geekhack

geekhack Community => Keyboards => Topic started by: Glod on Tue, 09 April 2013, 23:26:05

Title: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Glod on Tue, 09 April 2013, 23:26:05
So, the number of people who have completed their ErgoDox is starting to grow a little bit. I'm sure it will be a while until the 200+ sold in round 1 are built and roiund 2 is live now but for those who have assembled it let's talk about the finished product:

How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Pros? Cons? Learning Issues?
Willing to share pictures or your layout?

--

I wanted to separate this discussion from the main making stuff together! forum thread because any discussion of the ergodox--reviews, pictures, cheers, jeers, diy etc--was taking place in a single thread! hell, the phantom has at least 3 i know of. would be cooler to leave the diy stuff in the making stuff together! forum and talk about the finished product.  hope this isn't going into the un-replied topic abyss, most likely it will.  :-[
Title: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Halverson on Tue, 09 April 2013, 23:38:33
Quite simply:
Qwerty-kinesis layout
Linear grey switches, awesome!
Blank black uniform profile caps

Love the look of it, and the feeling of completing a project from nothing.

As for usage, damn near impossible for me. Going to really have to train myself for this one.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: hashbaz on Tue, 09 April 2013, 23:42:14
It looks great in its box, sitting there on my desk.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Glod on Tue, 09 April 2013, 23:45:53
Didnt put my thoughts in my own thread lol

I am currently enjoying mine but i'm having trouble using a keyboard without a staggered layout. I'm really trying to make this the only keyboard i use except when i travel where i plan to use the GH60 or use my poker. i may end up selling stuff because of this.

Pros so far
- As a user of the freestyle for 3 years, its great to go back to a split keyboard but this time with mechanical keys and a programable layout. I actually came to geekhack because i was ditching my freestyle for higher quality topre and mechanical keyboards, 8 months later i realize i missed the split design but hated the freestyle's layout, rubber domes, design, etc (pretty, much everything about it except the split design)
- i love how you can just change out the 3.5 cable if you want to adjust the separation, the Freestyle didn't have a replaceable center cable and the length was fixed; i prefer a large separation most of the time
- endlessly programmable
- easy to assemble, at least for me, the smd diodes were awesome
- yet another place for me to put novelty keycaps on

Cons so far
- Aluminium case issues (roughness, bad cut)
- Non-staggered key layout is a bit harder to learn than i thought it would be
- Heavy, Bulky, and not easy to travel with, i don't see myself putting this in my laptop bag and going through a airport with this thing, i wonder if it looks like a bomb in the xray.

(http://farm9.staticflickr.com/8265/8631586183_0afe0aa3b4_n.jpg) (http://www.flickr.com/photos/panicfx/8631586183/)

Here is my layout
(http://almightyglod.com/public_stack/Glod_ErgoDox_Layout_First_Try.png)

Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Glod on Tue, 09 April 2013, 23:49:06
It looks great in its box, sitting there on my desk.

youz makes me sad sir
Title: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Halverson on Wed, 10 April 2013, 00:00:31
Oh I forgot to say, I went with the acrylic case. Glad I did, hear too many issues with aluminum.
Although a full hand aluminum would probably feel nice and cool.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Larken on Wed, 10 April 2013, 00:42:31
Absolutely loving mine. Full hand acrylic, base vinyled white. Ergoclears variable weighted, with browns for side and thumb clusters.

(http://farm9.staticflickr.com/8100/8621178575_c229ee5904_b.jpg) (http://www.flickr.com/photos/89364707@N02/8621178575/)
switch layout

pros: minimal finger movement. noticeable less strain on my wrists after long hours. really helps with workin glong hours on the keyboard.

cons: not enough buttons for symbols. no room for a proper arrow cluster on layer 0 without sacrificing a button. even with a fullhand, I find the wrist rest inadequate. Pretty hard to find something perfectly suitable for this keyboard, and I'd already ruined one grifiti rest I had trying to cut it down to fit.

learning issues: I went cold turkey on my ergodox, muscle memory kicked in at about the third day. I'm on my 6th or 7th now and it feels pretty natural to be typing on the matrix layout. (I was having similar problems on the first few days on a non-staggered layout). Interestingly, I tried going back to a staggered layout for a few minutes and found myself hitting the wrong keys. Win some, lose some, I guess.

Posted this in the other thread already, but here's it again:

(http://farm9.staticflickr.com/8539/8618686083_d3dd5f5e9e_b.jpg) (http://www.flickr.com/photos/89364707@N02/8618686083/)

Layout:

(http://farm9.staticflickr.com/8262/8635941481_42760d1c7a_b.jpg) (http://www.flickr.com/photos/89364707@N02/8635941481/)


(http://farm9.staticflickr.com/8379/8635941477_a1081dfa0d_b.jpg) (http://www.flickr.com/photos/89364707@N02/8635941477/)

I know it looks weird to have the function buttons on layer 0, but those were my preset buttons for a few windows actions. I found that making those center buttons be used as 'layer pushes' a bad choice, as I still hit those buttons accidentally when reaching for that bhy buttons that doesn't exist on that side of the ergodox, and I didn't want to deal with having to change layers on accident.

layer 3 is a random layer I created for gaming purposes only - everything is the same except for shifting the common buttons from the right hand over to the left - i (inventory), m - map etc. More importantly was the spacebar.

I have another classic case ergox dox coming in which I plan to carry around to use if needed. The weight aside, the size is extremely portable to tote around in a backpack or a messenger.



Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Glod on Wed, 10 April 2013, 01:13:29
a gaming layer! why didnt i think about that? omg

man i love how this thing is so easily programmable. i went with the layout that i felt was easiest to transition to coming from so much use of a normal design qwerty. would love to see more layouts from people in this thread as the number of ergodox grows

on the portability side i didn't find it as portable. maybe i am just not putting it in my laptop bag proper. i'm also afraid it may cause some extra time at airport security lol.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Glod on Wed, 10 April 2013, 21:29:37
it is amazing how quickly i am learning to use this thing. Just throw yourself into a situation where you have to do a lot of typing and it speeds up learning. Its worth it.

i just plugged in my poker and tried to type on it and i almost couldn't do it, switching between matrix and staggered is seemingly impossible.

that leaves me with keyboards i may never type on again. Not going to go as far as to cancel my GH60 order but it is looking less likely I will have a regular rotation anymore and i'll be more of a "collector"
Title: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: mikelanding on Wed, 10 April 2013, 22:01:41
I yet to get mine. It is still assemble by someone. For those who have trouble getting use to the new matrix layout, you might want to follow few lessons from this Kinesis Training Material. It will help you to speed up the new layout very fast.
Link: http://www.micwil.com/images/additional_resources/training_materials_for_contoured_keyboards.pdf
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Larken on Wed, 10 April 2013, 22:17:44
I felt the same, once I got used to the matrix layout. The ergodox is my favorite board now, even though there's still some issues to iron out with regards to mods.

Another benefit is that it keeps me off the Topre train for now - tempting as it may be to try 30g Topres, I'm not going to buy another board without a matrix + split layout. (I know there's the utron, but man, the price is killer)

The longer you keep going in one session, generally diminishing returns would set in for the training of muscle memory. My experience with adapting to the ergodox is that I'd work on it for 2-3 hours, then go take a break, or even a short nap. I literally woke up on the third day and suddenly realized I wasn't mis-striking the keys I was the previous night before. Didn't feel gradual, it just happened. Guess my hands and brain is rewired for the matrix layout now.

I was considering getting a GH60, but I figured I'd never use that now I have my ergodox. Programmable keyboards are awesome.

Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: wiredPANDA on Thu, 11 April 2013, 14:15:32
It looks great in its box, sitting there on my desk.

Sadly, that's where I'm at now, too.  I have another kit off for assembly.

Just sitting here plotting out my layer layouts.  And Larken with the gaming layout --- +1.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: zoolzoo on Thu, 11 April 2013, 16:04:44
Looks like a pain in the ass.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Glod on Thu, 11 April 2013, 16:06:22
Looks like a pain in the ass.

to build or to use?

haters gonna hate
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: mashby on Thu, 11 April 2013, 16:41:42
I figured this would be something I might try out down the road in a year, or two, but seeing the new gb on MassDrop has me sorely tempted.

Thank you everyone for sharing your experiences thus far. I'm curious though, how hard has it been to get key caps for this board?
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Glod on Thu, 11 April 2013, 16:51:24
well the mass drop round 1 offered blank DSA profile pbt caps. dsa to me is the way to go but people complained without even trying them and the round 2 offers DCS (SP Profile) instead, these are blanks as well. the SP profile thing has to do with in my opinion cosmetics and not what profile is best for it.

as you have seen on my flickr I have the dsa caps on and then for the alpha-numeric i threw on some random OEM profile caps i have because i cant do all blanks, i can remember the modifiers but my hand starts to forget where it is unless i peak once in awhile. only problem is that the profiles are off so it doesnt look clean

the coolest thing is the DSA Retro set from Sam/Ron and Matteo offered some blanks to go over the misc 2x and 1.5 caps so the DSA retro kit i have coming is going on my ergodox, it will be a full set

TJ is planning a DSA sale this summer that will most likely also offer the ergodox-needed stuff :)
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Jagriff on Thu, 11 April 2013, 17:49:58
well the mass drop round 1 offered blank DSA profile pbt caps. dsa to me is the way to go but people complained without even trying them and the round 2 offers DCS (SP Profile) instead, these are blanks as well. the SP profile thing has to do with in my opinion cosmetics and not what profile is best for it.

It isn't instead. You can buy DSA and/or DCS this time.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: oneproduct on Thu, 11 April 2013, 17:58:35
The thumb cluster being somewhat far to reach makes me prefer my Kinesis for the moment. When soldering it I messed up one key, so waiting to fix that before I really dive into it though. I also don't have a proper set of keycaps for it, so everything is kind of the wrong profile. I'll need to wait for the flat spherical groupbuy with the commodore colored keys to arrive.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Glod on Thu, 11 April 2013, 18:30:14
well the mass drop round 1 offered blank DSA profile pbt caps. dsa to me is the way to go but people complained without even trying them and the round 2 offers DCS (SP Profile) instead, these are blanks as well. the SP profile thing has to do with in my opinion cosmetics and not what profile is best for it.

It isn't instead. You can buy DSA and/or DCS this time.

negative

https://www.massdrop.com/buy

just dcs


i stand ****ing corrected, its in the options when you buy the ergodox
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: haskellelephant on Thu, 11 April 2013, 18:44:55
Its amazing! All I ever dreamed it would be and then some! Here are some of the pictures from the unboxing: http://imgur.com/a/qSYpX
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Glod on Thu, 11 April 2013, 18:48:38
they boxed it beautifully i must say, hats off to massdrop!

Got to say im still getting use to the non-staggered matrix layout, was typing only 20wpm monday up to 45 today, hopefuly i get up past 70 like i am normally with the staggered (yeah yeah i know we got some beast typers that are much better than me up in geekhack :P)
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: bisl on Thu, 11 April 2013, 22:11:42
Here's mine: http://i.imgur.com/voUbYgI.jpg

I've been most excited about columnar keys since I heard about the ergodox, but in practice I made a strange realization: the staggerered layout of normal boards, along with the couple of cheater habits I learned along the way, allowed me to type all this time with my hands sort of naturally tented despite laying flat (well, on wrist rests). Now, with flat ergodox, and columnar keys, my fingers don't follow the tracks laid out by the columns unless I have my hands (or the boards) tented as well.

Moreover, when I try to use it when it's flat, I get some nasty tendon snapping in my right wrist, which has a history of threatening me with RSI. Thankfully, I have some extras of these tiny wrist rests that I use, so I'm using them to tent while I figure out a more permanent solution.

Overall though, I love the board. I could only be happier if I'd already finished lubing my switches by now, as they feel kind of scratchy at the moment. These might have been from before  Cherry was releasing switches into the wild already lubricated perhaps.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Larken on Thu, 11 April 2013, 22:44:15
how to tent the ergodox is definitely the priority issue for me now. The way I have it set up still isn't ideal yet, but short of constructing some sort of proper support frame, I can't get the angle I want. cardboard boxes doesn't cut it.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Glod on Thu, 11 April 2013, 22:50:33
working on creating a slope as well, trying to take the parts from my kinesis freestyle to make a tent
though if i add a very large slope like i want it makes me regret not getting the full hand
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: r3dx on Fri, 12 April 2013, 10:27:04
I finally got mine together last night and I'm using it at work today. So far I'm liking it, I'll do a proper write up with some pictures when I get home tonight. I still want to go back and lube my switches. I did one already just to see how it felt and there is a noticeable difference.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: davkol on Fri, 12 April 2013, 10:55:16
Got mine in the mail today, but I'm afraid I won't be able to assemble it for another month. Still trying to decide what switches I should use... Reds? Clears? Ergo clears? Maybe reds on one hand, and weighted clears on the other one, lol.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: r3dx on Fri, 12 April 2013, 11:02:27
Not sure if you know, but the switch tops on the ErgoDox can be opened and the parts can be swapped out. So if you do decide to change your mind you just need to switch out the parts.

Honestly, I'm using Clears right now and I'm loving them, although I'm really tempted to buy new springs to make them into ErgoClears. I think for now I'm just going to lube them until I can find a good source for springs.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: davkol on Fri, 12 April 2013, 12:03:03
I know that, but messing with it requires more time. The problem is that I like both reds and ergo clears equally. Maybe I should get another ergodox, and rotate them.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: r3dx on Fri, 12 April 2013, 12:12:27
Yeah, true. I was kind of thinking the same thing also but I'm still on the fence cause I'm cheap and running out of keyboard storage space.  ;D
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Larken on Fri, 12 April 2013, 12:12:39
I know that, but messing with it requires more time. The problem is that I like both reds and ergo clears equally. Maybe I should get another ergodox, and rotate them.

my personal observations are that the thumb buttons tend to jam a little on the way up with ergoclears. ended up using a mix of browns and reds to achieve smoother action. love the ergoclears on the alphanumeric keys, but they feel off on the other keys.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: r3dx on Fri, 12 April 2013, 12:22:44
Larken, just out of curiosity, is it possible the jamming is caused by the case and not the switch itself. I was having the same problem with the thumb keys getting stuck but it was caused by poor fitment of the case. I ended up just taking a Dremel to the case and slowly grinding some of the case to allow for room for the key cap. I think I'm going to have to go back and grind some more off cause it still happens sometimes.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Larken on Fri, 12 April 2013, 12:34:35
not for my case, though I know what you're referring to. the arcylic case for mine fits really well, and the only thing I had to do to get it to fit was to file a little bit of the pcb to get it to fit layer 4.

I'm referring to the ergoclear characteristics, as I saw you and davkol had interest to go for ergoclears, so figured I'll give a heads up. Its fine if you strike a key, but if you push, and hold down on the button, the upstroke becomes a little bit 'jammed' or 'stuck' for lack of a better word. I find it a little off-putting for certain keys like ctrl, alt, where either you have to hold the button, or space, bkspace, where its common to hit the key rapidly in succession.

Switching these out to brown stems (space and bkspace and arrow keys) and the ctrl alt modifiers (see the layout I posted earlier in an earlier post),  made the problem go away.

Keep in mind that I did lube my switches, but the springs used were 55g, so that's a factor. It's not a problem if I swap in 62g springs however. But when I thought about it, I figured I didn't really need the tactility for space and bkspace anyway, so those brown stems on my thumb clusters feel right after days after testing. (if you see my original picture, it was a tactile grey stem with a 62g spring where the spacebar is).
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: davkol on Fri, 12 April 2013, 12:35:22
I know that, but messing with it requires more time. The problem is that I like both reds and ergo clears equally. Maybe I should get another ergodox, and rotate them.

my personal observations are that the thumb buttons tend to jam a little on the way up with ergoclears. ended up using a mix of browns and reds to achieve smoother action. love the ergoclears on the alphanumeric keys, but they feel off on the other keys.

Is it the same kind of jamming as with too light springs in clears in general? I have Korean 62g springs.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: r3dx on Fri, 12 April 2013, 12:39:59
Thanks for clearing that up Larken. I'll keep that in mind if/when I switch out my springs. I've also heard that Clears have that type of problem with too light of springs but personally, I don't have much experience with them.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Glod on Fri, 12 April 2013, 17:41:59
Reds are working out pretty well for me, kind of rolled the dice on using reds instead of brown that i am used to. Tried lubing some reds the other day and they seem pretty fantastic so i am going to lube and sticker mine this weekend

4th work day using it the whole day, ive added a larger slope/tent

(http://farm9.staticflickr.com/8531/8641449125_988f7c7846.jpg) (http://www.flickr.com/photos/panicfx/8641449125/)


However i seem to be making more mistakes now, got to keep learning, it does make my hands hurt less for sure with it like this.l
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Glod on Sun, 14 April 2013, 15:05:22
Happy to see some new people getting their ergodox assembled, i wonder if they will share their experiences

last night i made some modifications to my ergodox

(http://farm9.staticflickr.com/8259/8649885986_9853d35c35.jpg) (http://www.flickr.com/photos/panicfx/8649885986/)
(http://farm9.staticflickr.com/8103/8649886284_c95e3e04ff.jpg) (http://www.flickr.com/photos/panicfx/8649886284/)
(http://farm9.staticflickr.com/8255/8648042974_9bda48a2b5.jpg) (http://www.flickr.com/photos/panicfx/8648042974/)

- White Vinyl stickers from techkeys
- White on black double shot from SP (used to be on my poker)
- Lubed Red Switches (103/205 Mix with teflon spring lube)
- Replaced aluminum top from un-built ergodox and replaced with the correct matching acrylic top (to shed weight)
- added Jdcarpe style geekhack badge
- VIP3 kit from Kenesis Freestyle 1
- Wasd o-rings

The lubed red switches are like my new favorite thing, holy **** awesome
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: seferphier on Sun, 14 April 2013, 22:56:36
I finally made completed my Ergodox! Special thanks to r3dx, larken, Glod for helping me out my soldering problems. Massdrop's service has been pretty good as well. i'm pretty satisfied, despite all the flaming comments on geekhack before the groupbuy is complete. What you guys feel about Massdrop?

I made all the mistakes a soldering newbie can make but the PCB was very forgiving and I managed to get all the keys working. I would still recommend this project to a beginner but they should watch some videos in soldering SMDs. Soldering SMDs is the first step in the process and also the hardest. Massdrop should make an extra page to introduce soldering videos to beginners as well as take pictures of the SMD to show the cathode of the diode.

(https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/21019600/IMG_1563.JPG)

I found that the keycaps were surprisingly pleasant due to the shape- it looks like the keycaps from kinesis keyboards. Like everyone else, I am not quite used to the matrix layout yet. My muscle memory seems to have disappeared and i need to relearn the qwerty layout - partly due to the fact that i am used to the dorvak layout and the positioning thing on the keys F and J. i plan to learn colemak layout since dorvak places too much emphasis on the right hand side. im also trying to figure out a new layout for my keys

here is my layout so far:
 (https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/21019600/layout.jpg)

there seems to be an interference with my windows layout with my current keyboard layout. i type in dorvak sometimes even though i have removed it from my system. weird.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: seferphier on Mon, 15 April 2013, 06:09:37
btw, what is the advantage of matrix layout?
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: davkol on Mon, 15 April 2013, 06:38:47
btw, what is the advantage of matrix layout?

(http://www.trulyergonomic.com/store/image/data/Staggered_ergonomic_keyboards.jpg)
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: seferphier on Mon, 15 April 2013, 08:28:40
btw, what is the advantage of matrix layout?

Show Image
(http://www.trulyergonomic.com/store/image/data/Staggered_ergonomic_keyboards.jpg)


so the staggered layout is a legacy layout that originated from type writers? And this is not natural?
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: seferphier on Mon, 15 April 2013, 08:31:55
Reds are working out pretty well for me, kind of rolled the dice on using reds instead of brown that i am used to. Tried lubing some reds the other day and they seem pretty fantastic so i am going to lube and sticker mine this weekend

4th work day using it the whole day, ive added a larger slope/tent

(http://farm9.staticflickr.com/8531/8641449125_988f7c7846.jpg) (http://www.flickr.com/photos/panicfx/8641449125/)


However i seem to be making more mistakes now, got to keep learning, it does make my hands hurt less for sure with it like this.l

how does the slope help ergonomically and by how much?
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: davkol on Mon, 15 April 2013, 08:40:28
so the staggered layout is a legacy layout that originated from type writers? And this is not natural?

Exactly! Do you have two right hands? I don't. Makes me wonder, how it would be to be left-handed with two right hands.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: sordna on Mon, 15 April 2013, 09:26:28
Anything not symmetric is not natural. Your fingers don't naturally both lean to the left, do they ?  Traditional keyboards are terrible for the left hand especially (lookup "ulnar deviaton").
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: TDub on Mon, 15 April 2013, 10:07:22
Build mine this weekend. Building it was soooooo much fun :) Still refining my layout. Mine has Clears which still need to be stickered and lubed (didn't have the patience for that his weekend, really wanted to get it up and running and start typing). I am using cherry DS but unfortunately that means tons of keys in the wrong size and profile (waiting for the DSA Retro GB).

Advantages:

+ LOOOOOVING it for gaming. Especially with games like League of Legends, the stagger annoyed the hell out of me for summoner spells. Left hand side + mouse is just perfect.
+ The programmable controller is just awesome. So many possibilities!
+ I like the split. Positioning each hand separately is often nice.
+ Exposes bad habits from staggered keyboards. On my left hand I seem to shift to the left (with my left hand) on the second row of alphas (from r to d for example) opposed to the direction of the stagger. Never noticed it until I started typing on the ErgoDox.
+ Fun to build
+ Unique
+ Very little hand movement (but then this is also true for my pokers)
+ Thumb buttons are a great improvement. No longer is my thumb confined to working the spacebar! FREEEEEEEDOOOOOM :P

Neutral:
. Kinda wish I had gone for the case with wrist rest (but I might figure out some way to add one)
. Still waiting for a fitting set of keycaps
. WPM still terrible (but partially because I am more hesitant than I really need to be)
. Doesn't come with feet but I already solved that.

Bad:
- Top 3 thumb buttons are hard to reach, for me to the point of being useless. Maybe this is due to the way I currently position my hand. Maybe I will get used to them. For now they get less frequently used functions like the windows key and it's fine.
- Moving both sides independently also irritates me sometimes. I am someone who moves his keyboards around a lot and with my pokers I move it with one hand and the second hand automatically orients itself after the move. With the ErgoDox I adjust each hand individually and my right hand seems to lose orientation more because of it. Hopefully this is just a matter
- For me the clear layerstack or L0 key doesn't seem to work. Not sure why, posted on massdrop and hopefully this will be resolved for me soon.

In short: lots to love, few cons which hopefully will lessen with time :)
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: seferphier on Mon, 15 April 2013, 14:01:48
+ Exposes bad habits from staggered keyboards. On my left hand I seem to shift to the left (with my left hand) on the second row of alphas (from r to d for example) opposed to the direction of the stagger. Never noticed it until I started typing on the ErgoDox.

agreed!!!
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Glod on Tue, 16 April 2013, 00:26:50
Reds are working out pretty well for me, kind of rolled the dice on using reds instead of brown that i am used to. Tried lubing some reds the other day and they seem pretty fantastic so i am going to lube and sticker mine this weekend

4th work day using it the whole day, ive added a larger slope/tent

(http://farm9.staticflickr.com/8531/8641449125_988f7c7846.jpg) (http://www.flickr.com/photos/panicfx/8641449125/)


However i seem to be making more mistakes now, got to keep learning, it does make my hands hurt less for sure with it like this.l

how does the slope help ergonomically and by how much?

well your wrists are not as twisted that way with slope and its all around more comfortable, many keyboards have allowed this slope like kinesis freestyle, freestyle2, and goldtouch adjustable and the super rare ibm m15 (among some others).

in fact i just added even more slope and its perfect now
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: seferphier on Tue, 16 April 2013, 02:03:47
Reds are working out pretty well for me, kind of rolled the dice on using reds instead of brown that i am used to. Tried lubing some reds the other day and they seem pretty fantastic so i am going to lube and sticker mine this weekend

4th work day using it the whole day, ive added a larger slope/tent

(http://farm9.staticflickr.com/8531/8641449125_988f7c7846.jpg) (http://www.flickr.com/photos/panicfx/8641449125/)


However i seem to be making more mistakes now, got to keep learning, it does make my hands hurt less for sure with it like this.l

how does the slope help ergonomically and by how much?

well your wrists are not as twisted that way with slope and its all around more comfortable, many keyboards have allowed this slope like kinesis freestyle, freestyle2, and goldtouch adjustable and the super rare ibm m15 (among some others).

in fact i just added even more slope and its perfect now

lets see a picture of it! i guess the best way to produce the slant is by buying the freestyle2 palm support?
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: bisl on Tue, 16 April 2013, 02:17:28

- Lubed Red Switches (103/205 Mix with teflon spring lube)

...

The lubed red switches are like my new favorite thing, holy **** awesome

I tried lubing up my reds as well, although I had only 205 and to be honest it felt like it kind of just gummed them up a little--they actually feel a little heavier than they did before, which is saddening since it took a long time to do and would doubtlessly take much longer to clean off.

Also, where do you even GET 103, anyway? Is there anything more conventionally available that could possibly replace it? Is it a necessary component in order to actually reduce the friction when lubricating?

To be honest I read through most of the MMB lubing thread and I came out with about as many questions as when I started. I'd love some pointers if anyone's got some.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Larken on Tue, 16 April 2013, 02:17:42
been trying out various angles with various household objects. (don't ask).

found the perfect angle for myself, though I'm toying with the idea of getting the VIP3, but I don't think it's able to hit the angle I want. Any opinions, Glod? Pics below.

The ascent model from kinesis would be able to do it, but 200 bucks for a tenting system is out of my reach.

(http://farm9.staticflickr.com/8114/8654759004_3f888eeb72_b.jpg) (http://www.flickr.com/photos/89364707@N02/8654759004/)

(http://farm9.staticflickr.com/8251/8653658181_4ec4cabf21_b.jpg) (http://www.flickr.com/photos/89364707@N02/8653658181/)


Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: seferphier on Tue, 16 April 2013, 02:24:06
Show Image
been trying out various angles with various household objects. (don't ask).

found the perfect angle for myself, though I'm toying with the idea of getting the VIP3, but I don't think it's able to hit the angle I want. Any opinions, Glod? Pics below.

The ascent model from kinesis would be able to do it, but 200 bucks for a tenting system is out of my reach.

(http://farm9.staticflickr.com/8114/8654759004_3f888eeb72_b.jpg) (http://www.flickr.com/photos/89364707@N02/8654759004/)


(http://farm9.staticflickr.com/8251/8653658181_4ec4cabf21_b.jpg) (http://www.flickr.com/photos/89364707@N02/8653658181/)


looks like the stand would make the keyboard rocky...
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Larken on Tue, 16 April 2013, 02:24:23

- Lubed Red Switches (103/205 Mix with teflon spring lube)

...

The lubed red switches are like my new favorite thing, holy **** awesome

I tried lubing up my reds as well, although I had only 205 and to be honest it felt like it kind of just gummed them up a little--they actually feel a little heavier than they did before, which is saddening since it took a long time to do and would doubtlessly take much longer to clean off.

Also, where do you even GET 103, anyway? Is there anything more conventionally available that could possibly replace it? Is it a necessary component in order to actually reduce the friction when lubricating?

To be honest I read through most of the MMB lubing thread and I came out with about as many questions as when I started. I'd love some pointers if anyone's got some.

from what I understand, 205 is too gummy to be used alone, but don't take my word for it, as I don't have access to the grease. there's a groupbuy for 103 done by jdcarpe in the groupbuy forums at the moment.

anyway it sounds like you used too much lube. I had one switch gum up like that when I purposely used a large amount of superlube on the switch and the springs to test how much would be effective. what you need is a thin film of the lube, enough to see the surface of the sliders shine under bright light, but not so much that you could actually use a new brush to reabsorb the lube from the switch to use on another switch. Hope that helps.

whitefiredragon has a pretty good video that I used as a guide, but I'm guessing that you already watched that?

Edit: as it is, I think 205 alone could probably be used, though it might not be optimal. Also, as it is a grease, there would be some increase in the force needed to actuate the switch, but it should settle out in a short while after you give the keys a good half hour of typing.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Glod on Tue, 16 April 2013, 04:29:24
yeah 205 alone is not a good ideal. the 103/205 mix on my reds is like the best thing ever

Reds are working out pretty well for me, kind of rolled the dice on using reds instead of brown that i am used to. Tried lubing some reds the other day and they seem pretty fantastic so i am going to lube and sticker mine this weekend

4th work day using it the whole day, ive added a larger slope/tent

However i seem to be making more mistakes now, got to keep learning, it does make my hands hurt less for sure with it like this.l

how does the slope help ergonomically and by how much?

well your wrists are not as twisted that way with slope and its all around more comfortable, many keyboards have allowed this slope like kinesis freestyle, freestyle2, and goldtouch adjustable and the super rare ibm m15 (among some others).

in fact i just added even more slope and its perfect now

lets see a picture of it! i guess the best way to produce the slant is by buying the freestyle2 palm support?

ok so here is now the slope looks now, i made it detachable so that i could break it down to put in my laptop bag

the lifter is the VIP3 kit for the kinesis freestyle, i already owned one for my freestyle of 3 years but its like $45 new for the kit itself
http://www.amazon.com/Kinesis-Freestyle2-Accessory-AC820-BLK-separately/dp/B008BVNQW4

There is a smaller/cheaper v-lifter kit that does not include the palm rest (which you wont need for the ergodox) and is shorter. its called the V3 and its about $30 it should do the same thing but is smaller
http://www.amazon.com/Kinesis-Corporation-Ac730-blk-Freestyle-Accessory/dp/B003F8MDPY

I put big grip feet to keep from scratching desk and slide. the feet i bought were like $5 at target, i'm using big ones like this because they are less likely to come off while going in and out of my laptop bag...and then i used 3M fasteners (hardcore velcro), they are about $4 for a small pack, to attach the lifters

Here is the underneath, attaching the vlifters
(http://farm9.staticflickr.com/8104/8653837041_cfdefc34ff_z.jpg) (http://www.flickr.com/photos/panicfx/8653837041/)
(http://farm9.staticflickr.com/8118/8653837539_96ddb31fb1_z.jpg) (http://www.flickr.com/photos/panicfx/8653837539/)

here is the finished product with my wrist rests in which only the right side of my wrist touches them
(http://farm9.staticflickr.com/8248/8653837737_33e734f574_c.jpg) (http://www.flickr.com/photos/panicfx/8653837737/)
damn it is so awesome

here is the high and low settings of the v lifters, i use the higher lift
(http://farm9.staticflickr.com/8251/8654939272_1530093672_z.jpg) (http://www.flickr.com/photos/panicfx/8654939272/)
(http://farm9.staticflickr.com/8249/8654939496_c9ec5d4f5c_z.jpg) (http://www.flickr.com/photos/panicfx/8654939496/)

be interesting to see others use either of these kits to make a slope mod, the slope is so much worth it. i imagine for the full hand ergodox things on the vlifters would need to be clipped off for it to work correctly

Next steps for me

- sleeve a 3.5 connector TRRS cable to connect the two hands to semi-match my mimic cable. I have the blue sleeving and black shrink
- cleanup/sand/polish/maybe-paint-or-vinyl my aluminium case and build my second ergodox. use ergo clears or lubed reds again.
- when DSA retro arrives attempt to switch to colemak layout.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: seferphier on Tue, 16 April 2013, 04:37:24
yeah 205 alone is not a good ideal. the 103/205 mix on my reds is like the best thing ever

Show Image
Show Image
Show Image
Show Image
Reds are working out pretty well for me, kind of rolled the dice on using reds instead of brown that i am used to. Tried lubing some reds the other day and they seem pretty fantastic so i am going to lube and sticker mine this weekend

4th work day using it the whole day, ive added a larger slope/tent

However i seem to be making more mistakes now, got to keep learning, it does make my hands hurt less for sure with it like this.l

how does the slope help ergonomically and by how much?

well your wrists are not as twisted that way with slope and its all around more comfortable, many keyboards have allowed this slope like kinesis freestyle, freestyle2, and goldtouch adjustable and the super rare ibm m15 (among some others).

in fact i just added even more slope and its perfect now

lets see a picture of it! i guess the best way to produce the slant is by buying the freestyle2 palm support?

ok so here is now the slope looks now, i made it detachable so that i could break it down to put in my laptop bag

the lifter is the VIP3 kit for the kinesis freestyle, i already owned one for my freestyle of 3 years but its like $45 new for the kit itself
http://www.amazon.com/Kinesis-Freestyle2-Accessory-AC820-BLK-separately/dp/B008BVNQW4

There is a smaller/cheaper v-lifter kit that does not include the palm rest (which you wont need for the ergodox) and is shorter. its called the V3 and its about $30 it should do the same thing but is smaller
http://www.amazon.com/Kinesis-Corporation-Ac730-blk-Freestyle-Accessory/dp/B003F8MDPY

I put big grip feet to keep from scratching desk and slide. the feet i bought were like $5 at target, i'm using big ones like this because they are less likely to come off while going in and out of my laptop bag...and then i used 3M fasteners (hardcore velcro), they are about $4 for a small pack, to attach the lifters

Here is the underneath, attaching the vlifters
(http://farm9.staticflickr.com/8104/8653837041_cfdefc34ff_z.jpg) (http://www.flickr.com/photos/panicfx/8653837041/)
(http://farm9.staticflickr.com/8118/8653837539_96ddb31fb1_z.jpg) (http://www.flickr.com/photos/panicfx/8653837539/)

here is the finished product with my wrist rests in which only the right side of my wrist touches them
(http://farm9.staticflickr.com/8248/8653837737_33e734f574_c.jpg) (http://www.flickr.com/photos/panicfx/8653837737/)
damn it is so awesome

here is the high and low settings of the v lifters, i use the higher lift
(http://farm9.staticflickr.com/8251/8654939272_1530093672_z.jpg) (http://www.flickr.com/photos/panicfx/8654939272/)
(http://farm9.staticflickr.com/8249/8654939496_c9ec5d4f5c_z.jpg) (http://www.flickr.com/photos/panicfx/8654939496/)

be interesting to see others use either of these kits to make a slope mod, the slope is so much worth it. i imagine for the full hand ergodox things on the vlifters would need to be clipped off for it to work correctly

Next steps for me

- sleeve a 3.5 connector TRRS cable to connect the two hands to semi-match my mimic cable. I have the blue sleeving and black shrink
- cleanup/sand/polish/maybe-paint-or-vinyl my aluminium case and build my second ergodox. use ergo clears or lubed reds again.
- when DSA retro arrives attempt to switch to colemak layout.

very cool. i just made my own stand using the massdrop cardbox. nothing fancy
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Larken on Tue, 16 April 2013, 04:46:36
Thanks for the picture of it on 'high'. Very helpful. My attempts at trying to make my own supports aren't going well at all. Any stability issues if you rest your hand on the keyboard in that setting? I have a bad habit of putting my whole hand's weight on the rests, although I don't press down on it.

I'm liking what I see, although I wish it could go a little higher. I'll probably order those off amazon in a few days along with other stuff.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Glod on Tue, 16 April 2013, 04:58:52
no stability issues with the VIP3 kit, the kit was made to support weight of hands on a wrist rest for the freestyle so they are structurally strong. it also has built in rubber feet so it doesn't slide. it also does not wobble if i put weight on any of the 4 corners of the hand.

either of the kenesis v-lifter kits should work for either the classic or full hand ergodox, but modding will be required: sanding off some plastic, fasteners like i used, glue maybe, etc; but hell, if you built the ergodox i am sure modding the kenesis v-lifters shouldn't be a big deal

The v-lifter kits also come in white for the mac version of the kinesis freestyle (rev 1) but i couldn't find them anywhere on sale.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Larken on Tue, 16 April 2013, 05:07:55
nice. as long as they're structurally stable, its good enough for me. thanks for helping a fella out.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: seferphier on Tue, 16 April 2013, 11:34:32
i am really missing the metal plate feel from the filco. I don't really regret getting the acrylic palm rest though, i can imagine the palm rest would feel very cold during winter.

Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Glod on Tue, 16 April 2013, 20:08:17
I'm wondering if the ergodox is going to give me trouble at airport security with its clear acrylic case exposing amateur soldering work and exposed components. it may not look like a keyboard in the xray machine. lol. only one way to fine out when i fly next in may lololol

damn i can't get over how awesome this keyboard is! I'm so glad i joined wallet hack or i never would have heard of this last year.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: bisl on Wed, 17 April 2013, 00:15:50

from what I understand, 205 is too gummy to be used alone, but don't take my word for it, as I don't have access to the grease. there's a groupbuy for 103 done by jdcarpe in the groupbuy forums at the moment.

anyway it sounds like you used too much lube. I had one switch gum up like that when I purposely used a large amount of superlube on the switch and the springs to test how much would be effective. what you need is a thin film of the lube, enough to see the surface of the sliders shine under bright light, but not so much that you could actually use a new brush to reabsorb the lube from the switch to use on another switch. Hope that helps.

whitefiredragon has a pretty good video that I used as a guide, but I'm guessing that you already watched that?

Edit: as it is, I think 205 alone could probably be used, though it might not be optimal. Also, as it is a grease, there would be some increase in the force needed to actuate the switch, but it should settle out in a short while after you give the keys a good half hour of typing.

This is good information--thanks. You're probably right; I probably have too much on my stems. Especially since it's just 205 alone!

More newb lewb questions, for anyone who wants to field them:

When 103 and 205 are used together, is it the oil on top of the grease, applied separately, or are the two literally mixed up in a slippery cocktail and applied together?
I notice that 105 oil is much more conventionally available than 103; could it possibly be used with 205 to the same effect? I'm in on jdcarpe's 103 buy, but the gumminess of my keys (even unlubed) is bad enough that I'd get 105 and clean it off only to replace it with 103 when it gets here.
I notice that 105 is muv
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Larken on Wed, 17 April 2013, 06:18:29



This is good information--thanks. You're probably right; I probably have too much on my stems. Especially since it's just 205 alone!

More newb lewb questions, for anyone who wants to field them:

When 103 and 205 are used together, is it the oil on top of the grease, applied separately, or are the two literally mixed up in a slippery cocktail and applied together?
I notice that 105 oil is much more conventionally available than 103; could it possibly be used with 205 to the same effect? I'm in on jdcarpe's 103 buy, but the gumminess of my keys (even unlubed) is bad enough that I'd get 105 and clean it off only to replace it with 103 when it gets here.
I notice that 105 is muv

those are some expensive lube mixtures you're playing with. I recommend you simply clean off the current layer you have at the moment and use them without relubing until the 103 arrives.

as to your other questions, watching http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=eRvtLEZJFKM will give you answers. WFD actually shows how it's mixed. short answer - mixed up together in a cocktail, shaken and stirred.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=4EaKBfLB28U will show you how it's applied.

I believe some geekhackers have actually used 105 alone with some success in the past, but I have no idea if it could be mixed with 205. I wouldn't try it myself. The new gold standard would appear to be 103 + 205.

For those on a lower budget, i.e. me, superlube is working fine.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: TDub on Thu, 18 April 2013, 04:16:50
I used only 205 for my switches and I love it. But I have to add that I am using much heavier switches to begin with (clears and vintage blacks). The 205 makes both of them feel incredibly smooth and actually made them feel a little lighter for me. But I can see how it might have the opposite effect for reds. I do think the tactile switches profit more from the lube anyways, since they felt scratchier before lubing then the blacks did. I do plan on buying some 103 in the GB though and giving a mixture a try.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: kurplop on Wed, 24 April 2013, 21:00:34
I have the aluminum case and while I haven't used it much yet because of a problem I encountered modifying a trackball to fit into a tray I built for it I have some comments to make about it.

Things I like
The hollow thunk sound it makes when I bottom out keys.
The ability to place the two sides exactly where I am most comfortable- tenting, splaying and spacing.
The thrill of it actually working when I downloaded the firmware. A couple of months ago I didn't know what firmware was.
The chance to try my hand at working with aluminum,  soldering on pcb's, helicoils, etc.
Massdrop exceeding all expectations.
To be part of a great experiment with all of you.

Things that I'd change if I could
I would have made a bigger arc on the rows.
I would have bought a second aluminum case when I could.
I would have taken more time between coats finishing the integrated keyboard tray. The water borne finish blushed slightly and the colors aren't as rich as they might have been.

Still to do
I will probably anodize the aluminum top plates. They are quite soft as is.
Hopefully, I can troubleshoot my scrolling problem in the trackball or I'll own a very expensive paperweight.

I've been using a Truly Ergonomic keyboard for a year and while it's been a great improvement over a standard keyboard, I don't think they angled the columns enough for me, it's not tented and their lack of response to inquires has been insulting. I know the ErgoDox is a great improvement on all counts and it's nice to be a part of a project conceived by and developed by people who volunteered much so the rest of us could benefit.

Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Larken on Thu, 25 April 2013, 22:31:20
could we get this moved to either the ergonomics subsection or reviews? does seem more appropriate.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Glod on Fri, 26 April 2013, 01:00:11
I actually meant to create this in the ergonomics forum. it would go better in the ergonomics instead of review area considering it is not a single review. in fact yeah i should have asked hashbaz while he was looking in this thread to move it......

would love to hear more people share though experiences. thanks kurplop for added your input

surely out of the 200+ sold in round 1 there has to be a couple dozen or more assembled in use......

Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Larken on Fri, 26 April 2013, 01:08:38
yea, I was just thinking it'll get more eyeballs in the ergo forums as the keyboards section does seem to move a little fast. I'm still waiting on my v3s to be delivered, can't wait.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Glod on Mon, 29 April 2013, 01:40:49
well a little update on my ergodox experience

I'm up to 70wpm which is what i was before on normal keyboards, i'm no awesome typist like some here but to me my 70wpm is acceptable.

Ive realized that i actually like the hands a bit closer together in a distance similar to the kinesis advantage.

i still i like my original layout and i haven't changed it though when the DSA retro comes in i may try colemak and try to focus some energy off my pinkies.

I've become a little annoyed with a few things though, some of which is my fault

1. the wrist pads i am using are just too low, especially with the way i have the ergodox tented, i need to find some much higher ones to maybe get a kenesis advantage kind of thing going on. i may have to make them myself. It does make me a little bit regret not getting the full hand.

2. I am not happy with the looks of it. I really imagine myself not getting a good reception at an office when i set it up and looking like a weirdo. Not for the fact it is a split keyboard; the clear acrylic case, exposed parts, and mismatched key caps really makes it look like more of a prototype i should leave at home. I still have the aluminium case for the other ergodox un-built that maybe i can clean up and with the DSA Retro key caps it should look much better. I am just not digging the clear acrylic most of all. I really wish there were other case options like the one on the ergodox website.

3. i think i am starting to regret putting reds on the ergodox. when i first put them on and then lubed them i thought wow lubed reds are completely different from anything i have used and i was liking them. 2 weeks later and trying out my other keyboards like the topre, blues, and browns i realize that the tactility is more desirable. What i realized is that while i was typing slow on the ergodox learning it the reds were great but as i started to type faster and faster on it the reds start leaving a feeling on my fingers that is not pleasant. when i type faster i am hard on my keyboard and bottom out always.

4. i just cant use this thing for gaming, i think the matrix layout is actually throwing me off when i'm playing games. I am using my HHKB instead for gaming. it could be the wrist rest thing the most, when i play games i really rely on setting my wrists down on something instead of floating above the keyboard

oh well
/rant

hell it is geekhack, where else am i going to leave rants about my keyboards :P
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: ksm123 on Mon, 29 April 2013, 02:31:57
After reading about clear acrylic keyboard looks I started to wonder:
Did any of you took this keyboard through airport security? Were there any problems?
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Glod on Mon, 29 April 2013, 03:26:03
i will find out in 2 weeks when i fly for a short business trip.

i mean i know i made that comment earlier about it looking a little bit suspicious but i think it will be fine
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Larken on Mon, 29 April 2013, 04:43:16
I'm toying with the idea of printing the words "This is a Ergonomic Keyboard" in sticker form and pasting it on my ergodox that I plan to bring around. A little direct, but less so than having to explain what it is to airport security.

@Glod
1. For a tented set up, fullhand does work a lot better than classic. After my set of v3 arrives, I'll look into finish modding my fullhand complete with extra leather wrist pads. I'll probably post back when I'm done with it, but it'll probably take a while. I hope the third ergodox you got was of the fullhand variety?

2. I actually really like the transparent look, but the tendency of the acrylic to attract dirt and scratches gave me no choice but to paste some vinyl over mine. I got decent results, though I do miss seeing the the beautiful designed pcb through the acrylic. You could look into having the one on the website printed by shapeways, but it's pretty pricey.

3. Lubed ergo-clears, try it. I've tried every mx switch with the except of whites, vintage blues or blacks, and super-blacks, and ergo-clears are downright the best for typing if you're looking to avoid the click of the blues but still have tons of tactility.

4. I know what you're referring to in your post, and my personal experience is that tenting doesn't really work well for gaming. Set your ergodox flat down with a wrist rest while you're gaming and you probably won't have any problems using it.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: kurplop on Mon, 29 April 2013, 07:43:46
Glod, your experience is like the groom, waking up the day after the wedding, taking a good look at his sleeping bride and thinking,  "what have I done". Don't worry. She'll brush her teeth, do her hair and your concerns will fade away. Take care of her and she'll treat you right.

I appreciate your honesty about the ErgoDox and I had anticipated some of your concerns.

1. Maybe you've overdone the tenting angle. There's always the temptation to think that more is better and we end up solving one problem only to discover a new one. I think by using longer screws to add another layer under the case that extends forward to hold a wrist rest would be an easy and effective solution.

2. The look of the ErgoDox in the raw is truly that of an enthusiast's keyboard. Larken vinyl solution or placing an opaque sheet under the first layer would help. When the dust settles, we may find the Shapeway design to be the most acceptable for workplace conformity.

3. Do you think O-rings would help the red's?

4. Why do you think the matrix design affects your gaming?

Do you sometimes think that we are more interested in searching for that pot of gold at the end of the rainbow than finding it?
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Glod on Mon, 29 April 2013, 08:25:27
@Larken

well.... the third i purchased was also not full hand as well :O  regretting that and its too late to change that. i am going to have to come up a wrist rest solution

The second will have ergo clears for sure, i didn't get clears through massdrop because I ordered a bunch of clears through the phantom parts group buy before the ergodox sale....I'm still waiting for those to come (*sigh*)

i think you are right, the tent is bad for gaming

@kurplop

i may have overdone the tent just a little bit.

i am using O-rings right now, added them last week and they help a little bit  but it doesn't change the fact they are linear and the only tactility is me bottoming out.

actually i take that back about the matrix affecting the gaming, i think it is more of the tent/slope i have created

--


i think later next month or June i am going to look into having another case made for the ergodox. ive never looked into any this stuff like cad, cnc stuff, 3d print/shapeways stuff; it would be a completely new adventure for me.


Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: wasabah on Mon, 29 April 2013, 12:14:41
After tweaking my layout, I'm actually satisfied with my Ergodox.
I still feel somewhat limited because my typing speed took a huge hit.
I was a really fast typist, but I never really learned the 10 finger system.
This in combination with the quite easy going browns (which I love) leads to a lot of mistakes.

Another thing I need to solve very soon is the friction issue. The Ergodox behaves on my desk like an air hockey puck.
Do you have any ideas how to solve this elegantly?
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: esoomenona on Mon, 29 April 2013, 12:16:41
MMMMM, come to me, ErgoDox! I hope I love this thing.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Larken on Mon, 29 April 2013, 12:30:36
After tweaking my layout, I'm actually satisfied with my Ergodox.
I still feel somewhat limited because my typing speed took a huge hit.
I was a really fast typist, but I never really learned the 10 finger system.
This in combination with the quite easy going browns (which I love) leads to a lot of mistakes.

Another thing I need to solve very soon is the friction issue. The Ergodox behaves on my desk like an air hockey puck.
Do you have any ideas how to solve this elegantly?

I use these. They would fit well with a transparent case. Alternatively, you could get a nonslip mat for your entire table.

(http://farm9.staticflickr.com/8103/8630680182_b01118de20_b.jpg) (http://www.flickr.com/photos/89364707@N02/8630680182/)

I'd pretty much hit the same speed I did with a usual qwerty keyboard, which was about 85wpm (not that impressive, I know). I never did learn the 10 finger system until I got the ergodox either, but at the moment I really dread going back to a staggered board.

@kurplop

I found my pot of gold, and I'm happy. I actually lost interest in getting any more keyboards. Btw I found your analogy of the newly married man pretty amusing :D and I'm a huge huge fan of your tray. have you fixed the issue with your expert mouse yet?

@the moose deity - I have no doubt you'd hate the first 2-3 days. but keep at it alright? it'll grow on you!
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: esoomenona on Mon, 29 April 2013, 12:32:32
Thanks! I intend to keep at it. I plan to use it at work, where I do almost all of my keyboard typing. Just need to determine a layout I might like! And hope that DSA Retro comes soon.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: CommunistWitchDr on Mon, 29 April 2013, 12:33:43
Pololu (http://www.pololu.com/catalog/product/749) prices a custom cut acrylic (Using two colors oreo style) at $100. Total, not per hand. One solid color would be cheaper.
So a black acrylic case wouldn't be too expensive.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: wasabah on Mon, 29 April 2013, 12:38:56
@Larken: interesting! What are the big ones?

Ah, and just for the record: I love the Ergodox for gaming! ;)
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: kurplop on Mon, 29 April 2013, 12:42:10
@Larken
It's nice to know that the simile wasn't wasted.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Larken on Mon, 29 April 2013, 12:45:14
@Larken: interesting! What are the big ones?

Ah, and just for the record: I love the Ergodox for gaming! ;)

its just some random door bumpers I got at a hardware store. its taller so to achieve a tented angle, but I'm finding the angle not extreme enough for me, so I'm waiting on the kinesis v3 kit Glod recommended earlier in this thread before I make anymore changes.

gotta say though, the split keyboard along with the tented angle works wonders for me - I type in excess of 8 hours daily, and was starting to show mild signs of CTS before I got the ergodox. turned to voice recognition for a while (didn't work out) and cut short my hours for about 1-2 weeks. don't have much of a wrist issue after I got the ergodox - except maybe for extensive gaming sessions with the mouse hand. love it.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: wasabah on Mon, 29 April 2013, 12:51:13
Okay, cool. Thanks!
I really like the idea, especially because I'm only looking for a slight angle.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: sordna on Tue, 30 April 2013, 00:27:15
i am using O-rings right now, added them last week and they help a little bit  but it doesn't change the fact they are linear and the only tactility is me bottoming out.

Why don't you install a buzzer like I did? You can make your reds "clicky" which REALLY helps avoid bottoming out:
http://geekhack.org/index.php?topic=22780.msg840977#msg840977
http://geekhack.org/index.php?topic=22780.msg844285#msg844285

(http://geekhack.org/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=22780.0;attach=17926;image)
(http://geekhack.org/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=22780.0;attach=18256;image)
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: tp4tissue on Tue, 30 April 2013, 01:00:36
Glod, your experience is like the groom, waking up the day after the wedding, taking a good look at his sleeping bride and thinking,  "what have I done". Don't worry. She'll brush her teeth, do her hair and your concerns will fade away. Take care of her and she'll treat you right.

I appreciate your honesty about the ErgoDox and I had anticipated some of your concerns.

1. Maybe you've overdone the tenting angle. There's always the temptation to think that more is better and we end up solving one problem only to discover a new one. I think by using longer screws to add another layer under the case that extends forward to hold a wrist rest would be an easy and effective solution.

2. The look of the ErgoDox in the raw is truly that of an enthusiast's keyboard. Larken vinyl solution or placing an opaque sheet under the first layer would help. When the dust settles, we may find the Shapeway design to be the most acceptable for workplace conformity.

3. Do you think O-rings would help the red's?

4. Why do you think the matrix design affects your gaming?

Do you sometimes think that we are more interested in searching for that pot of gold at the end of the rainbow than finding it?

Please don't compare trusty'ol electronics with women...

I'm not against objectifying, but eh... not nice..

However, I'd say the ergodox is way more reliable though it's function is more limited.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: litster on Tue, 30 April 2013, 02:25:14
any one has both the regular version and the full wrist rest version?  I know the aluminum case from Mass Drop is sucky.  Any feedback on the acrylic case designs besides not having an adjustable leg solution, or any leg solution?
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: ksm123 on Tue, 30 April 2013, 03:04:03
A question for those of you, who use acrylic plate from massdrop purchase.

Is it possible to disassemble a switch (to change spring or lube it) without un-soldering it first? If so, then what tools are required?
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Larken on Tue, 30 April 2013, 03:10:30
I have both, and prefer the full wrist rest version. Aside from really tight tolerances around the sides, there's also the issue of not the stabiliser slots for the thumb buttons not being usable, as well as something funky about the directions of stab mounts too, though I remember bpiphany commenting that he made a boo boo on the pcb on this, which I assume was how the placement in the acrylic came around (although in actual practice, it can be used without stabs, so no biggie). There's also a few funky stuff that cropped up (which I believe was due to the manufacturing rather than your design, so that's irrelevant).

Overall, I really like the case design and it works.

Here's an idea that could be considered though - detachable wrist rests using a hybrid of the classic case and the full hand. What kurplop said earlier about extending layers gave me the idea (I have no idea how to use CAD, so pardon my doodling):

(http://farm9.staticflickr.com/8544/8694449709_146e89d90c.jpg) (http://www.flickr.com/photos/89364707@N02/8694449709/)

1. Start off with the classic case design.
2. Take layers 2,3,4 and extend the side where the wrist rest was supposed to be, by another inch or so. add screw spots.
3. recess the wrist rest's 2,3,4 layers by the same amount.
4. add screw spots. (the blue dots) - using the same bolt and nuts in the original design to hold it together.

Just a idea that came up suddenly, as adding that part there (the red area) shouldn't interfere too much with the way people are holding their hands when using the classic, but still gives them the option of attaching a rest if they want. Screw hole placements all around would have to be adjusted of course.

A question for those of you, who use acrylic plate from massdrop purchase.

Is it possible to disassemble a switch (to change spring or lube it) without un-soldering it first? If so, then what tools are required?

it's possible. just use a screwdriver or tweezers, or if you can get your hands on a pair, Beast's switch tools. It's designed for the ez open method.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: kurplop on Tue, 30 April 2013, 07:15:18

@sordna

I really like your buzzer idea. I have a few questions.

1. Can it be turned off and on at will?

2. How loud is it and can the volume be adjusted? What does it sound like?

3. Would you say that the buzzer is vulnerable to damage where it's located and could there be any issues using it with the aluminum case?

4. Is it mounted after the case is assembled? How?

Sorry if you've answered these questions else ware.

Thanks for all the support you've offered to us on this project. For every question you've answered, there has undoubtably been scores of us who have quietly benefitted.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Grim Fandango on Tue, 30 April 2013, 07:58:11
I like ergonomic keyboards, and have used those which kind of separate your hands. The thing I like most about them, is the way they are shaped to facilitate a comfortable position of the hands. I have had little trouble adapting to the ones I tried.

The ergodox does not seem as appealing to me however. It just sits flat on the table, looking cool but it does not seem to do too much for you when it comes to ergonomics (or at least it seems that way compared to other ergonomic keyboards).



Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: esoomenona on Tue, 30 April 2013, 08:01:14
i am using O-rings right now, added them last week and they help a little bit  but it doesn't change the fact they are linear and the only tactility is me bottoming out.

Why don't you install a buzzer like I did? You can make your reds "clicky" which REALLY helps avoid bottoming out:
http://geekhack.org/index.php?topic=22780.msg840977#msg840977
http://geekhack.org/index.php?topic=22780.msg844285#msg844285

Show Image
(http://geekhack.org/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=22780.0;attach=17926;image)

Show Image
(http://geekhack.org/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=22780.0;attach=18256;image)

You have a video of that in action?
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: sordna on Tue, 30 April 2013, 13:31:40

@sordna

I really like your buzzer idea. I have a few questions.

1. Can it be turned off and on at will?

You would need to modify the firmware if you want the capability to turn it on/off with some hotkey. My firmware modification keeps it on since I can't live without it :-)  But they way I installed it I can unplug it easily.

Quote
2. How loud is it and can the volume be adjusted? What does it sound like?

It's about as loud as bottoming out without o-rings. It sounds similar to a Kinesis Advantage with clicks turned on.

Quote
3. Would you say that the buzzer is vulnerable to damage where it's located and could there be any issues using it with the aluminum case?

You would need to either drill a big hole in the case to fit it in (best option) or pull 2 little wires and somehow mount it on top. They I put it (on top of the case) is not a good option if you want to transport the keyboard.

Quote
4. Is it mounted after the case is assembled? How?

What I did is drill my case and squeeze in some wires in the relevant teensy holes (see my hi res pic). I haven't actually soldered it so I can easily pull it in and out!

Hopefully GH will allow posting of an mp3 file with the sound, first I type without the buzzer, then with the buzzer, and last type slowly without bottoming out at all so you can only hear the buzzer and not the keys.

[attachurl=1]
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: tp4tissue on Tue, 30 April 2013, 13:49:19

@sordna

I really like your buzzer idea. I have a few questions.

1. Can it be turned off and on at will?

You would need to modify the firmware if you want the capability to turn it on/off with some hotkey. My firmware modification keeps it on since I can't live without it :-)  But they way I installed it I can unplug it easily.

Quote
2. How loud is it and can the volume be adjusted? What does it sound like?

It's about as loud as bottoming out without o-rings. It sounds similar to a Kinesis Advantage with clicks turned on.

Quote
3. Would you say that the buzzer is vulnerable to damage where it's located and could there be any issues using it with the aluminum case?

You would need to either drill a big hole in the case to fit it in (best option) or pull 2 little wires and somehow mount it on top. They I put it (on top of the case) is not a good option if you want to transport the keyboard.

Quote
4. Is it mounted after the case is assembled? How?

What I did is drill my case and squeeze in some wires in the relevant teensy holes (see my hi res pic). I haven't actually soldered it so I can easily pull it in and out!

Hopefully GH will allow posting of an mp3 file with the sound, first I type without the buzzer, then with the buzzer, and last type slowly without bottoming out at all so you can only hear the buzzer and not the keys.

[attachurl=1]


Hey sordna, could space ship laser sounds be done? or startrek holo-deck sounds?
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Dgsbllx on Tue, 30 April 2013, 14:00:48
Hey sordna, could space ship laser sounds be done? or startrek holo-deck sounds?

(http://weknowmemes.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/12/mother-of-god-gif.gif)
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Glod on Tue, 30 April 2013, 16:07:45
put sound effects like that when changing layers, would be pretty cool instead

attempting some new ergonomics

No tenting/slope this time.
Instead of the 14 inches i usually had between the hands, the hands are only 6 inches apart at the bottom of the thumb clusters and 4 inches apart at the very top.
A higher wrist rest, 1.5 inch thich instead of .75 inch thick. the top of the wrist rest is .5 inches higher than the top of the the ergodox case. just a little higher than the keycaps.
Raising my chair up so that my elbows on the arm rests of my chair are the same height as the wrists on the rests.

I think the distance is better like this  and the height of the wrist rests seems correct now. there is still room for improvement. i think i may want to go back to tenting them up just a little bit, like 10 degree angle instead of the 35 degree angle i had before (!)
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Dreyer on Sat, 04 May 2013, 12:12:52
Man, after a week using my ErgoDox I am really loving it. Here are some thoughts thus far:

-It was really fun and intuitive to assembly it, even for a electronics layman like me.  It was the first time that i soldered smd and it was quite a mess. Even so the quality of the plates were so good that compensate my poor soldering skills.

- I really like the split design. It is very comfortable to type with even after long periods of time. It also helps to help me to revert some typing bad habits, like pushing some keys (like the "y")
with different hands depending of the world.

- The matrix layout is very nice, making easier to touch type. However it takes time to get use to it. For example even after a week I find somewhat odd to press the "n" key, it is only a few millimeters father than in a normal keyboard but for some reason I find myself making a lot of mistakes.

-I opted for black cherry switches, after a long time pondering between them and the reds. I think i made the right choice in the end since even with the blacks I find it very easy to press a key that I didn't mean to.

-I really liked all the customization possibilities. The configurator tool is really easy to use (much more after I discovered that I didn't need to press the teensy button each time I want to change profiles), and i find myself wasting long periods of time messing with different layouts.

-I find it very difficult to notice when the leds are on. I don't know if i mount then right tough.

-As many other people are complaining I find the thumb cluster a little to far away, making some of the keys, especially the most outer one, hard to press.

-I don't mind the blank keycaps. Since I touch type this isn't a problem at all. However a lot of my friend that liked the keyboard, couldn't use it.

All in all is a great keyboard that I would definitely  recommend to anyone into mechanical keyboards.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: seferphier on Sat, 04 May 2013, 14:00:25
The configurator tool is really easy to use (much more after I discovered that I didn't need to press the teensy button each time I want to change profiles), and i find myself wasting long periods of time messing with different layouts.

how do you change profiles without pressing the teensy button?
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Dreyer on Sat, 04 May 2013, 16:01:54
Well, in the configurator page you can assign one of the keyboard keys as a "tennsy bootloader", so you can press it instead of the actual button on the teensy.

I guess you still have to press a button, but it is much faster than to actual disassembling the plates each time you want to load a new profile.
Title: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: daerid on Sat, 04 May 2013, 17:24:29
F that. I wouldn't give up a key for that, I think I'm just going to wire in a small external switch for the boot loader.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: WRXChris on Sat, 04 May 2013, 17:46:48
F that. I wouldn't give up a key for that, I think I'm just going to wire in a small external switch for the boot loader.

But the teensy button can be put on any layer!  I believe the firmware is capable of 20 layers, surely you can find 1 free key out of 1560! ;)
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: tp4tissue on Sat, 04 May 2013, 17:51:37
F that. I wouldn't give up a key for that, I think I'm just going to wire in a small external switch for the boot loader.

But the teensy button can be put on any layer!  I believe the firmware is capable of 20 layers, surely you can find 1 free key out of 1560! ;)

that's alotta pancakes :D
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: daerid on Sat, 04 May 2013, 18:52:13
But the teensy button can be put on any layer!  I believe the firmware is capable of 20 layers, surely you can find 1 free key out of 1560! ;)

Ahhh ok. That makes things much nicer then. Thanks!
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Calyx on Thu, 06 June 2013, 15:55:15
I dont have an ErgoDox (yet) but I do have a TECK.  A lot of people have had concerns about the lack of tenting on the TECK.  I did too until I applied some cello ergonomics.  On the cello and violin the left hand fingers are slanted rather than perpendicular to the strings.  This provides a lot of ergonomic benefits that can transfer to the keyboard.  Most people see the aligned matrix keys and naturally want to line their fingers up with the rows.  While this may have been what the inventors intended it is not necessarily the best way to type.  Slanting your fingers outward allows your wrists to straighten out of ulnar deviation.  A picture is worth a thousand words. 

[attachimg=1]

This lessens the need for tenting because it allows the wrists to relax in the same direction.  If you are using a wrist rest then the wrists no longer lie flat but on the outer wrist bone. 

As always, YMMV.  But it works well for me.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: eviltobz on Thu, 06 June 2013, 17:03:09
But the teensy button can be put on any layer!  I believe the firmware is capable of 20 layers, surely you can find 1 free key out of 1560! ;)

Ahhh ok. That makes things much nicer then. Thanks!
i was thinking about adding in an additional switch for teensying, but after considering the layer options i've set up an admin layer to do a few functions that you don't want to be pressing accidentally, such as the teensy programming key. i've got a number layer that's only accessed whilst held down, which has another holdy-downy layer shift that contains my teensy (and the abilty to switch my base layer between colemak for mac, colemak for windows & qwerty for windows modes). having to hold down a few layer shifts makes it nice and safe from accidents and as mentioned, doesn't really impact your available buttons :)
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: seferphier on Fri, 07 June 2013, 04:31:13
I dont have an ErgoDox (yet) but I do have a TECK.  A lot of people have had concerns about the lack of tenting on the TECK.  I did too until I applied some cello ergonomics.  On the cello and violin the left hand fingers are slanted rather than perpendicular to the strings.  This provides a lot of ergonomic benefits that can transfer to the keyboard.  Most people see the aligned matrix keys and naturally want to line their fingers up with the rows.  While this may have been what the inventors intended it is not necessarily the best way to type.  Slanting your fingers outward allows your wrists to straighten out of ulnar deviation.  A picture is worth a thousand words. 

(Attachment Link)

This lessens the need for tenting because it allows the wrists to relax in the same direction.  If you are using a wrist rest then the wrists no longer lie flat but on the outer wrist bone. 

As always, YMMV.  But it works well for me.


good one. i realized this yesterday when i felt that ergodox wasnt that comfortable to type. i tilted the keyboard like you said and it works like a charm. that picture is very useful. i was thinking on how to determine the tilt, now i know.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: wasabah on Fri, 07 June 2013, 08:01:17
I dont have an ErgoDox (yet) but I do have a TECK.  A lot of people have had concerns about the lack of tenting on the TECK.  I did too until I applied some cello ergonomics.  On the cello and violin the left hand fingers are slanted rather than perpendicular to the strings.  This provides a lot of ergonomic benefits that can transfer to the keyboard.  Most people see the aligned matrix keys and naturally want to line their fingers up with the rows.  While this may have been what the inventors intended it is not necessarily the best way to type.  Slanting your fingers outward allows your wrists to straighten out of ulnar deviation.  A picture is worth a thousand words. 

(Attachment Link)

This lessens the need for tenting because it allows the wrists to relax in the same direction.  If you are using a wrist rest then the wrists no longer lie flat but on the outer wrist bone. 

As always, YMMV.  But it works well for me.


good one. i realized this yesterday when i felt that ergodox wasnt that comfortable to type. i tilted the keyboard like you said and it works like a charm. that picture is very useful. i was thinking on how to determine the tilt, now i know.

Mh, I thought he meant to tilt the fingers, not the keyboard?
Could you send a pic with your keyboard & hand tilt?
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: bisl on Fri, 07 June 2013, 14:49:46
Went tilting the wrists as seen in the picture, the fingers move slightly to the outside as you extend them, so I believe the idea would be to rotate the dox hands outward accordingly, so that the bottoms are closer together, and the tops farther apart.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: daerid on Fri, 07 June 2013, 14:53:19
I dont have an ErgoDox (yet) but I do have a TECK.  A lot of people have had concerns about the lack of tenting on the TECK.  I did too until I applied some cello ergonomics.  On the cello and violin the left hand fingers are slanted rather than perpendicular to the strings.  This provides a lot of ergonomic benefits that can transfer to the keyboard.  Most people see the aligned matrix keys and naturally want to line their fingers up with the rows.  While this may have been what the inventors intended it is not necessarily the best way to type.  Slanting your fingers outward allows your wrists to straighten out of ulnar deviation.  A picture is worth a thousand words. 

(Attachment Link)

This lessens the need for tenting because it allows the wrists to relax in the same direction.  If you are using a wrist rest then the wrists no longer lie flat but on the outer wrist bone. 

As always, YMMV.  But it works well for me.


Nice to see a picture demonstrating that. I've been typing with my hands/fingers tilted like that all my life, didn't realize there was a wrong way to do it.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: davkol on Fri, 07 June 2013, 15:00:52
I dont have an ErgoDox (yet) but I do have a TECK.  A lot of people have had concerns about the lack of tenting on the TECK.  I did too until I applied some cello ergonomics.  On the cello and violin the left hand fingers are slanted rather than perpendicular to the strings.  This provides a lot of ergonomic benefits that can transfer to the keyboard.  Most people see the aligned matrix keys and naturally want to line their fingers up with the rows.  While this may have been what the inventors intended it is not necessarily the best way to type.  Slanting your fingers outward allows your wrists to straighten out of ulnar deviation.  A picture is worth a thousand words. 

(Attachment Link)

This lessens the need for tenting because it allows the wrists to relax in the same direction.  If you are using a wrist rest then the wrists no longer lie flat but on the outer wrist bone. 

As always, YMMV.  But it works well for me.


Nice to see a picture demonstrating that. I've been typing with my hands/fingers tilted like that all my life, didn't realize there was a wrong way to do it.


Well... I was about to post the same thing. I can't really imagine why would anyone bend their wrists like in the first picture on a split keyboard. However, I do think tenting the whole keyboard (or rather its halves) is still beneficial, because of angle between forearms and the keyboard.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: daerid on Fri, 07 June 2013, 19:24:14
Well... I was about to post the same thing. I can't really imagine why would anyone bend their wrists like in the first picture on a split keyboard. However, I do think tenting the whole keyboard (or rather its halves) is still beneficial, because of angle between forearms and the keyboard.

I don't even do that on a standard straight keyboard. But then again, I have abnormally long fingers, so that's probably a help.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Larken on Fri, 07 June 2013, 22:50:33
for those looking to set something up with an adjustable tenting set up, I can vouch for the v3 supports from kinesis, even for the full hand version (just need a hacksaw for one part.) When tenting, my wrists are perfectly straight. Very comfortable to type on.

Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Glod on Sat, 08 June 2013, 14:35:11
for me the tenting is a must and my wrists are straight and hands level with my elbow rests. the only pain i have now is my finger tips because i jackhammer my keyboard, a habit i cant seem to shake. i have the kenesis V3 for my other ergodox that i am modding right now and im going to get the kenesis VIP kit to work with my Kurlop ErgoDock. its expensive for a piece of plastic but it already has the feet on it and its adjustable, i think after spending 3 bills on a keyboard, 20 something bucks USD isn't much to add to the cost. requires some modding to make pretty.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: tp4tissue on Sat, 08 June 2013, 18:31:40
I am only up to 100 wpm after 5 hours of use. maybe by the end of the week I'll be back to normal speed.

the main difficulty is that now I have " B and  " Y mapped to places where they're used with different fingers entirely

Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: SubGothius on Sun, 09 June 2013, 19:00:02
I accomplished tenting with some PCB standoffs I found at Radio Shack that happen to be M3 threaded, same as the screws provided with the ErgoDox:

[attach=1]

Some closeups from my initial prototyping before full assembly:

[attach=2]
[attach=3]

You can't really see it, but I thought it wise to add a washer between the case and standoffs to distribute stress, just in case those long legs might act as levers and possibly crack the acrylic; I might get a few more washers to put topside, under each tent leg's screw cap, for the same reason.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: tp4tissue on Sun, 09 June 2013, 19:07:02
I accomplished tenting with some PCB standoffs I found at Radio Shack that happen to be M3 threaded, same as the screws provided with the ErgoDox:

(Attachment Link)

Some closeups from my initial prototyping before full assembly:

(Attachment Link)
(Attachment Link)

Thanks for that, i just bought a stand off kit along with 40mm screws this would give me good adjustment in both axis to perfectly fit my hand plane.

http://www.amazon.com/Standoff-Hex-Head-Screw-Pcs/dp/B00CTWD4EQ/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1370822808&sr=8-1&keywords=m3+standoff+kit
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: pprjr on Wed, 12 June 2013, 23:00:15
I am interested in a ergodox, but I do not want to assemble one, someone would be willing to sell a assembled to me or tell me where I can find to buy?
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: seferphier on Tue, 18 June 2013, 20:18:30
surprisingly, I am still making quite a bit of typo with the ergodox. anyone with the same experience? especially with the numbers, given that 1-6 fit on the left hand
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: tp4tissue on Tue, 18 June 2013, 21:20:30
surprisingly, I am still making quite a bit of typo with the ergodox. anyone with the same experience? especially with the numbers, given that 1-6 fit on the left hand

I use the number layer on the ergodox to type numbers. I'm almost 95% accurate with this considering it's almost identical to a normal numberpad

I am now training my left hand for it since this is far more useful.. whereas prior to the ergodox I didn't have the option of using the numpad with my left hand.


Accuracy on alpha keys are at 99%.. even though I had to re-adapt to 4 new finger positions..
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: kurplop on Tue, 18 June 2013, 21:32:03
surprisingly, I am still making quite a bit of typo with the ergodox. anyone with the same experience? especially with the numbers, given that 1-6 fit on the left hand



I'm a little surprised by how quickly some have adapted to theirs. Different layouts, vertical columns, thumb clusters, experimenting with different slopes, tilts and separations. All of these things take time to get use to. Do yourself a favor. Remap the backspace to a comfortable location.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: tp4tissue on Tue, 18 June 2013, 22:05:49
surprisingly, I am still making quite a bit of typo with the ergodox. anyone with the same experience? especially with the numbers, given that 1-6 fit on the left hand



I'm a little surprised by how quickly some have adapted to theirs. Different layouts, vertical columns, thumb clusters, experimenting with different slopes, tilts and separations. All of these things take time to get use to. Do yourself a favor. Remap the backspace to a comfortable location.

The hardest part was adapting to the Awesome... I still can't get over just how much there is..
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: daerid on Tue, 18 June 2013, 23:14:32
It is pretty damn awesome. Much more relaxing for my shoulders. I just need to adjust to the where I've got the arrow keys and hopefully I'll be able to go full ErgoDox in a couple of days (still got actually work to do).
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: daerid on Tue, 18 June 2013, 23:15:28
I'll be honest though, I don't want to stop typing on this thing. I installed Vimium for Chrome just because I don't want to take my hands off the 'Dox while browsing (although Vimium fails hard at Facebook).
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Glod on Tue, 18 June 2013, 23:28:57
so happy its working out for people, i seriously doubt i will be using a non-"ergonomic" keyboard as my daily driver ever again. I am still interested in what Kenesis is planning.

Because i still like building and customizing keyboards--i just finished my first Phantom YAY!--i think im still going to use a standard staggered keyboard for doing games and then the ergonomic keyboard for everything else. i am getting a keyboard tray (the arm type not the shelf type) on my new desk so that i can have 2 keyboards set up :) weeee keyboards

i think one of the reasons i got used to the keyboard so quickly was because i use a keyboard so intensively each day that i put myself in a position where i had to learn, i removed all other keyboards. Another reason is my layout isn't very creative, i made it to resemble other keyboards so that i wouldn't have to completely retrain. im slowly learning how to use my thumb for backspace

(http://almightyglod.com/public_stack/ErgoDox_Layout/1/Glod_ErgoDox_Layout_June_2013.png)
i did however move the numbers back to next to each other, the -= keys are now next to the backspace again. at work i have to type in lots of things that required dashes and underscores and it became annoying trying to learn to do it next to the 6


I am starting to regret choosing the ergo whites on ERGODOX PRIME.. i love clicky switches the best but due to my HEAVY typing style the bottoming out plus the click is driving my wife nuts even when my office door is shut (i work mostly remotely). plus i think when you remove whites from their original assembly they must have some sort of lubrication, the click is no longer soft anymore, the whites are just as loud as blues, just a higher pitch.

thanks to the plate design, i think the next time i have like 5-6 hours free ill do a stem/slider swap and try ergo clears or lubed ergo clears. I already have a lubed red ergodox.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: CommunistWitchDr on Tue, 18 June 2013, 23:32:54
I'll be honest though, I don't want to stop typing on this thing. I installed Vimium for Chrome just because I don't want to take my hands off the 'Dox while browsing (although Vimium fails hard at Facebook).

Vimperator on Firefox absolutely kills Vimium.

One of the main reasons I'm on firefox.



As for edoxes I am so tempted to get a second one with clears as a portable board.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: daerid on Tue, 18 June 2013, 23:34:48
Yah. I know about Vimperator. I don't want to talk about it :(
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: CommunistWitchDr on Tue, 18 June 2013, 23:51:26
Yah. I know about Vimperator. I don't want to talk about it :(

I will admit it can be huge and confusing, even if you're already proficient in vim.

You can use the browser normally in vimium and not even know it's there until you want to use it.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Larken on Wed, 19 June 2013, 00:10:44
so happy its working out for people, i seriously doubt i will be using a non-"ergonomic" keyboard as my daily driver ever again. I am still interested in what Kenesis is planning.

Because i still like building and customizing keyboards--i just finished my first Phantom YAY!--i think im still going to use a standard staggered keyboard for doing games and then the ergonomic keyboard for everything else. i am getting a keyboard tray (the arm type not the shelf type) on my new desk so that i can have 2 keyboards set up :) weeee keyboards

i think one of the reasons i got used to the keyboard so quickly was because i use a keyboard so intensively each day that i put myself in a position where i had to learn, i removed all other keyboards. Another reason is my layout isn't very creative, i made it to resemble other keyboards so that i wouldn't have to completely retrain. im slowly learning how to use my thumb for backspace

Show Image
(http://almightyglod.com/public_stack/ErgoDox_Layout/1/Glod_ErgoDox_Layout_June_2013.png)

i did however move the numbers back to next to each other, the -= keys are now next to the backspace again. at work i have to type in lots of things that required dashes and underscores and it became annoying trying to learn to do it next to the 6


I am starting to regret choosing the ergo whites on ERGODOX PRIME.. i love clicky switches the best but due to my HEAVY typing style the bottoming out plus the click is driving my wife nuts even when my office door is shut (i work mostly remotely). plus i think when you remove whites from their original assembly they must have some sort of lubrication, the click is no longer soft anymore, the whites are just as loud as blues, just a higher pitch.

thanks to the plate design, i think the next time i have like 5-6 hours free ill do a stem/slider swap and try ergo clears or lubed ergo clears. I already have a lubed red ergodox.


Are the media keys on L1 actually working, or are those placeholders to show what it's supposed to do?
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: noisyturtle on Wed, 19 June 2013, 02:25:35
[attach=1]
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: tp4tissue on Wed, 19 June 2013, 02:33:12
(Attachment Link)

well, y do you not have one?
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Glod on Wed, 19 June 2013, 03:35:19
Are the media keys on L1 actually working, or are those placeholders to show what it's supposed to do?

I wish they worked by they no work. I really want the volume control...
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Larken on Wed, 19 June 2013, 03:38:45
Are the media keys on L1 actually working, or are those placeholders to show what it's supposed to do?

I wish they worked by they no work. I really want the volume control...

ah damn. I was hoping you'd tell me otherwise, as I have a similar layout with regards to volume control. doing it with autohotkey at the moment, but that doesn't work when I'm not using my own computer. would be cool if I could just plug in the ergodox at work and mute the volume as an when I like.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: daerid on Wed, 19 June 2013, 09:40:40
I think I'm going to take a look at the firmware and see if we can't get those pesky VK codes showing up in Windows
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: tp4tissue on Wed, 19 June 2013, 09:47:42
I think I'm going to take a look at the firmware and see if we can't get those pesky VK codes showing up in Windows

Awesome thanks.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: daerid on Wed, 19 June 2013, 10:33:48
Yah. I know about Vimperator. I don't want to talk about it :(

I will admit it can be huge and confusing, even if you're already proficient in vim.

You can use the browser normally in vimium and not even know it's there until you want to use it.

You misunderstand me. I absolutely love Vimperator. I don't want to talk about it because I'm so bummed that Vimium  sucks in comparison. It's not enough to get me to switch back to Firefox, but it's close.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Calyx on Thu, 20 June 2013, 14:41:02
Where can I get a blank one of these to make my own layout?


Show Image
(http://almightyglod.com/public_stack/ErgoDox_Layout/1/Glod_ErgoDox_Layout_June_2013.png)



Thanks
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: daerid on Thu, 20 June 2013, 18:14:51
Try here (http://www.massdrop.com/ext/ergodox/)
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: fisofo on Tue, 25 June 2013, 17:07:35
A question for you all: I'm going to hop in and buy the ErgoDox before this latest GB expires (4 days!), but I was wondering what you all thought of the option to get Blank PBT DSA key caps included with it for $37? I'm a bit leery of this as I've never done blanks before, although I am a touch-typist and don't need to look at my keyboard.

I am hoping to learn a new layout with the ErgoDox, so blanks may force me to learn, but maybe that's too much at once (haven't decided on layout yet)? I'm also not really sure what the best option would be to get labelled key caps for this thing even if I wanted to though.

Any thoughts? Thank you!
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Glod on Tue, 25 June 2013, 18:41:39
you really NEED to grab massdrop's keycaps even if you are going to use your own. It is almost impossible otherwise to get the right profile 2x, 1.5x, and 1x caps for the pinky areas and thumb cluster. You can always mix in other keycaps into the massdrop ones if you absolutely need legends instead of blank.

You have a choice of DSA and DCS, DSA is an offered add on and is cheap and if you want DCS you have to purchase it in the separate DCS group buy that closes in 2 days instead of an add on like the DSA. DSA looks better but has a bit of disadvantage if you have never used the keyboard before because everything feels the same. the DCS is a bit more in cost because less people jumped on them.

its a little hypocritical of me because i have legends on my keycaps on my ergodox, but that's mostly for aesthetics only.
Easing yourself into learning how to do blanks is better for you, looking at the keys while typing can somewhat cancel out some of the advantages of the keyboard. You can always put on some cheap OEM keycaps with labels as training wheels until you learn the keyboard and then swap with the blanks after you are comfortable.

Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: fisofo on Tue, 25 June 2013, 19:57:24
Sound advice, thanks Glod!

It sounds like DCS might be better for the feel then? I'm planning to use this primarily for typing at work (maybe very occasional gaming), so I'd planned to go with the Cherry Blue switches and the full hand model. Any thoughts on DSA vs DCS for this usage scenario?

I know a lot of this is very preference based, but with no experience, it's difficult to decide. I suppose I could buy both, but another $60 for the DCS key caps is not insignificant for my budget :/
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: tp4tissue on Tue, 25 June 2013, 20:21:56
Sound advice, thanks Glod!

It sounds like DCS might be better for the feel then? I'm planning to use this primarily for typing at work (maybe very occasional gaming), so I'd planned to go with the Cherry Blue switches and the full hand model. Any thoughts on DSA vs DCS for this usage scenario?

I know a lot of this is very preference based, but with no experience, it's difficult to decide. I suppose I could buy both, but another $60 for the DCS key caps is not insignificant for my budget :/

the DCS is a solid choice..  I prefer it over the DSA, I got both...

The DCS has larger vertical surface area, so it's easier to jump between rows than it is with DSA which are spaced far apart.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: kurplop on Tue, 25 June 2013, 20:42:18
In my opinion, the only advantage to having legends is for the benefit of guest users. The separate halves almost require touch typing and seeing the legends may encourage bad habits and slow the process of learning the layout.

As for the keycap profile, my vote would go to the dcs profile. The dsa's solved the confusion of creating a profiled layout that would work with the ErgoDox  and some say that they look better but I find some of the keys are easier to hit with the sculpted rows. I find that particularly true with the upper thumb keys.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: actionbastard on Tue, 25 June 2013, 20:44:40
Disregard, found info on layer modifying right after I asked a question about where to find it.

Standard.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: fisofo on Tue, 25 June 2013, 21:06:20
Thanks kurplop and tp4tissue, the DCS definitely sounds like what I want to start with, so I'm going to go that route. Now if only there were 25 more buyers in the last day!
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: daerid on Tue, 25 June 2013, 23:30:16
Oh man oh man I want a second one but I just can't afford it right now :( :( :(  Hopefully they'll do another one at some point in the future.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: ksm123 on Wed, 26 June 2013, 04:45:13
@daerid: I know your feeling exactly, I need second ErgoDox to keep it at work, and stop commuting with my keyboard, unfortunately, with my wedding in August I can't afford it.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: insilica on Wed, 26 June 2013, 09:22:36
Oh man oh man I want a second one but I just can't afford it right now :( :( :(  Hopefully they'll do another one at some point in the future.

Same boat except I would like just the one. Definitely in for one in round 4.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: wiredPANDA on Wed, 26 June 2013, 09:47:06
Don't think they were expecting to have as many buys as they've already done.  The demand is there, though.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: SubGothius on Thu, 27 June 2013, 18:15:48
you really NEED to grab massdrop's keycaps even if you are going to use your own. It is almost impossible otherwise to get the right profile 2x, 1.5x, and 1x caps for the pinky areas and thumb cluster. You can always mix in other keycaps into the massdrop ones if you absolutely need legends instead of blank.

FWIW, you can get individual blank caps from Signature Plastics for $1 each (http://www.keycapsdirect.com/key-capsinventory.php). I'd recommend the following if you'll be scavenging from an OEM board or filling out a tenkeyless set and want a DCS profile:Make sure you get the 2x keys with 1 or 3 mounts, as the 2-mount versions won't have the center mount you'll need. Of course, it's even easier if you want DSA blanks, since there's no row profiles to choose, so just get the 1.5x, 2x and 1x quantities you need in whatever color you want.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: daerid on Thu, 27 June 2013, 18:24:32
Sold the RF AE 87U for a second one, classic case this time. Looking forward to putting it together again :)
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Glod on Fri, 28 June 2013, 01:13:28
I've observed for awhile that daerid is a huge topre fan (nothing wrong with that!) and i imagine you still love the topre switch over cherry but Ergodox is so awesome that you are willing to give up the switch you love as your primary keyboard and even sell a Realforce keyboard for another one. that is a statement right there.

bah in other news i chickened out on getting the DCS massdrop keys, Money is mainly the reason but that's a lame excuse given i dropped money recently for the dolch dsa GB....
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: daerid on Fri, 28 June 2013, 10:40:23
To be honest, I still think the Topre switch is the best, especially the 55g. However, before getting into mechanical keyboards I was using Microsoft Natural keyboards since 2000. Split ergonomic boards have always been my favorite layout, so naturally I had to give the ErgoDox a try. It has exceeded my expectations wildly. The only thing that would make it better (obviously) is if it were available in a Topre 55g switch. However, that's probably never going to happen, for quite a number of technical reasons.

So while I haven't given up my love for Topre, at the moment layout (and programmability!) trumps keyswitch. Plus 65g clears are the closest I can get to a Topre feel (nowhere near as crisp, but definitely tolerable).
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Poom on Fri, 28 June 2013, 11:22:11
Hi there,  I just got to know the Ergodox and very interested in the GB that is concluding in 2 days, though i can solder, but dont have the equipments with me and not worth buying new ones just for this and especially absolutely no time. also a noob at keyboards.

maybe this isnt the right place to ask, but does anyone know if someone is offering assembly service?

Thanks
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: actionbastard on Fri, 28 June 2013, 11:54:45
Hi there,  I just got to know the Ergodox and very interested in the GB that is concluding in 2 days, though i can solder, but dont have the equipments with me and not worth buying new ones just for this and especially absolutely no time. also a noob at keyboards.

maybe this isnt the right place to ask, but does anyone know if someone is offering assembly service?

Thanks

I think there are a few people offering Edox assembly in the classified section.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: daerid on Fri, 28 June 2013, 12:10:30
Here's one (http://geekhack.org/index.php?topic=44841.0)
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Poom on Fri, 28 June 2013, 12:45:06
thank you, i contacted some of them already.

have a question though, and may sounds stupid, but as of yet there is only PCB mount right? does that mean removing the switch cover to mod does not need desoldering?
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: wiredPANDA on Fri, 28 June 2013, 13:20:01
Correct - you do not need to desolder switches to mod them.  The case/layers were designed to allow modding of the switches.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: daerid on Fri, 28 June 2013, 15:51:13
One of the layers of the case sort of acts like a plate, but be wary that it doesn't do anything to reduce the strain when pulling keycaps off.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: tp4tissue on Fri, 28 June 2013, 16:03:32
In my opinion, the only advantage to having legends is for the benefit of guest users. The separate halves almost require touch typing and seeing the legends may encourage bad habits and slow the process of learning the layout.

As for the keycap profile, my vote would go to the dcs profile. The dsa's solved the confusion of creating a profiled layout that would work with the ErgoDox  and some say that they look better but I find some of the keys are easier to hit with the sculpted rows. I find that particularly true with the upper thumb keys.

No one touches my ergodox.. but me.... :D
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: tp4tissue on Fri, 28 June 2013, 16:05:32
One of the layers of the case sort of acts like a plate, but be wary that it doesn't do anything to reduce the strain when pulling keycaps off.

On the caps subject... Pick one, and just leave it that way... these clear stems are epic tight....
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: daerid on Fri, 28 June 2013, 17:38:31
I've swapped out from DSA to DCS and back a few times, just gotta be gentle and rock the puller back and forth.

Takes a while though.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: SubGothius on Fri, 28 June 2013, 21:33:42
One of the layers of the case sort of acts like a plate, but be wary that it doesn't do anything to reduce the strain when pulling keycaps off.

On the caps subject... Pick one, and just leave it that way... these clear stems are epic tight....

Once I realized the mounting plate is too thick for the switch bodies to properly "latch in", I decided to be extra-generous with the solder points on my switches, pretty much completely filled in the entire thru-holes with solder, since that's all that holds the switch down when pulling caps off.  That said, the black POM cap set I scavenged off that Cherry G81 board turned out to fit the stems perfectly, just snug enough to be secure, but still pop off easily when pulled. I reckon the slightly waxy/self-lubricating texture of POM also helps with removal.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Jur on Fri, 05 July 2013, 14:15:09
I am currently waiting for my Ergodox from the most recent Massdrop and want to order some colored acrylic plates.
Now i just need the measurements, i have this picture : http://i.imgur.com/cw4nX0w.png are the combined plates 3/4" and the individual ones 0,013 inches ?
If someone could give me the exact thickness that would be awsome. <3

Greetings,

Jur
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: daerid on Fri, 05 July 2013, 14:38:53
Once I realized the mounting plate is too thick for the switch bodies to properly "latch in", I decided to be extra-generous with the solder points on my switches, pretty much completely filled in the entire thru-holes with solder, since that's all that holds the switch down when pulling caps off.  That said, the black POM cap set I scavenged off that Cherry G81 board turned out to fit the stems perfectly, just snug enough to be secure, but still pop off easily when pulled. I reckon the slightly waxy/self-lubricating texture of POM also helps with removal.

I would suggest doing that anyways, you'll generally get a better solder joint.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: MOZ on Fri, 05 July 2013, 15:13:56
I am currently waiting for my Ergodox from the most recent Massdrop and want to order some colored acrylic plates.
Now i just need the measurements, i have this picture : http://i.imgur.com/cw4nX0w.png are the combined plates 3/4" and the individual ones 0,013 inches ?
If someone could give me the exact thickness that would be awsome. <3

Greetings,

Jur

Top and bottom layers are 3/32" and three middle layers are 3/16". You can get the CAD files from ergodox.org

I am getting acrylic plates cut for myself as well in these thickness:
Top - 2/16" = 1/8"
Spacer - 3/16"
Plate - 2/16" = 1/8"
Spacer - 4/16" = 1/4"
Bottom - 3/16"

Total thickness = 14/16"
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Jur on Fri, 05 July 2013, 15:40:15
Thank you mohitgarg, i downloaded the cad files and will send them inc these measurements to the cutter right away.
I will post some pictures when its done.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: oTurtlez on Fri, 05 July 2013, 15:44:12
When I first saw the ErgoDox amongst other ergo boards I thought people were crazy to use them. I to this day have never sued an ergo board, but after reading a bunch of this thread it makes me hope that a round 3 goes through on Massdrop. I'd love to get to love one of these things. Do the full kits include case, pcb, controller, cables, and switches?
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Jur on Fri, 05 July 2013, 15:49:11
This is wat is in the kit that i ordered :

2 x PCB
10 x Acrylic case Plates (see this image for layer ordering)
1 x Teensy USB Board, Version 2
1 x MCP23018 I/O expander
2 x 3.5mm TRRS connector
1 x USB mini B plug
1 x 0.1uF ceramic capacitor
76 x 1N4148 diode (through-hole) or 1N4148W-7-F diode (surface-mount)
2 x 2.2kΩ resistor
3 x 3mm T1 LED
3 x 220Ω resistor
76 x Cherry MX clear switch
2 x USB cable Male A to male mini B
1 x TRRS cable
14 (16 for Full cases) x Case screws/nuts

I also got : Keycaps (Blank PBT DSA )
Case Style: Classic


Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Latin00032 on Sun, 07 July 2013, 02:46:24
Thank you mohitgarg, i downloaded the cad files and will send them inc these measurements to the cutter right away.
I will post some pictures when its done.

I'm trying to find a way to get a custom top plate.

Does anyone know what rubber feet I can use on this?
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: litster on Sun, 07 July 2013, 03:55:17
I am currently waiting for my Ergodox from the most recent Massdrop and want to order some colored acrylic plates.
Now i just need the measurements, i have this picture : http://i.imgur.com/cw4nX0w.png are the combined plates 3/4" and the individual ones 0,013 inches ?
If someone could give me the exact thickness that would be awsome. <3

Greetings,

Jur

Top and bottom layers are 3/32" and three middle layers are 3/16". You can get the CAD files from ergodox.org

I am getting acrylic plates cut for myself as well in these thickness:
Top - 2/16" = 1/8"
Spacer - 3/16"
Plate - 2/16" = 1/8"
Spacer - 4/16" = 1/4"
Bottom - 3/16"

Total thickness = 14/16"

This is what I told Massdrop, and the thickness I used for the ErgoDox case I designed.  From top to bottom:

1/8"
3/16"
3/16" <--- mounting plate
3/16"
1/8"


Acrylic sheets thickness vary from batch to batch, even from the same company.  Generally they are 1/64" to 1/32" thinner than they are spec'ed.  Buy and cut your acrylic sheets with caution.  You want the acrylic mounting plate be as thick as possible to minimize plate flex while still fits between the switches and the PCB.  This is not a problem with aluminum or stainless steel plates.  But acrylic is too flexible at 1/16" or even 1/8". 
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: daerid on Sun, 07 July 2013, 17:33:30
I too am interested in rubber feet
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Glod on Thu, 01 August 2013, 16:17:15
ATTENTION Ergodoxers!

Keycaps for ErgoDox, SA Profile - Military Theme

http://geekhack.org/index.php?topic=45655.0

Base set + ErgoDox Add On = Ergodox Set

We need 25 Add On Kits

Spread the word

Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: daerid on Thu, 01 August 2013, 16:32:03
Oh man, I totally would, but I'm not digging on the *SA profile these days. Colors look sick though!
Title: What About the Key Caps?
Post by: Pandora on Tue, 20 August 2013, 12:01:35
If I understand their ordering process, you can order blank key caps but not lettered?  Where do you buy
the ones with letters on them? I have some stick-on letters but they fade very quickly.
Title: Re: What About the Key Caps?
Post by: MOZ on Tue, 20 August 2013, 12:19:25
If I understand their ordering process, you can order blank key caps but not lettered?  Where do you buy
the ones with letters on them? I have some stick-on letters but they fade very quickly.

You will have to order a base set from elsewhere as you only require the alphanumeric set in legends. Some members use other layouts and thus you won't find printed keycap ergodox sets.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: tp4tissue on Tue, 20 August 2013, 12:27:36
If I understand their ordering process, you can order blank key caps but not lettered?  Where do you buy
the ones with letters on them? I have some stick-on letters but they fade very quickly.

You will have to order a base set from elsewhere as you only require the alphanumeric set in legends. Some members use other layouts and thus you won't find printed keycap ergodox sets.

this is a huge problem.. My layout is radically more awesome than everyone else's..

They just don't print caps that are as awesome as my layout.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Pandora on Tue, 20 August 2013, 13:41:31
That's kind of funny when the picture on their website shows a qwerty key layout.  Would I be
able to swap the keys from the keyboard I'm using now? I think the switches are Cherry red.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: kurplop on Tue, 20 August 2013, 13:53:07
 Welcome to geekhack. Yes, you can use any cap that will fit a Cherry MX switch. You may have to order separate 1.5x and 2x blank keys however because it's unlikely you will have the proper legends and sizes in a conventional keyboard.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: fisofo on Wed, 21 August 2013, 18:03:51
Does anyone know if these line key caps from wasd:
http://www.wasdkeyboards.com/index.php/row-2-size-1x1-line-cherry-mx-keycap.html

will work with the DCS key caps group buy?
https://www.massdrop.com/buy/ergodox-keycap

Thanks!
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Glod on Wed, 21 August 2013, 18:46:06
Does anyone know if these line key caps from wasd:
http://www.wasdkeyboards.com/index.php/row-2-size-1x1-line-cherry-mx-keycap.html

will work with the DCS key caps group buy?
https://www.massdrop.com/buy/ergodox-keycap

Thanks!

wasd uses "OEM" profile which is noticeably higher than SP DCS profile. I mean you can use any key caps you wont with it, it just may not be flush.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: fisofo on Wed, 21 August 2013, 19:00:20
Does anyone know if these line key caps from wasd:
http://www.wasdkeyboards.com/index.php/row-2-size-1x1-line-cherry-mx-keycap.html

will work with the DCS key caps group buy?
https://www.massdrop.com/buy/ergodox-keycap

Thanks!

wasd uses "OEM" profile which is noticeably higher than SP DCS profile. I mean you can use any key caps you wont with it, it just may not be flush.

Good to know. Do you know where I could get a couple key caps like this that will match the DCS profile? Thanks!
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Glod on Wed, 21 August 2013, 19:06:21
Does anyone know if these line key caps from wasd:
http://www.wasdkeyboards.com/index.php/row-2-size-1x1-line-cherry-mx-keycap.html

will work with the DCS key caps group buy?
https://www.massdrop.com/buy/ergodox-keycap

Thanks!

wasd uses "OEM" profile which is noticeably higher than SP DCS profile. I mean you can use any key caps you wont with it, it just may not be flush.

Good to know. Do you know where I could get a couple key caps like this that will match the DCS profile? Thanks!

its a bit expensive, but i use a mix of the White on Black Doubleshot Set from SP, DCS Blanks, and DSA Blanks.

The set is here: http://www.keycapsdirect.com/marketplace.php for $60

here is what the mix looks like mixed together. I dont think it looks bad at all.

(http://farm6.staticflickr.com/5550/9564138047_00f4dca0c5.jpg) (http://www.flickr.com/photos/panicfx/9564138047/)

Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: fisofo on Wed, 21 August 2013, 20:15:54
Does anyone know if these line key caps from wasd:
http://www.wasdkeyboards.com/index.php/row-2-size-1x1-line-cherry-mx-keycap.html

will work with the DCS key caps group buy?
https://www.massdrop.com/buy/ergodox-keycap

Thanks!

wasd uses "OEM" profile which is noticeably higher than SP DCS profile. I mean you can use any key caps you wont with it, it just may not be flush.

Good to know. Do you know where I could get a couple key caps like this that will match the DCS profile? Thanks!

its a bit expensive, but i use a mix of the White on Black Doubleshot Set from SP, DCS Blanks, and DSA Blanks.

The set is here: http://www.keycapsdirect.com/marketplace.php for $60

here is what the mix looks like mixed together. I dont think it looks bad at all.

(http://farm6.staticflickr.com/5550/9564138047_00f4dca0c5.jpg) (http://www.flickr.com/photos/panicfx/9564138047/)



Yeah, you've got a beautiful setup there; love the custom wood palm rests!

Anyway, thanks for the direction. Maybe I'll contact SP about getting just the keys I need.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: flc on Tue, 27 August 2013, 21:12:02
I got my ergodox in round 3 and put it together on Saturday. This is my first mechanical keyboard and most of my soldering experience is from about 20 years ago. That said here is my experience building and using the ergodox so far.

The only tools I used were a $5 soldering iron from Radio Shack, a pair of diagonal cutters, a pair of tweezers, a sharp utility knife, a nail file and a magnifying glass. Since the soldering iron was going to be on for hours I also bought the cheapest dimmer switch I could buy and rigged it so that I could regulate the temperature of the iron as needed.

A video I saw from a member here was a lot of help, especially with ideas on how to solder the surface mount diodes. I found the massdrop instructions to be spot on for the most part. There were a few times I got a little confused as to which side of the thru-hole components I should solder but a close look at the PC revealed that it mostly did not matter as soldering either side would create the same electrical connection. I really got a chance to appreciate all the work and thought that went into the design of the ergodox.

I decided to check each diode with a meter as I went along to confirm connectivity and orientation. This proved to be very useful as I caught a few on backwards early on. After the better part of the afternoon/evening the project was complete and fully tested.

The board does take some getting used to, but it is not as bad as I thought. I am loving the split design and the feel for the cherry clear switches that I got with it – but then again I have nothing else to compare them to. The hardest thing so far is getting used to the location of some keys on the top rows due to the matrix design. I'm also experiencing the same problem someone else had with the thumb naturally resting just to the side of the thumb keys, making one wish they were slightly closer. But I'm sure I will get used to both these minor issues rather quickly. I also wished the keycaps had a bump on the home keys. I've temporarily resolved that with a piece of tape.

Now, off to trying to customize the layout.

* Modified to include a magnifying glass to the list of tools.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: kurplop on Tue, 27 August 2013, 22:05:07
I've been curious about your opinion of the ErgoDox. Thanks for the update. I think you will get use to the straight columns in short order. I agree that the thumb clusters could be improved upon, but I still think it's currently the best thing out there.

I'm also glad to hear that you had little trouble assembling it. 
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: daerid on Tue, 27 August 2013, 22:13:45
I agree that the thumb clusters could be improved upon, but I still think it's currently the best thing out there.

For me (as I have large hands), I think the 2x thumb buttons are perfect. But I'll be honest, I don't use the 1x buttons in the thumb cluster at all (well I do have two of them setup to load the bootloader when I press both, but that's it).
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: kurplop on Tue, 27 August 2013, 23:02:21
I guess that's my point. The thumbs could easily control more of the modifying load but the 2-2x keys are the only ones that are very comfortable to use.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Larken on Tue, 27 August 2013, 23:12:58
I agree that the thumb clusters could be improved upon, but I still think it's currently the best thing out there.

For me (as I have large hands), I think the 2x thumb buttons are perfect. But I'll be honest, I don't use the 1x buttons in the thumb cluster at all (well I do have two of them setup to load the bootloader when I press both, but that's it).

I guess that's my point. The thumbs could easily control more of the modifying load but the 2-2x keys are the only ones that are very comfortable to use.



even after months of using the thing, i still have trouble touch typing the top row of numbers, specifically when typing in long strings for authentication purposes. Individual numbers while typing sentences are mostly fine.

I agree with both of you on the thumb cluster usage, on both sides - I only use the inner most 2x keys regularly, and the other 2x keys are relegated to del and enter, which aren't actually necessary all the time. (well, I have a duplicate enter key at the regular position, which is the one I use more often.)

The rest of the thumb cluster keys on my layout are used mostly for layer changes, and the characters [], home, end, windows key and a off center ctrl (another duplicate - there's an easier to reach ctrl elsewhere). It's true that the 1x keys aren't in the best positions to be reached easily on a consistent basis, so that's where the keys that I use on the least frequent basis go.

But I could see an issue if the layout used requires constant usage of the thumb cluster for other than the 2x keys.

But the beauty of the setup is that the layout can be tweaked over and over until you're happy with it in use.(looking at a folder I set aside for the hex files I downloaded, I went through at least 40 revisions before I settled on what I've been using for the last few months. I suspect if I started playing games again, that number would likely grow.)

I've more or less settled on one where I actually have more than enough keys on layer 0 to work with in normal usage, so much so that I ignore the rest of the thumb cluster, not consciously, but because I don't miss those keys at all. The only thing I'm not satisfied with would probably be the lack of a dedicated arrow cluster on layer 0 (I've tried many swaps with various keys, just doesn't feel right while typing)
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: daerid on Tue, 27 August 2013, 23:18:16
My layout (https://www.massdrop.com/ext/ergodox/?referer=QJGS5L&hash=daa0262d170d78bfc724d9a8382143ee)'s fairly QWERTY, but with a few tweaks. The arrows are actually really easy to use on the 2nd layer after a few days use. Especially since I mainly use my left thumb to toggle L1. Since I write code for a living, I really needed access to []{} on L1. The two Z's are due to the fact that I hit a different one depending on if I'm normally typing words, or hitting Ctrl+Z for undo. The odd B placement also has to do with standard QWERTY muscle memory. Probably not the best ergonomically, but I just can't get used to hitting X with my ring finger and C with my middle finger. Just feels weird....
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: MOZ on Tue, 27 August 2013, 23:25:16
My layout (https://www.massdrop.com/ext/ergodox/?referer=QJGS5L&hash=daa0262d170d78bfc724d9a8382143ee)'s fairly QWERTY, but with a few tweaks. The arrows are actually really easy to use on the 2nd layer after a few days use. Especially since I mainly use my left thumb to toggle L1. Since I write code for a living, I really needed access to []{} on L1. The two Z's are due to the fact that I hit a different one depending on if I'm normally typing words, or hitting Ctrl+Z for undo. The odd B placement also has to do with standard QWERTY muscle memory. Probably not the best ergonomically, but I just can't get used to hitting X with my ring finger and C with my middle finger. Just feels weird....

That is a neat layout.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Larken on Tue, 27 August 2013, 23:40:18
My layout (https://www.massdrop.com/ext/ergodox/?referer=QJGS5L&hash=daa0262d170d78bfc724d9a8382143ee)'s fairly QWERTY, but with a few tweaks. The arrows are actually really easy to use on the 2nd layer after a few days use. Especially since I mainly use my left thumb to toggle L1. Since I write code for a living, I really needed access to []{} on L1. The two Z's are due to the fact that I hit a different one depending on if I'm normally typing words, or hitting Ctrl+Z for undo. The odd B placement also has to do with standard QWERTY muscle memory. Probably not the best ergonomically, but I just can't get used to hitting X with my ring finger and C with my middle finger. Just feels weird....

I've seen your qwerty layout before and noticed the zzxcvb - specifically the B on the 1.5 key. I understand why its done, because I actually had the same problem as you when I first started using the dox, but it went away after about a week of typos. I did have to force myself to go slow to adapt to the ring finger, x and middle finger, c combination, so you're not alone in that. You could probably adapt if you give it time, not that you need to; as long as it works for you, its fine.

Personally, I don't notice it anymore, and I've stopped making those typos - but it does plays havoc with my typing when I switch to a standard staggered qwerty board, specifically with that row of cvb letters.

My work mainly revolves around writing long running sentences, so I didn't need {}[] as much as I did ;". Might be a good idea for me to go think about layering the arrow cluster elsewhere with a toggle. Though I've already mostly adapted to the bottom right row arrow cluster.

for reference, this is the layout I've been using since June https://www.massdrop.com/ext/ergodox/?referer=7M8A25&hash=abea9e64e407519557c52c7dc0e9c0c3
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: JohnDiew0107 on Wed, 28 August 2013, 10:24:51
what do you guys think of Classic vs Full hand case?
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: daerid on Wed, 28 August 2013, 10:50:03
what do you guys think of Classic vs Full hand case?

TBH, I'm on the fence. I really like using the full hand as gives my palms a place to rest. It also resonates with the switches more giving a louder sound. The keys are more clacky.

The classic case, on the other hand, kinda makes me type more correctly. I hover my hands over the desk and just use my fingertips, rather than resting my wrists on a surface. I also really like that there's no extra plastic, it seems cleaner for some reason (probably because there's less acrylic to pick up dust and fingerprints etc...).
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: flc on Wed, 28 August 2013, 16:14:43
what do you guys think of Classic vs Full hand case?
I decided to go with the classic for portability with the intent on eventually making a tenting platform with palm rests similar to what Glod has done - although I seriously doubt it will be as nice.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: MOZ on Wed, 28 August 2013, 16:35:10
Like my full hand.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Jon in PDX on Thu, 29 August 2013, 17:41:20
I've been mildly obsessed with the ErgoDox since I learned about it a few days ago. (It will hopefully be on its way soon from Massdrop.) Mostly, I've been playing with layouts. After mocking up a keyboard, I put together something that I haven't seen elsewhere, and while this probably means it is a bad idea, I still thought I'd share. :)

https://www.massdrop.com/ext/ergodox/?referer=TUHZR6&hash=c8bc2cfbfad1747b980b597cee637a49

The good:
I won't need to move my hands at all to ctrl-c, ctrl-v, alt-tab, alt-F4, shift-control-arrow, or any of the other shortcuts that I frequently use. I'll also be able to easily use shortcuts that I don't currently employ because they're hard to get to, like ctrl-alt-tab.

The bad:
I won't have ready access to ctrl, alt, or gui without accessing another layer first.

The ugly:
This design is highly modal, meaning a steep learning curve, especially when the keys will be unlabeled.

Details:
Starting with a Dvorak base, I added thumb layer toggles to move the command keys--ctrl, alt, shift, gui--under the four home keys. The far 2x key leaves the other side at its default settings. Tucking the thumb under the hand toggles the arrow layer (right hand) and Fx keys (left hand), with F1-F5 on the home row. A further thumb tuck will push a ten-key or a Qwerty layer.

The center keys are designed for convenience when I'm not touch typing, but I suspect that won't work too well if/when I add tenting. So I've started laying out one-handed setups, with the idea of ultimately being able to use either side alone as a one-handed chording keyboard. It may be pure fantasy, but the idea of typing with my left hand and writing with a pen in my right hand is quite appealing. Perhaps even adding a Teensy to the left side to be able to use it independently...but one step at a time.

No doubt the ten-key layer will be modified once I start using it with Excel. Anyone know how well the extended number pad keys are supported in calculator applications?

I guess whether it works will depend on my ability to climb the learning curve, as well as how easy it is to use the thumbs for what I have laid out. But I've put together a cheat sheet and the thumb keys seem no more difficult to reach than the alt keys or trackpad buttons on my laptop, so I'm eager to give it a try.

Oh, and I'm not a programmer, so I hardly ever touch some characters they use frequently, which is why they're tucked away in the corners. Also, no media keys are used because I'm mostly in Windows. I'm sure I'll end up attaching some of the extended Fx keys to, say, AutoHotKey.

Many thanks to all those who've made this project happen!
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: jondkinney on Sun, 01 September 2013, 20:28:31
Quote
here is what the mix looks like mixed together. I dont think it looks bad at all.

Show Image
(http://farm6.staticflickr.com/5550/9564138047_00f4dca0c5.jpg) (http://www.flickr.com/photos/panicfx/9564138047/)


Looks awesome! Do you have any details on how someone could build those wooden wrist rests themselves? What type of wood, dimensions, etc.

Thanks!
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: MOZ on Sun, 01 September 2013, 21:03:06
Quote
here is what the mix looks like mixed together. I dont think it looks bad at all.

(http://farm6.staticflickr.com/5550/9564138047_00f4dca0c5.jpg) (http://www.flickr.com/photos/panicfx/9564138047/)

Looks awesome! Do you have any details on how someone could build those wooden wrist rests themselves? What type of wood, dimensions, etc.

Thanks!

It is called the ErgoDock, kurplop made it,  he has a thread on it.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: daerid on Mon, 02 September 2013, 01:57:57
On another note: Just did a couple TypeRacer runs and it seems as though I'm actually about 10wpm faster on the ErgoDox than on a standard QWERTY board now.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: wasabah on Tue, 03 September 2013, 05:48:20
Having used my Ergodox for quite a while now, I don't know if I can ever go without again.
When faced with a normal keyboard recently, I actually had quite some difficulties.
Especially with hitting enter and space, which are both located on my right thumb cluster.
I have quite long fingers btw, so I can use the 2x keys of the thumb cluster easily.

I didn't really have the time yet, but I want to tinker with my layout more.
Right now I'm basically using German layout with some keys like ´<#+ shifted around due to space issues.
But I would actually prefer the US layout plus German Umlaute öäü.
I will have to figure out how that is possible.

For gaming I had some trouble too. I prefer jumping in shooters with my left thumb, but space is on my right thumb.
Also, my arrow keys are separated: up and down on the right half (bottom left) and left and right on the same position of the left half.
But for games, it's often necessary to be able to navigate them all with one hand.

So far I changed the mappings in the games, but in the future I want to make a gaming layer.
This layer will basically be my normal layout except for the changes I addressed above.

Edit: oh and at some point I want to have a solution that allows me to easily fix my two keyboard halves in respect to each other,
but also allows me to move them around separately if necessary.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: fisofo on Tue, 03 September 2013, 23:39:02
I've been mildly obsessed with the ErgoDox since I learned about it a few days ago. (It will hopefully be on its way soon from Massdrop.) Mostly, I've been playing with layouts. After mocking up a keyboard, I put together something that I haven't seen elsewhere, and while this probably means it is a bad idea, I still thought I'd share. :)

https://www.massdrop.com/ext/ergodox/?referer=TUHZR6&hash=c8bc2cfbfad1747b980b597cee637a49
...

Jon, you may want to take a look at the customized firmware I just posted over here: http://geekhack.org/index.php?topic=22780.msg1027892#msg1027892

I tried a layout similar to what you proposed and liked the idea, but decided that as long as I was doing another layer like that, why not fill them with the most common macros for each letter that I use to decrease the complexity and keys I need to hit for them? The layer toggle key effectively becomes a "Smart" modifier key.

I like it so far, but will be continuing to modify it. Thought I'd mention it.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: therecorder on Wed, 04 September 2013, 07:10:01
How about a miniDox?

http://www.riitek.com/en/product-detail-427.html  (Click to Enlarge Photos)

(espicially fot tp4tissue)
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: jdeblese on Tue, 17 September 2013, 11:25:48
I agree about the 1x thumb buttons. Got the Ergodox to be able to move the modifiers (which I use constantly) and to better use my thumbs without strain. The two 2x keys are fine - I use 'em for enter, space and shifts - but it's hard to use mods on the others. I don't want to move the mods back to the bottom left and right, however, as that strains my thumb and pinky.

Thinking of maybe putting ctrl and alt on the first two inner keys of the bottom row. On the outer 1.5x column is no good, as I don't mind those for stuff like tab and backspace but can't stand them for anything I have to hold.

Has anyone tried putting a higher keycap on the 1x thumbs, for instance an SA row 1 or DCS row 5, so that it's easier to reach over the 2x thumb keys?

Current layout, as I'm learning the board:
https://www.massdrop.com/ext/ergodox/?referer=4DQTDG&hash=5ce9978e58b8542158c3060d7d11856f
Haven't yet decided what to do with the inner 1.5s as they're acting a bit funny and I haven't had time to debug them. I've based it on querty so it's less of a problem when I have to use other people's keyboards.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: wuqe on Wed, 02 October 2013, 14:35:54
I've been mildly obsessed with the ErgoDox since I learned about it a few days ago. (It will hopefully be on its way soon from Massdrop.) Mostly, I've been playing with layouts. After mocking up a keyboard, I put together something that I haven't seen elsewhere, and while this probably means it is a bad idea, I still thought I'd share. :)

https://www.massdrop.com/ext/ergodox/?referer=TUHZR6&hash=c8bc2cfbfad1747b980b597cee637a49 (https://www.massdrop.com/ext/ergodox/?referer=TUHZR6&hash=c8bc2cfbfad1747b980b597cee637a49)


I've actually used an AHK script to do some of this without the thumb involvement:

http://www.autohotkey.com/board/topic/95099-dual-role-modifier-keys/?p=616668 (http://www.autohotkey.com/board/topic/95099-dual-role-modifier-keys/?p=616668)

It's time-based, which means it can give unexpected results occasionally, but it saves me from too much modality.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: tp4tissue on Wed, 02 October 2013, 15:09:37
I agree about the 1x thumb buttons. Got the Ergodox to be able to move the modifiers (which I use constantly) and to better use my thumbs without strain. The two 2x keys are fine - I use 'em for enter, space and shifts - but it's hard to use mods on the others. I don't want to move the mods back to the bottom left and right, however, as that strains my thumb and pinky.

Thinking of maybe putting ctrl and alt on the first two inner keys of the bottom row. On the outer 1.5x column is no good, as I don't mind those for stuff like tab and backspace but can't stand them for anything I have to hold.

Has anyone tried putting a higher keycap on the 1x thumbs, for instance an SA row 1 or DCS row 5, so that it's easier to reach over the 2x thumb keys?

Current layout, as I'm learning the board:
https://www.massdrop.com/ext/ergodox/?referer=4DQTDG&hash=5ce9978e58b8542158c3060d7d11856f
Haven't yet decided what to do with the inner 1.5s as they're acting a bit funny and I haven't had time to debug them. I've based it on querty so it's less of a problem when I have to use other people's keyboards.

Are you tenting your ergodox ?..

Without tenting the thumb cluster keys are too far away from your thumb.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: tp4tissue on Wed, 02 October 2013, 15:12:21
How about a miniDox?

http://www.riitek.com/en/product-detail-427.html  (Click to Enlarge Photos)

(espicially fot tp4tissue)

Idk what fot is...

But, a smaller ergodox would be fine, as long as it retains split design and center-tenting ability...

Since it's fully programmable,  there are numerous keys that could be sacrificed for "size".
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Calyx on Wed, 02 October 2013, 16:30:26
How about a miniDox?

http://www.riitek.com/en/product-detail-427.html  (Click to Enlarge Photos)

(espicially fot tp4tissue)

Idk what fot is...

But, a smaller ergodox would be fine, as long as it retains split design and center-tenting ability...

Since it's fully programmable,  there are numerous keys that could be sacrificed for "size".

This is the MicroDox layout that I'll be using. https://www.massdrop.com/ext/ergodox/?referer=CTL63V&hash=9ff8ddbb75e03e517aaa39acabc81669
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: davkol on Wed, 02 October 2013, 17:55:49
Wouldn't a mini ergodox be basically the original (and still evolving) key64 design? I mean, you can't get much smaller than that, because keys won't get much smaller without sacrificing comfort.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: MOZ on Wed, 02 October 2013, 18:07:40
Look up the ErgoTravel ;)
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Oobly on Tue, 08 October 2013, 06:48:29
Look up the ErgoTravel ;)

No thumb clusters on that one.  :'( Must... have.... thumb... clusters...  :-\

At least for my use.  :rolleyes:

Otherwise a very nice looking little board.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Ch0nG on Thu, 28 November 2013, 16:11:52
I recently got my Ergodox (Full-Hand, ErgoClears) and I'm really enjoying it. :)

My favorite things about it (in no particular order):

Since I've never used a split keyboard I decided to go Colemak from the get go and it's working out OK.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Glod on Thu, 30 January 2014, 22:10:21
so im bringing this thread back

wanted to share my layout overhaul

after using the ergodox for what i can't believe has been 9 months almost i have been wanting to make these tweaks for a long time to my layout. priority 1 was to get the f keys into my layout

(http://almightyglod.com/public_stack/January_rev1.png)

its also a layout in which with a DSA keycap set from group buys like Hyperfuse, you can use many of the key caps with legends and if you wanted to use a DCS group buy with it it would only take finding 4x2u keys and 8x1.5u keys to allow a dcs kit to work with decent results

Secondly ive decided another big change. I got rid of the tenting and switched to flat but i have the hands far away from each other, they are near the width of my shoulders. the mouse or trackball is in the center.

(http://farm4.staticflickr.com/3734/12230461754_766f6a430a.jpg) (http://flic.kr/p/jCLjbf)
I think its fine ergonomically like this, one of the biggest things i notice is that without tenting my typing speed increases

If your wondering my wooden/aluminium/white edox is pretty much broke for good, im going to rebuild it with a new pcb instead of wasting my time figuring out whats up.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: plainbriny on Fri, 31 January 2014, 05:21:58

The ugly:
This design is highly modal, meaning a steep learning curve, especially when the keys will be unlabeled.


You can use tmk firmware for ergodox (http://geekhack.org/index.php?topic=48106.0 (http://geekhack.org/index.php?topic=48106.0)), the tap action can let you access another layer by holding a key, or make a key acting as a modifier key by holding the key (https://github.com/tmk/tmk_keyboard/blob/master/doc/keymap.md#41-tap-key (https://github.com/tmk/tmk_keyboard/blob/master/doc/keymap.md#41-tap-key))

In your case, I think the ACTION_MODS_TAP_KEY(MOD_RSFT, KC_GRV) function is what you need

Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Fatrat on Fri, 31 January 2014, 14:55:01
How am I liking my Ergodox? It's awsome.

I got it in the August drop. Arrived in the UK sometime in Nov/Dec but I didn't get it built until the Christmas holiday. I was totally amazed that it worked. The last soldering I did was in school and didn't work. Thanks to some great tips from friends and the loan of a load of gear I managed to complete the board with only two dodgy SMDs, which were easily fixed.

The pictures show it in use and my solution to getting some tenting. I use it with the two halves fairly far apart so the degree of tenting I need is small. I can't remember who it was on the forum that suggested using the door stops but they work well and are very cheap. I also cut and filed the screws down to tidy the bottom up and remove the sharp edges for when the board goes in my bag.

[attach=1]
[attach=2]
[attach=3]

The layout (https://www.massdrop.com/ext/ergodox/?referer=T2T4QN&hash=05dca23f1c61874c3d7cd093179e46cf) is fairly standard. I need to swap between the Dox and my laptop keyboard all the time so needed to keep some of the keys nearer where they are on the Mac. I moved CTRL to a thumb for Emacs shortcuts I use a lot (ctri-a, d, f, b, k etc) and have another ctrl on the bottom row for some of the combo shortcuts I use to move windows around and change virtual desktops.

Layer 2 is pretty blank. I haven't really got to grips with what I can use it for yet. The next stage is to get the tmc firmware installed (I have it compiled but haven't modified the layout to match the massdrop one yet) so that I can have mouse keys and media keys. I also need screen brightness: has anyone got that to work?
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: wiredPANDA on Fri, 31 January 2014, 16:05:00
Glad to see this thread brought back.  I just got my ErgoDox built earlier this month (thanks MistakeMistake!).  Couple things I'm thinking about now, though:

1.  Do I want to tent my classic case?
2.  Do I want to find a full-hand case?  My second kit is another classic case - not sure I want two.

I haven't had the chance to use it extensively, yet, due to my current workload/deadlines.  Though I have been able to load/test out a few layouts on/off for a couple hours. 

I've tried both Glod's and daerid's (thanks to both of you for sharing).  And another that I created by merging a few aspects from both.  I'm constantly scripting so some layouts I've found floating around GH and online just don't work for my day to day.  One thing I've found is that, like Glod, I need F5/F8 on my primary layer.

[Layout.01 (https://www.massdrop.com/ext/ergodox/?referer=7BUWPX&hash=bdf61225096f64bc7f71843155243ab1)]
[Layout.02 (https://www.massdrop.com/ext/ergodox/?referer=7BUWPX&hash=40bd4b9913db6167446ad69eed347ed8)]

...something that's been on my mind, too - creating a sub-layer to simulate the Matias Half-Keyboard (http://www.matias.ca/halfkeyboard/index.php?refID=7).
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: kod on Fri, 31 January 2014, 19:48:02
So the massdrop package showed up...
and my immediate reaction upon trying it is theres no way the thumb clusters will work for my hands.

Ive used columnar layouts with thumb keys before (kinesis), but I can't see this working for me.

Did anyone else who had that initial reaction end up liking it, or should I just sell this one on?  I havent even taken the paper off the acrylic yet....
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: tp4tissue on Fri, 31 January 2014, 20:25:57
So the massdrop package showed up...
and my immediate reaction upon trying it is theres no way the thumb clusters will work for my hands.

Ive used columnar layouts with thumb keys before (kinesis), but I can't see this working for me.

Did anyone else who had that initial reaction end up liking it, or should I just sell this one on?  I havent even taken the paper off the acrylic yet....

LOL... tenting bro.. tenting..

i didn't think the thumb cluster would work either. until the board was tented, and then i though.. Ohhh.......


if you just lay your hand on it...  realize that you're still thinking  "regular" rectangular keyboard..

Your mind hasn't adjusted to the "NEW" movements that will be required to use the ergodox..

Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: daerid on Thu, 13 February 2014, 11:11:16
I really only use the two long keys of the thumb clusters during everyday typing. The 1x buttons are used for extraneous stuff.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: jacobolus on Thu, 13 February 2014, 19:10:11
The overall idea of the ergodox is great, and in practice it’s better than a standard keyboard, but the thumb key layout is IMO pretty silly, with only 2 very-easy-to-press keys per thumb, and an awkward gap next to the main thumb key that should have a key in it.

Basically, the design of the thumb cluster was just copied from the Kinesis and flattened, without much thought going into the physical movements that are easiest for the thumb. Among keyboards with this particular style of thumb cluster, the Maltron has the best 3-dimensional position/angle of the thumb keys, in my opinion. For a keyboard that’s going to have each half in its own flat plane, it’s possible to do much better than the current Ergodox design.

For example, Obra’s http://keyboard.io design is dramatically better.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Internet Friend on Thu, 13 February 2014, 21:38:33
No doubt there's room for improvement, but as it is I use all of the thumb keys. I've got navigation keys and cut/copy/paste/undo on the 1x keys. I do have a pretty severe 15 degree tent going on, if that's really the difference.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: bisl on Fri, 28 March 2014, 12:54:05
I agree about the 1x thumb buttons. Got the Ergodox to be able to move the modifiers (which I use constantly) and to better use my thumbs without strain. The two 2x keys are fine - I use 'em for enter, space and shifts - but it's hard to use mods on the others. I don't want to move the mods back to the bottom left and right, however, as that strains my thumb and pinky.

Thinking of maybe putting ctrl and alt on the first two inner keys of the bottom row. On the outer 1.5x column is no good, as I don't mind those for stuff like tab and backspace but can't stand them for anything I have to hold.

Has anyone tried putting a higher keycap on the 1x thumbs, for instance an SA row 1 or DCS row 5, so that it's easier to reach over the 2x thumb keys?

Current layout, as I'm learning the board:
https://www.massdrop.com/ext/ergodox/?referer=4DQTDG&hash=5ce9978e58b8542158c3060d7d11856f
Haven't yet decided what to do with the inner 1.5s as they're acting a bit funny and I haven't had time to debug them. I've based it on querty so it's less of a problem when I have to use other people's keyboards.

This post is really old, but here's my current config with keycaps:
(http://i.imgur.com/9UPzuRL.png)

(http://i.imgur.com/OjYVCio.png)

(http://i.imgur.com/WjCKwcC.png)

My thumb rests, generally, on the left 1.5x key, which is Shift. I have my arrows on layer 1, and F-keys/keypad on layer 2, and both layer 1 and layer 2 are accessible on the thumb clusters as well. Furthermore, the contour of the keys makes it very easy to chord many modifier combinations: Ctrl-Shift, Ctrl-L1, Shift-L1, Alt-Shift, Alt-Shift-F2, Ctrl-Shift-F2, Ctrl-F2, etc. Right thumb does all modifiers, while left thumb handles space/backspace.

To accomplish this, I do need two Ctrl keys, which is too bad. Furthermore, Ctrl-Alt is annoying to hit--but honestly, I've only needed Ctrl-Alt about three times in the past year in order to reset my password in Windows for work.

Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Glod on Wed, 09 April 2014, 14:47:47
This week does mark 1 year of using the ErgoDox and making it my primary keyboard.

I think i had to be one of the first handful of people to build the massdrop round 1 kit. The ergodox was a game changer for me. I have a a history, dating back before i was using mechanical, of switching up mice and keyboards every few months and the fact i am still using this ergodox shows just how much i love it. Anyone that follows me knows my ergodoxes changes appearances often so i never go bored lol.

My first ergodox was built April 8th 2013 with krytox-mix lubed reds. reds i pulled from the famous $25 RK9000 deal
(https://farm9.staticflickr.com/8395/8631585775_38db68e539.jpg) (https://flic.kr/p/e9K8Jp)
(https://farm9.staticflickr.com/8255/8648042974_9bda48a2b5.jpg) (https://flic.kr/p/ebctTd)

As documented on Flickr, I've build and rebuilt my 2nd(RIP) and 3rd ergodox with whites, blues, feather blues, browns, clears, and ergo clears and although all that testing was fun, I keep going back to the first, now heavily beat up, ergodox because after so much use the broken in lubed reds the quietest, smoothest, absolute buttery switches i have ever used, i want to change the weight with different springs but i am afraid to mess up how good these feel. Stock reds feel nothing like these. I thought I liked clicky and tactile switches but i keep coming back to lubed linear.

This is my current layout and favorite layout so far, similar to my last shared layout its pc gaming and keycap friendly and also allows me quick uses of keys i need for work and gaming.
(http://www.almightyglod.com/public_stack/Glod_ErgoDox_Layout_March_2014.png)


If any ergodox owners are unaware, there is a keycap group buy going on via signature plastics called Granite http://www.pimpmykeyboard.com/deals/granite-set-pbt-dye-sub-dsa/ it is dye sub pbt DSA, should last forever, and allows ergodox users to grab keys with legends for every key properly. this is THE essential key cap set for the ergodox and i think is worth the cost.


/rant
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: Glod on Wed, 09 April 2014, 15:05:54
Also wanted to add something about how people have their ergodox arranged on their desk

i have tried tented and not tented and i found that i like to tent if i want/need both my hands close together but i like it flat if i put the hands far apart with the mouse in the center. My hands are alligned with my shoulder width and i have my desk tray lowered where my wrists are level with my elbows.

(https://farm3.staticflickr.com/2823/13745376564_09c1ea0bf5.jpg) (https://flic.kr/p/mWCDz7)

In fact i think the hands at shoulder width is the proper way you should use the erogodox (tented or not tented), i see many people recently with their ergodox hands really close together and wonder if they have tried the hands far apart yet, one of the key design elements of the erogodox is the ability to spread them out. the ergonomics seem better far apart, especially if you want to keep them flat.

as for what is in the center of my ergodox hands, I was using a slimblade trackball with my ergodox for most of last year but my slimblade broke and i went back to mouse, the mionix naos 3200 and found i like the mouse better as a gamer, ergonomics be damned.

/second rant
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: wuqe on Wed, 09 April 2014, 15:31:39
Congratulations, Glod! Meanwhile, I am only six months in myself, but also loving the thing.

I appreciate your thoughts on placement; I may have to look at mine more critically now.

I'll second PBT granite for being the perfect set for the Ergodox. I'm looking forward to mine gaining some legit legends.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: AntiFish03 on Tue, 29 July 2014, 09:14:05
(https://scontent-a-dfw.xx.fbcdn.net/hphotos-xap1/v/t1.0-9/10527334_920816034610970_5300357497095650040_n.jpg?oh=9f5f08515e528ceff25fff3443bf03b7&oe=5452F88F)

Just finished mine about 4 hours ago... its like learning to type all over again.

Pros:  nice smooth keypress with the cherry mx reds I choose.


Cons: not enough keys for all the symbols to be in the correct location.  So I am trying to not only learn the keyboard but my custom layout too.
Title: Re: How are you liking your ErgoDox?
Post by: davkol on Tue, 29 July 2014, 09:24:24
Fewer keys isn't a con! At least once you get used to layers with these special symbols right in the resting home position. I recommend using the bottom-row keys under FJ as modifiers.