geekhack
geekhack Community => Ergonomics => Topic started by: TK0 on Sun, 11 April 2021, 14:13:05
-
Hello there,
I'm considering a switch to an ergonomic keyboard, like an ergodox or similar. But I'm not sure which keycap profile would be more ergonomic.
I see that most people opt to go with non-sculpted profiles (like DSA ou XDA). Is it a personal preference thing, or is there an ergonomic benefit? I know that non-sculpted profiles allow you to switch your keycaps between rows and make your own layout, but I'd probaby go with blanks keycaps, so this wouldn't be an issue.
What keycaps have you tried with ergodox or similar keebs?
Have anyone here tried the KAT pofile? They do say something about comfort and ergonomics in their marketing material. But, you know, it's marketing... it can be all bs.
Thanks for helping a new hobbyist, and sorry for the loads of questions!
-
I know that non-sculpted profiles allow you to switch your keycaps between rows and make your own layout
yes, this is the main reason.
i've used only a couple profiles & materials over the years (cherry, oem, xda, pbt & abs) and have been using blanks for years.
for me, i like thick blank pbt cherry profile, and thick pbt oem isn't horrible either on a small ergo board either.
- i like the stepping of the rows, especially being blank. (i "rest" my fingers between keys, not on home keys)
- i like the feel of pbt over abs (doesn't shine or get "sticky" when abs shines)
- going blank will force you to touch type
uniform profile is usually the only way to get legends correct with whatever odd layout you're using on your ergo board.
though, going for an ergodox, your options are a lot better than most because it is one of the few ergo boards that you can get extra kits made for ergodox in "most?" keycap group buys.
i can't speak to other profiles or GMK sets as i've never had any
good luck on your hunt and welcome to the hobby.
-
Thanks a lot for the answer. Didn't expect it so fast!
for me, i like thick blank pbt cherry profile, and thick pbt oem isn't horrible either on a small ergo board either.
I also prefer the more "rough/gritty" feel of PBT over the "smoothness" of ABS, but I've never used good quality/thick keycaps (PBT or ABS). Got my PBT set from aliexpress (OEM profile), but they aren't that thick. Where can I find thick ones with cherry profile? The only cherry profile keycaps I can find are GMK (ABS) and on aliexpress (not sure about thickness/quality).
I'm already used to blank keycaps (at least on a staggered QWERTY-ish keyboard), so I don't think it will be a problem after a couple of days if I decide to switch to an ergodox.
-
I'll have to look up the brand of the one set I have that cherry profile pbt (was through massdrop a long time ago) probabably ydmk, but I'll double check.
Currently using a oem profile thick pbt for plank from AE.
-
Unnecessary. Tent the keyboard at 45 degrees + and you're good to go.
Stack books in the middle, try it out.
-
Thanks a lot for the answer. Didn't expect it so fast!
for me, i like thick blank pbt cherry profile, and thick pbt oem isn't horrible either on a small ergo board either.
I also prefer the more "rough/gritty" feel of PBT over the "smoothness" of ABS, but I've never used good quality/thick keycaps (PBT or ABS). Got my PBT set from aliexpress (OEM profile), but they aren't that thick. Where can I find thick ones with cherry profile? The only cherry profile keycaps I can find are GMK (ABS) and on aliexpress (not sure about thickness/quality).
I'm already used to blank keycaps (at least on a staggered QWERTY-ish keyboard), so I don't think it will be a problem after a couple of days if I decide to switch to an ergodox.
- the one set i have is NPKC thick blank cherry profile pbt that i got from massdrop (https://drop.com/buy/blank-pbt-keycaps) in 2015
- the other was YMDK thick blank oem profile pbt from aliexpress (https://www.aliexpress.com/item/32819009338.html) (listing still live)
*** both sets the keycap sidewalls are 1.5 - 1.7mm thick
believe i've seen some on amazon as well. but not sure if that's an option where you are....
search for "thick blank pbt" & see what you come up with.
-
- the one set i have is NPKC thick blank cherry profile pbt that i got from massdrop (https://drop.com/buy/blank-pbt-keycaps) in 2015
- the other was YMDK thick blank oem profile pbt from aliexpress (https://www.aliexpress.com/item/32819009338.html) (listing still live)
*** both sets the keycap sidewalls are 1.5 - 1.7mm thick
Wow. Thanks a lot for all the effort you put to answer my questions. It is a really good welcome to the community, I really appreciate that. :D :thumb:
I will check those keycaps. Thanks again!