the non alphabetic keys.

Something like this.
[attach=1]
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: Krakob on Sun, 19 February 2017, 04:09:08
Wouldn't be worth replacing ANSI keys with NorDe equivalents rather than having both?
The only ANSI caps included are left shift, enter, and pipe (blank).
Not those. I mean the number strip and the non alphabetic keys.

Something like this.
(Attachment Link)

Those are ISO UK  ;)
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: longtran1568 on Sun, 19 February 2017, 04:09:28
Quote
I do wonder is if it would be reasonable to change the mentioned keys to R1 instead, as it'll make the kit better for a lot of non-standard layouts while still being pretty much the same for TKL, considering that they're not part of the main cluster anyway.

That would be a neat idea. Looking forward to this :)

About color, you could throw in many colors, then make a poll to see which will get more sale.
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: grayish on Sun, 19 February 2017, 04:10:09
Interested!
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: thel on Sun, 19 February 2017, 05:06:26
I am definitly intersted. Do you already have a timeline?
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: Mechboards on Sun, 19 February 2017, 05:57:46
Looks good :)
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: Blackhawk on Sun, 19 February 2017, 06:04:29
Somewhat interested, but the lack of a proper left numberrow key is a killer. I strongly prefer correct legends for all languages at an extra cost. I'm also in favor of changing the the 1.5u R2 ANSI key above the enter to #' or '* (similar to the HADapter kit - it might even be worth it to include both).

EDIT: Have you thought about including "E€" and "M΅" keys as well?
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: TalkingTree on Sun, 19 February 2017, 06:18:50
Those are ISO UK
Look again.
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: Krakob on Sun, 19 February 2017, 06:28:51
I am definitly intersted. Do you already have a timeline?
Hoping to finish up the IC within two weeks and request a quote. After that it's just a matter of waiting and launching!

Somewhat interested, but the lack of a proper left numberrow key is a killer. I strongly prefer correct legends for all languages at an extra cost. I'm also in favor of changing the the 1.25u R2 ANSI key above the enter to #' or '* (similar to the HADapter kit - it might even be worth it to include both).

EDIT: Have you thought about including "E€" and "M΅" keys as well?
My philosophy was to unconditionally include correct secondary legends, while discarding tertiary legends if it would mean one set got the correct legend while others wouldn't, e.g. +? is correct for Danish and Norwegian, but it should be +?\ for Swedish. I think it's better to discard the backslash in this case as it will still be "correct" for Swedish, even if it misses a backslash.

I did consider legending the 1.5u key but it would require four  keycaps to be added as you'd need to have the UK, DE, and Nordic variants plus a backspace (or is it delete?) to cover HHKB. Since it's more of a modifier key plainly in terms of size and position I think it's fine for it to be blank in this case.

As for secondary legends on letters (@, €, Mu), I chose to discard them as they aren't part of ISO UK and would have to add three keys, which isn't worth the price in this case.

Quote
I do wonder is if it would be reasonable to change the mentioned keys to R1 instead, as it'll make the kit better for a lot of non-standard layouts while still being pretty much the same for TKL, considering that they're not part of the main cluster anyway.

That would be a neat idea. Looking forward to this :)

About color, you could throw in many colors, then make a poll to see which will get more sale.

Well I want to keep it very simple in order to make sure it has a broad appeal, so it pretty much boiled down to white on black or black on white. However, black on white can be found on vintage Cherry boards and can be produced through dyesubbing PBT. Therefore I believe the set will have a stronger spot on the market as black on white, since there's a larger gap to fill. In fact, I'm not sure if any white on black double shot sets that cover nordic/german have made it to the market.
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: Krakob on Sun, 19 February 2017, 06:32:31
Those are ISO UK
Look again.

Looking as hard as I can and disregarding tilde and the tertiary legend on 4, it's matching the images I'm finding on Google. https://ultimatehackingkeyboard.com/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/uk-layout.svg and https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/9/9c/ISO_keyboard_(105)_QWERTY_UK.svg/750px-ISO_keyboard_(105)_QWERTY_UK.svg.png
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: Blackhawk on Sun, 19 February 2017, 06:51:57
Somewhat interested, but the lack of a proper left numberrow key is a killer. I strongly prefer correct legends for all languages at an extra cost. I'm also in favor of changing the the 1.25u R2 ANSI key above the enter to #' or '* (similar to the HADapter kit - it might even be worth it to include both).

EDIT: Have you thought about including "E€" and "M΅" keys as well?
My philosophy was to unconditionally include correct secondary legends, while discarding tertiary legends if it would mean one set got the correct legend while others wouldn't, e.g. +? is correct for Danish and Norwegian, but it should be +?\ for Swedish. I think it's better to discard the backslash in this case as it will still be "correct" for Swedish, even if it misses a backslash.

I did consider legending the 1.5u key but it would require four  keycaps to be added as you'd need to have the UK, DE, and Nordic variants plus a backspace (or is it delete?) to cover HHKB. Since it's more of a modifier key plainly in terms of size and position I think it's fine for it to be blank in this case.

As for secondary legends on letters (@, €, Mu), I chose to discard them as they aren't part of ISO UK and would have to add three keys, which isn't worth the price in this case.


I was refering to the one you left as a dot in the mockup (~` in ANSI layout, ½§ in danish etc.). I can get behind the choice of disregarding the tertiary legends.

Regarding the 1.5u pipe key: I might be in the minority but I exclusive use the standard ANSI layout, so having a blank key greatly detracts from the aesthetic of the set. However your argument for not including those keys is valid. Maybe this set is not for me.
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: TalkingTree on Sun, 19 February 2017, 07:05:41
These are the differences between UK and the NORDE kit that Wodan proposed (https://deskthority.net/workshop-f7/designing-the-ultimate-norde-kit-for-gmk-t14443.html).
The yellow keys are optional.
[attachimg=1]

For your convenience, KLE source is here (http://www.keyboard-layout-editor.com/#/gists/c97b4468f769d80e276331ca21ff80d5).
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: ricyuyc on Sun, 19 February 2017, 07:13:19
Would you consider to include Dvorak(English) add-on kit on this classic set?
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: Krakob on Sun, 19 February 2017, 10:05:04
These are the differences between UK and the NORDE kit that Wodan proposed (https://deskthority.net/workshop-f7/designing-the-ultimate-norde-kit-for-gmk-t14443.html).
The yellow keys are optional.
(Attachment Link)

For your convenience, KLE source is here (http://www.keyboard-layout-editor.com/#/gists/c97b4468f769d80e276331ca21ff80d5).
I'm not seeing the miss match here. UK, DE, Swedish/Finnish, Danish, and Norwegian are all covered. While I did base it on Wodan's kit I did make a few small changes and I based it on UK ISO since ANSI was not the goal.

Would you consider to include Dvorak(English) add-on kit on this classic set?

I won't, it requires too many keys for a relatively uncommon niche that would be better handled by a uniform profile.
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: TalkingTree on Sun, 19 February 2017, 12:01:52
Ok, sorry, I was focusing on the Norde part of the kit and forgot it also had to include the UK layout.
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: Krakob on Sun, 19 February 2017, 15:32:37
Ok, sorry, I was focusing on the Norde part of the kit and forgot it also had to include the UK layout.

You had me confused there! :P

In other news, updating the image tomorrow. The tilde (dotted R1) key will be replaced with a blank unless we can come up with something better. R2 of the nav cluster (delete, end, page down) will be turned into R1. This will allow for better fit to 65% boards as the nav cluster, in that case located on the rightmost column, will not be a mess of R1 and R2 caps. It will also be nice for 75% boards depending on layout. For TKLs, this will be a slight deviation from standard but I'm pretty confident it's the better design choice. I did consider uniform R2, but it would not blend with the top row of 75%s as well.
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: ricyuyc on Sun, 19 February 2017, 18:19:19
These are the differences between UK and the NORDE kit that Wodan proposed (https://deskthority.net/workshop-f7/designing-the-ultimate-norde-kit-for-gmk-t14443.html).
The yellow keys are optional.
(Attachment Link)

For your convenience, KLE source is here (http://www.keyboard-layout-editor.com/#/gists/c97b4468f769d80e276331ca21ff80d5).
I'm not seeing the miss match here. UK, DE, Swedish/Finnish, Danish, and Norwegian are all covered. While I did base it on Wodan's kit I did make a few small changes and I based it on UK ISO since ANSI was not the goal.

Would you consider to include Dvorak(English) add-on kit on this classic set?

I won't, it requires too many keys for a relatively uncommon niche that would be better handled by a uniform profile.
Thank you Sir. I would join still if you would ship to Hong Kong in affordable shipping cost.  ;)
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: Gosnat on Mon, 20 February 2017, 01:20:55
I would easily jump on this, more support for Europe! And when i come to think of it, i do not own a really plain set that has higher quality.
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: maximm on Mon, 20 February 2017, 01:24:46
I don't like the idea. Releasing popular sets with an optional NOR/DE works well enough. We get a great set, and a chance for a NOR/DE set as well.
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: hansichen on Mon, 20 February 2017, 02:41:21
I don't like the idea. Releasing popular sets with an optional NOR/DE works well enough. We get a great set, and a chance for a NOR/DE set as well.

Plum is at 28/100 orders at the moment. I don't think that it will not the 100. Terminal failed hitting the 100 too. And even if it would hit it is at a price of 200+ for most europeans. If this kit stays at <150$ everyone has a affordable chance getting norde. And there are quite many people who only want norde sets, those people wouldn't buy a normal plum set.
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: wodan on Mon, 20 February 2017, 02:45:45
I am assuming PLUM International is approaching ~50 as we speak, the 28 is from 17th of feb.

That kit has the potential to get close enough to 100 for GMK to give in and still make it despite missing MOQ. they WANT to make international kits and serve the EU market better!

Same with the GMK Carbon international kit that we also got despite missing MOQ ... don't be so negative, have faith.
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: Applet on Mon, 20 February 2017, 02:55:33
In other news, updating the image tomorrow. The tilde (dotted R1) key will be replaced with a blank unless we can come up with something better.
Maybe you could have a community cap or something else that's a bit more fun than a blank? :) Maybe reuse some existing novelty cap? (please not the cherry-icon tho)

Since it covers HHKB-layout, I might join it for the good cause (if I can afford it when it goes live), the Swedish caps might come in handy some day, you never know :P
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: hansichen on Mon, 20 February 2017, 03:08:21
I am assuming PLUM International is approaching ~50 as we speak, the 28 is from 17th of feb.

That kit has the potential to get close enough to 100 for GMK to give in and still make it despite missing MOQ. they WANT to make international kits and serve the EU market better!

Same with the GMK Carbon international kit that we also got despite missing MOQ ... don't be so negative, have faith.
You are right, numbers should be at 45-50 now. We will see if they'll produce it. Either way, I think that this is a good set to spread some norde love
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: kevral on Mon, 20 February 2017, 03:55:06
Interested, probably in 2 sets.

Thanks, this is a very good idea!
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: My_Thoughts on Mon, 20 February 2017, 03:58:56

Feedback needed:
What do we do with the top left key that is currently a dot? Given that it’s not the same for any of the languages (and its frequent replacement by escape in 60% boards), it would be relatively expensive to properly legend it. Some symbol is ideal but making an entirely new novelty cap will raise the price, which is not quite what’s being aimed at.


I liked the idea GMK Terminal had.  They had a blank key there.  Then no one has the wrong symbol :)
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: My_Thoughts on Mon, 20 February 2017, 04:05:11
Wouldn't be worth replacing ANSI keys with NorDe equivalents rather than having both?
The only ANSI caps included are left shift, enter, and pipe (blank).
Not those. I mean the number strip and the non alphabetic keys.

Something like this.
(Attachment Link)

Those are ISO UK  ;)

Not sure if it would annoy other people but any chance of the 4 key having $ and € symbols on it?
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: My_Thoughts on Mon, 20 February 2017, 04:08:16
I don't like the idea. Releasing popular sets with an optional NOR/DE works well enough. We get a great set, and a chance for a NOR/DE set as well.

Plum is at 28/100 orders at the moment. I don't think that it will not the 100. Terminal failed hitting the 100 too. And even if it would hit it is at a price of 200+ for most europeans. If this kit stays at <150$ everyone has a affordable chance getting norde. And there are quite many people who only want norde sets, those people wouldn't buy a normal plum set.

I suspect Terminal would have done a lot better on Massdrop :(  But the price was also a killer for it
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: My_Thoughts on Mon, 20 February 2017, 04:10:12
My thoughts:

I really like the idea. But I'm not sold because of the color choice. The classic black and white look is the epitome of simplicity. I get that. But why not go all-in with a more interesting color story.


I agree that the white on black is not amazing for me. But finding a colour everyone is happy with might be a challenge

Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: Applet on Mon, 20 February 2017, 04:23:18
I'm fine keeping it a 1U blank, I really like the approach of keeping it as cheap and flexible as possible. The blank R2 1,75 a blank makes me a bit sad tho, but I get it. Do you really think there will be many "regular" ANSI users joining it?
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: dorf on Mon, 20 February 2017, 04:34:59
If I'm jumping on this I would like all legends correct so for me you need to include @ on 2, £ on 3 and \ on + so that all keys are "swedish".
For me I would say that I have a larger need to insert "extra" keys such as a function key to the right of right shift on smaller boards. I do not have this need on a TKL. And if you are considering changing rows to match 65% and 75%, I would say that it's not fully TKL compatible. I'm not saying that this is bad. Look at the kit that Zennasyndroxx made. I love it with all the special sizes of keys which lets me configure my GH60. So it's more important for me to have legends correct than compromises. € symbol on E and ΅ on M would be a bonus.
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: maximm on Mon, 20 February 2017, 04:59:52
Yeah, but what you get here is a WoB set with nordic legends.
This will never reach MOQ, as the only reason for getting this is the nordic legends. Very few others will buy it. So it will still have exactly the same issues as any nordic addition to other sets, which still have the advantage of being popular to the 500+ MOQ limits.
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: dorf on Mon, 20 February 2017, 05:12:11
Like Wodan pointed out, we need to stay positive and I totally understand that creating a kit with compromises is better than none. What this hopefully will lead to is that more people will actually have keyboards with their languages rather than converting to US/ANSI.
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: maximm on Mon, 20 February 2017, 05:28:58
Staying positive is fine, but this is an IC, and I am giving my simple opinions on the matter. The IC phase is about gathering info from everyone before time and energy is put into a GB.

Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: Krakob on Mon, 20 February 2017, 08:32:05
These are the differences between UK and the NORDE kit that Wodan proposed (https://deskthority.net/workshop-f7/designing-the-ultimate-norde-kit-for-gmk-t14443.html).
The yellow keys are optional.
(Attachment Link)

For your convenience, KLE source is here (http://www.keyboard-layout-editor.com/#/gists/c97b4468f769d80e276331ca21ff80d5).
I'm not seeing the miss match here. UK, DE, Swedish/Finnish, Danish, and Norwegian are all covered. While I did base it on Wodan's kit I did make a few small changes and I based it on UK ISO since ANSI was not the goal.

Would you consider to include Dvorak(English) add-on kit on this classic set?

I won't, it requires too many keys for a relatively uncommon niche that would be better handled by a uniform profile.
Thank you Sir. I would join still if you would ship to Hong Kong in affordable shipping cost.  ;)
Hong Kong shipping will be possible, but I can't say what the price will be yet. I believe it will be the same price for everyone except swedes, though!

If I'm jumping on this I would like all legends correct so for me you need to include @ on 2, £ on 3 and \ on + so that all keys are "swedish".
For me I would say that I have a larger need to insert "extra" keys such as a function key to the right of right shift on smaller boards. I do not have this need on a TKL. And if you are considering changing rows to match 65% and 75%, I would say that it's not fully TKL compatible. I'm not saying that this is bad. Look at the kit that Zennasyndroxx made. I love it with all the special sizes of keys which lets me configure my GH60. So it's more important for me to have legends correct than compromises. € symbol on E and ΅ on M would be a bonus.
As I discussed briefly earlier, the philosophy behind the set is that all secondary legends must be correct, but tertiary legends (including € and mu) will not be included if it means the set will require more keycaps.

The change I proposed was to make Del, End, and PgDn R1, nothing else. I agree that it's not truly TKL compatible but since it's not part of the main cluster it's pretty negligible. Just wanna make sure we're on the same page ;)

In other news, updating the image tomorrow. The tilde (dotted R1) key will be replaced with a blank unless we can come up with something better.
Maybe you could have a community cap or something else that's a bit more fun than a blank? :) Maybe reuse some existing novelty cap? (please not the cherry-icon tho)

Since it covers HHKB-layout, I might join it for the good cause (if I can afford it when it goes live), the Swedish caps might come in handy some day, you never know :P
A new novelty cap would increase the price more than I'd like. Reusing a novelty cap is not a bad idea, but I have no clue what we'd actually use in that case. Since it's a minimalist set, I'm not sure if there is anything that will fit and look better than a blank.

Wouldn't be worth replacing ANSI keys with NorDe equivalents rather than having both?
The only ANSI caps included are left shift, enter, and pipe (blank).
Not those. I mean the number strip and the non alphabetic keys.

Something like this.
[attach=1]

Those are ISO UK  ;)

Not sure if it would annoy other people but any chance of the 4 key having $ and € symbols on it?
Nope. That is only part of ISO UK. ISO DE does not have the € sign there, so we're skipping it.

I don't like the idea. Releasing popular sets with an optional NOR/DE works well enough. We get a great set, and a chance for a NOR/DE set as well.
and
Yeah, but what you get here is a WoB set with nordic legends.
This will never reach MOQ, as the only reason for getting this is the nordic legends. Very few others will buy it. So it will still have exactly the same issues as any nordic addition to other sets, which still have the advantage of being popular to the 500+ MOQ limits.
I understand the skepticism but I also believe there's a few good reasons this will succeed:
1. It's being shipped within Europe, reducing shipping prices.
2. It's also not subject to import tax, which can be very steep.
3. It's being run minimum profit, meaning it will undercut competition pretty well.
4. There have been few successful international kits, resulting in german and nordic buyers often being left out. UK tends to have a bit more luck but it's often not true ISO UK and just ANSI + the three extra keys.

All in all these factors will contribute to a pretty large amount of potential buyers with strong incentives to join in.
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: Krakob on Mon, 20 February 2017, 10:36:31
Updated the main post! Tilde changed to blank, Delete/End/Pgdn changed to R1, legend positioning and text corrected, modifiers changed to legends as far as possible. I'm not sure if GMK can provide icon legends for bottom row modifiers. From what I gather, they only provide icons for Windows and Menu, which will not be used as it is to remain OS agnostic and since we're using Fn, not Menu. I'm also not entirely sure if they have molds for Super, most sets that use text for it seem to use Code instead. Nevertheless I'll be asking them about it to make sure.

I'll leave the set design open to discussion until Friday or so, but I think the set is more or less done. Thanks for the feedback so far!

Ed, Edd 'n Eddit: Sierra (Discord mod; credit where credit is due) suggested the GMK or Cherry logo is used for the tilde. I think this is a great idea as it doesn't leave a hole in the design while also playing nicely with the icon modifier theme and paying homage to Cherry, the original creators of our beloved switches and also the very tools these keycaps will be made with! The GMK logo was also suggested, but I honestly think it just doesn't look as good and wouldn't fit the iconography. You can find the GMK logo at the bottom here: https://geekhack.org/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=84756.0;attach=158456;image

Edit 2: changed again! Changed Super to Code and added Cherry logo.
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: pomk on Mon, 20 February 2017, 13:03:10
would you consider running this split into three kits like this:

[attach=1]

It would give correct legends while keeping the price low by separating ansi and UK keys.
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: Krakob on Mon, 20 February 2017, 13:16:32
would you consider running this split into three kits like this:

(Attachment Link)

It would give correct legends while keeping the price low by separating ansi and UK keys.

One of the core principles of the set is that it will not be split. In most GBs, you have ANSI as the default. For international support it's often just the bare necessities for ISO, maybe enough for correct ISO UK if you're lucky. German and nordic packs very often fail to hit MOQ due to all the segregation, which is pretty much why this set is run. From a business point of view, it makes sense because it means you can get more ANSI/US buyers by having a lower price, and if there are enough who are willing to buy an international kit, you can get those as well.

By combining our efforts into a single amount of purchases, it means we'll have a much easier time reaching MOQ as instead of having 50 going for the UK kit, 30 for the German kit, and 20 for the Nordic kit we'll get maybe 80-90 people going for the full kit instead. Some buyers will be lost due to the inherent cost of a bigger kit but it's just about the only solution we have to this issue until the keyboard community has grown a whole lot more, or until manufacturers drop their MOQs. In GMK's case, they've already dropped from 250 to 150, and I believe they've run international add-on kits at less. As mentioned in the OP, I'm hoping they'll be willing to run this kit even if we don't hit 150, but we can't know for sure yet.

Should the GB end before we hit the MOQ, I will of course contact them and see if they'll run it at whatever amount we are at then. If not, we'll simply have to cancel.
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: mathiasn on Mon, 20 February 2017, 13:18:17
We-ell :-\, DE :D :thumb:, but black :(.
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: Krakob on Mon, 20 February 2017, 13:37:10
We-ell :-\, DE :D :thumb:, but black :(.

To quote myself from last page
Quote from: Krakob
Well I want to keep it very simple in order to make sure it has a broad appeal, so it pretty much boiled down to white on black or black on white. However, black on white can be found on vintage Cherry boards and can be produced through dyesubbing PBT. Therefore I believe the set will have a stronger spot on the market as black on white, since there's a larger gap to fill. In fact, I'm not sure if any white on black double shot sets that cover nordic/german have made it to the market.
If you're looking for German black on white caps of similar quality, I believe you may have a relatively easy time finding them on vintage Cherry boards :)
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: TalkingTree on Mon, 20 February 2017, 14:02:08
I don't think the colour scheme should be a concern. If the GB is successful, other rounds with different colours could be run.
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: pomk on Mon, 20 February 2017, 14:15:10
would you consider running this split into three kits like this:

(Attachment Link)

It would give correct legends while keeping the price low by separating ansi and UK keys.

One of the core principles of the set is that it will not be split. In most GBs, you have ANSI as the default. For international support it's often just the bare necessities for ISO, maybe enough for correct ISO UK if you're lucky. German and nordic packs very often fail to hit MOQ due to all the segregation, which is pretty much why this set is run. From a business point of view, it makes sense because it means you can get more ANSI/US buyers by having a lower price, and if there are enough who are willing to buy an international kit, you can get those as well.

By combining our efforts into a single amount of purchases, it means we'll have a much easier time reaching MOQ as instead of having 50 going for the UK kit, 30 for the German kit, and 20 for the Nordic kit we'll get maybe 80-90 people going for the full kit instead. Some buyers will be lost due to the inherent cost of a bigger kit but it's just about the only solution we have to this issue until the keyboard community has grown a whole lot more, or until manufacturers drop their MOQs. In GMK's case, they've already dropped from 250 to 150, and I believe they've run international add-on kits at less. As mentioned in the OP, I'm hoping they'll be willing to run this kit even if we don't hit 150, but we can't know for sure yet.

Should the GB end before we hit the MOQ, I will of course contact them and see if they'll run it at whatever amount we are at then. If not, we'll simply have to cancel.

OK, fair enough. Would you then consider supporting the 'included' layouts fully, maybe at the expense of some less used keys like the WKL bottom row?

Sorry for the quotation marks, but I can't agree that a set supports some locale until my gandpa would be a able to enter an email address using the keys.
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: Krakob on Mon, 20 February 2017, 15:03:58
would you consider running this split into three kits like this:

(Attachment Link)

It would give correct legends while keeping the price low by separating ansi and UK keys.

One of the core principles of the set is that it will not be split. In most GBs, you have ANSI as the default. For international support it's often just the bare necessities for ISO, maybe enough for correct ISO UK if you're lucky. German and nordic packs very often fail to hit MOQ due to all the segregation, which is pretty much why this set is run. From a business point of view, it makes sense because it means you can get more ANSI/US buyers by having a lower price, and if there are enough who are willing to buy an international kit, you can get those as well.

By combining our efforts into a single amount of purchases, it means we'll have a much easier time reaching MOQ as instead of having 50 going for the UK kit, 30 for the German kit, and 20 for the Nordic kit we'll get maybe 80-90 people going for the full kit instead. Some buyers will be lost due to the inherent cost of a bigger kit but it's just about the only solution we have to this issue until the keyboard community has grown a whole lot more, or until manufacturers drop their MOQs. In GMK's case, they've already dropped from 250 to 150, and I believe they've run international add-on kits at less. As mentioned in the OP, I'm hoping they'll be willing to run this kit even if we don't hit 150, but we can't know for sure yet.

Should the GB end before we hit the MOQ, I will of course contact them and see if they'll run it at whatever amount we are at then. If not, we'll simply have to cancel.

OK, fair enough. Would you then consider supporting the 'included' layouts fully, maybe at the expense of some less used keys like the WKL bottom row?

Sorry for the quotation marks, but I can't agree that a set supports some locale until my gandpa would be a able to enter an email address using the keys.
I totally understand, but I think the use case for WKL and such is bigger than the need for tertiary legends is. The biggest issue with those is that we'd have to add a pretty big amount of keys in order to satisfy all of the included locales, which raises the price and in turn makes MOQ harder to reach, making it contrary to the goal of this set.

I don't think the colour scheme should be a concern. If the GB is successful, other rounds with different colours could be run.
This is something I've given a bit of thought! I wanted to avoid getting ahead of myself but as the community grows, there will be opportunities to run even bigger sets with more variations for niches like this. This run should serve as a good measure of how big the current UK/DE/Nordic community is and show us what we can aim for right now and what might have to wait for the future.
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: TalkingTree on Mon, 20 February 2017, 15:12:09
This run should serve as a good measure of how big the current UK/DE/Nordic community is and show us what we can aim for right now and what might have to wait for the future.
This. That's the very goal of this GB, in my opinion. The colour scheme, for this run, is secondary. Props to you for trying.
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: longtran1568 on Mon, 20 February 2017, 16:35:03
Thank you for hearing me out!

Now that Del, End and Page Down are R1 I can fill my 96 keys keyboard :)


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: mathiasn on Tue, 21 February 2017, 01:59:20
We-ell :-\, DE :D :thumb:, but black :(.

In fact, I'm not sure if any white on black double shot sets that cover nordic/german have made it to the market.

If you're looking for German black on white caps of similar quality, I believe you may have a relatively easy time finding them on vintage Cherry boards :)

Sure, just my opinion.
(and, btw. I've got some 5 vintage Cherrys at home)

https://www.computerbase.de/forum/showthread.php?t=1601148 (https://www.computerbase.de/forum/showthread.php?t=1601148) made it to some 120 for DE alone
(I'm not organizing that, numbers added up just from that thread).
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: My_Thoughts on Tue, 21 February 2017, 03:05:25
When are you going to run this?  GMK Yuri and GMK Nautilus happen soon
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: Krakob on Tue, 21 February 2017, 04:00:08
When are you going to run this?  GMK Yuri and GMK Nautilus happen soon
Submitting to GMK on Friday, albeit I'm already in touch with them! I got a quote for an earlier revision of the set this morning and it looks like it's ending at about €115 + shipping. That's with VAT, shipping to me, and profit margin included!

Currently not sure exactly how much the shipping will be but I think it will be around €15 worldwide at most. It depends on the weight and dimensions of the packages.
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: pomk on Thu, 23 February 2017, 02:24:03
would you consider running this split into three kits like this:

(Attachment Link)

It would give correct legends while keeping the price low by separating ansi and UK keys.

One of the core principles of the set is that it will not be split. In most GBs, you have ANSI as the default. For international support it's often just the bare necessities for ISO, maybe enough for correct ISO UK if you're lucky. German and nordic packs very often fail to hit MOQ due to all the segregation, which is pretty much why this set is run. From a business point of view, it makes sense because it means you can get more ANSI/US buyers by having a lower price, and if there are enough who are willing to buy an international kit, you can get those as well.

By combining our efforts into a single amount of purchases, it means we'll have a much easier time reaching MOQ as instead of having 50 going for the UK kit, 30 for the German kit, and 20 for the Nordic kit we'll get maybe 80-90 people going for the full kit instead. Some buyers will be lost due to the inherent cost of a bigger kit but it's just about the only solution we have to this issue until the keyboard community has grown a whole lot more, or until manufacturers drop their MOQs. In GMK's case, they've already dropped from 250 to 150, and I believe they've run international add-on kits at less. As mentioned in the OP, I'm hoping they'll be willing to run this kit even if we don't hit 150, but we can't know for sure yet.

Should the GB end before we hit the MOQ, I will of course contact them and see if they'll run it at whatever amount we are at then. If not, we'll simply have to cancel.

OK, fair enough. Would you then consider supporting the 'included' layouts fully, maybe at the expense of some less used keys like the WKL bottom row?

Sorry for the quotation marks, but I can't agree that a set supports some locale until my gandpa would be a able to enter an email address using the keys.
I totally understand, but I think the use case for WKL and such is bigger than the need for tertiary legends is. The biggest issue with those is that we'd have to add a pretty big amount of keys in order to satisfy all of the included locales, which raises the price and in turn makes MOQ harder to reach, making it contrary to the goal of this set.


You seem quite set on the kit already, but I'll just ask one more thing.

How about getting rid of the UK support, and then supporting (just) the full de/swe/dk/fi/no?
UK GMK sets exist already and many different ones are in stock for one to purchase. The thing is that I find it hard to believe that someone would purchase a limited UK set like this instead of one that would include all of the keys necessary for that locale.

The end result would be to have full support for five locales (instead of none) at a cheaper price, while just losing a couple of people who wish to have an incomplete UK GMK set instead of a full one for a very limited margin.

Just a thought. Good luck with the buy however you decide to continue!  :thumb:
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: Krakob on Thu, 23 February 2017, 02:32:17
would you consider running this split into three kits like this:

(Attachment Link)

It would give correct legends while keeping the price low by separating ansi and UK keys.

One of the core principles of the set is that it will not be split. In most GBs, you have ANSI as the default. For international support it's often just the bare necessities for ISO, maybe enough for correct ISO UK if you're lucky. German and nordic packs very often fail to hit MOQ due to all the segregation, which is pretty much why this set is run. From a business point of view, it makes sense because it means you can get more ANSI/US buyers by having a lower price, and if there are enough who are willing to buy an international kit, you can get those as well.

By combining our efforts into a single amount of purchases, it means we'll have a much easier time reaching MOQ as instead of having 50 going for the UK kit, 30 for the German kit, and 20 for the Nordic kit we'll get maybe 80-90 people going for the full kit instead. Some buyers will be lost due to the inherent cost of a bigger kit but it's just about the only solution we have to this issue until the keyboard community has grown a whole lot more, or until manufacturers drop their MOQs. In GMK's case, they've already dropped from 250 to 150, and I believe they've run international add-on kits at less. As mentioned in the OP, I'm hoping they'll be willing to run this kit even if we don't hit 150, but we can't know for sure yet.

Should the GB end before we hit the MOQ, I will of course contact them and see if they'll run it at whatever amount we are at then. If not, we'll simply have to cancel.

OK, fair enough. Would you then consider supporting the 'included' layouts fully, maybe at the expense of some less used keys like the WKL bottom row?

Sorry for the quotation marks, but I can't agree that a set supports some locale until my gandpa would be a able to enter an email address using the keys.
I totally understand, but I think the use case for WKL and such is bigger than the need for tertiary legends is. The biggest issue with those is that we'd have to add a pretty big amount of keys in order to satisfy all of the included locales, which raises the price and in turn makes MOQ harder to reach, making it contrary to the goal of this set.


You seem quite set on the kit already, but I'll just ask one more thing.

How about getting rid of the UK support, and then supporting (just) the full de/swe/dk/fi/no?
UK GMK sets exist already and many different ones are in stock for one to purchase. The thing is that I find it hard to believe that someone would purchase a limited UK set like this instead of one that would include all of the keys necessary for that locale.

The end result would be to have full support for five locales (instead of none) at a cheaper price, while just losing a couple of people who wish to have an incomplete UK GMK set instead of a full one for a very limited margin.

Just a thought. Good luck with the buy however you decide to continue!  :thumb:
Well, the only other GMK white on black kit that I know of is originative, and it doesn't provide proper UK support, just the minimum in order to have the set fill an ISO board. A lot of kits do the same, albeit a few have succeeded in full support for non-US locales.

The biggest appeal here is the price combined with better coverage. Only a couple of legends are incorrect for ISO UK, and the price is going to be around €60 cheaper than originative while also not being subject to import taxes and possibly having cheaper shipping.
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: pomk on Thu, 23 February 2017, 02:57:13
Well, good luck!

if this fails will you then reconsider? I'd very much like some GMK in my life.
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: Krakob on Thu, 23 February 2017, 03:10:28
Well, good luck!

if this fails will you then reconsider? I'd very much like some GMK in my life.
I might, depending on the buyers. If it's 80% UK buyers for example, it would probably not succeed without them.
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: Abefyren on Thu, 23 February 2017, 04:11:38
This is a really nice step towards more sets for us northern europeans. I was pretty bummed, that the international kit for Terminal did not hit MOQ.
I have one thing though.
Would you consider adding another 1X1 R4 key next to left shift with < > \ for Danish layout?
And also either another 3 key with # and £ or adding it to the existing for Norwegian and Danish layout.
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: My_Thoughts on Thu, 23 February 2017, 04:22:37

How about getting rid of the UK support, and then supporting (just) the full de/swe/dk/fi/no?
UK GMK sets exist already and many different ones are in stock for one to purchase. The thing is that I find it hard to believe that someone would purchase a limited UK set like this instead of one that would include all of the keys necessary for that locale.


How is this an incomplete UK ISO set?  As far as I can see the only thing missing is the secondary € symbol on the 4 key but I don't believe that has ever been offered in a GMK group buy and for reasons already explained in this thread it's not being offered here.  Apart from that minor issue this is a complete UK ISO set I think
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: pomk on Thu, 23 February 2017, 04:23:49
The key next to '1' is missing
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: Krakob on Thu, 23 February 2017, 04:32:44
This is a really nice step towards more sets for us northern europeans. I was pretty bummed, that the international kit for Terminal did not hit MOQ.
I have one thing though.
Would you consider adding another 1X1 R4 key next to left shift with < > \ for Danish layout?
And also either another 3 key with # and £ or adding it to the existing for Norwegian and Danish layout.

Thanks for pointing out the < > \ key! It will be changed to just < > . There will also be a few changes to the number row in order to make it more consistent with the design philosophy, as I noticed a few issues while looking into this.
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: Abefyren on Thu, 23 February 2017, 05:49:16
This is a really nice step towards more sets for us northern europeans. I was pretty bummed, that the international kit for Terminal did not hit MOQ.
I have one thing though.
Would you consider adding another 1X1 R4 key next to left shift with < > \ for Danish layout?
And also either another 3 key with # and £ or adding it to the existing for Norwegian and Danish layout.

Thanks for pointing out the < > \ key! It will be changed to just < > . There will also be a few changes to the number row in order to make it more consistent with the design philosophy, as I noticed a few issues while looking into this.


Nice.

You are doing some great work here. I really appreciate it. :thumb:
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: My_Thoughts on Thu, 23 February 2017, 06:12:53
The key next to '1' is missing

That key is different on every ISO layout and I cannot remember ever using it.  I like the idea of replacing it with a cherry :)
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: Findecanor on Thu, 23 February 2017, 06:48:19
I suppose that the chart is not literal. I believe GMK uses ISO row numbering, not SP row numbering.

No need for ANSI Enter.
Is the home-row Control key stepped or centre-stemmed?
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: Giorgio on Thu, 23 February 2017, 07:16:38
Considering that this set is identical to originative, could it be considered a good idea to offer an addon including only the european keys?

Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: Krakob on Thu, 23 February 2017, 07:38:06
I suppose that the chart is not literal. I believe GMK uses ISO row numbering, not SP row numbering.

No need for ANSI Enter.
Is the home-row Control key stepped or centre-stemmed?
I suppose, I am only familiar with this form of row numbering, seems to be the most common (even used in GMK renders afaik)

ANSI is only supported through left shift, enter, and pipe so as to enable people who may prefer ANSI but still use their own layout or just plain ANSI users who would like a cheap set. It's a pretty small price for a huge benefit!

Home row Ctrl is center stem, as it is on HHKB. I hadn't seen a stepped Ctrl key before but I feel like it's too niche as both home row Ctrl and stepped caps are supported and I wouldn't imagine a lot of people mix the two.
Considering that this set is identical to originative, could it be considered a good idea to offer an addon including only the european keys?


No, addon kits failing to reach MOQ is the reason we almost never see some locales covered. Not to mention, this full kit will be far cheaper than Originative. If this set is very successful, it might be reasonable to run a similar set covering even more locales like French, Spanish, Portugese, Mongolian, Vatican, etc.
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: Giorgio on Thu, 23 February 2017, 07:51:24
I suppose that the chart is not literal. I believe GMK uses ISO row numbering, not SP row numbering.

No need for ANSI Enter.
Is the home-row Control key stepped or centre-stemmed?
I suppose, I am only familiar with this form of row numbering, seems to be the most common (even used in GMK renders afaik)

ANSI is only supported through left shift, enter, and pipe so as to enable people who may prefer ANSI but still use their own layout or just plain ANSI users who would like a cheap set. It's a pretty small price for a huge benefit!

Home row Ctrl is center stem, as it is on HHKB. I hadn't seen a stepped Ctrl key before but I feel like it's too niche as both home row Ctrl and stepped caps are supported and I wouldn't imagine a lot of people mix the two.
Considering that this set is identical to originative, could it be considered a good idea to offer an addon including only the european keys?


No, addon kits failing to reach MOQ is the reason we almost never see some locales covered. Not to mention, this full kit will be far cheaper than Originative. If this set is very successful, it might be reasonable to run a similar set covering even more locales like French, Spanish, Portugese, Mongolian, Vatican, etc.

Vatican layout?
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: Krakob on Thu, 23 February 2017, 08:41:38
I suppose that the chart is not literal. I believe GMK uses ISO row numbering, not SP row numbering.

No need for ANSI Enter.
Is the home-row Control key stepped or centre-stemmed?
I suppose, I am only familiar with this form of row numbering, seems to be the most common (even used in GMK renders afaik)

ANSI is only supported through left shift, enter, and pipe so as to enable people who may prefer ANSI but still use their own layout or just plain ANSI users who would like a cheap set. It's a pretty small price for a huge benefit!

Home row Ctrl is center stem, as it is on HHKB. I hadn't seen a stepped Ctrl key before but I feel like it's too niche as both home row Ctrl and stepped caps are supported and I wouldn't imagine a lot of people mix the two.
Considering that this set is identical to originative, could it be considered a good idea to offer an addon including only the european keys?


No, addon kits failing to reach MOQ is the reason we almost never see some locales covered. Not to mention, this full kit will be far cheaper than Originative. If this set is very successful, it might be reasonable to run a similar set covering even more locales like French, Spanish, Portugese, Mongolian, Vatican, etc.

Vatican layout?
Gotta look out for the holy father ;)
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: Giorgio on Thu, 23 February 2017, 09:10:31
I suppose that the chart is not literal. I believe GMK uses ISO row numbering, not SP row numbering.

No need for ANSI Enter.
Is the home-row Control key stepped or centre-stemmed?
I suppose, I am only familiar with this form of row numbering, seems to be the most common (even used in GMK renders afaik)

ANSI is only supported through left shift, enter, and pipe so as to enable people who may prefer ANSI but still use their own layout or just plain ANSI users who would like a cheap set. It's a pretty small price for a huge benefit!

Home row Ctrl is center stem, as it is on HHKB. I hadn't seen a stepped Ctrl key before but I feel like it's too niche as both home row Ctrl and stepped caps are supported and I wouldn't imagine a lot of people mix the two.
Considering that this set is identical to originative, could it be considered a good idea to offer an addon including only the european keys?


No, addon kits failing to reach MOQ is the reason we almost never see some locales covered. Not to mention, this full kit will be far cheaper than Originative. If this set is very successful, it might be reasonable to run a similar set covering even more locales like French, Spanish, Portugese, Mongolian, Vatican, etc.

Vatican layout?
Gotta look out for the holy father ;)

[attachimg=1]
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: Krakob on Thu, 23 February 2017, 15:59:23
Last few changes! Noticed that the norwegian backslash/grave key would've been incorrect (backslash is the neutral state), so it needed a new key. Pipe has been removed from < >, as is in line with the idea of correct first and secondary legends, but tertiary may be removed to reduce key count. £ was added to 3 #, as only SE and DK use 3 #, so there's no conflicts with the pound sign there.

Submitting to GMK tomorrow European evening, so approx. 18 GMT. Please voice any concerns about incorrect legends before then! (Remember, first and second must be correct, third will be removed if it means one key less; no tertiary legend may be incorrect, only removed)

Changes marked in red:
[attach=1]
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: Krakob on Fri, 24 February 2017, 13:53:43
I have now sent a request for a final quote and a render! Hopefully the GB can start in two or three weeks, depending on how long it takes for GMK to get back and for me to set up :)
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: dsaf on Fri, 24 February 2017, 17:30:26
Two questions:

1) Which GMK white exactly?
2) Which GMK black exactly?

Just want to know GMK Stormtrooper combinability.
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: Krakob on Fri, 24 February 2017, 17:41:17
Two questions:

1) Which GMK white exactly?
2) Which GMK black exactly?

Just want to know GMK Stormtrooper combinability.
The whitest white on the blackest black, should've made that clearer. So WS1 on CR.
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: Geroximo on Fri, 24 February 2017, 19:44:34
I love my ISO-DE so I would definitely be down for 2 sets, but the white on black is just the most boring colorway I could think of.
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: pon10 on Fri, 24 February 2017, 23:35:36
IN, IN, IN. Price does not matter (only a little) just as long as we can get more norde kits to hit MOQ.
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: Krakob on Sat, 25 February 2017, 06:24:03


[...] white on black is just the most boring colorway I could think of.

Exactly what I aimed for ;)

A simple design to gauge the market and give us something neutral but high quality
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: My_Thoughts on Sat, 25 February 2017, 06:52:32
I love my ISO-DE so I would definitely be down for 2 sets, but the white on black is just the most boring colorway I could think of.

If I can sort some funds out I will  get one to support the idea but yes, this really is a boring colourway :(
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: longtran1568 on Sat, 25 February 2017, 11:51:01
I still REALLY wish that this set would be BLACK ON WHITE. It would be not only more beautiful but easier to mix and match with other GMK sets. There are more GMK sets with white alpha than black.  :thumb:
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: HerrGartenzwerg on Sun, 26 February 2017, 08:46:22
I still REALLY wish that this set would be BLACK ON WHITE. It would be not only more beautiful but easier to mix and match with other GMK sets. There are more GMK sets with white alpha than black.  :thumb:

Same here.
A Black on white set for ~150€ would have been an instant buy for me. As it is now, I will see what the final price is and decide then.
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: pon10 on Sun, 26 February 2017, 09:02:49
My WF keyset lastet about a week being white.. I prefer darker caps  :cool:
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: DuFF on Sun, 26 February 2017, 09:45:07
while black on white probably would mix better with other keysets, im in anyway.
thinking about not canceling gmk plum and mixing it with this one.  :p
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: Findecanor on Sun, 26 February 2017, 11:30:25
I think German double-shot white-on-black is much easier to get hold of otherwise than any of the other layouts that are supported by this set.

I'm a cheap bastard who already has a lot of white-on-black keys from German keyboards and a couple others, so I would prefer getting only the missing keys that are special to Swedish/Finnish layout.
That would mean waiting until the run is over and then buy leftovers from some British guy. But it wouldn't work if everyone else in the Nordic countries did that.
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: Krakob on Sun, 26 February 2017, 11:54:00
I think German double-shot white-on-black is much easier to get hold of otherwise than any of the other layouts that are supported by this set.

I'm a cheap bastard who already has a lot of white-on-black keys from German keyboards and a couple others, so I would prefer getting only the missing keys that are special to Swedish/Finnish layout.
That would mean waiting until the run is over and then buy leftovers from some British guy. But it wouldn't work if everyone else in the Nordic countries did that.
But surely you want some brand new caps? There will be no colour matching issues and they'll have that nice factory new smell and just be astonishing quality! ;)
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: arsenics on Wed, 01 March 2017, 23:51:19
I want some brand new caps! Any news from GMK?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: Krakob on Thu, 02 March 2017, 01:31:50
I want some brand new caps! Any news from GMK?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro
They're working on the render! Sadly they aren't allowed to distribute Cherry logo keys, so it has been changed back to blank.
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: LeandreN on Thu, 02 March 2017, 02:56:05
This fantastic keyset by CMD/Originative has support:

https://www.originativeco.com/products/blue-alert-international-kit

Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: My_Thoughts on Thu, 02 March 2017, 03:29:00
I want some brand new caps! Any news from GMK?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro
They're working on the render! Sadly they aren't allowed to distribute Cherry logo keys, so it has been changed back to blank.

But they made these:
https://geekhack.org/index.php?topic=79230.0
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: Krakob on Thu, 02 March 2017, 03:51:44
I want some brand new caps! Any news from GMK?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro
They're working on the render! Sadly they aren't allowed to distribute Cherry logo keys, so it has been changed back to blank.

But they made these:
https://geekhack.org/index.php?topic=79230.0
Here's what GMK told me:
Quote
Your draft includes a Cherry logo key. Due to the copyright we are not allowed to offer these keys to other companies/people.
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: TalkingTree on Thu, 02 March 2017, 03:57:30
But they made these:
https://geekhack.org/index.php?topic=79230.0
That's a generic cherry novelty, I don't think they are copyrighted.

xiaodian317 had a keyset (https://geekhack.org/index.php?topic=80942.0;topicseen) made with the actual Cherry logo but, as far as I know, he's a ZF Electronics employee.
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: My_Thoughts on Thu, 02 March 2017, 08:03:55
D'oh
I liked the idea of the white cherry on black
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: Krakob on Thu, 02 March 2017, 10:35:20
D'oh
I liked the idea of the white cherry on black

Could always get one separately ;)

In other news, the render is already here! GB launching in a week, give or take a few days if everything goes according to plan.
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: pon10 on Thu, 02 March 2017, 12:03:45
Maybe the blank cap could be a little more creative?
any other graphic to put in use other then the cherry copyrighted logo? or maybe a color?..

No "2" with a @ key for DK?

Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: Krakob on Thu, 02 March 2017, 12:24:19
Maybe the blank cap could be a little more creative?
any other graphic to put in use other then the cherry copyrighted logo? or maybe a color?..

No "2" with a @ key for DK?

The GMK and Uniqey logos were considered, but I chose not to use them since they're text based, and not icons, which kind of breaks the style.

The @ is not included since it's a tertiary legend, and would require adding an extra key.
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: pomk on Thu, 02 March 2017, 12:24:32
Maybe something like this for that key next to '1'?  :))
[attachimg=1]
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: Krakob on Thu, 02 March 2017, 12:27:09
Maybe something like this for that key next to '1'?  :))
(Attachment Link)

That is contradictory to the design ideals, i.e. no legend may be incorrect, tertiary legends may be missing. It would probably require a new mold as well, which is quite expensive!
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: pomk on Thu, 02 March 2017, 13:04:37
the tertiary to senary legends can be pad printed ;)
IMO some legend like a novelty in better than none.
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: dorf on Sat, 04 March 2017, 15:09:04
In other news, the render is already here! GB launching in a week, give or take a few days if everything goes according to plan.

We're good to go! Let's make it happen. Do you have a price indication at this point?
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: Krakob on Sat, 04 March 2017, 15:18:30
In other news, the render is already here! GB launching in a week, give or take a few days if everything goes according to plan.

We're good to go! Let's make it happen. Do you have a price indication at this point?
Going by the last quote, about €135 shipped. I can't say what the shipping will be yet, so I counted with €20. It depends on the weight and dimensions, for which I have nothing but guesses so far. €20 is a relatively high guess though. Worst case in case GMK can't give a good estimate of measurements, I'll take €20 and just offer partial refunds.
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans
Post by: Krakob on Sun, 19 March 2017, 04:38:09
Update: no update. Haven't heard back since the 2nd, so I'm going to pop them another mail.
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans [GB started]
Post by: pon10 on Wed, 03 January 2018, 17:38:47
Can we try again? :p
Title: .
Post by: TastyNico on Wed, 03 January 2018, 18:44:48
.
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans [GB started]
Post by: CandyKeys on Wed, 03 January 2018, 18:55:39
This is really nice, pitching in from the EU side here.

The whole talk of what is successful regarding NORDE kits and all that stuff is really hard to judge. The idea is great, 135 EUR is still steep if that ends up being the final price, I think it could be cheaper.
We are currently on the same page with cheap GMK sets with GMK Fishbed, so the base will be really cheap and the add-on a bit more expensive due to custom molds. From what I know it does not make a difference what color the set is and all, white on black is a smart decision as that will be the preferred one.

Krakob, I can help you with the shipping cost ideas, if you want to ship to Sweden from Germany or wherever you are located, you should be able to ship at around 1 EUR per set to you and then the shipping costs from your country is up to you.

If each set weights half a kilo, you have a 40cm by 40cm by 40cm squared box and you put 20 sets in each box, it should be roughly 1 EUR to the set. Hope that helps :)

Maybe discussing another packaging option to make it even cheaper would be an option but not sure if you would have to provide the material yourself or not.


I wish you the best for the GB!
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans [GB started]
Post by: Puddsy on Wed, 03 January 2018, 18:58:32
This is really nice, pitching in from the EU side here.

The whole talk of what is successful regarding NORDE kits and all that stuff is really hard to judge. The idea is great, 135 EUR is still steep if that ends up being the final price, I think it could be cheaper.
We are currently on the same page with cheap GMK sets with GMK Fishbed, so the base will be really cheap and the add-on a bit more expensive due to custom molds. From what I know it does not make a difference what color the set is and all, white on black is a smart decision as that will be the preferred one.

Krakob, I can help you with the shipping cost ideas, if you want to ship to Sweden from Germany or wherever you are located, you should be able to ship at around 1 EUR per set to you and then the shipping costs from your country is up to you.

If each set weights half a kilo, you have a 40cm by 40cm by 40cm squared box and you put 20 sets in each box, it should be roughly 1 EUR to the set. Hope that helps :)

Maybe discussing another packaging option to make it even cheaper would be an option but not sure if you would have to provide the material yourself or not.

I wish you the best for the GB!

you know that this ran and failed miserably, right?
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans [GB started]
Post by: Krakob on Thu, 04 January 2018, 03:22:30
Can we try again?
Hey! I'm pursuing other projects right now, so I'm afraid I won't be trying this. Should I get some decent income, I would honestly consider saving up to buy the sets myself but I am but a poor student hahaha
This is really nice, pitching in from the EU side here.

The whole talk of what is successful regarding NORDE kits and all that stuff is really hard to judge. The idea is great, 135 EUR is still steep if that ends up being the final price, I think it could be cheaper.
We are currently on the same page with cheap GMK sets with GMK Fishbed, so the base will be really cheap and the add-on a bit more expensive due to custom molds. From what I know it does not make a difference what color the set is and all, white on black is a smart decision as that will be the preferred one.

Krakob, I can help you with the shipping cost ideas, if you want to ship to Sweden from Germany or wherever you are located, you should be able to ship at around 1 EUR per set to you and then the shipping costs from your country is up to you.

If each set weights half a kilo, you have a 40cm by 40cm by 40cm squared box and you put 20 sets in each box, it should be roughly 1 EUR to the set. Hope that helps :)

Maybe discussing another packaging option to make it even cheaper would be an option but not sure if you would have to provide the material yourself or not.

I wish you the best for the GB!
Hey! Thanks for the input, but as mentioned we tried running the GB a few months ago without luck. Got some MX silvers from you the other day by the way, they're going in a pretty cool thing coming up :)
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans [GB started]
Post by: CandyKeys on Thu, 04 January 2018, 05:27:18
This is really nice, pitching in from the EU side here.

The whole talk of what is successful regarding NORDE kits and all that stuff is really hard to judge. The idea is great, 135 EUR is still steep if that ends up being the final price, I think it could be cheaper.
We are currently on the same page with cheap GMK sets with GMK Fishbed, so the base will be really cheap and the add-on a bit more expensive due to custom molds. From what I know it does not make a difference what color the set is and all, white on black is a smart decision as that will be the preferred one.

Krakob, I can help you with the shipping cost ideas, if you want to ship to Sweden from Germany or wherever you are located, you should be able to ship at around 1 EUR per set to you and then the shipping costs from your country is up to you.

If each set weights half a kilo, you have a 40cm by 40cm by 40cm squared box and you put 20 sets in each box, it should be roughly 1 EUR to the set. Hope that helps :)

Maybe discussing another packaging option to make it even cheaper would be an option but not sure if you would have to provide the material yourself or not.

I wish you the best for the GB!

you know that this ran and failed miserably, right?

Am aware, sorry, 3 in the morning shenanigans and brain shut-off
Title: Re: [IC] GMK NorDeUK - cheap GMK for Europeans [GB started]
Post by: avid on Thu, 04 January 2018, 06:55:22
I would really love to see a GMK WoB keyset being ran. Doesnt need to be norde, but rather normal to hit MOQ