Author Topic: Ars Reviews Ubuntu 10.04  (Read 13801 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline Rajagra

  • Posts: 1930
Ars Reviews Ubuntu 10.04
« Reply #50 on: Thu, 20 May 2010, 18:23:42 »
Quote from: ch_123;184994
people are like "HURR DURR COMMAND LINE LOLOLOL" and fail to appreciate that it's objectively better by just about any metric.


How about intuitiveness?

Quote
Linux -

1) Open a terminal.
2) [OPTIONAL] I run 'apt-cache search xyz' if I dont know the exact name of the software package I'm looking for.
3) Type 'sudo apt-get install zyx'


Point proven.

If you could type in "help how do I install a new program" and it gave you concise, clear instructions (as above), then it wouldn't matter so much.

Offline ch_123

  • * Exalted Elder
  • Posts: 5860
Ars Reviews Ubuntu 10.04
« Reply #51 on: Thu, 20 May 2010, 18:26:50 »
Quote
Point proven.


Which is?

Quote
If you could type in "help how do I install a new program" and it gave you concise, clear instructions (as above), then it wouldn't matter so much.


Oh no! People have to learn two commands to install software on their computers! God forbid that they have to have any concept about what they are doing!

Actually, god forbid that indeed... People like me would be out of a job!

Excuse me while I Mac-rant here, but the most retarded thing is the Mac OS X installation process. It gives you a dialog box which shows an icon of the software, and an icon of your hard drive, and asks you to drag the software icon to the hard drive icon... Words escape me when I think about all the things wrong about this...
« Last Edit: Thu, 20 May 2010, 18:29:12 by ch_123 »

Offline kishy

  • Posts: 1576
  • Location: Windsor, ON Canada
  • Eye Bee M
    • http://kishy.ca/
Ars Reviews Ubuntu 10.04
« Reply #52 on: Thu, 20 May 2010, 18:27:33 »
I don't think anyone said Linux needed a better package management system...just that whoever made the remark was saying they didn't like it.

Certainly the case with me. The comparison you provided ch is definitely accurate, but I (if anyone cares what I think) prefer the Windows way. Inefficient? Sure...but it does what I want better than a package manager. That's my opinion, so it doesn't need justification. You're absolutely right that when you remove opinion, package managers are better.
Enthusiast of springs which buckle noisily: my keyboards
Want to learn about the Kishsaver?
kishy.ca

Offline TexasFlood

  • Posts: 1084
Ars Reviews Ubuntu 10.04
« Reply #53 on: Thu, 20 May 2010, 18:28:36 »
Quote from: ripster;184775
Does this version require the ability to compile your own drivers as well?   Maybe I should stop following this thread..........


I'm a cheap so and so.

I bought this card on a Newegg shell shocker deal without even bothering to check the driver situation.  As it turned out I didn't find Linux drivers on the Belkin support site.  I tried to load the windows driver via ndiswrapper but that didn't work.  Well, actually it worked but only as 802.11g as with the built-in driver.  The drivers within Ubuntu had also worked "right out of the box" so to speak, just not at 802.11n speeds.  This is better than I probably deserved considering that I didn't check up front.  But as I posted earlier, I did find generic Linux source code on the chipset vendor website and was able to compile a working 802.11n driver from that.

Compare this to a few years ago when I bought an 802.11g card on clearance for my Windows box.  It had drivers but they were old and terrible and not going to get better since the company selling them was not going to develop them any more.  I spent much more time looking for Windows drivers for that card and it never really worked as well as I would have liked.

Both situations were the result of my short sighted cheapness.  I feel at least as good about the Linux situation than the Windows, if not better.  From my perspective I'm running the lastest released code for this card's chipset compiled right on my box.  Heck if I had a little more time and gumption I'd compile the firmware for my Linux based routers to, but I've so far been proven too lazy to do that.  To be honest had there been a binary up there I would have just grabbed it and called it good, but there wasn't.  So if I wanted the latest version I had to compile it.

Folks don't seem to shy away from compiling their own stuff so much in the Linux world and it isn't considered as extreme a thing to do as in the Windows world.  But it's not typically REQUIRED.  In fact it wasn't required in my case for the card to work, it worked out of the box.  But considering Belkin didn't offer Linux drivers, it was the only choice I found if I wanted to run at 802.11n speeds.

Offline kishy

  • Posts: 1576
  • Location: Windsor, ON Canada
  • Eye Bee M
    • http://kishy.ca/
Ars Reviews Ubuntu 10.04
« Reply #54 on: Thu, 20 May 2010, 18:30:39 »
Quote from: TexasFlood;185005
I'm a cheap so and so.

I bought this card on a Newegg shell shocker deal without even bothering to check the driver situation.  As it turned out I didn't find Linux drivers on the Belkin support site.  I tried to load the windows driver via ndiswrapper but that didn't work.  Well, actually it worked but only as 802.11g as with the built-in driver.  The drivers within Ubuntu had also worked "right out of the box" so to speak, just not at 802.11n speeds.  This is better than I probably deserved considering that I didn't check up front.  But as I posted earlier, I did find generic Linux source code on the chipset vendor website and was able to compile a working 802.11n driver from that.

Compare this to a few years ago when I bought an 802.11g card on clearance for my Windows box.  It had drivers but they were old and terrible and not going to get better since the company selling them was not going to develop them any more.  I spent much more time looking for Windows drivers for that card and it never really worked as well as I would have liked.

Both situations were the result of my short sighted cheapness.  I feel at least as good about the Linux situation than the Windows, if not better.  From my perspective I'm running the lastest released code for this card's chipset compiled right on my box.  Heck if I had a little more time and gumption I'd compile the firmware for my Linux based routers to, but I've so far been proven too lazy to do that.  To be honest had there been a binary up there I would have just grabbed it and called it good, but there wasn't.  So if I wanted the latest version I had to compile it.

Folks don't seem to shy away from compiling their own stuff so much in the Linux world and it isn't considered as extreme a thing to do as in the Windows world.  But it's not typically REQUIRED.  In fact it wasn't required in my case for the card to work, it worked out of the box.  But considering Belkin didn't offer Linux drivers, it was the only choice I found if I wanted to run at 802.11n speeds.


Suggesting someone is cheap for buying Belkin (just an example) which happens to be a reputable company which manufacturers decent quality products is ridiculous.
Enthusiast of springs which buckle noisily: my keyboards
Want to learn about the Kishsaver?
kishy.ca

Offline ch_123

  • * Exalted Elder
  • Posts: 5860
Ars Reviews Ubuntu 10.04
« Reply #55 on: Thu, 20 May 2010, 18:32:19 »
Usually I don't judge companies on the basis of one bad product... But after that router of their's I had....

Offline Rajagra

  • Posts: 1930
Ars Reviews Ubuntu 10.04
« Reply #56 on: Thu, 20 May 2010, 18:35:50 »
Quote from: ch_123;185003
Which is?

That obscure commands are not intuitive. Even when you know what they do it's hard to work out what the abbreviation/acronym stands for! SUDO? Even DOS had semi workoutable acronyms. Wanted to change directory? Type CD. Is there similar logic behind SUDO? It sure as hell doesn't stand for Install Application.

Quote
Oh no! People have to learn two commands to install software on their computers! God forbid that they have to have any concept about what they are doing!

That attitude is precisely why Linux has the odds against it. An unwillingness to meet users half way.

Offline kishy

  • Posts: 1576
  • Location: Windsor, ON Canada
  • Eye Bee M
    • http://kishy.ca/
Ars Reviews Ubuntu 10.04
« Reply #57 on: Thu, 20 May 2010, 18:35:57 »
Quote from: ch_123;185009
Usually I don't judge companies on the basis of one bad product... But after that router of their's I had....


My Wireless G router (I believe it's the -2000 revision, and not the G Plus) has proven to be pretty much excellent in range, throughput and connection reliability. It's got a funny LED glitch but no serious problems.

Friend has a G+ and also has had no issues.

Friend with an N, however...has experienced some minor connection issues.
Enthusiast of springs which buckle noisily: my keyboards
Want to learn about the Kishsaver?
kishy.ca

Offline kishy

  • Posts: 1576
  • Location: Windsor, ON Canada
  • Eye Bee M
    • http://kishy.ca/
Ars Reviews Ubuntu 10.04
« Reply #58 on: Thu, 20 May 2010, 18:36:39 »
Quote from: Rajagra;185010
That obscure commands are not intuitive. Even when you know what they do it's hard to work out what the abbreviation/acronym stands for! SUDO? Even DOS had semi workoutable acronyms. Wanted to change directory? Type CD. Is there similar logic behind SUDO? It sure as hell doesn't stand for Install Application.

Oh no! People have to learn two commands to install software on their computers! God forbid that they have to have any concept about what they are doing![/QUOTE]

That attitude is precisely why Linux has the odds against it. An unwillingness to meet users half way.[/QUOTE]

SUDO = Super User (or switch user, to super user) Do (basically, run as admin)

It is intuitive if you already know...lol.

This got butchered by someone's poor multiquoting, not sure whose exactly...
Enthusiast of springs which buckle noisily: my keyboards
Want to learn about the Kishsaver?
kishy.ca

Offline ch_123

  • * Exalted Elder
  • Posts: 5860
Ars Reviews Ubuntu 10.04
« Reply #59 on: Thu, 20 May 2010, 18:42:44 »
Quote from: Rajagra;185010
That obscure commands are not intuitive. Even when you know what they do it's hard to work out what the abbreviation/acronym stands for! SUDO? Even DOS had semi workoutable acronyms. Wanted to change directory? Type CD. Is there similar logic behind SUDO? It sure as hell doesn't stand for Install Application.


apt-get install is the thing that does the installation. sudo is a thing for running things with root privileges, coming from Super User DO, as far as I know. Linux has cd, Linux even has dir (although the preferred one is 'ls' for list)

Quote
That attitude is precisely why Linux has the odds against it. An unwillingness to meet users half way.


Let me get my Google Translate on that -

"It's not the same thing as Windows"

Seriously, have you ever sat back and objectively looked at the Windows experience after trying out most of the major alternatives? It's not a user friendly OS at all. I'm not saying Linux is either, and the sad fact is that all the good Linux distros out there require you to understand Linux well to get the most out of them. I'm just pointing out that a lot of stuff that people perceive as being difficult about Linux is in fact just because it's different to what they are used to.

Quote
My Wireless G router (I believe it's the -2000 revision, and not the G Plus) has proven to be pretty much excellent in range, throughput and connection reliability. It's got a funny LED glitch but no serious problems.

Friend has a G+ and also has had no issues.

Friend with an N, however...has experienced some minor connection issues.


Had a funny experience with one of their routers, but that's a story for another night... Linksys is the way to go for routers, although Dlink make some great ones too.
« Last Edit: Thu, 20 May 2010, 18:45:26 by ch_123 »

Offline kishy

  • Posts: 1576
  • Location: Windsor, ON Canada
  • Eye Bee M
    • http://kishy.ca/
Ars Reviews Ubuntu 10.04
« Reply #60 on: Thu, 20 May 2010, 18:46:27 »
Quote from: ch_123;185013
Had a funny experience with one of their routers, but that's a story for another night... Linksys is the way to go for routers, although Dlink make some great ones too.


My experiences with BOTH of those brands have been nothing short of hell...so I suppose experiences can vary lol :)
Enthusiast of springs which buckle noisily: my keyboards
Want to learn about the Kishsaver?
kishy.ca

Offline ch_123

  • * Exalted Elder
  • Posts: 5860
Ars Reviews Ubuntu 10.04
« Reply #61 on: Thu, 20 May 2010, 18:48:25 »
The WRT54 family is like the Model M of wireless routers...

My main bone of contention with Belkin was their customer service... Oh dear God...

Offline ch_123

  • * Exalted Elder
  • Posts: 5860
Ars Reviews Ubuntu 10.04
« Reply #62 on: Thu, 20 May 2010, 18:53:38 »
Quote from: kishy;185012

SUDO = Super User (or switch user, to super user) Do (basically, run as admin)

It is intuitive if you already know...lol.

This got butchered by someone's poor multiquoting, not sure whose exactly...


There's operating systems like DEC's VMS which is counterintuitive even if you know what you're doing with it...

Offline InSanCen

  • Posts: 560
Ars Reviews Ubuntu 10.04
« Reply #63 on: Thu, 20 May 2010, 19:05:59 »
Mint 9, on a torrent now.

Will play with that tomorrow. If it sorts my wireless issues, it's staying. Hopefully the Polaris window decorations still play nice with it.
Currently Using :- IBM M13 1996, Black :
Currently Own :- 1391406 1989 & 1990 : AT Model F 1985 : Boscom 122 (Black) : G80-3000 : G80-1800 (x2) : Wang 724 : G81-8000LPBGB (Card Reader, MY) : Unitek : AT102W : TVS Gold :
Project\'s :- Wang 724 Pink-->White Clicky : USB Model M : IBM LPFK :
Pointing stuff :- Logitech MX-518 : I-One Lynx R-15 Trackball : M13 Nipple : Microsoft Basic Optical\'s
:

Offline bigpook

  • Posts: 1723
Ars Reviews Ubuntu 10.04
« Reply #64 on: Thu, 20 May 2010, 19:28:10 »
Quote from: Rajagra;185010
That obscure commands are not intuitive. Even when you know what they do it's hard to work out what the abbreviation/acronym stands for! SUDO? Even DOS had semi workoutable acronyms. Wanted to change directory? Type CD. Is there similar logic behind SUDO? It sure as hell doesn't stand for Install Application.



That attitude is precisely why Linux has the odds against it. An unwillingness to meet users half way.


I started life using DOS 5 with windows 3.1. Running on a 486/33 w/ 4M ram. I had no computer experience prior to that and to make it even worse, was somewhat late to the game since I was in my late 20's.
As an aside, you kids today have no idea how good you got it when it comes to technology.

Anyways, I had to learn the DOS commands from scratch and after a few weeks, learn how to reinstall win 3.1. Needless to say, I got lots of practice.
I got into Linux around Redhat 5.1, only because my win95 box wouldn't stay up for more then two days at a time.
Linux was a complete mindf*ck for me. NOTHING was like I was used to. At that point, it was either persist or give up. I persisted and made myself learn something new.
Remember, everything is "unintuitive" when its new and alien.

Oddly, that seems to put me in the minority. I don't know anyone personally that runs linux.
Except for my wife and a friend in Phoenix.

The people that have seen it on my laptop comment on the cube and multiple desktops but have no interest in actually running it. Its too different, its not like windows, I don't want to learn something new.

One of the things that windows has in its favor is its huge installed base, and inertia. That along with people not liking change will keep it in the lead for a long time to come.

oh, linux does meet you halfway, but you need to do the same.
HHKB Pro 2 : Unicomp Spacesaver : IBM Model M : DasIII    

Offline TexasFlood

  • Posts: 1084
Ars Reviews Ubuntu 10.04
« Reply #65 on: Thu, 20 May 2010, 19:44:58 »
Marathon ginormous reply mode on, :biggrin:

Quote from: itlnstln;184785
I hate that.  I just want to double-click a setup executable and move on.

I can do that on Ubuntu now with a *.deb package, just prefer to work within the package manager to be more assured of getting tested packages.  But it's always an option.  For example when I read the review linked to in the first post of this thread, I learned about the pinta graphics software, downloaded the deb package, double-clicked it and installed easy as pie.

Quote from: ch_123;184994
Linux -

1) Open a terminal.
2) [OPTIONAL] I run 'apt-cache search xyz' if I dont know the exact name of the software package I'm looking for.
3) Type 'sudo apt-get install zyx'
4) I enter my password and press y.
5) Without any further intervention it downloads and completes.

You were saying something about a certain OS needing a better software installation procedure?


apt-get is pretty nice, but I still tend to be lazy and like some degree of a GUI so usually use the synaptic package manager.  It's fortunate for me though that Ubuntu has command line options.  When I screwed up my GUI by running out of disk space during package updates, I was able to go to the command line and upgrade to 10.04 by typing:
sudo apt-get update; sudo apt-get upgrade; apt-get dist-upgrade
After that everything worked fine.

Quote from: bigpook;184856
Software package management is very different on linux when compared to windows.

YMMV of course, but I have had good luck. Instead of searching the internet for drivers and software packages like I do for windows, I use synaptic or apt-get to access a software package database. If its in the repo, and theres lots of stuff in the repos, I click and install.  

I use both linux and windows, and really, its hard to beat apt-get for software management. Now, you could say that the software that is available for linux is ****. And I suppose to a certain degree that would be true; things like autocad, photoshop and other advanced apps are not available for linux. Thankfully, I don't use those apps so its not  like I am missing out.
But thats not the fault of linux. It would be up to the software vendor to write the app so it runs under linux. That is a whole nother story though.

Just for clarity, the only reason I even use windows (XP in a vm) is because the applications I do use are only available for windows and are needed by me to program the phone switches I work on. The past few years have brought some relief as the programming interfaces can now be accessed via a web browser.

I think the apt-get is great.  I do recognize though that not everyone is comfortable with a command line, although some love it.  To me it's a matter of what you are used to & comfortable with.  This can easily become a religious debate and I don't want to go there.  I can swing both ways myself, :wink:.  Synaptic is better for GUI oriented folks, or lazy folks like myself.  Folks should check out the Ubuntu Software Center covered in the review linked to at the start of this thread.  It's even more GUI oriented.

I agree, if Linux has an Achilles heel, it's the lack of some software packages, like Micro$oft Office/Visio, VPN software and Outlook which hamper it's widespread adoption as a desktop platform.  There are good alternatives like Open Office, Dia diagram editor, GIMP for Photoshop, Evolution or Outlook, etc.  This is some great software but might not cut it in a corporate environment although more than likely fine for most home use.  

Quote from: kishy;185008
Suggesting someone is cheap for buying Belkin (just an example) which happens to be a reputable company which manufacturers decent quality products is ridiculous.

Well, first it was me I was suggesting was cheap, :wink:.  It wasn't necessarily because the card was made by Belkin, any vendor can make a good or bad product.  It was because I bought it on sale without checking if one of the drivers I needed was available.  That's what I meant.

Quote from: ch_123;185018
The WRT54 family is like the Model M of wireless routers...

My main bone of contention with Belkin was their customer service... Oh dear God...

Unfortunately bad customer service seems epidemic now.  Fortunately I haven't needed it much.  I try to buy routers I can load good open source firmware on and never look back.  My first (wired) home router was a Netgear which I loaded Zyxel firmware on.  This was my first experience with hacking router firmware although it wasn't linux open source based.  Then I got a WRT54G wireless router, followed by a Motorola WR850G which was basically the same hardware, then an Asus, etc.  With the exception of that first router, now retired, they all run 3rd party open source linux code.  I now have 5 wireless routers running in my house, different brands, all happily playing nice with each other.  One, the Asus 802.11n router is my primary WAN router and access point.  The others really just supply Ethernet ports around the house where I need them as my house isn't wired.

Offline TexasFlood

  • Posts: 1084
Ars Reviews Ubuntu 10.04
« Reply #66 on: Thu, 20 May 2010, 19:46:53 »
Quote from: bigpook;185038
Oddly, that seems to put me in the minority. I don't know anyone personally that runs linux.
Except for my wife and a friend in Phoenix.

Quote from: ripster;185047
Now that's true love.  I would NEVER risk that with my wife.
Oh hell no.  Might have a little hacker in my soul and love Linux myself but I'm not that crazy.  YMMV, but I know my wife.

Offline bigpook

  • Posts: 1723
Ars Reviews Ubuntu 10.04
« Reply #67 on: Thu, 20 May 2010, 19:51:37 »
: ) My wife doesn't use much beyond the browser, thunderbird and our financial program. She could use any OS for that.
Nowadays, 95% of what she is doing is via a browser anyway.
HHKB Pro 2 : Unicomp Spacesaver : IBM Model M : DasIII    

Offline TexasFlood

  • Posts: 1084
Ars Reviews Ubuntu 10.04
« Reply #68 on: Thu, 20 May 2010, 20:16:13 »
Quote from: bigpook;185055
: ) My wife doesn't use much beyond the browser, thunderbird and our financial program. She could use any OS for that.
Nowadays, 95% of what she is doing is via a browser anyway.

Cool.  Linux is a cheap way to DIY "roll your own netbook" on a small old laptop.

Offline bigpook

  • Posts: 1723
Ars Reviews Ubuntu 10.04
« Reply #69 on: Thu, 20 May 2010, 20:22:45 »
no doubt. she has that too already on the asus 1000. I check it every now and then and run the updates.
Otherwise, I don't have to deal with it. Thats another nice thing about linux. I don't worry about maintaining it.
I don't know what a virus is, and I don't know what malware is. I stopped caring about that stuff a long time ago.
HHKB Pro 2 : Unicomp Spacesaver : IBM Model M : DasIII    

Offline nowsharing

  • Posts: 247
  • Swoop
Ars Reviews Ubuntu 10.04
« Reply #70 on: Thu, 20 May 2010, 20:26:35 »
Quote
Looks like Mint just released a new version based on 10.04
I wish there were a Mint Netbook Edition. I was a big fan of Mint and used it on my desktop, but I've basically given up on using any Linux distro on it. When I build my next machine, I'll do the homework ahead of time to find vendors that offer better support.

I'm not a fan of Windows...at all. But using it means that I can have hardware accelerated video playback, ATI crossfire support, and 24-bit WASAPI audio output after about 30 mins of setup after a fresh install. And my wireless network card is installed in Windows as well.

As much as I love the idea of Ubuntu, Mint, Debian, etc, none of them offer a singe piece of the above just yet.

Offline bigpook

  • Posts: 1723
Ars Reviews Ubuntu 10.04
« Reply #71 on: Fri, 21 May 2010, 04:17:01 »
Quote from: ripster;185075
Bigpook - that's what YOU think.  My keylogger on her machine tells me she's been hanging around those Russian porn sites.


haha, thats funny but not very likely : )
HHKB Pro 2 : Unicomp Spacesaver : IBM Model M : DasIII