No mention of commission in that thread, interesting.
Honestly, I don't even get the concept behind ortholinear, so I I can't tell how that board is less practical than any other ortholinear. I like how you lined up all of the diodes in a row on the top, which I imagine are meant to be visible in the case, along with the controller.
I all fairness, I don get it either - yet. So I decided to just make one for myself and try.
Inspired by the Mysterium, but I hate through hole components where I need to cut leads. So SMT it is. People seem to fear SMD, but its just so much easier than TH.
When people complain about SMD components, it makes me wonder what sort of bargain bin hardware store tools they're trying to use. Some $15 Weller works for soldering some switches into some LEGO board, but I would never attempt to use such a thing when trying to work with components smaller than a grain of rice.
I have never been big on the whole custom board thing myself, so I haven't soldered 100+ SMD diodes one at a time, but I do swap SMD LEDs, etc, from time to time. I have never had a problem either dual wielding irons or making one big blob to remove and using a nice fine tip and even just a flathead in order to install.
At the same time, there's something endearing to me about through-hole. I even find clipping legs down a little therapeutic, maybe like how some people like pruning gardens. I'm sure being able to just bake all of the components on in one go is easier than through-hole, but most people, even here, don't have anything set up for doing that.