geekhack

geekhack Community => Keyboards => Topic started by: Internetlad on Mon, 04 June 2012, 18:07:59

Title: Anyone have experience with "projection" keyboards
Post by: Internetlad on Mon, 04 June 2012, 18:07:59
Example:http://www.youtube.com/watch?NR=1&v=y-wbOlWa-gk&feature=endscreen

I never get the idea behind these. It's all the downsides of having a touch-screen keyboard (no tactility, no feedback, very difficult to touch type) while STILL being tied to a desk.

They're cool but totally impractical.

Y/N?
Title: Anyone have experience with "projection" keyboards
Post by: Reptile on Mon, 04 June 2012, 18:36:56
He sounds like the shiffty five guy lol. Looks cool but I couldn't use it everyday
Title: Anyone have experience with "projection" keyboards
Post by: cactux on Mon, 04 June 2012, 18:41:18
Whoever invented this stuff, does not type faster than 5wpm. Can you imagine using this on a hard surface fir a few hrs. You will end up whit big finger issues
Title: Anyone have experience with "projection" keyboards
Post by: Squelos on Mon, 04 June 2012, 18:49:20
Hehe, pretty hilarious.
Really, not many advantages over touch screens.
Cheaper than touchscreens, so it could be used in kitchens for example, but it really isnt any good for typing anything than a search ...

They have been around for a while now.
Title: Anyone have experience with "projection" keyboards
Post by: Lethal Squirrel on Mon, 04 June 2012, 23:12:54
And I will tell you how to do it, faster than you can say poopty puepty pants-ss
Title: Anyone have experience with "projection" keyboards
Post by: elef on Tue, 05 June 2012, 04:04:37
These were never intended to replace "real" keyboards. They could be useful as travel keyboards, paired with a tablet, and I think I've heard they might be used in sterile environments (a flat surface is much easier to sterilize than a keyboard). Obviously they are not meant for home/office use.

Come to think of it, this technology should be integrated into tablets. Just prop up your tablet on a desk, switch on keyboard & mouse projection and you have a somewhat usable laptop.
Title: Anyone have experience with "projection" keyboards
Post by: fohat.digs on Tue, 05 June 2012, 09:03:58
That last suggestion about integrating it in devices that don't actually have keyboards is a great idea.

I could see these things being useful in "specialty" or "emergency" situations, especially with ersatz "mouse-pad" capability built in.

The device would have to be cheap and small before I would consider it, if I had a tablet, which I don't, and for transportability, flat is much better than cubic.

I bet it would make you very happy to get back to your real keyboard!
Title: Anyone have experience with "projection" keyboards
Post by: The_Beast on Tue, 05 June 2012, 09:08:49
Even if I had a tablet, I'd still rather type on the touch screen
Title: Anyone have experience with "projection" keyboards
Post by: Internetlad on Tue, 05 June 2012, 11:16:00
elef makes a good point, and one I hadn't though of, for use in sterile enviroments. Nifty stuff.

Has anybody ever used one first hand?
Title: Anyone have experience with "projection" keyboards
Post by: Djuzuh on Tue, 05 June 2012, 11:17:25
There are special keyboards for sterile inveronments.

I guess it's only for the look, the gadgety-side and the portability.
Title: Anyone have experience with "projection" keyboards
Post by: smknjoe on Tue, 05 June 2012, 11:21:34
I tried one at directron.com here in Houston about 10 years ago and again about 4 years later when they were trying to get rid of the same stock. Just as you would think it's like pounding on your desk and is prone to errors. They look neat though.
Title: Anyone have experience with "projection" keyboards
Post by: Internetlad on Tue, 05 June 2012, 12:33:43
Quote from: smknjoe;607878
I tried one at directron.com here in Houston about 10 years ago and again about 4 years later when they were trying to get rid of the same stock. Just as you would think it's like pounding on your desk and is prone to errors. They look neat though.

For a second there I thought you were discribing Windows Vista.

I kid, I kid.
Title: Anyone have experience with "projection" keyboards
Post by: noodles on Tue, 05 June 2012, 14:20:58
we had one of these Delvin cleankey in our medical device manufacturing cleanroom- horrible horrible typing experience! mushy doesn't even begin to describe it!
[ATTACH=CONFIG]52318[/ATTACH]
Title: Anyone have experience with "projection" keyboards
Post by: Internetlad on Tue, 05 June 2012, 14:28:40
Quote from: noodles;607987
we had one of these Delvin cleankey in our medical device manufacturing cleanroom- horrible horrible typing experience! mushy doesn't even begin to describe it!
(Attachment) 52318[/ATTACH]


that thing looks like it would go "splat" if you touched it.
Title: Anyone have experience with "projection" keyboards
Post by: noodles on Tue, 05 June 2012, 14:52:55
surprisingly durable it weighs 2kg! throw it at a wall and its likely to knock you out on the rebound!....its got a clean button that disables all keyboard inputs when your disinfecting it with 99% IPA
Title: Anyone have experience with "projection" keyboards
Post by: Cindori on Tue, 05 June 2012, 17:55:52
I had a projection keyboard. They are all pretty much identical to each other. Same layout, sound when clicking, etc.

It was a cool gadget and that was it. The lack of tactile response made it pretty hard to use. It was also not that great precision, although much higher then what I expected. It took some learning because if you accidently block out the ray-path with your hand or finger it will react as if you are mashing your palm on the keyboard.
Title: Anyone have experience with "projection" keyboards
Post by: Internetlad on Tue, 05 June 2012, 18:09:18
Quote from: noodles;608013
its got a clean button that disables all keyboard inputs when your disinfecting it with 99% IPA


I wish every keyboard had that. Wiping down a laptop keyboard, look up and the search box is open and all my desktop icons are gone.
Title: Anyone have experience with "projection" keyboards
Post by: elef on Wed, 06 June 2012, 03:06:17
Quote from: Djuzuh;607873
There are special keyboards for sterile inveronments.

I guess it's only for the look, the gadgety-side and the portability.


1984: "There are keyboards already. I guess this Model M is just for the looks and the weird sound it makes, and fighting zombies of course."
How much do the existing sterilizable keyboards cost and how much will a projection keyboard cost when the economies of scale kick in? Which is easier to sterilize?