geekhack

geekhack Community => Keyboards => Topic started by: phinix on Tue, 05 August 2025, 17:20:24

Title: Hall effect switches vs standard ones
Post by: phinix on Tue, 05 August 2025, 17:20:24
Apart from that variable actuation levels, what else is different in Hall effect switches?
Are they better cause they dont have leafs? I like heavy linears, like oil kings with 85g springs.
Could I mod he switches to have heavy springs as well as regular ones?
Title: Re: Hall effect switches vs standard ones
Post by: YALE70 on Tue, 05 August 2025, 18:34:47
Are they better cause they dont have leafs?

You'd think that, but honestly I don't find they're dramatically smoother compared to a competently designed lubed linear - if at all.

Could I mod he switches to have heavy springs as well as regular ones?

Apparently you should be able to - I haven't tried it - but I would test the new springs in a switch or two just to be sure. I don't think interference is much of a problem with standard MX springs but specifically non-magnetic ones for HE switches are readily available. Worst case, you might just have to recalibrate each switch.
Title: Re: Hall effect switches vs standard ones
Post by: phinix on Wed, 06 August 2025, 06:48:09
Are they better cause they dont have leafs?

You'd think that, but honestly I don't find they're dramatically smoother compared to a competently designed lubed linear - if at all.

Could I mod he switches to have heavy springs as well as regular ones?

Apparently you should be able to - I haven't tried it - but I would test the new springs in a switch or two just to be sure. I don't think interference is much of a problem with standard MX springs but specifically non-magnetic ones for HE switches are readily available. Worst case, you might just have to recalibrate each switch.

Thanks for confirming that.
Meeeeh, sounds like it would not be a huge upgrade for me, I dont need that actuation level customisation.
Title: Re: Hall effect switches vs standard ones
Post by: edbods on Wed, 06 August 2025, 09:06:35
They're good for durability but unless you're a professional gamer needing absolute maximum and precise response they're not really worth getting