Thank you everyone for the comments, IC responses, etc so far! It's been a couple of weeks since the IC launched, I've been reading every single response & comment and really appreciate the kind words and enthusiasm 💙 I've made a few small kitting changes, and have several other things I'm monitoring but want to collect more IC feedback about first before actioning as they are larger changes.
Wanted to share my detailed thoughts for those who are interested but will put a tldr/summary first:
Summary* 40s/Ortho kit has been updated: added 2u r3 backspace (gradient and non gradient versions) and changed 1.75u r1 lock to a novelty
* Revisiting idea of novelty/gradient spacebars & looking into base kit capslock novelty (either text novelty or image novelty)
* Will be continuing to collect IC feedback to inform larger changes - may make more kitting updates in the future
* Set is staying as KAT
* Deskmat design up next
* Artisan collabs will come when set is further along (hesitant to reach out to makers this early)
General feedback* 4 requests for different font/capitalised alphas: The lowercase serif font and the gradient top row are the two main features of the design in my mind so I'm not planning on changing those, though I understand the quirkiness will be a draw for some and a dealbreaker for others. The set does use Keyreative's stock white, so it's theoretically mix-and-match-able with other KAT sets like KAT Alpha (which has blanks):
https://divinikey.com/products/kat-alpha-keycap-set-dye-sub-pbt* 3 requests for Colevrak support: this isn't enough for me to justify adding a new kit for it yet (as each additional kit makes the whole set more expensive) but I'll continue monitoring IC feedback about this. Similar for the 1 request about iso fr support and 1 request for night version
* 3 requests for more colour: I previously looked into gradient spacebars but personally found it too distracting & preferred having the top row gradient as the main focus. I'll be picking this back up to see if I can find something I'm happy with
* 2 requests to have alpha legend gradient in 40s/ortho: will not be happening as it would require additional keys to be added (as depending on the board, some keys could be different colours e.g. on a minivan, W would be purple, but on a QAZ it'd be blue)
* 1 request for icon mods: I actually did originally want to do full, custom icon modifiers that matched the font/theme but I wasn't able to design a set I was happy with, hence the text mods instead 😔
Specific kitting requestsFor these, I'm balancing making sure the kits work to cover as many boards as possible while also trying to keep the cost of the set affordable. As such, I'm prioritising adding keys that add net new support over keys that already have alternatives (i.e. physical support already exists), and also prioritising keys that are more flexible (e.g. a novelty over specific legends)
Here are the minor changes I've already made based on feedback, both in the 40s/ortho kit:
* change 1.75u r1 Lock to the iris novelty; this allows it to be used more flexibly (e.g. as a second shift on boards with 2 x 1.75u Shift). This is the same novelty as 1.75u r2 Enter, AFAICT there aren't boards where you'd have to use both together, but I made it face the other way for variety anyway
* Added 2u r3 Back for Candybar
Here's a summary of the other feedback and how I'm thinking about it:
Base kit* 1 request for r2 1.75u fn - base kit currently has caps and ctrl. I'll be considering replacing these with a text novelty or image novelty if I can think of something that works well
* 1 request for Mac legends (cmd/opt) - punting for now as novelties can be used instead of ctrl, and "shine" is already OS neutral
40s/Ortho* 2 requests for ISO enter - punting for now due to cost; there are two iso enters in the base kit, so i think it'd be possible to get the ISO keys affordably aftermarket from someone who bought the base kit that doesn't need them
* 2 requests for more novelties - 1.75u r1 has been added
* 1 request for QAZ legend support (currently only has physical support) - punting again for cost concerns
* 1 request for 2u backspace for candybar - done
* 1 request for second 1.75u shift; 1 request for 1.75u r1 novelty for full novelty mods - done (changed 1.75u lock to novelty)
* 1 request for double 3u spacebars - punting for now as i revisit gradient/novelty spacebars. if i end up adding a separate spacebars kit itll go in there instead
Profile: will stay as KAT46.8% of responses were neutral, 30.6% preferred KAT and 22.6% preferred KAM - this is enough for me to rule out switching to KAM, the question has been removed from the IC.
Accessories/collabsArtisan collabs and Deskmat were the most requested by far! I want to do both of these, but also want to wait until the set is further along and has more certainty before reaching out for artisan collabs. So, I'll be working on deskmat designs next ^^