geekhack

geekhack Marketplace => Group Buys and Preorders => Topic started by: kboardvintage on Thu, 02 May 2013, 15:17:04

Title: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: kboardvintage on Thu, 02 May 2013, 15:17:04
Update 05/07

I read a lot of comments in the GB. My apologies to all those who feel frustrated with the actual situation. Most of you guys have file a complain via paypal and so far paypal is already taking care of those (I ll be consider as a "scammer" in the paypal system so, again, THANKS).
About BSP, the people responsible of dealing with my order are now on holidays (as they just told me via phone) and will be back somewhere end of July. I have already request a full refund, but apparently within the "backup" team left, no accountant is present...so SURPRISE, your money is still at BSP's hands, at least until August.

I will be off on holidays for the becoming 3 weeks, but I will connect once in awhile to update here, if necessary.

I will keep u guys informed as soon as I get news from them. I see there is a lot of talk about this, but I do not have the time or energy to  answer everyone, specially not to those who haven't purchase any set.





Update 25/06

First of all, my paypal account is "suspended" due to all the disputes open and my funds nearly -2k (thanks)

So for those who want their  money back asap, I cannot do anything about this. I understand your position but the money is still at BSP's hands. I am trying to keep this GB going, because WE have the right to get what we purchased. They do not have the right to cancel an order based on NOTHING, although some would argue this was sherry whatsoever, well they offered me a product, I purchase it, end of the discussion about jumping on others MOQ, I didn't ask for that, I initially request for samples.. .
As the Contract of Sales of goods states (under the european normative, this is a clear breach of contract, and so far I am trying to persuade them that what they are doing is not legit.

About the blank orders, I do not know why Sherry keeps saying that those would be cancelled. So Sherry, please, do not keep screwing up things here. The blank sets are NOT canceled. Actually BSP is trying to send me the Blank + RGB blank with 1 set of each color (DYESUB sets) which is not acceptable for me, because is not what I purchased.

Conclusion: Sherry, u are giving me a HUGE headache with this situation, and I really hope that u can have a lovely bath with your 400sets. Plus the MOQ stated by BSP was a big bull**** (yes, I got quotations for 25, 50 and 100 MOQ ;), deal with it :D)




Update 17/06

GB (almost) CANCELLED; Trying to agree with Sherry that 19 key sets won't hurt his business more than shutting down a GroupBuy @ GH.

More details here:

http://geekhack.org/index.php?topic=44630.0


IN PRODUCTION!  

Update 28/05

PICS AVAILABLE :D

BLACK SET
Well guys today I got a couple of pics of the BLACK sets (were the first sets done apparently). I requested pics of the rest of the sets. Hopefully I will get more pics tomorrow .

(Attachment Link)

(Attachment Link)

BLUE SET

(http://i.imgur.com/Q5XYRZR.jpg?1)

Update 08/05

Payment DONE -  Sets are already in production since last monday :>.

Hopefully I can get pics of the sets next week!!

Please, help me with the unpaid orders that I had to cover!!!

2xblack DYESUB TKL
1xgreen DYESUB TKL
1xblue DYESUB TKL
1xred DYESUB TKL
3x BLANK sets & 2x RGB (B-profile)

Those sets were ordered but not paid/canceled too late...

I will kindly appreciate if someone could help me getting rid of some extras...else I will have a lovely dyesub collection that I don't need!

Update 06/05

PAYMENT DUE DATE:
Wednesday 8 of May 00:00 CST.

For those unpaid orders after Wednesday I will make them available for people who miss the GB. Leftovers available on Thursday 9


Update 04/05

BSP initial quotation for blank caps was based on  a MOQ 100. For this GB, and due to the "special" conditions given (NO MOQ, no set up cost) prices are different for RGB blank and Full set.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Available stuff:

1- Cherry Classic 2-tone DYE SUB TKL sets, a total of 85 keycaps; 1.5x mods and two 1x caps A-profile for the bottom row. Possibility to choose 4 different font colors. BLANK Classic 2-tone PBT 102 keycaps sets.
2- BSP PBT BLANK Classic 2-tone sets (102 caps, Grey&beige)
3- Possibility to add PBT BLANK RGB set (1.5x mods, A & B profile available) with any of the sets.


1- Cherry classic 2 tone sets (Grey&Beige) TKL ANSI sets

Options:

DYESUB Font color (black, blue, green, red).

Remarks:
Bottom row is A-profile. TKL sets include two 1x A profile caps (to be decided becoming Monday if those will be dyesub or blank), hence the 85 keycaps winkeyless tkl consist of 83 caps.
NO SPACE BAR

Limited units

Price per set = 95,60 €


2- BSP PBT BLANK Classic 2-tone sets (102 caps, Grey&beige)

This sets also include two extra blank 1x keycap in A profile, hence a total of 102 keycaps

Price per set =  68,35€


3- EXTRA PBT RGB Blank set

Price per set = 15,5€



Shipcost:

1-2 sets:  €17 worldwide, 10€ anywhere in Europe.  PostNL Priority "brief" with Track&Trace.
2+ sets: €24,30 wordwide, 14 to 19,50€ depends where in Europe. PostNL small package with Track&Trace.

Got few questions about combining shipment. I think it could be great for Americans to combine shipping, but you need to propose who would do that. I cannot organize it.

Payment via paypal/bank transfer as an option (if you are in Europe).
Buyer pays paypal/transfer fees.

Lead time: 3 weeks (Week 22)

No pictures (yet).  If someone is wondering about the spacebar, it is likely that 7x GMK spacebars will be available soon being a perfect match for this set.
Title: Re: BSP DYE SUB TKL sets - 85 caps - no spacebar
Post by: Patchwrks on Thu, 02 May 2013, 15:18:59
I'll take a set

font color: Black

could I have the mods explained to me so I can pick from them better?
Title: Re: BSP DYE SUB TKL sets - 85 caps - no spacebar
Post by: boost on Thu, 02 May 2013, 15:19:21
Do you have pics of this set as I would like a red font. Do these come with 1.5 mods and/or 1.25?

I'm interested in a set!
Title: Re: BSP DYE SUB TKL sets - 85 caps - no spacebar
Post by: kboardvintage on Thu, 02 May 2013, 15:23:44
I'll take a set

font color: Black

could I have the mods explained to me so I can pick from them better?

A profile is the classic 1.5x Cherry profile. B profile is the modern mods profile (same as the Shift I believe)
Title: Re: BSP DYE SUB TKL sets - 85 caps - no spacebar
Post by: ekw808 on Thu, 02 May 2013, 15:25:53
Down for a set
Title: BSP DYE SUB TKL sets - 85 caps - no spacebar
Post by: iArson on Thu, 02 May 2013, 15:27:57
Down for a set.
Title: Re: BSP DYE SUB TKL sets - 85 caps - no spacebar
Post by: Grim Fandango on Thu, 02 May 2013, 15:28:04
Interesting. Mat get a set, and sell the one I have coming in the mail.
Title: Re: BSP DYE SUB TKL sets - 85 caps - no spacebar
Post by: kboardvintage on Thu, 02 May 2013, 15:29:01
Do you have pics of this set as I would like a red font. Do these come with 1.5 mods and/or 1.25?

I'm interested in a set!

BSP only does 1.5x. they dont have 1.25x molds (unfortuantely)

No pics available. They had never done sets with red font until I requested...so I cannot send you any picture (yet).
Title: Re: BSP DYE SUB TKL sets - 85 caps - no spacebar
Post by: kboardvintage on Thu, 02 May 2013, 15:33:44
Down for a set
Down for a set.

Send me your paypal details via pm, I will send you the bill tomorrow morning the latest.

Forgot to mention that shipping options are rather limited here in The Netherlands...(and expensive) I prefer track&trace service to avoid any problems with paypal
Shipping via PostNL with track&trace is around €17 worldwide (I will have to double check that).
Title: Re: BSP DYE SUB TKL sets - 85 caps - no spacebar
Post by: kboardvintage on Thu, 02 May 2013, 15:34:52


I'm interested in a set!

Send me a pm with your paypal details too :P
Title: Re: BSP DYE SUB TKL sets - 85 caps - no spacebar
Post by: Patchwrks on Thu, 02 May 2013, 15:45:12
I'll take a set

font color: Black

could I have the mods explained to me so I can pick from them better?

A profile is the classic 1.5x Cherry profile. B profile is the modern mods profile (same as the Shift I believe)

so it's a height difference. can anybody relate it to the sp caps?
Title: Re: BSP DYE SUB TKL sets - 85 caps - no spacebar
Post by: kboardvintage on Thu, 02 May 2013, 15:49:49
I'll take a set

font color: Black

could I have the mods explained to me so I can pick from them better?

A profile is the classic 1.5x Cherry profile. B profile is the modern mods profile (same as the Shift I believe)

so it's a height difference. can anybody relate it to the sp caps?

Here a clear example of A profile vs B profile (the tallest is the A profile)

(http://i.imgur.com/Wyi9cpv.jpg)
Title: Re: BSP DYE SUB TKL sets - 85 caps - no spacebar
Post by: bazemk1979 on Thu, 02 May 2013, 15:56:38
question: space bar, alt,win,page,ctrl,caps lock wont fit Costar boards right?
Title: Re: BSP DYE SUB TKL sets - 85 caps - no spacebar
Post by: esoomenona on Thu, 02 May 2013, 15:58:52
question: space bar, alt,win,page,ctrl,caps lock wont fit Costar boards right?
No space bar included, not sure about the caps lock (might include both), but all the others won't fit. Wrong sizing.
Title: Re: BSP DYE SUB TKL sets - 85 caps - no spacebar
Post by: kboardvintage on Thu, 02 May 2013, 15:59:21
question: space bar, alt,win,page,ctrl,caps lock wont fit Costar boards right?

Exactly...this sets, unfortunately, don't fit modern costar keyboards (1.5x modifiers & 6x spacebar, stepped capslock) unless you use a moogle kit from SP.
Title: Re: BSP DYE SUB TKL sets - 85 caps - no spacebar
Post by: bazemk1979 on Thu, 02 May 2013, 16:01:45
ok thanks, going to past due to cost + having to chase Moogle that no one runs GB for them anymore
Title: Re: [FS] BSP DYE SUB TKL sets - 85 keys - no spacebar
Post by: pasph on Thu, 02 May 2013, 17:46:54
Only ANSI?
Title: Re: [FS] BSP DYE SUB TKL sets - 85 keys - no spacebar
Post by: kboardvintage on Thu, 02 May 2013, 17:57:39
Only ANSI?

Yes, BSP don't have left shift or big Enter molds.
Title: [FS] BSP DYE SUB TKL sets - 85 keys - no spacebar
Post by: Acetrak on Thu, 02 May 2013, 20:25:19
Down for a set, PM sent yo
Title: Re: [FS] BSP DYE SUB TKL sets - 85 keys - no spacebar
Post by: Rendom on Thu, 02 May 2013, 20:27:58
Would really want a picture before I decide. : D
Title: Re: [FS] BSP DYE SUB TKL sets - 85 keys - no spacebar
Post by: i488 on Thu, 02 May 2013, 22:01:01
i will take at least one set. :D
Title: Re: [FS] BSP DYE SUB TKL sets - 85 keys - no spacebar
Post by: kboardvintage on Fri, 03 May 2013, 00:07:46
Would really want a picture before I decide. : D
could I get a picture of the blue text and red text ones?

For those wanting pictures...sets are not in production yet so I cannot provide any pictures.


Title: Re: [FS] BSP DYE SUB TKL sets - 85 keys - no spacebar
Post by: kboardvintage on Fri, 03 May 2013, 00:19:59
Would really want a picture before I decide. : D
could I get a picture of the blue text and red text ones?

For those wanting pictures...sets are not in production yet so I cannot provide any pictures.
will they look like this?:https://www.originativeco.com/classic-beige-blue-two-tone

Yes, but PBT and DYE SUB rather than doubleshot ABS.
Title: Re: [FS] BSP DYE SUB TKL sets - 85 keys - no spacebar
Post by: calavera on Fri, 03 May 2013, 00:29:54
Would really want a picture before I decide. : D
could I get a picture of the blue text and red text ones?

For those wanting pictures...sets are not in production yet so I cannot provide any pictures.
will they look like this?:https://www.originativeco.com/classic-beige-blue-two-tone

Yes, but PBT and DYE SUB rather than doubleshot ABS.
darn :/ I like PBT and all but the colors are so much clearer in the originitiveco version and probably a bit cheaper.

Well those are double shots so you shouldn't really compare those two. DS will have the most crisp fonts but dye sub is superior in every other way IMO.
Title: Re: [FS] BSP DYE SUB TKL sets - 85 keys - no spacebar
Post by: alixinhzai on Fri, 03 May 2013, 02:13:14
Can i buy only rgb?
Title: Re: [FS] BSP DYE SUB TKL sets - 85 keys - no spacebar
Post by: kboardvintage on Fri, 03 May 2013, 02:18:15
Can i buy only rgb?

No sorry.

RGB is an option of the TKL set.

Title: Re: [FS] BSP DYE SUB TKL sets - 85 keys - no spacebar
Post by: mm87 on Fri, 03 May 2013, 04:36:52
But it's an addition not a replacement of the regular mods right? Also is it only 1 RGB possible per set ordered or can you order 1 set and and 2x RGB for example?
Title: Re: [FS] BSP DYE SUB TKL sets - 85 keys - no spacebar
Post by: Elrick on Fri, 03 May 2013, 04:48:45
Cherry classic 2 tone sets (Grey&Beige) ANSI sets

Options:
1- Font colour (black).
2- B mods profile

This is the ONE I want to buy from you, have already PM'd you with my details.

Looking forward to trying these out on a Cherry board soon.
Title: [FS] BSP DYE SUB TKL sets - 85 keys - no spacebar
Post by: remedyhalopc on Fri, 03 May 2013, 05:33:04
The GoW is SEXY. When will they be available?
Title: Re: [FS] BSP DYE SUB TKL sets - 85 keys - no spacebar
Post by: Mandolin on Fri, 03 May 2013, 05:49:34

Examples:

Blue; replica of Olivetti dye sub

Show Image
(http://i1313.photobucket.com/albums/t554/Jorge_Bosch/olivetti_zps9141880e.png)




That's my thumb  :-X.

PD: I never signed an affidavit to use my personal image as a marketing scheme, I'd settle for a cut  :cool:
Title: Re: [FS] BSP DYE SUB TKL sets - 85 keys - no spacebar
Post by: kboardvintage on Fri, 03 May 2013, 06:09:47
But it's an addition not a replacement of the regular mods right? Also is it only 1 RGB possible per set ordered or can you order 1 set and and 2x RGB for example?

Exactly, it is an ADD-On of the actual 85 keycap set.

Cherry classic 2 tone sets (Grey&Beige) ANSI sets

Options:
1- Font colour (black).
2- B mods profile

This is the ONE I want to buy from you, have already PM'd you with my details.

Looking forward to trying these out on a Cherry board soon.

Got it. Will send you the bill later.

The GoW is SEXY. When will they be available?

I guess you mean green on white? It won't happen now, but who knows what will the future bring?? Maybe Blue/Green Alert (blue on white, green on white), G81-3000SAV replicas... :cool:





Title: Re: [FS] BSP DYE SUB TKL sets - 85 keys - no spacebar
Post by: kboardvintage on Fri, 03 May 2013, 06:16:30

Examples:

Blue; replica of Olivetti dye sub

Show Image
(http://i1313.photobucket.com/albums/t554/Jorge_Bosch/olivetti_zps9141880e.png)




That's my thumb  :-X.

PD: I never signed an affidavit to use my personal image as a marketing scheme, I'd settle for a cut  :cool:

thanks for letting me "stealing" your pic :P
Title: Re: [FS] BSP DYE SUB TKL sets - 85 keys - no spacebar
Post by: alixinhzai on Fri, 03 May 2013, 07:26:54
PM for shipping option :D
Title: Re: [FS] BSP DYE SUB TKL sets - 85 keys - no spacebar
Post by: kboardvintage on Fri, 03 May 2013, 08:26:33
Sad news.

Due to extra cost associated to tooling change I have to stick to A profile sets.

For those who wanted B profile, I am sorry but It won't happen this time.\

Will edit OP to make it clear there too.
Title: Re: [FS] BSP DYE SUB TKL sets - 85 keys - no spacebar
Post by: IvanIvanovich on Fri, 03 May 2013, 08:32:07
You really probably should have put this in the groupbuy section since that is what you are doing essentially as you don't have the items in hand to sell right now.
Was thinking about it until see only A profile. Oh well will keep eye for another time with B profile.
Title: Re: [FS] BSP DYE SUB TKL sets - 85 keys - no spacebar
Post by: kboardvintage on Fri, 03 May 2013, 08:53:52
Aaalright...well for BLANK RGB A & B profile will be available. Confirmed 100%. Sorry, again, for the confusion caused.

Added to OP:  Classic 2-tone BLANK PBT sets (102caps) to match with the blank RGB!
Title: Re: BSP stuff: DYE SUB TKL sets - PBT Blank 2-tone full sets - Blank RGB 1.5x
Post by: pasph on Fri, 03 May 2013, 09:15:39
Sorry, not interested in A profile
Title: Re: BSP stuff: DYE SUB TKL sets - PBT Blank 2-tone full sets - Blank RGB 1.5x
Post by: zenuty on Fri, 03 May 2013, 09:23:52
Verry Nice Group Buy

i want Olivetti ( Blue Legend + Dark Gray Modi )
Title: Re: BSP stuff: DYE SUB TKL sets - PBT Blank 2-tone full sets - Blank RGB 1.5x
Post by: adamseto on Fri, 03 May 2013, 10:23:22
Dear kboardvintage

Pls kindly post more pic.
Title: Re: BSP stuff: DYE SUB TKL sets - PBT Blank 2-tone full sets - Blank RGB 1.5x
Post by: alixinhzai on Fri, 03 May 2013, 10:35:19
He don't have any set on hand my friend :)
Title: Re: BSP stuff: DYE SUB TKL sets - PBT Blank 2-tone full sets - Blank RGB 1.5x
Post by: quochung1989 on Fri, 03 May 2013, 10:36:32
Only suit Iso kit? :-X
Title: Re: BSP stuff: DYE SUB TKL sets - PBT Blank 2-tone full sets - Blank RGB 1.5x
Post by: kboardvintage on Fri, 03 May 2013, 10:39:16
He don't have any set on hand my friend :)

Exactly :)
Title: Re: BSP stuff: DYE SUB TKL sets - PBT Blank 2-tone full sets - Blank RGB 1.5x
Post by: kboardvintage on Fri, 03 May 2013, 10:41:18
Only suit Iso kit? :-X

What do you mean? This are ANSI sets, both of them. No ISO stuff here :(
Title: Re: BSP stuff: DYE SUB TKL sets - PBT Blank 2-tone full sets - Blank RGB 1.5x
Post by: quochung1989 on Fri, 03 May 2013, 10:47:17
Only suit Iso kit? :-X

What do you mean? This are ANSI sets, both of them. No ISO stuff here :(
Sorry I view image above. So I think ISO set (Enter key).
I'm very sorry  :-[
Title: BSP stuff: DYE SUB TKL sets - PBT Blank 2-tone full sets - Blank RGB 1.5x
Post by: remedyhalopc on Fri, 03 May 2013, 11:06:19
A profile = OEM
B = cherry

Is that correct?
Title: Re: BSP stuff: DYE SUB TKL sets - PBT Blank 2-tone full sets - Blank RGB 1.5x
Post by: IvanIvanovich on Fri, 03 May 2013, 11:21:12
(http://www.cherrycorp.com/english/switches/key/images/mx_keydim_cyl.gif)

A row is old school style. Modern boards have B profile like shift on the bottom row.
Title: Re: BSP stuff: DYE SUB TKL sets - PBT Blank 2-tone full sets - Blank RGB 1.5x
Post by: The_Beast on Fri, 03 May 2013, 11:23:50
Forgive my ignorance, but what's the difference between this set and say an imsto set of PBTs?
Title: Re: BSP stuff: DYE SUB TKL sets - PBT Blank 2-tone full sets - Blank RGB 1.5x
Post by: IvanIvanovich on Fri, 03 May 2013, 11:26:12
Availability of 1.5 mods and they have the original legends, not community made copy. For those that want 1.5 this is the way to go, for those that want 1.25 I will be starting similar buy next week.
Title: Re: BSP stuff: DYE SUB TKL sets - PBT Blank 2-tone full sets - Blank RGB 1.5x
Post by: The_Beast on Fri, 03 May 2013, 11:27:12
Availability of 1.5 mods and they have the original legends, not community made copy. For those that want 1.5 this is the way to go, for those that want 1.25 I will be starting similar buy next week.

Any difference in quality or feel? Is BSP using cherry molds?
Title: Re: BSP stuff: DYE SUB TKL sets - PBT Blank 2-tone full sets - Blank RGB 1.5x
Post by: IvanIvanovich on Fri, 03 May 2013, 11:28:28
BSP is the maker of Desko etc. so it should be top notch.
Title: Re: BSP stuff: DYE SUB TKL sets - PBT Blank 2-tone full sets - Blank RGB 1.5x
Post by: The_Beast on Fri, 03 May 2013, 11:30:56
Any idea of what legends are going to be used?
Title: Re: BSP stuff: DYE SUB TKL sets - PBT Blank 2-tone full sets - Blank RGB 1.5x
Post by: agor on Fri, 03 May 2013, 11:38:05
These should be as close to original as it gets. Cherry Font.
Ansi only though... :(
Title: Re: BSP stuff: DYE SUB TKL sets - PBT Blank 2-tone full sets - Blank RGB 1.5x
Post by: Dianoda on Fri, 03 May 2013, 12:14:50
I'm tempted to order a green set (BSP PBT w/ cherry legends = hot), are these ABCDEF profile?  Or ABCDEE?

Is there a source for modern looking 1x A profile winkeys?  What's the availability like for 7x A profile spacebars?
Title: Re: BSP stuff: DYE SUB TKL sets - PBT Blank 2-tone full sets - Blank RGB 1.5x
Post by: kaiserreich on Fri, 03 May 2013, 12:48:58
Availability of 1.5 mods and they have the original legends, not community made copy. For those that want 1.5 this is the way to go, for those that want 1.25 I will be starting similar buy next week.

1.25 as in GMK or BSP?
Title: Re: BSP stuff: DYE SUB TKL sets - PBT Blank 2-tone full sets - Blank RGB 1.5x
Post by: kboardvintage on Fri, 03 May 2013, 12:59:20
I'm tempted to order a green set (BSP PBT w/ cherry legends = hot), are these ABCDEF profile?  Or ABCDEE?

Is there a source for modern looking 1x A profile winkeys?  What's the availability like for 7x A profile spacebars?

Sets are ABCDEE profile

The sets include 1x A profile keys, but blank. I won't do any print on it this time. Maybe in future Gbuys it is an option to padprint the w8 logo or something.
Title: Re: BSP stuff: DYE SUB TKL sets - PBT Blank 2-tone full sets - Blank RGB 1.5x
Post by: Dianoda on Fri, 03 May 2013, 13:06:03
Availability of 1.5 mods and they have the original legends, not community made copy. For those that want 1.5 this is the way to go, for those that want 1.25 I will be starting similar buy next week.

1.25 as in GMK or BSP?

I'm pretty sure Ivan is referring to round 2 of IMSTO thick PBT dye-sub sets w/ cherry replica font GB - round 1 was all white keys, 104 ANSI layout.  IIRC round 2 is new colorways on white keys w/ light gray (or maybe beige?) mods.  There was a preview of the new colorways in the round 1 thread.
Title: Re: BSP stuff: DYE SUB TKL sets - PBT Blank 2-tone full sets - Blank RGB 1.5x
Post by: kboardvintage on Fri, 03 May 2013, 14:02:17
Any idea of what legends are going to be used?

BSP uses Cherry molds & legends. Desko caps were, indeed, made by BSP.
Title: Re: BSP stuff: DYE SUB TKL sets - PBT Blank 2-tone full sets - Blank RGB 1.5x
Post by: The_Beast on Fri, 03 May 2013, 14:04:35
Any idea of what legends are going to be used?

BSP uses Cherry molds & legends. Desko caps were, indeed, made by BSP.

I was just wondering about the legend.

ex: would the shift say shift and have the symbol, or would it just be the symbol. Would the backspace say backspace or just have the symbol.....

When does this close BTW?
Title: Re: BSP stuff: DYE SUB TKL sets - PBT Blank 2-tone full sets - Blank RGB 1.5x
Post by: kboardvintage on Fri, 03 May 2013, 14:07:23
Any idea of what legends are going to be used?

BSP uses Cherry molds & legends. Desko caps were, indeed, made by BSP.

I was just wondering about the legend.

ex: would the shift say shift and have the symbol, or would it just be the symbol. Would the backspace say backspace or just have the symbol.....

When does this close BTW?

Becoming monday. Got a spot in production but I had to addapt to a really tight schedule. I guess 06/05 is the 5th of June in the rest of the world...in Europe we undersand 06/05 as 6 of May.
Title: Re: FLASH GB - BSP stuff: Cherry DYE SUB TKL - PBT Blank full sets - 3DAYS LEFT!
Post by: Acanthophis on Fri, 03 May 2013, 20:13:07
ex: would the shift say shift and have the symbol, or would it just be the symbol. Would the backspace say backspace or just have the symbol...
Symbols only would be dope. If that's feasible.
Title: Re: BSP stuff: DYE SUB TKL sets - PBT Blank 2-tone full sets - Blank RGB 1.5x
Post by: Elrick on Fri, 03 May 2013, 20:23:37
For those that want 1.5 this is the way to go, for those that want 1.25 I will be starting similar buy next week.

Very nice and definitely interested.  Looks like GB's on some PBT sets are coming, especially with the Cherry Admiration Club  8) .
Title: Re: FLASH GB - BSP stuff: Cherry DYE SUB TKL - PBT Blank full sets - 3DAYS LEFT!
Post by: tsangan on Fri, 03 May 2013, 20:27:35
in for each colour minus black I have those
Title: Re: FLASH GB - BSP stuff: Cherry DYE SUB TKL - PBT Blank full sets - 3DAYS LEFT!
Post by: kaiserreich on Fri, 03 May 2013, 22:30:42
in for each colour minus black I have those

Keyboardless guy buying a ton of dyesubs :p
Title: Re: FLASH GB - BSP stuff: Cherry DYE SUB TKL - PBT Blank full sets - 3DAYS LEFT!
Post by: demik on Fri, 03 May 2013, 22:55:38
now i have to ask, it being a GB and all.. are you making a dime off this?
Title: Re: FLASH GB - BSP stuff: Cherry DYE SUB TKL - PBT Blank full sets - 3DAYS LEFT!
Post by: kboardvintage on Sat, 04 May 2013, 04:51:18
now i have to ask, it being a GB and all.. are you making a dime off this?

Well BSP is definetly making it...

I accept their proposal of getting limited sets and no MOQ / setup cost with the condition of paying a "premium".

Title: Re: FLASH GB - BSP stuff: Cherry DYE SUB TKL - PBT Blank full sets - 2DAYS LEFT!
Post by: pmh1410 on Sat, 04 May 2013, 07:12:28
2- BSP PBT BLANK Classic 2-tone sets (102 caps, Grey&beige)

This sets also include two extra blank 1x keycap in A profile, hence a total of 102 keycaps

Price per set =  68,35€ (yesterday ----->55€ )

3- EXTRA PBT RGB Blank set

Price per set = 15,5€ (yesterday ------> 11€ )
***********************************

I don't understand at all.
Title: Re: FLASH GB - BSP stuff: Cherry DYE SUB TKL - PBT Blank full sets - 2DAYS LEFT!
Post by: kboardvintage on Sat, 04 May 2013, 07:22:24
2- BSP PBT BLANK Classic 2-tone sets (102 caps, Grey&beige)

This sets also include two extra blank 1x keycap in A profile, hence a total of 102 keycaps

Price per set =  68,35€ (yesterday ----->55€ )

3- EXTRA PBT RGB Blank set

Price per set = 15,5€ (yesterday ------> 11€ )
***********************************

I don't understand at all.

Well explained @ the OP.

Update 04/05

BSP initial quotation for blank caps was based on  a MOQ 100. For this GB, and due to the "special" conditions given (NO MOQ, no set up cost) prices are different for RGB blank and Full set.
Title: Re: FLASH GB - BSP stuff: Cherry DYE SUB TKL - PBT Blank full sets - 2DAYS LEFT!
Post by: pmh1410 on Sat, 04 May 2013, 08:11:33
okie, thanks for new info :)
Title: Re: FLASH GB - BSP stuff: Cherry DYE SUB TKL - PBT Blank full sets - 2DAYS LEFT!
Post by: i488 on Sat, 04 May 2013, 10:09:44
order sent via pm please confirm
Title: Re: FLASH GB - BSP stuff: Cherry DYE SUB TKL - PBT Blank full sets - 2DAYS LEFT!
Post by: kboardvintage on Sat, 04 May 2013, 10:10:08
order sent via pm please confirm

done.
Title: Re: FLASH GB - BSP stuff: Cherry DYE SUB TKL - PBT Blank full sets - 2DAYS LEFT!
Post by: i488 on Sat, 04 May 2013, 10:38:23
order sent via pm please confirm

done.
:'( :'( here I am, again.
I forget that I have 101 set in black legends already.
So my Final order will have to be:
1 red 85
1 green 85
1 blue 85
1 blank set
2 rgb
all in A profile.
My paypal is
i488james@live.com
Title: Re: FLASH GB - BSP stuff: Cherry DYE SUB TKL - PBT Blank full sets - 2DAYS LEFT!
Post by: guilleguillaume on Sat, 04 May 2013, 13:46:27
You should remove your paypal email from the post or you will be flooded with spam and tons of emails.

Is there any chance to have 1.75 RShift?
Title: Re: FLASH GB - BSP stuff: Cherry DYE SUB TKL - PBT Blank full sets - 2DAYS LEFT!
Post by: kboardvintage on Sat, 04 May 2013, 13:59:42
You should remove your paypal email from the post or you will be flooded with spam and tons of emails.

Is there any chance to have 1.75 RShift?

Guille BSP cannot do 1.75 right shift...but lets see if they decide to purchase new molds (spacebars, 1.25x mods & 1.75 row4 mold). This kind of orders or Red-Line groupbuy, makes them understand that there is an existing demand for MX keycaps, so hopefully they will decide to invest in few new MX molds. But from now, 1.75 right shift is not available.
Title: Re: FLASH GB - BSP stuff: Cherry DYE SUB TKL - PBT Blank full sets - 2DAYS LEFT!
Post by: guilleguillaume on Sat, 04 May 2013, 14:26:19
You should remove your paypal email from the post or you will be flooded with spam and tons of emails.

Is there any chance to have 1.75 RShift?

Guille BSP cannot do 1.75 right shift...but lets see if they decide to purchase new molds (spacebars, 1.25x mods & 1.75 row4 mold). This kind of orders or Red-Line groupbuy, makes them understand that there is an existing demand for MX keycaps, so hopefully they will decide to invest in few new MX molds. But from now, 1.75 right shift is not available.


That makes sense. I thought they did have the tooling to produce those keys. Well was just for knowing if I could be using the full sets in some layouts or just stick to the classic ones.

I really like the idea of 1x Blank A profile keys.

We should expect those keys to be produced in the end of May and that's great. I guess I should place a large order before Monday.
Title: Re: FLASH GB - BSP stuff: Cherry DYE SUB TKL - PBT Blank full sets - 2DAYS LEFT!
Post by: kboardvintage on Sat, 04 May 2013, 15:02:10
You should remove your paypal email from the post or you will be flooded with spam and tons of emails.

Is there any chance to have 1.75 RShift?

Guille BSP cannot do 1.75 right shift...but lets see if they decide to purchase new molds (spacebars, 1.25x mods & 1.75 row4 mold). This kind of orders or Red-Line groupbuy, makes them understand that there is an existing demand for MX keycaps, so hopefully they will decide to invest in few new MX molds. But from now, 1.75 right shift is not available.


That makes sense. I thought they did have the tooling to produce those keys. Well was just for knowing if I could be using the full sets in some layouts or just stick to the classic ones.

I really like the idea of 1x Blank A profile keys.

We should expect those keys to be produced in the end of May and that's great. I guess I should place a large order before Monday.

Indeed.  I will place the final order on monday and the due date to pay bills is going to be, likely, becoming tuesday. BSP will start production from Monday on. ETA is expected for week 23
Title: Re: FLASH GB - BSP stuff: Cherry DYE SUB TKL - PBT Blank full sets - 2DAYS LEFT!
Post by: sleepy916 on Sat, 04 May 2013, 15:25:05
Just to make sure, the RGB only come in blank right?
Title: Re: FLASH GB - BSP stuff: Cherry DYE SUB TKL - PBT Blank full sets - 2DAYS LEFT!
Post by: kboardvintage on Sat, 04 May 2013, 15:28:37
Just to make sure, the RGB only come in blank right?

Yes, only blank.
Title: Re: FLASH GB - BSP stuff: Cherry DYE SUB TKL - PBT Blank full sets - 2DAYS LEFT!
Post by: remedyhalopc on Sat, 04 May 2013, 23:41:20
can you provide a picture of what exactly each set will come with? trying to figure out a way to use these on a modern board.
Title: Re: FLASH GB - BSP stuff: Cherry DYE SUB TKL - PBT Blank full sets - 2DAYS LEFT!
Post by: kboardvintage on Sun, 05 May 2013, 00:03:27
can you provide a picture of what exactly each set will come with? trying to figure out a way to use these on a modern board.


The set will have same layout as this kmac2: ANSI winkeyless TKL. So 1.5x modifiers, two 1x A-profile caps, in the pics those are the yellow caps. This GB offers them in grey and A-profile to match the modifiers color and profile.

(http://i.imgur.com/XzoiPuD.jpg)
Title: Re: Last Day!! BSP stuff: Cherry DYE SUB TKL - PBT Blank full sets.
Post by: alixinhzai on Sun, 05 May 2013, 01:44:04
wow :) 1x keycap grey color :x
Title: Re: FLASH GB - BSP stuff: Cherry DYE SUB TKL - PBT Blank full sets - 2DAYS LEFT!
Post by: sleepy916 on Sun, 05 May 2013, 12:51:06


Show Image
(http://i.imgur.com/XzoiPuD.jpg)


Is it going to have all that front printed text?
Title: Re: FLASH GB - BSP stuff: Cherry DYE SUB TKL - PBT Blank full sets - 2DAYS LEFT!
Post by: kboardvintage on Sun, 05 May 2013, 13:12:50


Show Image
(http://i.imgur.com/XzoiPuD.jpg)


Is it going to have all that front printed text?


What do you mean? the TKL set?

Those will be like this one (excluding the numpad, so Tenkeyless sets)

(http://enjoyclick.org/data/attachment/forum/201304/08/231514k8qg080cogengell.jpg)
Title: Re: Last Day!! BSP stuff: Cherry DYE SUB TKL - PBT Blank full sets.
Post by: sleepy916 on Sun, 05 May 2013, 13:17:06
Yeah in the picture I quoted, it had front text printed on. I'm glad it won't, a bit too busy looking for me.
Title: Re: Last Day!! BSP stuff: Cherry DYE SUB TKL - PBT Blank full sets.
Post by: Dianoda on Sun, 05 May 2013, 17:22:39
Are the F+J keys scoops or nubs?
Title: Re: Last Day!! BSP stuff: Cherry DYE SUB TKL - PBT Blank full sets.
Post by: Elrick on Sun, 05 May 2013, 21:30:38
Just paid my Bill now.  Looking forward to some Cherry Goodness from you kboardvintage  ;) .

I use to spend heaps buying second hand 'crap conditioned' original dye-sub caps.  Now I want the REAL deal, meaning - new and perfect versions of these babies.
Title: Re: Last Day!! BSP stuff: Cherry DYE SUB TKL - PBT Blank full sets.
Post by: kboardvintage on Mon, 06 May 2013, 03:06:47
Are the F+J keys scoops or nubs?

They don't have deep dish molds anymore. They changed to standard ones...so no, no F&J deepdished  :'(
Title: Re: [CLOSED] BSP stuff: Cherry DYE SUB TKL - PBT Blank full sets.
Post by: kboardvintage on Wed, 08 May 2013, 00:42:46
Available unpaid orders.

If no one wants them I will be "stuck" with them...and to be sincere I cannot afford it right now.
Title: Re: [IN PRODUCTION] BSP DYE SUB CUSTOM COLORS - FEW sets LEFT!!
Post by: kboardvintage on Wed, 08 May 2013, 11:34:22
Order Paid.

Sets already in production! I will try to get pics next week (we have a long weekend here in Europe, atleast in DK and NL ^^)


Title: Re: [IN PRODUCTION] BSP DYE SUB CUSTOM COLORS - FEW sets LEFT!!
Post by: calavera on Wed, 08 May 2013, 11:55:09
I might take one red font set and one rgb set but not sure how the red fonts will look like so undecided.
Title: Re: [IN PRODUCTION] BSP DYE SUB CUSTOM COLORS - FEW sets LEFT!!
Post by: kboardvintage on Wed, 08 May 2013, 12:10:11
I might take one red font set and one rgb set but not sure how the red fonts will look like so undecided.

Well really red-ish! Cherry red font on beige&grey will definetly look awesome...
Title: Re: [IN PRODUCTION] BSP DYE SUB CUSTOM COLORS - FEW sets LEFT!!
Post by: yearn4 on Wed, 08 May 2013, 21:11:45
Do the f and j keys have scoop?
Title: Re: [IN PRODUCTION] BSP DYE SUB CUSTOM COLORS - FEW sets LEFT!!
Post by: Elrick on Wed, 08 May 2013, 21:48:11
Sets already in production! I will try to get pics next week (we have a long weekend here in Europe, atleast in DK and NL ^^)

Damn kboardvintage, you move faster than a Tokyo Express Train  ^-^ .

Looking forward to seeing the pictures next week.  Don't worry about long weekends just bust open a keg and enjoy the days.  Long weekends are made for drinking (especially here in Australia)  8) .
Title: Re: [IN PRODUCTION] BSP DYE SUB CUSTOM COLORS - FEW sets LEFT!!
Post by: kboardvintage on Thu, 09 May 2013, 00:55:57
Do the f and j keys have scoop?

No. BSP stopped using those molds long time ago  :'(
Title: Re: [IN PRODUCTION] BSP DYE SUB CUSTOM COLORS - FEW sets LEFT!!
Post by: Rendom on Thu, 09 May 2013, 00:57:51
95.60 euro per set?
Title: Re: [IN PRODUCTION] BSP DYE SUB CUSTOM COLORS - FEW sets LEFT!!
Post by: kboardvintage on Thu, 09 May 2013, 01:03:36
Sets already in production! I will try to get pics next week (we have a long weekend here in Europe, atleast in DK and NL ^^)

Damn kboardvintage, you move faster than a Tokyo Express Train  ^-^ .

Looking forward to seeing the pictures next week.  Don't worry about long weekends just bust open a keg and enjoy the days.  Long weekends are made for drinking (especially here in Australia)  8) .

BSP gave me just 4 days for this GB due to an open spot in their production...I had to react fast!
Now BSP is fully aware of the reactio capacity of this great community and we got their trust. 30 DYESUB sets, 12 Blank & 15 RGB sets in less than 3 days is quite remarkable, considering the steep price and lack of pictures!!
Thanks to those who made it happen :)
Title: Re: [IN PRODUCTION] BSP DYE SUB CUSTOM COLORS - FEW sets LEFT!!
Post by: Elrick on Thu, 09 May 2013, 01:17:11

BSP gave me just 4 days for this GB due to an open spot in their production...I had to react fast!

Thanks to those who made it happen :)

Hey, we are already use to FAST Group Buys here on Geekhack.  Because it's from BSP we just had to have them.  I personally want to examine each key-set made by various companies so that we know who has the BEST quality  ;) .
Title: Re: [IN PRODUCTION] BSP DYE SUB CUSTOM COLORS - FEW sets LEFT!!
Post by: sleepy916 on Sat, 18 May 2013, 05:32:25
Pictures please? ;]
Title: Re: [IN PRODUCTION] BSP DYE SUB CUSTOM COLORS - FEW sets LEFT!!
Post by: kboardvintage on Wed, 22 May 2013, 01:47:26
Pictures please? ;]

BSP's dyesub film supplier was slightly delayed. It is expected that the first sets will be done by the end of the week. Will keep you guys informed with more news as soon as I get any from BSP.
Title: Re: [IN PRODUCTION] BSP DYE SUB CUSTOM COLORS - FEW sets LEFT!!
Post by: Elrick on Wed, 22 May 2013, 05:45:45
It is expected that the first sets will be done by the end of the week. Will keep you guys informed with more news as soon as I get any from BSP.

Nice. looking forward to any potato pics on these babies.
Title: Re: [IN PRODUCTION] BSP DYE SUB CUSTOM COLORS - FEW sets LEFT!!
Post by: kboardvintage on Tue, 28 May 2013, 10:22:56
Well guys today I got a couple of pics of the BLACK sets (were the first sets done apparently). I requested pics of the rest of the sets. Hopefully I will get more pics tomorrow .

[attach=1]

[attach=2]
Title: Re: [IN PRODUCTION] BSP DYE SUB CUSTOM COLORS - FEW sets LEFT!!
Post by: Photekq on Tue, 28 May 2013, 10:32:35
Well guys today I got a couple of pics of the BLACK sets (were the first sets done apparently). I requested pics of the rest of the sets. Hopefully I will get more pics tomorrow .

(Attachment Link)

(Attachment Link)
This is making me wish I had listened to you when I had the money...
Title: Re: [IN PRODUCTION] BSP DYE SUB CUSTOM COLORS - FEW sets LEFT!!
Post by: codyeatworld on Tue, 28 May 2013, 10:43:09
Well guys today I got a couple of pics of the BLACK sets (were the first sets done apparently). I requested pics of the rest of the sets. Hopefully I will get more pics tomorrow .

(Attachment Link)

(Attachment Link)
This is making me wish I had listened to you when I had the money...

Same here!

Also just realized its PBT not ABS :O
Title: Re: [IN PRODUCTION] BSP DYE SUB - REAL PICS - Leftovers available!!!
Post by: sleepy916 on Tue, 28 May 2013, 17:06:23
Those look very nice!
Title: Re: [IN PRODUCTION] BSP DYE SUB - REAL PICS - Leftovers available!!!
Post by: boost on Tue, 28 May 2013, 19:07:26
Well guys today I got a couple of pics of the BLACK sets (were the first sets done apparently). I requested pics of the rest of the sets. Hopefully I will get more pics tomorrow .

(Attachment Link)

(Attachment Link)

Looks really nice...

No spacebar :(
Title: Re: [IN PRODUCTION] BSP DYE SUB - REAL PICS - Leftovers available!!!
Post by: demik on Tue, 28 May 2013, 21:09:15
why was my post deleted when i asked if you were making any kind of profit from this?

id still like an answer..
Title: Re: [IN PRODUCTION] BSP DYE SUB - REAL PICS - Leftovers available!!!
Post by: SmallFry on Tue, 28 May 2013, 22:40:09
:( I would presume they are making profit, but deleting posts sucks. I can attest to that.
Title: Re: [IN PRODUCTION] BSP DYE SUB - REAL PICS - Leftovers available!!!
Post by: kboardvintage on Wed, 29 May 2013, 01:46:31
why was my post deleted when i asked if you were making any kind of profit from this?

id still like an answer..

now i have to ask, it being a GB and all.. are you making a dime off this?

Well BSP is definetly making it...

I accept their proposal of getting limited sets and no MOQ / setup cost with the condition of paying a "premium".

I believe I already answered you...
Title: Re: [IN PRODUCTION] BSP DYE SUB - REAL PICS - Leftovers available!!!
Post by: kboardvintage on Wed, 29 May 2013, 03:24:12
Just got a pic of the blue set! Wow it looks amazing...

(http://i.imgur.com/Q5XYRZR.jpg?1)
Title: Re: [IN PRODUCTION] BSP DYE SUB - REAL PICS - Leftovers available!!!
Post by: kaiserreich on Wed, 29 May 2013, 03:26:58
Please show Red and Green.
My wallet says I can get another set :p
Title: Re: [IN PRODUCTION] BSP DYE SUB - REAL PICS - Leftovers available!!!
Post by: kboardvintage on Wed, 29 May 2013, 03:29:21
those are still in production :(
Title: Re: [IN PRODUCTION] BSP DYE SUB - REAL PICS - Leftovers available!!!
Post by: naokira on Wed, 29 May 2013, 15:23:47
I think greens would be epic! Too bad, no spare money for the leftovers :(
Title: Re: [IN PRODUCTION] BSP DYE SUB - REAL PICS - Leftovers available!!!
Post by: demik on Wed, 29 May 2013, 23:46:44
why was my post deleted when i asked if you were making any kind of profit from this?

id still like an answer..

now i have to ask, it being a GB and all.. are you making a dime off this?

Well BSP is definetly making it...

I accept their proposal of getting limited sets and no MOQ / setup cost with the condition of paying a "premium".

I believe I already answered you...

that doesnt answer my question..

i know BSP is making money. the question is, are you?
Title: Re: [IN PRODUCTION] BSP DYE SUB - REAL PICS - Leftovers available!!!
Post by: pmh1410 on Sun, 02 June 2013, 00:33:05
YGPM :)
Title: Re: [IN PRODUCTION] BSP DYE SUB - REAL PICS - Leftovers available!!!
Post by: tinlong117 on Sun, 02 June 2013, 03:48:15
why was my post deleted when i asked if you were making any kind of profit from this?

id still like an answer..

now i have to ask, it being a GB and all.. are you making a dime off this?

Well BSP is definetly making it...

I accept their proposal of getting limited sets and no MOQ / setup cost with the condition of paying a "premium".

I believe I already answered you...

that doesnt answer my question..

i know BSP is making money. the question is, are you?

I believe he did make profit.
Title: Re: [IN PRODUCTION] BSP DYE SUB - REAL PICS - Leftovers available!!!
Post by: zenuty on Sun, 02 June 2013, 11:11:13
it is my Cherry Olivetti DyeSub

KeyColor is more darkness
but BSP is More Brightness and White Color...

(http://i.imgur.com/7V47GYr.jpg)
Title: Re: [IN PRODUCTION] BSP DYE SUB - REAL PICS - Leftovers available!!!
Post by: pmh1410 on Mon, 03 June 2013, 02:47:42
Paied, pls re-confirm ?
Title: Re: [IN PRODUCTION] BSP DYE SUB - REAL PICS - Leftovers available!!!
Post by: Dianoda on Fri, 07 June 2013, 13:58:28
Any updates on production for these sets?  I'd love to see how the green turned out...
Title: Re: [IN PRODUCTION] BSP DYE SUB - REAL PICS - Leftovers available!!!
Post by: sleepy916 on Wed, 12 June 2013, 04:08:12
This thread needs an update.
Title: Re: [IN PRODUCTION] BSP DYE SUB - REAL PICS - Leftovers available!!!
Post by: Acetrak on Wed, 12 June 2013, 10:36:01
Agreed.
Title: Re: [IN PRODUCTION] BSP DYE SUB - REAL PICS - Leftovers available!!!
Post by: kaiserreich on Wed, 12 June 2013, 18:30:06
Sheraton just mentioned that the part number shown here is jumping on his own MOQ.
He has requested some orders to be cancelled.

I hope it isn't the case.
Title: Re: [IN PRODUCTION] BSP DYE SUB - REAL PICS - Leftovers available!!!
Post by: sleepy916 on Wed, 12 June 2013, 18:31:47
Yeah that was what I was worried about...
Title: Re: [IN PRODUCTION] BSP DYE SUB - REAL PICS - Leftovers available!!!
Post by: Acetrak on Wed, 12 June 2013, 21:02:38
Yeah same here, need some clarification here
Title: Re: [IN PRODUCTION] BSP DYE SUB - REAL PICS - Leftovers available!!!
Post by: jil_jil32 on Sat, 15 June 2013, 07:25:19
An update is needed!
Title: Re: [IN PRODUCTION] BSP DYE SUB - REAL PICS - Leftovers available!!!
Post by: sleepy916 on Sun, 16 June 2013, 01:10:30
It's almost been a week since he was on Geekhack.
Title: Re: [IN PRODUCTION] BSP DYE SUB - REAL PICS - Leftovers available!!!
Post by: kaiserreich on Sun, 16 June 2013, 03:09:20
Let's give him time.
Title: Re: [IN PRODUCTION] BSP DYE SUB - REAL PICS - Leftovers available!!!
Post by: heissler on Sun, 16 June 2013, 05:11:14
Willing to take a leftover blank set if still available!  :)
Title: Re: [IN PRODUCTION] BSP DYE SUB - REAL PICS - Leftovers available!!!
Post by: Photoelectric on Sun, 16 June 2013, 19:32:01
Sad about the lack of transparency from Kboardvintage about him encroaching on Sherryton's GB order.  Even the bagged set pictured here is labeled with Sherry's name, and this guy's not made any note about the conflict or talked about actual available numbers.  Seems rather shady.
Title: Re: [IN PRODUCTION] BSP DYE SUB - REAL PICS - Leftovers available!!!
Post by: kaiserreich on Mon, 17 June 2013, 04:46:28
While i did say we should wait, my payment was made on the 5th of May.
+45 days means I have another 1 or 2 days for the Paypal dispute window to close.

He has yet to respond here. Let me try his email/paypal email/eBay ID/phone num/deskthority ID....whatever method?


Will I be deemed a lesser being if i resort to paypal asking refunds for a Group Buy?
After what went on with 7bit's switch GB...people who do this might go to keyboard Hell.
Title: Re: [IN PRODUCTION] BSP DYE SUB - REAL PICS - Leftovers available!!!
Post by: Photekq on Mon, 17 June 2013, 05:22:19
While i did say we should wait, my payment was made on the 5th of May.
+45 days means I have another 1 or 2 days for the Paypal dispute window to close.

He has yet to respond here. Let me try his email/paypal email/eBay ID/phone num/deskthority ID....whatever method?


Will I be deemed a lesser being if i resort to paypal asking refunds for a Group Buy?
After what went on with 7bit's switch GB...people who do this might go to keyboard Hell.
There has been no response from the seller in a while and Sherry has said there's a large possibility this may be cancelled.

I'm by no means saying kboardvintage is a scammer as he has sold many items smoothly here but I think it's acceptable to dispute this.

You should also contact Sherry to see if he has any information before you dispute.
Title: Re: [IN PRODUCTION] BSP DYE SUB - REAL PICS - Leftovers available!!!
Post by: kaiserreich on Mon, 17 June 2013, 05:40:10
While i did say we should wait, my payment was made on the 5th of May.
+45 days means I have another 1 or 2 days for the Paypal dispute window to close.

He has yet to respond here. Let me try his email/paypal email/eBay ID/phone num/deskthority ID....whatever method?


Will I be deemed a lesser being if i resort to paypal asking refunds for a Group Buy?
After what went on with 7bit's switch GB...people who do this might go to keyboard Hell.
There has been no response from the seller in a while and Sherry has said there's a large possibility this may be cancelled.

I'm by no means saying kboardvintage is a scammer as he has sold many items smoothly here but I think it's acceptable to dispute this.

You should also contact Sherry to see if he has any information before you dispute.

I do not like to call anyone a scammer either, not without solid proof anyway.
Being a no show is not a solid proof at this stage. But it is a cause for concern, as some of the people who joined the GB are as well.

I have contacted sherryton and will see what he says.
Title: Re: [IN PRODUCTION] BSP DYE SUB - REAL PICS - Leftovers available!!!
Post by: pmh1410 on Mon, 17 June 2013, 09:55:47
here is his post from Deskthority, i really want to clear this problem because i was paied 2 sets for him:

http://deskthority.net/marketplace-f11/flash-gb-bsp-cherry-dye-sub-tkl-blank-2-tone-102cap-rgb-t5718.html

and here is his answer with limmy on KBD forum:

" id: Limmy

I don't like a sale without an actual picture of the item. Too risky. It is risky because it is unlikely that the person would take additional measures to correct any issues. You might end up funding prototypes.
실물이 없는 상태에서 품질에 대한 보증도 없이 판매를 하겠다는 건데 판매자가 불량품이나 기대에 못미치는 결과에 대해서 책임을 지지 않을 공산이 크기 때문에 상당히 위험한 구매같네요. 프로토 타입을 생산하는데 자금을 대주는 꼴이 될 수도 있을 것 같습니다.
Comment
2013.05.03 16:08:14 (*.138.227.11)


MinhaWinner

Dear Limmy,
This is a serious sale and a great opportunity to get unique stuff. Pictures are not available because the items are not in production.

I will take all the additional measures required to correct any issue due to the business agreements that I have with the supplier, and of course I will get all the required support from BSP in case of a faulty item.

Don't jeopardize my sale please.

Keyboardvintage ''
Title: Re: [IN PRODUCTION] BSP DYE SUB - REAL PICS - Leftovers available!!!
Post by: WhiteFireDragon on Mon, 17 June 2013, 14:18:03
It's very uncharacteristic of any GB leader to disappear like this, right after collecting payment. Reminds me of Profosist and Changdrew. According to Sherryton, he will pull the plug on this GB, so most likely this GB won't happen. Based on these two points, I would be concerned.

My personal opinion, is to file a paypal dispute. After you file the dispute, don't escalate it, but just let it sit. That way you have a few more weeks of buffer time, and can later decide to cancel the dispute or escalate it if Keyboardvintage decides to do some shady stuff. BUT, if you let the 45 days pass, nothing you can do. And even if this GB gets canceled and Keyboardvintage decides to refund, that is not possible. He'll have to "pay" back through a separate transaction, which will involve more paypal fees.
Title: Re: [IN PRODUCTION] BSP DYE SUB - REAL PICS - Leftovers available!!!
Post by: Dianoda on Mon, 17 June 2013, 15:56:25
It's very uncharacteristic of any GB leader to disappear like this, right after collecting payment. Reminds me of Profosist and Changdrew. According to Sherryton, he will pull the plug on this GB, so most likely this GB won't happen. Based on these two points, I would be concerned.

My personal opinion, is to file a paypal dispute. After you file the dispute, don't escalate it, but just let it sit. That way you have a few more weeks of buffer time, and can later decide to cancel the dispute or escalate it if Keyboardvintage decides to do some shady stuff. BUT, if you let the 45 days pass, nothing you can do. And even if this GB gets canceled and Keyboardvintage decides to refund, that is not possible. He'll have to "pay" back through a separate transaction, which will involve more paypal fees.

That sounds like a pretty reasonable course of action to me.  Anyone else want to comment?  I mean, I have 2 days before I hit the dispute limit, and would prefer not to file one, but if we don't hear anything from kboardvintage in the next few days, well...  given the choice, I think I'd prefer not to wave my chance of recovering the $150+ I paid for my order.
Title: Re: [IN PRODUCTION] BSP DYE SUB - REAL PICS - Leftovers available!!!
Post by: kboardvintage on Mon, 17 June 2013, 16:09:47
I am back after a week off and SURPRISE!!!!

Got an email from BSP stating the following:

"We will not be able to offer you these keysets, as other customer has paid us for setup charges and has placed their orders in accordance with our MOQ terms. These
customers have placed orders worth a lot of money, and we will support any customer's investments by making sure that we only sell these sets in accordance
with our standard terms. We will therefore only be able to make the exact same keysets to you, based on the MOQ 100 pcs terms."

It took them 1 month to tell me this?! I just ****ing requested for samples by May and I got offered the possibility of purchasing sets with a 85 keycaps and 4 different colour scheme...
Well to those who are concern about their money, I will start the refund once I get the money back from BSP, considering that they haven't refund me yet.

And about those who order BLANK sets, I haven't agreed yet on that, but I believe that I will be able to supply those, although I still have to confirm it tomorrow with BSP.

So guys, unless Sherry let us get this sets (19 dyesub in total), I can say that I won't fight against BSP and their decision, considering the fact that Sherry has been threatening them with cancelling the order (well 400 sets is kinda different than 19 :P).

Title: Re: [IN PRODUCTION] BSP DYE SUB - REAL PICS - Leftovers available!!!
Post by: jil_jil32 on Mon, 17 June 2013, 16:31:18
I recommend you should try to work it out with Sherryton in private and find a good way to resolve this unexpected problem. The sets are already made anyway.
Title: Re: [IN PRODUCTION] BSP DYE SUB - REAL PICS - Leftovers available!!!
Post by: kboardvintage on Mon, 17 June 2013, 16:37:15
I recommend you should try to work it out with Sherryton in private and find a good way to resolve this unexpected problem. The sets are already made anyway.


That is what I am trying...and your point is really clear. Sets are made already, including my "surplus". It is up to Sherry to keep this going or not...
Title: Re: [IN PRODUCTION] BSP DYE SUB - REAL PICS - Leftovers available!!!
Post by: Photoelectric on Mon, 17 June 2013, 16:40:59
Yes, but since this is originally his order, I'm surprised you didn't get in touch with him to start with.  Not much point to do 2 separate group buys for the same thing.  Combining efforts would have been more like the thing to do or transferring these orders to  Sherry's orders.  But this is definitely something you and Originative would need to discuss.  He's not posting here, and you're not posting in his thread, and it's just all weird :)
Title: Re: [IN PRODUCTION] BSP DYE SUB - REAL PICS - Leftovers available!!!
Post by: kboardvintage on Mon, 17 June 2013, 16:45:27
Yes, but since this is originally his order, I'm surprised you didn't get in touch with him to start with.  Not much point to do 2 separate group buys for the same thing.  Combining efforts would have been more like the thing to do or transferring these orders to  Sherry's orders.  But this is definitely something you and Originative would need to discuss.  He's not posting here, and you're not posting in his thread, and it's just all weird :)

I just posted on his thread mate. Plus you need to understand that I order based on what BSP offered me. I initially requested SAMPLES (so couple of keycaps) for professional purpose and I ended up with an offer of 85 keycaps sets and 4 DYESUB font colour... Well I guess this was a good chance to grab some DYESUB sets in unique colours! How should I know that it was Sherry's order??
Btw, I sent him a message and he didn't seem to be really up for negotiations. $$ rules his business, which seems totally understandable to me.
Title: Re: [IN PRODUCTION] BSP DYE SUB - REAL PICS - Leftovers available!!!
Post by: Photoelectric on Mon, 17 June 2013, 16:47:30
I just posted on his thread mate. Plus you need to understand that I order based on what BSP offered me. I initially requested SAMPLES (so couple of keycaps) for professional purpose and I ended up with an offer of 85 keycaps sets and 4 DYESUB font colour... Well I guess this was a good chance to grab some DYESUB sets in unique colours! How should I know that it was Sherry's order??
Btw, I sent him a message and he didn't seem to be really up for negotiations. $$ rules his business, which seems totally understandable to me.

My bad.  But it's great to see discussion here, since a lot of people  have been curious, and transparency is a good thing.

ETA: it appears it's BSP's fault, as Sherry said, but if the group buys were made in good faith (hopefully), I hope you guys can still work out how to combine the orders or switch these orders to Sherry's (if you're not making anything out of this yourself).
Title: Re: [IN PRODUCTION] BSP DYE SUB - REAL PICS - Leftovers available!!!
Post by: Elrick on Mon, 17 June 2013, 20:29:37
Btw, I sent him a message and he didn't seem to be really up for negotiations. $$ rules his business, which seems totally understandable to me.

Alright then so what happens with the money already paid by us?

If you do indeed want to end this amicably then please transfer the money over to Sherryton as soon as possible so that we the "customers" can finally own a BSP dye-sub set.

I understand that everything was a complete mistake and an innocent misunderstanding by you, but please don't make us suffer for it.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: calavera on Mon, 17 June 2013, 20:33:49
Once he gets a refund from BSP he said he would refund you guys. I think asking to transfer your orders to sherryton is asking too much.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Photoelectric on Mon, 17 June 2013, 20:35:01
Alright then so what happens with the money already paid by us?

If you do indeed want to end this amicably then please transfer the money over to Sherryton as soon as possible so that we the "customers" can finally own a BSP dye-sub set.

I understand that everything was a complete mistake and an innocent misunderstanding by you, but please don't make us suffer for it.

Well to those who are concern about their money, I will start the refund once I get the money back from BSP, considering that they haven't refund me yet.

And about those who order BLANK sets, I haven't agreed yet on that, but I believe that I will be able to supply those, although I still have to confirm it tomorrow with BSP.

So guys, unless Sherry let us get this sets (19 dyesub in total), I can say that I won't fight against BSP and their decision, considering the fact that Sherry has been threatening them with cancelling the order (well 400 sets is kinda different than 19 :P).

Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: kaiserreich on Mon, 17 June 2013, 20:35:23
I ordered the Blank sets.
Please let me know the soonest as the 45day limit is nea
If you cannot reach a consensus with BSP/Sheraton, please perform a full refund.

Sorry about you taking your time to organize this GB and it end up this way.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: guilleguillaume on Mon, 17 June 2013, 22:06:10
If you were ordering from BSP I don't understand why is Sherryton involved in anything.

Is he going to take down every GB we want to do? He is starting to be a pain in the ass.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Photekq on Mon, 17 June 2013, 22:09:22
If you were ordering from BSP I don't understand why is Sherryton involved in anything.

Is he going to take down every GB we want to do? He is starting to be a pain in the ass.
Sherry ordered these EXACT keysets. He paid for the very high MOQ and kboardvintage was allowed to join in on this without an MOQ. Understandably Sherry wasn't happy about this. Would you be happy if you had just paid for a high MOQ keyset and someone else was allowed to buy the same sets without an MOQ?
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Elrick on Mon, 17 June 2013, 22:10:02
Once he gets a refund from BSP he said he would refund you guys. I think asking to transfer your orders to sherryton is asking too much.

Yep, because this is BSP a registered business in Germany I suspect they will make payment refunds in about 3 to 6 months time.  All businesses hold onto capital for the legal amount of time which is way longer than necessary.

Here in Australia, they can hold onto refunds till 6 months (minimum) before making payments simply because the money helps to shore up their financial situation if they are currently in deficit between certain expenditures, with any given month.  I had to wait 8 months to get a payment sent back to me due to a company that dropped supplying the product I had ordered.

Hence I suspect I'll need again to fork out more money for Sherryton's BSP key caps because I doubt he'll wait 6 months for any payments to be made.

This has certainly opened my eyes up to NO more participating in Flash Group Buys any more.  Just isn't safe and the organizer can just walk away without giving any certainty simply because it's not their problem anymore.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: tsangan on Mon, 17 June 2013, 22:18:55
I recommend you should try to work it out with Sherryton in private and find a good way to resolve this unexpected problem. The sets are already made anyway.


That is what I am trying...and your point is really clear. Sets are made already, including my "surplus". It is up to Sherry to keep this going or not...

So as I have posted in Sherry's subforum. Don't make it sound like Sherry is the bad guy here, he is offering the _same price_ as you for the sets (yes I understand sherry has no blanks) but yet he has to spend thousands of dollars to place this order. So lets take a minute and soak that in you did not invest in any of this and selling it at the _same price_ as what sherry is offering to the public

That makes a whole lot of sense
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Elrick on Mon, 17 June 2013, 22:41:03
Sorry I had to do a Paypal Call-back on this.  Simply because I paid on the 6th of May and it's still within the time frame for Paypal to conduct a refund.

Hence anyone else who has paid up front please go to paypal and do it because as soon as their time period lapses you have no way of ever getting your money back.  This is what happens when a "Cancelled" Group Buy is announced, everyone should do their legal 'thing' in getting back their money.

Thank god for having Paypal here.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Dianoda on Mon, 17 June 2013, 22:47:48
Sorry I had to do a Paypal Call-back on this.  Simply because I paid on the 6th of May and it's still within the time frame for Paypal to conduct a refund.

Hence anyone else who has paid up front please go to paypal and do it because as soon as their time period lapses you have no way of ever getting your money back.  This is what happens when a "Cancelled" Group Buy is announced, everyone should do their legal 'thing' in getting back their money.

Thank god for having Paypal here.

Doing that screws over kboardvintage - BSP hasn't sent a refund to him yet.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Elrick on Mon, 17 June 2013, 23:04:11
Doing that screws over kboardvintage - BSP hasn't sent a refund to him yet.

If you announce that a Group Buy has been cancelled then my only concern is to get back my money.  If indeed BSP has all the money then he can wait for the FULL refund into his own back account.  So no worries there about being out of pocket.

So nothing has been lost in regards to us the customers who have paid in the first place.  Remember all bets are off when a Group Buy collapses, because everyone has the right to get their own money back by any LEGAL means possible.

Sorry but that is how it works when you conduct a Group Buy that collapses, hence everyone has the right to their own money.  Customers should never have to suffer the long ordeal of begging for their own money from a failed Group Buy.

It's not my cause to bare the full collapse of this Group Buy because of other influences, which has nothing to do with me whatsoever.  I am just re-acting to a very bad situation within a very tight time period set down by Paypal and kboardvintage.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: alixinhzai on Tue, 18 June 2013, 01:22:08
and where's my money? where's my keycap? :(
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: kaiserreich on Tue, 18 June 2013, 01:29:55
Sherryton informed me that blank orders are cancelled as well.

This is BSP conducting funny deals.
If all of us did not lurk at the same section of the internet, the company might have got away with it. We wouldn't even know.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: sleepy916 on Wed, 19 June 2013, 15:35:59
As long as everybody gets their money back then no harm no foul.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Acetrak on Mon, 24 June 2013, 12:54:32
hey kbdvintage, any updates?
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: demik on Mon, 24 June 2013, 19:04:57
If you were ordering from BSP I don't understand why is Sherryton involved in anything.

Is he going to take down every GB we want to do? He is starting to be a pain in the ass.

nobody is forcing you to not purchase from BSP.

you have 2 choices, take the risk and pay for the MOQ, or do your own GB until you reach MOQ.

you really think it's fair for sherry to take the risk and reach the MOQ so somebody else can ride his order?
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: pmh1410 on Mon, 24 June 2013, 22:20:57
kbdvintage, pls update information of your GB. i still wait your update but i can't patience a longtime. Maybe i must to dispute on Paypal for moneyback.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: alixinhzai on Tue, 25 June 2013, 06:52:28
Cancel and we lose all money and keycap? Lol
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Acanthophis on Thu, 27 June 2013, 07:43:15
Yep, update should be made.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Bencze on Thu, 27 June 2013, 08:16:05
I had some interest in BSP, was glads to see european keycap maker... but I'm not sure what is happening here...

Big fish found out that Small fish also ordered at same price so Big fish is pissed off and blackmails company to cancel Small fish' orders? Is this what happened?
Is it safe to assume that Bsp and this Sherryton guy are to be avoided?
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: BimboBB on Thu, 27 June 2013, 11:26:44
BSP I dont know...in my opinion they can sell their products like they want. If they have a current order from someone with a huge MOQ, they can offer other people same time a smaller quantity but based on this MOQ/production run. I dont see any problem with that. Especially when we are talking about 19 sets or something.  :rolleyes:

Sherryton, I avoid long time already. This just another case showing his very selfish attitude. There would be different and better ways for all involved to handle that case and he just went for the worst one (again).


Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Topre on Thu, 27 June 2013, 13:01:12
BSP I dont know...in my opinion they can sell their products like they want. If they have a current order from someone with a huge MOQ, they can offer other people same time a smaller quantity but based on this MOQ/production run. I dont see any problem with that. Especially when we are talking about 19 sets or something.  :rolleyes:

Sherryton, I avoid long time already. This just another case showing his very selfish attitude. There would be different and better ways for all involved to handle that case and he just went for the worst one (again).

MOQ should not be spread through a group of people, unless if all parties agree to it. It makes no sense that one party has to buy at least 100 sets (not sure how many Sherry needs) and he pays for that 100, but the supplier allows another group of people to join it for only 20 sets. That's like me hopping onto Microsoft's Surface Pro production line and just buying 100 of them. Microsoft would not like it because their MOQ that they have to pay for is much higher than just 100. The supplier (BSP) is the only greedy and selfish person here, BSP should not have even allowed people to hop on another person's order. It is obvious that they are willing to make and sell keycap sets with a lower MOQ, but refuse to give that privilege to everyone.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: BimboBB on Thu, 27 June 2013, 14:14:47
I thought as a company you can sell yr products as you want. If they want to sell it in a groupbuy way, they can do that. You describe it as someone who hits a MOQ has an exclusive right for the product. What if BSP decides to prodcue 50% more of the actual MOQ and put them on their own stock? Its not allowed according yr definition. MOQ just means minimum order quantity...not maximum order quantity. For BSP its just important to make this actual prodcution run profitable, thats why they have a MOQ. If the MOQ is reached they can produce how many units they want on top and selling them on whoever is interested unless somebody has an exclusive right on exactly that product.

Anyway, just seeing Sherryton fighting over such marginal amount of a few sets and even declaring he doesnt want to have exclusive right (lol) is enough to confirm my personal opinion about this guy (....useful like a hole in the head!).
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Acanthophis on Thu, 27 June 2013, 14:28:48
We don't know facts, so speculating won't do any good.

It could also be, that BSP is like "Oh well, we are not moving a finger (or our machines) unless our MOQ of x is met. When MOQ of x is met, we don't care who buys the sets or how many parties are involved in buying our sets, just as long as we get our money."

I don't think they much care if there is a second, smaller party, because MOQ is already met, might as well produce 20 more sets. The machines are running anyway.
I can understand Sherry might feel to be stepped on his toes, and thus his interference (cancellation) with this GB.

But I will never buy my GB-ordered set at Sherry's store. I don't like his business/GB attitude and his shop itself.


But again, all this talking won't bring us any further.
Main concern is: What's up with our money? AFAIK payment to BSP went out. So, did they already make the sets? If so, is Sherry forcing BSP to not hand them over to us? Or do we get them after all? Are you, kboardvintage in contact with Sherry and working on a solution?

I don't care how this ends. All I care is that at the end of the day, I either have my money back or my ordered keycaps.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Topre on Thu, 27 June 2013, 14:36:08
I thought as a company you can sell yr products as you want. If they want to sell it in a groupbuy way, they can do that. You describe it as someone who hits a MOQ has an exclusive right for the product. What if BSP decides to prodcue 50% more of the actual MOQ and put them on their own stock? Its not allowed according yr definition. MOQ just means minimum order quantity...not maximum order quantity. For BSP its just important to make this actual prodcution run profitable, thats why they have a MOQ. If the MOQ is reached they can produce how many units they want on top and selling them on whoever is interested unless somebody has an exclusive right on exactly that product.

Anyway, just seeing Sherryton fighting over such marginal amount of a few sets and even declaring he doesnt want to have exclusive right (lol) is enough to confirm my personal opinion about this guy (....useful like a hole in the head!).

Yes, as a company you can sell your products however you want. But it is unethical to tell two groups of people different numbers for minimum order quantity, which is why I'm calling BSP selfish. Again, I don't know how many sets Sherryton had to buy, but 20 sets compared to his order is still probably a lot. Assuming he did have to buy 100 sets, 20 sets is 20% of how much he is ordering. If he only had to buy 50 sets, then 20 sets is 40% of his order. What if Sherry only wanted to buy 50 sets, but because of the MOQ he had to buy 100? It's not cool that another group of people are allowed to get the same sets (any maybe for the same price) for way less than the quoted MOQ. It is very true that BSP can sell the keycaps by themselves. But they don't, that's why people need to order directly from them, and that's why there is a MOQ. I'm sure that Sherryton does not have any exclusive rights and if someone meets the amount quoted from BSP then he has no rights in saying that the person can not order.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: ApocalypseMaow on Thu, 27 June 2013, 14:43:05
I thought as a company you can sell yr products as you want. If they want to sell it in a groupbuy way, they can do that. You describe it as someone who hits a MOQ has an exclusive right for the product. What if BSP decides to prodcue 50% more of the actual MOQ and put them on their own stock? Its not allowed according yr definition. MOQ just means minimum order quantity...not maximum order quantity. For BSP its just important to make this actual prodcution run profitable, thats why they have a MOQ. If the MOQ is reached they can produce how many units they want on top and selling them on whoever is interested unless somebody has an exclusive right on exactly that product.

Anyway, just seeing Sherryton fighting over such marginal amount of a few sets and even declaring he doesnt want to have exclusive right (lol) is enough to confirm my personal opinion about this guy (....useful like a hole in the head!).
You wouldn't have been able to get the keys in the first place, if it wasn't for Sherry paying the MOQ! BSP would have never made them and I know damn well Vintage isn't coughing up the money to have them made. Hell, he won't even respond to people wanting their money back! lol

Not to mention if anyone of you pissing and moaning about this was trying to make a living selling these keys and someone jumped on your coat tails to make a quick buck. I do believe you'd lose your **** too! If you want those keys SO BAD, why not buy them from the man that put the effort and huge chunk of cash up to get them made.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: BimboBB on Thu, 27 June 2013, 15:14:46
We don't know facts, so speculating won't do any good.

It could also be, that BSP is like "Oh well, we are not moving a finger (or our machines) unless our MOQ of x is met. When MOQ of x is met, we don't care who buys the sets or how many parties are involved in buying our sets, just as long as we get our money."

I guess thats exactly the way BSP is thinking. And its quite normal. If you look at big online stores like eg. mouser....its the same principal. If they are out of stock they are requesting a certain MOQ to get the product in. If the MOQ is reached (by whomever) they order on top and stock it themselves and selling it for the MOQ unit price (plus a few percent for themselves). If you want everybody to hit the MOQ like "Topre" is suggesting....yeah...have fun to ever get yr desired components.

You wouldn't have been able to get the keys in the first place, if it wasn't for Sherry paying the MOQ! BSP would have never made them and I know damn well Vintage isn't coughing up the money to have them made. Hell, he won't even respond to people wanting their money back! lol

Thanks god, Sherryton is the leading example in responding well when it comes to certain problems. lol...you guys forget quick.

Not to mention if anyone of you pissing and moaning about this was trying to make a living selling these keys and someone jumped on your coat tails to make a quick buck. I do believe you'd lose your **** too! If you want those keys SO BAD, why not buy them from the man that put the effort and huge chunk of cash up to get them made.

No thanks. As long as we have cool dudes around who are not making a living out of re-selling kecaps, but still organizing GB's and as long as we have vendors like techkeys who are working with the community instead against...I will not support this guy. I wish he would get some other job he could make a living of....honestly.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: demik on Thu, 27 June 2013, 15:59:06
We don't know facts, so speculating won't do any good.

It could also be, that BSP is like "Oh well, we are not moving a finger (or our machines) unless our MOQ of x is met. When MOQ of x is met, we don't care who buys the sets or how many parties are involved in buying our sets, just as long as we get our money."

I guess thats exactly the way BSP is thinking. And its quite normal. If you look at big online stores like eg. mouser....its the same principal. If they are out of stock they are requesting a certain MOQ to get the product in. If the MOQ is reached (by whomever) they order on top and stock it themselves and selling it for the MOQ unit price (plus a few percent for themselves). If you want everybody to hit the MOQ like "Topre" is suggesting....yeah...have fun to ever get yr desired components.

You wouldn't have been able to get the keys in the first place, if it wasn't for Sherry paying the MOQ! BSP would have never made them and I know damn well Vintage isn't coughing up the money to have them made. Hell, he won't even respond to people wanting their money back! lol

Thanks god, Sherryton is the leading example in responding well when it comes to certain problems. lol...you guys forget quick.

Not to mention if anyone of you pissing and moaning about this was trying to make a living selling these keys and someone jumped on your coat tails to make a quick buck. I do believe you'd lose your **** too! If you want those keys SO BAD, why not buy them from the man that put the effort and huge chunk of cash up to get them made.

No thanks. As long as we have cool dudes around who are not making a living out of re-selling kecaps, but still organizing GB's and as long as we have vendors like techkeys who are working with the community instead against...I will not support this guy. I wish he would get some other job he could make a living of....honestly.

oh shut the **** up.

you're obviously already voting with your wallet, why are you going to sit here and **** on somebody else's business because you couldn't get what you want?

please stay in deskthority where everybody feels holier than thou.

BSP ****ed up, sherry called them on it. BSP know they ****ed up or else they wouldn't have canceled OP's order.

OP was also making money off this GB and failed to address it. But **** it right, only Sherry is the bad guy here.

and FYI, every vendor makes money, the whole "working with the community" crap is a bunch of bull.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Topre on Thu, 27 June 2013, 16:06:47
We don't know facts, so speculating won't do any good.

It could also be, that BSP is like "Oh well, we are not moving a finger (or our machines) unless our MOQ of x is met. When MOQ of x is met, we don't care who buys the sets or how many parties are involved in buying our sets, just as long as we get our money."

I guess thats exactly the way BSP is thinking. And its quite normal. If you look at big online stores like eg. mouser....its the same principal. If they are out of stock they are requesting a certain MOQ to get the product in. If the MOQ is reached (by whomever) they order on top and stock it themselves and selling it for the MOQ unit price (plus a few percent for themselves). If you want everybody to hit the MOQ like "Topre" is suggesting....yeah...have fun to ever get yr desired components.


Yes, Mouser doesn't order extra stock until they hit the minimum PRE-order number. That is basically preordering something and not getting it until enough people orders. What you are saying is basically Mouser should sell all their products at the cheapest MOQ. For example Mouser selling a Cherry MX switch for $0.468 each when you need to order 500 of those to get that price. Why bother having a MOQ if you are going to sell that many switches sooner or later? MOQ is not a preorder number. Also the way Mouser works is fine because everyone buying it knows that they are pitching in to be part of that minimum pre-order number, which is basically a groupbuy organized by Mouser.

It's like a possible consumer calling up Signature Plastics and telling them they want to hop on Keypop's coffee set, and they would like to order 10 of those sets. Signature Plastics would be making the caps anyway right? If I was Keypop, I would hope that Signature Plastics told that consumer to **** off. This example may be over exaggerated because Keypop designed the keys themselves, but it's the same concept.

Let's say BSP's minimum order quantity was 100 and you guys hit 80. The last 20 more orders takes you a year to get. Then Sherryton just calls up BSP and tells them that he wants 20 sets of keycaps (and they agree). That means 120 sets in total. But then because the groupbuy took so long to organize, you now only have 90 orders because some people decided they don't want the set anymore. This not including Sherryton's 20 sets. Sherryton is not joining your group buy and BSP tells you that your groupbuy need 100 sets to be ordered in order for them to produce it for you. You only have 90 orders so that means you can not complete the order from BSP. That is why it is unethical for a company to let another person hop on to the MOQ.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: sleepy916 on Thu, 27 June 2013, 16:09:18
Refund update?
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: ApocalypseMaow on Thu, 27 June 2013, 16:14:44
Refund update?
Don't hold your breath.

As for Bimbo... Yeah, Sherry ****ed up but all I've seen from him since then is keeping people up to date. Which was the main problem in the first place. I guess your still butt hurt about that huh?

Bimbo, you just don't get it... No one running GBs has to fork out loads of cash to start one. It cost nothing but time to start a GB, maybe tooling cost every know and then. Nine times outta ten that is added to the cost of the set or the OP pays it. Lets talk about that cost... $300 is what DrugER payed for some tooling on DSA Dolch, PLEASE compare that to Sherry Paying $50 to $60 a set at 400 MOQ! GTFO Bimbo!


Demik made a real solid point too, Vintage was selling this kit $10 less then Sherry? Oh look at the savings!!!  :rolleyes:

Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: sleepy916 on Thu, 27 June 2013, 16:26:53
Refund update?
Don't hold your breath.

Yes, thank you space marine cat.  :(
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: BimboBB on Thu, 27 June 2013, 16:27:38
hello demik  ;D

i am sure you never get my point...either not being able or just not willing.

i never wrote anything against "making money". i am moaning only about the way "making money". some vendors doing it right and some not. thats everything and only my personal opinion. if you dont agree and insisting that Sherry is the good guy who is doing everything right......cool.

but if anyone asks about sherryton I will always write down my view on it. especially here on GH, as on DT, i assume, most people are well aware.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: demik on Thu, 27 June 2013, 16:31:20
but yet, nobody asked you your opinion about sherryton.

unless i missed that part.

nope, i dont remembering reading "hey bimbobb, what do you think about sherryton" anywhere on this page, or last.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: demik on Thu, 27 June 2013, 16:35:48
I had some interest in BSP, was glads to see european keycap maker... but I'm not sure what is happening here...

Big fish found out that Small fish also ordered at same price so Big fish is pissed off and blackmails company to cancel Small fish' orders? Is this what happened?
Is it safe to assume that Bsp and this Sherryton guy are to be avoided?

blackmailed? where are you getting your information?

im sure sherryton contacted BSP about this. and BSP knew they were in the wrong and cancelled the order themselves.

if they didn't feel it was wrong, they would have told sherryton to suck it up and have gone through with it.

some of you dudes act like sherryton slept with your mothers.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: ApocalypseMaow on Thu, 27 June 2013, 16:47:04
Refund update?
Don't hold your breath.

Yes, thank you space marine cat.  :(
Sorry to be so blunt... Space Marine Cats have no feelings...

Last thing Bimbo. Good thing Vintage is sooooo cool and such a great GB organizer. Logged on today and failed to inform anyone about what is going on with $1600+ of GHs money he (or BSP) has.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Photekq on Thu, 27 June 2013, 16:48:22
To those wondering where their money has gone check the OP. He posted an update on the 25th.

Imo what Sherry did was just. He is running a business. He paid the large sum for the large MOQ and it's fair enough he wasn't happy about BSP allowing someone to jump on the MOQ.
Kboardvintage did nothing wrong either. He simply took an opportunity that BSP gave him.
BSP was in the wrong. They shouldn't have allowed kboardvintage to jump on the MOQ.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Dianoda on Thu, 27 June 2013, 17:03:07
To those wondering where their money has gone check the OP. He posted an update on the 25th.

Good call, totally missed that.  Thanks.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: IPT on Thu, 27 June 2013, 17:21:14
Nice guy the op is. Its not like the item numbers on these sets have sherrytons name on them or anything. Also when asked if he was gonna make $$, no response. But hey its cool to **** of sherryton instead.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: BimboBB on Thu, 27 June 2013, 17:38:15
Guys yr order/money is frozen because only one guy ****ed it up. And its not kbvintage nor BSP. Its a matter of fact sofar. If you keep on defending that dude, I cannot help you....sorry...because thats just out my understanding. Also its a beautiful example what happens if you get to serious/greedy with yr re-selling business. Everyone is ****ed up in the end....YEAH....but seems a few people here like that very much. hilarious it is. :blank:
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: IPT on Thu, 27 June 2013, 17:41:38
sorry you're so much better than us.
please teach us in your superior ways.
Anything to get mine right?  screw others and morals.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: demik on Thu, 27 June 2013, 18:13:37
Guys yr order/money is frozen because only one guy ****ed it up. And its not kbvintage nor BSP. Its a matter of fact sofar. If you keep on defending that dude, I cannot help you....sorry...because thats just out my understanding. Also its a beautiful example what happens if you get to serious/greedy with yr re-selling business. Everyone is ****ed up in the end....YEAH....but seems a few people here like that very much. hilarious it is. :blank:

you truly are stupid, aren't you?
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Acanthophis on Thu, 27 June 2013, 18:50:09
I, too, totally missed the update in the OP. Thanks Photekq for pointing that out.

Well, I'm curious how this GB will continue.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: sleepy916 on Tue, 02 July 2013, 07:51:38
BSP sure takes a long time to refund somebody.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: kaiserreich on Tue, 02 July 2013, 08:07:01
That's cause vintage is still asking BSP to honor the sale.

BSP F-ed up royally this time.
Sherry is in the right. Vintage is kinda in the right.
BSP thought nobody would know.
If BSP honors the agreement with Vintage, they might out of a lot of money.
If BSP honors the prior agreement with Sherry, they might be in some legal quandry depending on how Vintage is going to pursue this.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: sleepy916 on Tue, 02 July 2013, 08:14:50
But they already said they were going to cancel over 2 weeks ago. I know Vintage is trying to get the blank sets through so that may be what is holding it back.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Acetrak on Tue, 02 July 2013, 08:19:44
His explanation/update in the OP last week sounds like he's still trying to get BSP to honor the original purchase.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: IPT on Tue, 02 July 2013, 10:22:14
while saying FU to sherryton.
classy
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: litster on Wed, 03 July 2013, 03:18:02
Just  caught up with this thread. 

Signature Plastics has tiered pricing, not exactly MOQ.  But SP has never tried to let one order to get to a cheaper price tier and let another smaller order come in for the same goods for the same lower-tiered pricing.  BSP is in the wrong here.  Don't set MOQ if you don't mean it for everyone.  If it wasn't for Sherryton ordering up the MOQ and putting his money in to bring us these dye sub caps, you guys would still be paying $300+ for a set of Cherry dye sub.

You people who appear to have a problem with Sherryton, you are missing out the new genuine Cherry keycaps he has to offer.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: BimboBB on Wed, 03 July 2013, 03:46:15
Update 17/06
GB (almost) CANCELLED; Trying to agree with Sherry that 19 key sets won't hurt his business more than shutting down a GroupBuy @ GH.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: litster on Wed, 03 July 2013, 03:52:09
your point is?
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: ApocalypseMaow on Wed, 03 July 2013, 04:07:32
your point is?
Don't waste your time lister! Bimbo is still hellbent on demonizing Sherry.  :rolleyes:
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: BimboBB on Wed, 03 July 2013, 04:15:04
Just hope that this GB turns out good for everybody involved (by rather getting their money back or getting the ordered keys). Anybody can make his own mind about the roles of certain people involved.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: litster on Wed, 03 July 2013, 04:26:59
Sure, I hope people get their money back.  You can blame Paypal for that, or kboardvintage's inexperience in running group buys using Paypal. 

Bimbo and kboardvintage, put yourself in Sherryton's shoes, what would you do?  I would absolutely do the same as what Sherryton did.  If I invested tens of thousands of dollars to buy up to MOQ, and them someone else come in and bought just 19 sets for the same per-set price that I paid for ordering up to MOQ, you'd be sure I would be talking to BSP and ask them WTF.  And to see someone else post a picture of what I ordered, with my fxxking name on it? 

If you think that is OK, why don't you buy up to MOQ, and then announce it here so we all can call BSP and start our mini group buys?  Maybe I should just email BSP to ask them what they are currently making and I will just order a few sets and then flip them here on GH.  Would that be OK with you Bimbo?
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: BimboBB on Wed, 03 July 2013, 04:28:56
Maybe I should just email BSP to ask them what they are currently making and I will just order a few sets and then flip them here on GH.  Would that be OK with you Bimbo?

Thats actually a very interesting idea.....absolutely fine with me. Let us know the outcome.

Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: litster on Wed, 03 July 2013, 04:31:22
Bimbo, you should do it, since you think it is OK.  And since you think it is fine, you are a bigger idiot than I thought you were.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: ApocalypseMaow on Wed, 03 July 2013, 04:33:27
Maybe I should just email BSP to ask them what they are currently making and I will just order a few sets and then flip them here on GH.  Would that be OK with you Bimbo?

Thats actually a very interesting idea.....absolutely fine with me. Let us know the outcome.
It's got to be said! Bimbo, you're a total ****ing scumbag
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: BimboBB on Wed, 03 July 2013, 04:47:28
I dont see any problem if there is a big industrial order (for an airport or parliament or whatever) and some keyboard freaks ordering a few sets on top of that. If that makes me a scumbag....so I am. And if it makes me a scumbag when I am of the opinion that this GB dilemma could have been handled in a different way by certain people.....than iam guilty as well.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: ApocalypseMaow on Wed, 03 July 2013, 05:23:44
I dont see any problem if there is a big industrial order (for an airport or parliament or whatever) and some keyboard freaks ordering a few sets on top of that. If that makes me a scumbag....so I am. And if it makes me a scumbag when I am of the opinion that this GB dilemma could have been handled in a different way by certain people.....than iam guilty as well.
But it's not an airline or parliament! This is one of are own, trying to bring truly hard to find keys to everyone. So he makes a couple bucks off of us, not a big deal.

Knowing a little about retail, I'm sure Sherry isn't making more than $20 a set on all those keys. Not to mention, how many sets do you really think he is selling?

Come on!
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: sleepy916 on Wed, 03 July 2013, 07:23:24
As I'm only speaking for myself, I would like kboardvintage to just stop trying to convince BSP to continue with the group buy. I don't think they are going to budge on their stand. So the people with their money in limbo can get on with it and get the refund.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: IPT on Wed, 03 July 2013, 11:20:55
I dont see any problem if there is a big industrial order (for an airport or parliament or whatever) and some keyboard freaks ordering a few sets on top of that. If that makes me a scumbag....so I am. And if it makes me a scumbag when I am of the opinion that this GB dilemma could have been handled in a different way by certain people.....than iam guilty as well.
But it's not an airline or parliament! This is one of are own, trying to bring truly hard to find keys to everyone. So he makes a couple bucks off of us, not a big deal.

Knowing a little about retail, I'm sure Sherry isn't making more than $20 a set on all those keys. Not to mention, how many sets do you really think he is selling?

Come on!


save your breath, sherryton's always in the wrong with him
bias will blind him from the facts.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: mbc on Thu, 04 July 2013, 05:26:35
I have to say, that this whole thing appears to be a giant cluster****, with all ppl involved.
BSP not being true to their word
Sherry claiming possession over something he doesn't have
The organiser being unable to resolve the issue with the participants
And the participants filing paypal disputes knowing this would only worsen everything

What a shame
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: sleepy916 on Thu, 04 July 2013, 05:33:52
I have to say, that this whole thing appears to be a giant cluster****, with all ppl involved.
BSP not being true to their word
Sherry claiming possession over something he doesn't have
The organiser being unable to resolve the issue with the participants
And the participants filing paypal disputes knowing this would only worsen everything

What a shame

It is a shame, I didn't dispute with paypal, I was hoping things would work out. I wonder about if his account is suspended, would the refund be able to go back into paypal? I'm not sure if the OP paid directly through them or not.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: WhiteFireDragon on Thu, 04 July 2013, 05:54:31
Assuming you guys will all get your refunds eventually, it certainly won't be the full amount. It's past paypal's refund time frame, which means kboardvintage will have to make refund payments on a different transactions. He can't refund the initial paypal fees. For fairness, the question is who will take the hit on this second paypal fee on the refund payment.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: IPT on Thu, 04 July 2013, 07:53:39
I have to say, that this whole thing appears to be a giant cluster****, with all ppl involved.
BSP not being true to their word
Sherry claiming possession over something he doesn't have
The organiser being unable to resolve the issue with the participants
And the participants filing paypal disputes knowing this would only worsen everything

What a shame
sorry but sherryton does have possession over it. If he didn't BSP wouldn't have cancelled the orders. Also if you look at the model identifiers for the keys it has his name in it lol.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Acetrak on Thu, 04 July 2013, 08:18:13
My impression was Sherry made an order for X amount, reaching MOQ. BSP started producing and when vintage approached BSP about samples, he was offered the same items being produced. BSP then modify X to X+19 to accommodate for the new total. Sherry seeing this unfair treatment by BSP (no/lower MOQ for vintage) and contacted them about it. Obviously I don't know what he said, but I'm under the impression it's something like "Don't sell those sets or I demand a refund on all of my orders" to hold enough weight that BSP went back on their transaction with vintage, after the keycaps were paid for already.

I'm pretty sure the thing with Sherry's name is just the order code, something to identify the items. So yes it was his order, but it wasn't Sherry's items in the sense that he ordered those 19 sets. It's not like BSP took sets from Sherry and sold them to vintage. They simply produced more of the same items, hence why options were limited and the only different item offered at the time were blank sets.

The above is my impression based on the whole ordeal, no I do not have proof to back up what I'm saying, this is just my speculation.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: damorgue on Thu, 04 July 2013, 08:40:11
I find it weird that BSP recalled keyboardvintage's order at all unless Sherry paid to have his order exclusive beforehand.

For instance, when I order things at work we always pay an extra fee so that the items are exclusive and under NDA. Otherwise they could make our pats to others, distribute our drawings, create knockoffs etc. I find it hard to believe Sherry ordered this and if so, BSP is doing it purely out of good will to Sherry. They are more likely to want the entity who made the large order to be happy rather than break the contract of the smaller order. They honoured something they in no way had to honour unless specified, and instead cancelled the other order. Was there any specification on the invoice regarding cancellations keyboardvintage? You should be able to get compensation out of that if it.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: litster on Thu, 04 July 2013, 09:40:00
How the FXXK do you do business if you tell one customer you have to meet MOQ and then tell another one customer he doesn't need to?  HOW?  BSP sets the rules and they need to enforce and honor it.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: whiskerBox on Thu, 04 July 2013, 09:52:52
Wow this is weird. So if I was sherry I would demand that BSP not let another person piggy back on my MOQ. Just saying its business and no one else was willing to put up the money. Sherry has done a lot to bring many cool things to the community and invested his own money. So we repay him by cutting him out of loop on his own order lol.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Photoelectric on Thu, 04 July 2013, 09:57:03
I don't understand why people toss around such strong statements, like someone is repaying someone bad for good and all that.  It's not like this was done with a malicious intent.  Where small communities are involved, I think it'd be better to work together on this where such a situation arises.  The real victims here are the people who paid to get dye sub PBT sets by BSP and are now out of money and without a clear perspective.  And perhaps kboardvintage if he's going to lose money on this too.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: IPT on Thu, 04 July 2013, 17:13:52
I don't understand why people toss around such strong statements, like someone is repaying someone bad for good and all that.  It's not like this was done with a malicious intent.  Where small communities are involved, I think it'd be better to work together on this where such a situation arises.  The real victims here are the people who paid to get dye sub PBT sets by BSP and are now out of money and without a clear perspective.  And perhaps kboardvintage if he's going to lose money on this too.

I find it weird that BSP recalled keyboardvintage's order at all unless Sherry paid to have his order exclusive beforehand.

For instance, when I order things at work we always pay an extra fee so that the items are exclusive and under NDA. Otherwise they could make our pats to others, distribute our drawings, create knockoffs etc. I find it hard to believe Sherry ordered this and if so, BSP is doing it purely out of good will to Sherry. They are more likely to want the entity who made the large order to be happy rather than break the contract of the smaller order. They honoured something they in no way had to honour unless specified, and instead cancelled the other order. Was there any specification on the invoice regarding cancellations keyboardvintage? You should be able to get compensation out of that if it.

There seems to be 2 separate things going on:
1.  Keyboardvintage's order wouldn't have existed without Sherryton's initial MOQ order.
As a business, if i paid to produce the said item, and someone piggy backs on my order, you'll be sure i'd be upset.
BSP screwed up and tried to sell a product line that someone else put into order.
Sherryton found out and instead of losing his MOQ order which he has every right to cancel, they cancelled keyboardvintage's order.

2.  People are now upset that their $$ is held up.  This is keyboardvintage trying to negotiate with BSP to authorize the order.
BSP already said they were going to cancel his order, he's trying to get them to honor it.
This is what's holding up the $$ side on refunds.  He's still trying to get this GB to be processed, so he hasn't formally asked BSP to refund the $$ as shown from his post:
Quote
So for those who want their  money back asap, I cannot do anything about this. I understand your position but the money is still at BSP's hands. I am trying to keep this GB going, because WE have the right to get what we purchased. They do not have the right to cancel an order based on NOTHING, although some would argue this was sherry whatsoever, well they offered me a product, I purchase it, end of the discussion about jumping on others MOQ, I didn't ask for that, I initially request for samples.. .
As the Contract of Sales of goods states (under the european normative, this is a clear breach of contract, and so far I am trying to persuade them that what they are doing is not legit.

Again i don't know exactly how the court system handles these types of things in Europe, but if OP's going to go after BSP legally, I'd predict this would take a long ass time to settle.
Also the amount of $$ talked about in this situation for the US Legal system would be handled in Small Claims court if that. 
Does OP deserve some compensation from BSP for them ****ing up?  Absolutely. 
And it looks like BSP is trying to do that with this:
Quote
About the blank orders, I do not know why Sherry keeps saying that those would be cancelled. So Sherry, please, do not keep screwing up things here. The blank sets are NOT canceled. Actually BSP is trying to send me the Blank + RGB blank with 1 set of each color (DYESUB sets) which is not acceptable for me, because is not what I purchased.
So it looks like BSP is trying to correct the problem with the Blank orders that seem to be able to go through, and giving OP a set of each dyesub color.
I assume they will refund the other purchase $$.

Is OP directing his anger at the wrong person?  I think so. 
Could OP handle this a bit better instead of attacking sherryton?  I'd say yes, but he decided instead to attack sherryton.
Quote
Conclusion: Sherry, u are giving me a HUGE headache with this situation, and I really hope that u can have a lovely bath with your 400sets. Plus the MOQ stated by BSP was a big bull**** (yes, I got quotations for 25, 50 and 100 MOQ ;), deal with it :D)

Btw for those who are arguing that MOQ shouldn't matter, the additional orders shouldn't make a difference, I have to ask you why do you think SP doesn't sell our GB item orders directly to other people?  Why doesn't SP overproduce some sets and sell them from their store?  Why doesn't SP sell the keys that are on sale from techkeys or keypop?  Don't let your personal bias with sherryton blind you on the fact that BSP made this error, its up to them to fix it.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: litster on Thu, 04 July 2013, 19:14:20
ProjectD is a good man and a smart man.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: kboardvintage on Fri, 05 July 2013, 06:40:08
OP updated.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: The_Beast on Fri, 05 July 2013, 11:54:20
ProjectD is a good man and a smart man.

2x


Whatever personal beef you have with sherry doesn't apply (he's not a perfect businessman, however, he's gotten better). Simply ask yourself, if you were in sherry's shoes, what would you have done? I would have done the same
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: tricheboars on Fri, 05 July 2013, 12:01:28
ProjectD is a good man and a smart man.

2x


Whatever personal beef you have with sherry doesn't apply (he's not a perfect businessman, however, he's gotten better). Simply ask yourself, if you were in sherry's shoes, what would you have done? I would have done the same

i wouldnt have only because i would rather this community love me as a business man rather than squeeze every penny.  but in reality BSP is the bad guy in this case, not Sherry.  IF they promised something they should follow through, even if they screwed up.  They messed up the MOQ.

now if SHERRY owned the legends to these sets that would be a different situation.

i asked myself this:  would |3oilermaker have done this? i doubt it... i dont know for a fact but that would be my guess.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: IPT on Fri, 05 July 2013, 12:10:09
ProjectD is a good man and a smart man.

2x


Whatever personal beef you have with sherry doesn't apply (he's not a perfect businessman, however, he's gotten better). Simply ask yourself, if you were in sherry's shoes, what would you have done? I would have done the same

i asked myself this:  would |3oilermaker have done this? i doubt it... i dont know for a fact but that would be my guess.

i love techkeys as much as the next guy, but has techkeys ordered a full keyboard set by themselves??
I think the TMNT set is the 1st one he's doing, and he turned that into a GB to offset some of the cost.
the fullsets he sells are ones he buys off the various GBs.

different situations, hard to say how someone will act.
but if a 400 MOQ order at say 80 a set (im guessing), that's $32,000 we're talking about here.
if i dropped $32K on an order you're damn sure i'd make sure im the only one who should have the rights to sell it.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: litster on Fri, 05 July 2013, 12:13:51
I asked myself this: if <insert any name> spent tens of thousands dollars of his or her own money on an order with BSP to meet the BSP-imposed MOQ, would <insert same name here> have contacted BSP to ask them WTF and ask them to fix the fxxkup they created?  I bet your ass that he or she would.  I don't know for a fact but that would be my guess.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: mashby on Fri, 05 July 2013, 12:19:02

I asked myself this: if <insert any name> spent tens of thousands dollars of his or her own money on an order with BSP to meet the BSP-imposed MOQ, would <insert same name here> have contacted BSP to ask them WTF and ask them to fix the fxxkup they created?  I bet your ass that he or she would.  I don't know for a fact but that would be my guess.

You better believe that's a paddlin'!
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Topre on Fri, 05 July 2013, 14:09:27
I asked myself this: if <insert any name> spent tens of thousands dollars of his or her own money on an order with BSP to meet the BSP-imposed MOQ, would <insert same name here> have contacted BSP to ask them WTF and ask them to fix the fxxkup they created?  I bet your ass that he or she would.  I don't know for a fact but that would be my guess.

Nope, I would have cancelled my order on the spot. No second chance for that big of a **** up.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Photekq on Fri, 05 July 2013, 14:10:56
I asked myself this: if <insert any name> spent tens of thousands dollars of his or her own money on an order with BSP to meet the BSP-imposed MOQ, would <insert same name here> have contacted BSP to ask them WTF and ask them to fix the fxxkup they created?  I bet your ass that he or she would.  I don't know for a fact but that would be my guess.

Nope, I would have cancelled my order on the spot. No second chance for that big of a **** up.
I don't think you would've. BSP have some of the most desired keycaps in the world. It's not as if Sherry could've just gone to another company and got the same keycaps. BSP is the one and only source - if he wants the keycaps he must do business with them even if they do **** up.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Topre on Fri, 05 July 2013, 14:13:46
I asked myself this: if <insert any name> spent tens of thousands dollars of his or her own money on an order with BSP to meet the BSP-imposed MOQ, would <insert same name here> have contacted BSP to ask them WTF and ask them to fix the fxxkup they created?  I bet your ass that he or she would.  I don't know for a fact but that would be my guess.

Nope, I would have cancelled my order on the spot. No second chance for that big of a **** up.
I don't think you would've. BSP have some of the most desired keycaps in the world. It's not as if Sherry could've just gone to another company and got the same keycaps. BSP is the one and only source - if he wants the keycaps he must do business with them even if they do **** up.

Actually, I would have. I care about ethics more than money. Also, how much money can Sherry be making by selling keycaps? I'm sure 400 sets will take over a year to sell. There are much faster ways to make profits if he is actually looking for money.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Photekq on Fri, 05 July 2013, 14:16:20
Actually, I would have. I care about ethics more than money. Also, how much money can Sherry be making by selling keycaps? I'm sure 400 sets will take over a year to sell. There are much faster ways to make profits if he is actually looking for money.
Well in that case you'd fail to deliver what the customer wants. Sometimes you have to tolerate mistakes, even if they are larges ones, in order to gain a superior product.

If Sherry wasn't making a good profit do you think he'd pour money into these high MOQs?
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Topre on Fri, 05 July 2013, 14:23:24
Well in that case you'd fail to deliver what the customer wants. Sometimes you have to tolerate mistakes, even if they are larges ones, in order to gain a superior product.

If Sherry wasn't making a good profit do you think he'd pour money into these high MOQs?

I don't doubt he will be making good profits. But it will take a while before he breaks even and start making profit. I don't own any keycap companies so I don't know exactly how many he would sell. But he is selling more than one set of keycaps anyway, so it's not like that is his only product he needs to get rid of. At $95 (not sure about this), how long will it take him to sell enough sets and break even? After he sells everything his profits won't be more than three quarters of what he spent. There are much faster ways to earn money if he was actually looking to.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Cafiend on Fri, 05 July 2013, 14:44:59
Vendors/hobbyist salespersons need to keep in touch with their buyers.

 I know we all have a million things going on like life,work and selling keycaps. But if you want that 2nd "hobby" business to work you better be ready for ridicule. And its good customer service to keep us informed.

If you can't handle a second business or side job then DON'T DO IT!

This is just an observation from a newb getting used to group buys.

But i build boats and do HVAC on the side so i know when i'm over my head. Some vendors don't.






Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: litster on Fri, 05 July 2013, 15:30:15
I asked myself this: if <insert any name> spent tens of thousands dollars of his or her own money on an order with BSP to meet the BSP-imposed MOQ, would <insert same name here> have contacted BSP to ask them WTF and ask them to fix the fxxkup they created?  I bet your ass that he or she would.  I don't know for a fact but that would be my guess.

Nope, I would have cancelled my order on the spot. No second chance for that big of a **** up.
I don't think you would've. BSP have some of the most desired keycaps in the world. It's not as if Sherry could've just gone to another company and got the same keycaps. BSP is the one and only source - if he wants the keycaps he must do business with them even if they do **** up.

Actually, I would have. I care about ethics more than money. Also, how much money can Sherry be making by selling keycaps? I'm sure 400 sets will take over a year to sell. There are much faster ways to make profits if he is actually looking for money.

Well in that case you'd fail to deliver what the customer wants. Sometimes you have to tolerate mistakes, even if they are larges ones, in order to gain a superior product.

If Sherry wasn't making a good profit do you think he'd pour money into these high MOQs?

I don't doubt he will be making good profits. But it will take a while before he breaks even and start making profit. I don't own any keycap companies so I don't know exactly how many he would sell. But he is selling more than one set of keycaps anyway, so it's not like that is his only product he needs to get rid of. At $95 (not sure about this), how long will it take him to sell enough sets and break even? After he sells everything his profits won't be more than three quarters of what he spent. There are much faster ways to earn money if he was actually looking to.

Topre, it is pretty obvious from your posts that you have no idea what you are talking about.  What's so unethical being done here?  You would have canceled your order if you were Sherryton?  How funny! 

"oh crap, I paid BSP tens of thousands of dollars to order up to MOQ that BSP requires for any order, and then someone else rides my order's coattail and don't have to order up to MOQ, I must now cancel my big order because that is the ethical thing to do."  Yes, that makes soooooo much sense.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: litster on Fri, 05 July 2013, 15:31:52
Vendors/hobbyist salespersons need to keep in touch with their buyers.

 I know we all have a million things going on like life,work and selling keycaps. But if you want that 2nd "hobby" business to work you better be ready for ridicule. And its good customer service to keep us informed.

If you can't handle a second business or side job then DON'T DO IT!

This is just an observation from a newb getting used to group buys.

But i build boats and do HVAC on the side so i know when i'm over my head. Some vendors don't.

Who are you referring to? 

Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Topre on Fri, 05 July 2013, 15:33:59
I asked myself this: if <insert any name> spent tens of thousands dollars of his or her own money on an order with BSP to meet the BSP-imposed MOQ, would <insert same name here> have contacted BSP to ask them WTF and ask them to fix the fxxkup they created?  I bet your ass that he or she would.  I don't know for a fact but that would be my guess.

Nope, I would have cancelled my order on the spot. No second chance for that big of a **** up.
I don't think you would've. BSP have some of the most desired keycaps in the world. It's not as if Sherry could've just gone to another company and got the same keycaps. BSP is the one and only source - if he wants the keycaps he must do business with them even if they do **** up.

Actually, I would have. I care about ethics more than money. Also, how much money can Sherry be making by selling keycaps? I'm sure 400 sets will take over a year to sell. There are much faster ways to make profits if he is actually looking for money.

Well in that case you'd fail to deliver what the customer wants. Sometimes you have to tolerate mistakes, even if they are larges ones, in order to gain a superior product.

If Sherry wasn't making a good profit do you think he'd pour money into these high MOQs?

I don't doubt he will be making good profits. But it will take a while before he breaks even and start making profit. I don't own any keycap companies so I don't know exactly how many he would sell. But he is selling more than one set of keycaps anyway, so it's not like that is his only product he needs to get rid of. At $95 (not sure about this), how long will it take him to sell enough sets and break even? After he sells everything his profits won't be more than three quarters of what he spent. There are much faster ways to earn money if he was actually looking to.

Topre, it is pretty obvious from your posts that you have no idea what you are talking about.  What's so unethical being done here?  You would have canceled your order if you were Sherryton?  How funny! 

"oh crap, I paid BSP tens of thousands of dollars to order up to MOQ that BSP requires for any order, and then someone else rides my order's coattail and don't have to order up to MOQ, I must now cancel my big order because that is the ethical thing to do."  Yes, that makes soooooo much sense.

How is what BSP did not unethical? They are telling two people different numbers for MOQ. Everyone should be following the same MOQ, but yet they are doing this for greed. They wanted to make a few extra bucks so they tell one person that there is no MOQ and he is fine to order what ever he likes.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: litster on Fri, 05 July 2013, 15:46:21
I asked myself this: if <insert any name> spent tens of thousands dollars of his or her  own money on an order with BSP to meet the BSP-imposed MOQ, would <insert same name here> have contacted BSP to ask them WTF and ask them to fix the fxxkup they created?  I bet your ass that he or she  would.  I don't know for a fact but that would be my guess.

Nope, I would have cancelled my order on the spot. No second chance for that big of a **** up.
I don't think you would've. BSP have some of the most desired keycaps in the world. It's not as if Sherry could've just gone to another company and got the same keycaps. BSP is the one and only source - if he wants the keycaps he must do business with them even if they do **** up.

Actually, I would have. I care about ethics more than money. Also, how much money can Sherry be making by selling keycaps? I'm sure 400 sets will take over a year to sell. There are much faster ways to make profits if he is actually looking for money.

Well in that case you'd fail to deliver what the customer wants. Sometimes you have to tolerate mistakes, even if they are larges ones, in order to gain a superior product.

If Sherry wasn't making a good profit do you think he'd pour money into these high MOQs?

I don't doubt he will be making good profits. But it will take a while before he breaks even and start making profit. I don't own any keycap companies so I don't know exactly how many he would sell. But he is selling more than one set of keycaps anyway, so it's not like that is his only product he needs to get rid of. At $95 (not sure about this), how long will it take him to sell enough sets and break even? After he sells everything his profits won't be more than three quarters of what he spent. There are much faster ways to earn money if he was actually looking to.

Topre, it is pretty obvious from your posts that you have no idea what you are talking about.  What's so unethical being done here?  You would have canceled your order if you were Sherryton?  How funny! 

"oh crap, I paid BSP tens of thousands of dollars to order up to MOQ that BSP requires for any order, and then someone else rides my order's coattail and don't have to order up to MOQ, I must now cancel my big order because that is the ethical thing to do."  Yes, that makes soooooo much sense.

How is what BSP did not unethical? They are telling two people different numbers for MOQ. Everyone should be following the same MOQ, but yet they are doing this for greed. They wanted to make a few extra bucks so they tell one person that there is no MOQ and he is fine to order what ever he likes.

Topre, you really don't have a clue what you are talking about.  You have all the subjects mixed up.  Re-read what you posted.  Made the font larger for you in case you don't find what you said that contradicts yourself.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Topre on Fri, 05 July 2013, 15:58:47
I asked myself this: if <insert any name> spent tens of thousands dollars of his or her  own money on an order with BSP to meet the BSP-imposed MOQ, would <insert same name here> have contacted BSP to ask them WTF and ask them to fix the fxxkup they created?  I bet your ass that he or she  would.  I don't know for a fact but that would be my guess.

Nope, I would have cancelled my order on the spot. No second chance for that big of a **** up.
I don't think you would've. BSP have some of the most desired keycaps in the world. It's not as if Sherry could've just gone to another company and got the same keycaps. BSP is the one and only source - if he wants the keycaps he must do business with them even if they do **** up.

Actually, I would have. I care about ethics more than money. Also, how much money can Sherry be making by selling keycaps? I'm sure 400 sets will take over a year to sell. There are much faster ways to make profits if he is actually looking for money.

Well in that case you'd fail to deliver what the customer wants. Sometimes you have to tolerate mistakes, even if they are larges ones, in order to gain a superior product.

If Sherry wasn't making a good profit do you think he'd pour money into these high MOQs?

I don't doubt he will be making good profits. But it will take a while before he breaks even and start making profit. I don't own any keycap companies so I don't know exactly how many he would sell. But he is selling more than one set of keycaps anyway, so it's not like that is his only product he needs to get rid of. At $95 (not sure about this), how long will it take him to sell enough sets and break even? After he sells everything his profits won't be more than three quarters of what he spent. There are much faster ways to earn money if he was actually looking to.

Topre, it is pretty obvious from your posts that you have no idea what you are talking about.  What's so unethical being done here?  You would have canceled your order if you were Sherryton?  How funny! 

"oh crap, I paid BSP tens of thousands of dollars to order up to MOQ that BSP requires for any order, and then someone else rides my order's coattail and don't have to order up to MOQ, I must now cancel my big order because that is the ethical thing to do."  Yes, that makes soooooo much sense.

How is what BSP did not unethical? They are telling two people different numbers for MOQ. Everyone should be following the same MOQ, but yet they are doing this for greed. They wanted to make a few extra bucks so they tell one person that there is no MOQ and he is fine to order what ever he likes.

Topre, you really don't have a clue what you are talking about.  You have all the subjects mixed up.  Re-read what you posted.  Made the font larger for you in case you don't find what you said that contradicts yourself.

I'm reading, can you make it bigger? Anyway I guess I made it confusing about what I was talking about. If I was Sherryton, I would have cancelled my orders because I prefer to not work with an unethical company.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: litster on Fri, 05 July 2013, 16:31:49
I'm reading, can you make it bigger? Anyway I guess I made it confusing about what I was talking about.

Or you have no idea what you are talking about and doing an about face now.

If I was Sherryton, I would have cancelled my orders because I prefer to not work with an unethical company.


Right.  Because it makes soooooo much sense:

"oh crap, I paid BSP tens of thousands of dollars to order up to MOQ that BSP requires for any order, and then someone else rides my order's coattail and don't have to order up to MOQ, I must now cancel my big order because BSP screws.  I must now ask for a refund for what I already ordered, lose money on exchange rate both ways, lose money on return shipping, and send all the goods I received from BSP back, like nothing happened."

You are so smart.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Topre on Fri, 05 July 2013, 16:46:27
I'm reading, can you make it bigger? Anyway I guess I made it confusing about what I was talking about.

Or you have no idea what you are talking about and doing an about face now.

If I was Sherryton, I would have cancelled my orders because I prefer to not work with an unethical company.


Right.  Because it makes soooooo much sense:

"oh crap, I paid BSP tens of thousands of dollars to order up to MOQ that BSP requires for any order, and then someone else rides my order's coattail and don't have to order up to MOQ, I must now cancel my big order because BSP screws.  I must now ask for a refund for what I already ordered, lose money on exchange rate both ways, lose money on return shipping, and send all the goods I received from BSP back, like nothing happened."

You are so smart.

I never really did an about-face. I been ****ting on BSP since page 6.

I don't think BSP shipped the stuff to Sherryton at the time he found out that they were sharing the same production thing. I wouldn't mind losing a bit on exchange rate, but there is nothing to be lost from shipping. If the stuff was already shipped, then that would have been my last business deal with BSP.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Acanthophis on Sat, 13 July 2013, 11:38:50
Any news/updates?
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: IPT on Sat, 13 July 2013, 20:53:27
Any news/updates?

his update in the OP on 7/5:

Quote
About BSP, the people responsible of dealing with my order are now on holidays (as they just told me via phone) and will be back somewhere end of July. I have already request a full refund, but apparently within the "backup" team left, no accountant is present...so SURPRISE, your money is still at BSP's hands, at least until August.

I will be off on holidays for the becoming 3 weeks, but I will connect once in awhile to update here, if necessary.

So 3 weeks i'd say end of july for any news
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: demik on Sun, 14 July 2013, 00:51:14
Quote
i asked myself this:  would |3oilermaker have done this? i doubt it... i dont know for a fact but that would be my guess.

lol, lets not act like boiler is a saint.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: zenuty on Mon, 15 July 2013, 02:34:49
How i can refund money ?  :(

G.B go to the Refund Prograss ?

Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Acetrak on Tue, 23 July 2013, 12:47:52
any word on refunds?
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: alixinhzai on Mon, 05 August 2013, 18:58:30
And now Aug, any update Vintage?
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: sleepy916 on Fri, 09 August 2013, 05:40:05
I'm hoping for some good news soon...
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: feng on Fri, 09 August 2013, 09:14:07
Still waiting for refund..
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: sleepy916 on Tue, 13 August 2013, 09:18:41
An update is needed.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Photoelectric on Tue, 13 August 2013, 09:25:13
He's not logged in since July 5th.  Doesn't seem to be actively resolving the situation.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: SpAmRaY on Tue, 13 August 2013, 09:36:58
He's not logged in since July 5th.  Doesn't seem to be actively resolving the situation.

Wonder if is ' 3 week holiday' was extended??  ???
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Photekq on Tue, 13 August 2013, 11:58:34
He's not logged in since July 5th.  Doesn't seem to be actively resolving the situation.
There probably still isn't anything he can do. BSP are most likely still holding the money.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: berserkfan on Tue, 13 August 2013, 12:41:38
I"m terribly sorry to see a group buy practically totally destroyed like that. I feel deeply sorry for all parties involved. Still, I think it was a mistake to rush too quickly into this group buy. There are probably some communication and other errors along the way leading to nothing getting done.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: sleepy916 on Sun, 18 August 2013, 18:07:36
This is one long vacation he is taking...
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: sleepy916 on Tue, 20 August 2013, 22:25:49
I emailed him, hopefully he responds.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: sleepy916 on Tue, 27 August 2013, 18:08:14
Well, 3 emails later, and a big fat nothing.

I guess most people got their money back from paypal earlier. Those who held out like me, trusting the OP are SOL it seems.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: meiosis on Tue, 27 August 2013, 18:49:21
Well, 3 emails later, and a big fat nothing.

I guess most people got their money back from paypal earlier. Those who held out like me, trusting the OP are SOL it seems.

Sadly it seemed he got balled by paypal and in the front page he said to start a chargeback and he'd take the hit as a "scammer" they locked his account and everything, maybe you can call paypal
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Acetrak on Tue, 27 August 2013, 19:36:09
Well, 3 emails later, and a big fat nothing.

I guess most people got their money back from paypal earlier. Those who held out like me, trusting the OP are SOL it seems.
I feel your pain sleepy :\
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Acanthophis on Tue, 27 August 2013, 21:04:26
Oh well, what should I do then? I paid via bank transfer :/
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: sleepy916 on Tue, 27 August 2013, 21:35:49
Well, 3 emails later, and a big fat nothing.

I guess most people got their money back from paypal earlier. Those who held out like me, trusting the OP are SOL it seems.
I feel your pain sleepy :\

This and the Prof's GB is why I'm not going to do any more groupbuys anytime soon.

Oh well, what should I do then? I paid via bank transfer :/

We can be SOL together.  :p
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: meiosis on Tue, 27 August 2013, 22:38:37
Well, 3 emails later, and a big fat nothing.

I guess most people got their money back from paypal earlier. Those who held out like me, trusting the OP are SOL it seems.
I feel your pain sleepy :\

This and the Prof's GB is why I'm not going to do any more groupbuys anytime soon.

Oh well, what should I do then? I paid via bank transfer :/

We can be SOL together.  :p

You were in profs too? :\ I joined like during the time he decided to go silent
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: sleepy916 on Wed, 28 August 2013, 02:27:40

You were in profs too? :\ I joined like during the time he decided to go silent

Yes, thankfully I didnt have nearly as much put into the Prof's GB. A QFR and some assembly services. 
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: The_Beast on Wed, 28 August 2013, 02:38:01
Note to self: Don't join GBs sleepy916 is also in...


hahha :D
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: meiosis on Wed, 28 August 2013, 04:23:11
Note to self: Don't join GBs sleepy916 is also in...


hahha :D

What if he joins a group buy you are hosting :D
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: sleepy916 on Wed, 28 August 2013, 22:59:48

Note to self: Don't join GBs sleepy916 is also in...


hahha :D

What if he joins a group buy you are hosting :D

I am the groupbuy killer! My last GB was the DSA Dolch so whoever is on that beware!
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: The_Beast on Wed, 28 August 2013, 23:10:15
Note to self: Don't join GBs sleepy916 is also in...


hahha :D

What if he joins a group buy you are hosting :D

Well, shiiiiii

:)
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: zenuty on Sat, 31 August 2013, 01:10:33
I hope earlly this g.b refund  :blank:
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: alixinhzai on Sat, 31 August 2013, 10:12:13
I hope earlly this g.b refund  :blank:

lol, I hope too :3 let hope we lucky bro :D
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: kaiserreich on Mon, 16 September 2013, 01:47:18
I paid using paypal but has not seen a cent being refunded.
How to do a chargeback?
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Lu_e on Mon, 16 September 2013, 11:59:28
You have to contact paypal.

Pretty funny this guy complains about people locking his account and getting it flagged.... Yet disappears with no updates or communication. (Thanks)

Like, what did you expect? Seeing as this is how you treat customers. (Thanks)
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: berrymxblue on Mon, 16 September 2013, 23:55:37
Well, 3 emails later, and a big fat nothing.

I guess most people got their money back from paypal earlier. Those who held out like me, trusting the OP are SOL it seems.
I feel your pain sleepy :\

This and the Prof's GB is why I'm not going to do any more groupbuys anytime soon.

Oh well, what should I do then? I paid via bank transfer :/

We can be SOL together.  :p

What happened to the Prof's GB?
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: demik on Tue, 17 September 2013, 00:20:17
Well, 3 emails later, and a big fat nothing.

I guess most people got their money back from paypal earlier. Those who held out like me, trusting the OP are SOL it seems.
I feel your pain sleepy :\

This and the Prof's GB is why I'm not going to do any more groupbuys anytime soon.

Oh well, what should I do then? I paid via bank transfer :/

We can be SOL together.  :p

What happened to the Prof's GB?

whole lot of nothing also.

dude basically vanished. and when people were asking for him in his thread he threw a hissy fit and said he wasn't going to reply to PMs/post in the thread.

IIRC.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: zenuty on Mon, 23 September 2013, 20:20:48
Please Start to Refund.

Time was passed a long time.
I was wait 4 month over.

No answer, No update
How i can refund from G.B organizer ?

Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: kaiserreich on Mon, 23 September 2013, 23:50:42
You have to contact paypal.

Pretty funny this guy complains about people locking his account and getting it flagged.... Yet disappears with no updates or communication. (Thanks)

Like, what did you expect? Seeing as this is how you treat customers. (Thanks)

The dispute has been closed as the time limit has passed.
Paypal will tell me to F-off.

If I do a chargeback, paypal is not going to like me.
Seeing how paypal is the more common way to pay for stuff around here, that's going to cause me more trouble.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: IPT on Tue, 24 September 2013, 00:05:43
your OP hasn't signed into GH since Fri, 05 July 2013, 06:39:49

Pretty much GG on getting your $$ back.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: feng on Tue, 24 September 2013, 00:18:45
More than $500 is just gone like that... ? Oh my....
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Photoelectric on Tue, 24 September 2013, 00:21:17
There has to be some way to deal with this.  Maybe combine the efforts of your financial institutions and PayPal?  Consult both on how it could be done.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: piraterice on Tue, 24 September 2013, 05:57:53
THERE IS NO WAY TO FIGURE OUT WHETHER THE HOST OF THIS GB HAD RAN AWAY WITH ALL OUR MONEY.....
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: sleepy916 on Tue, 24 September 2013, 06:05:26
I've emailed him many times through his the email that is connected with his paypal. I've still have yet to receive a reply.

I think the time which you can go and file a dispute is 45 days. We are well over that so the chances of us getting our money back is nonexistent. I just think of it as a expensive lesson learned.  :mad:
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: litster on Tue, 24 September 2013, 10:20:16
Well, there should be a policy here on GH that you can't start a group buy if you have less than 500 posts *AND* have not been a member for more than 6 months.

But there isn't such policy here.  And this has happened multiple times.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: phetto on Tue, 24 September 2013, 10:25:36
As you say, there have to be some sort of rules here. Post count doesnt work, I have seen way to many spammers lately.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: TLSC.wipeOut on Tue, 24 September 2013, 10:26:15
Well, there should be a policy here on GH that you can't start a group buy if you have less than 500 posts *AND* have not been a member for more than 6 months.

But there isn't such policy here.  And this has happened multiple times.

I second this motion!
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: litster on Tue, 24 September 2013, 10:30:23
As you say, there have to be some sort of rules here. Post count doesnt work, I have seen way to many spammers lately.

Look for the "AND" in my post.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Photoelectric on Tue, 24 September 2013, 10:31:45
Well, there should be a policy here on GH that you can't start a group buy if you have less than 500 posts *AND* have not been a member for more than 6 months.

But there isn't such policy here.  And this has happened multiple times.

Nothing is stopping people from realizing that they can't handle a group buy they got themselves into running.  That can happen at any number of posts.  Look at the Prof's situation or recently Bavman's (Phantom PCB GB).  There've been plenty of successful group buys by people with fewer posts than you've listed.  It's all on a case-by-case basis.  We can exclude the team Red Line subforum and Keypop, then if we want 500-post minimum, etc.  Many vendors and people running group buys don't post that much otherwise.  Some are generally quiet but still reliable. 

There's no easy solution to this problem, other than exercising caution and making personal judgements whether to get involved and how much money you're prepared to lose.  Risk vs. Benefit.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: phetto on Tue, 24 September 2013, 10:32:59
Yes I saw that, litster. I just wanted to point out that I think the same. :)
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: BunnyLake on Tue, 24 September 2013, 10:39:12
Well, there should be a policy here on GH that you can't start a group buy if you have less than 500 posts *AND* have not been a member for more than 6 months.

But there isn't such policy here.  And this has happened multiple times.

Nothing is stopping people from realizing that they can't handle a group buy they got themselves into running.  That can happen at any number of posts.  Look at the Prof's situation or recently Bavman's (Phantom PCB GB).  There've been plenty of successful group buys by people with fewer posts than you've listed.  It's all on a case-by-case basis.  We can exclude the team Red Line subforum and Keypop, then if we want 500-post minimum, etc.  Many vendors and people running group buys don't post that much otherwise.  Some are generally quiet but still reliable. 

There's no easy solution to this problem, other than exercising caution and making personal judgements whether to get involved and how much money you're prepared to lose.  Risk vs. Benefit.

+ 1
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: litster on Tue, 24 September 2013, 10:40:48
For people who has a vendor subforum, GH's admins explicitly approve them to have a subforum.  And vendors are vendors, they are for profit.  GBs are not supposed to be for profit. 

If you are new and you want to start a group buy, the policy should require the GB to have another member who qualifies to be part of the GB, to cosign it.  It is true that you can't stop someone who is really set out to scam.  A set policies do weed out jerks like this so-called group buy organizer, people who think they could run a group buy but run away when something goes wrong.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: IPT on Tue, 24 September 2013, 10:54:17
Well, there should be a policy here on GH that you can't start a group buy if you have less than 500 posts *AND* have not been a member for more than 6 months.

But there isn't such policy here.  And this has happened multiple times.

Nothing is stopping people from realizing that they can't handle a group buy they got themselves into running.  That can happen at any number of posts.  Look at the Prof's situation or recently Bavman's (Phantom PCB GB).  There've been plenty of successful group buys by people with fewer posts than you've listed.  It's all on a case-by-case basis.  We can exclude the team Red Line subforum and Keypop, then if we want 500-post minimum, etc.  Many vendors and people running group buys don't post that much otherwise.  Some are generally quiet but still reliable. 

There's no easy solution to this problem, other than exercising caution and making personal judgements whether to get involved and how much money you're prepared to lose.  Risk vs. Benefit.

+ 1

lets just be honest, we'll make Bunny do all GBs =)
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: piraterice on Fri, 27 September 2013, 06:34:48
I think we all would like to get ur caps rather than get ur money back,but the disapearance of the GB host was a great attack on me.i have took part in 2 gbs,one is the diablo 3 caps started by sherryton who have also been disaprearing for months and finally come to send ur caps,the other one is this bsp gb,and the starter of it just disapeared again.....Is there anybody of gh could ask the starters of gb to pay some money for insurance and when their gbs ended succesfully,the money they have paid will be back to the starters...i think it a good rule for them.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: damorgue on Fri, 27 September 2013, 13:03:46
Is there anybody of gh could ask the starters of gb to pay some money for insurance and when their gbs ended succesfully,the money they have paid will be back to the starters...i think it a good rule for them.

How much money were you thinking of as insurance? I don't think that solution would work at all either way.

-If you did it to ensure that there was enough money to cover everyone, the GB organizer would be required to have a LARGE amount of money at hand to deposit for this. They would be taking the entire risk on themselves and essentially become a Vendor rather than a GB organizer.

-One could do it with a smaller amount of money that that of the entire GB. It is a bit naive to think that this would discourage a GB organizer from walking away with everyone's investments since they will still benefit from this transaction because the amount they put up as insurance is less than the total cost of the GB.

Both of these solutions negates the point of having a GB. People are allowed to get things without one person having to take all the risk and no one needs to have the investment required to begin with since everyone contributes. With this, you would essentially turn every GB into a sale where the GB organizer takes the entire risk etc.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: zenuty on Thu, 03 October 2013, 04:44:36
When is it strat refund.

How i can resolve this problems..
I just want to refund.
I wish get back my money.

Where are you ? ?
Why still not update ? ?
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: mattics on Thu, 03 October 2013, 09:44:55
Snip
Snip

I think rather than a deposit, a holding middle man would work (slightly) better, but also has it's flaws... lots of them...

This approach would see the user paying an intermediary who holds onto the money until it comes to paying the supplier. The first problem would be who would be that intermediary, if they were a commercial entity would this even be financially viable? If it was "Geekhack" as an entity how could they collect the money? The potential extra transfer through PayPal would introduce fees and lots of group buys would possibly trigger blocks and freezes from PP.

The second issue is introduced as the supplier needs playing as either the intermediary would need to pay the supplier directly (which could become a logistical problem and see the intermediary becoming a co organiser) or it is an opportunity for the organiser to take the money and run before paying the supplier.

I am really selling this approach aren't I?  :))

There is always the possibility that the organiser runs away with the goods which is impossible to protect against.

I think the bottom line is just reiterating what others have said - Group buys are a risk. They are a risk to the organiser who may get in over their head, they may end up forking out cash because MOQs weren't met and they didn't correctly account for this. They are a risk to the buyer as this thread is a good example of. I think most of the time the risk pays off for the majority involved as you get goods that would never otherwise reach the market and you get them for a reasonable price most times.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Rabbit on Thu, 03 October 2013, 10:43:33
Asking For refund.......
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: SpAmRaY on Thu, 03 October 2013, 10:47:28
Since the OP hasn't even logged in in almost 3 months, sadly I'm thinking you all might be out of luck :(
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: elton5354 on Thu, 03 October 2013, 10:58:29
If you used your credit card to purchase these, you can dispute this through your CC given it hasn't been over 6 months.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: The_Beast on Thu, 03 October 2013, 11:01:17
Is there anybody of gh could ask the starters of gb to pay some money for insurance and when their gbs ended succesfully,the money they have paid will be back to the starters...i think it a good rule for them.

How much money were you thinking of as insurance? I don't think that solution would work at all either way.

-If you did it to ensure that there was enough money to cover everyone, the GB organizer would be required to have a LARGE amount of money at hand to deposit for this. They would be taking the entire risk on themselves and essentially become a Vendor rather than a GB organizer.

-One could do it with a smaller amount of money that that of the entire GB. It is a bit naive to think that this would discourage a GB organizer from walking away with everyone's investments since they will still benefit from this transaction because the amount they put up as insurance is less than the total cost of the GB.

Both of these solutions negates the point of having a GB. People are allowed to get things without one person having to take all the risk and no one needs to have the investment required to begin with since everyone contributes. With this, you would essentially turn every GB into a sale where the GB organizer takes the entire risk etc.

This is correct. Everyone takes a risk when entering a GB. It really sucks that your money is gone, but you should have known this before entering the GB.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: pasph on Fri, 04 October 2013, 05:27:22
Is there anybody of gh could ask the starters of gb to pay some money for insurance and when their gbs ended succesfully,the money they have paid will be back to the starters...i think it a good rule for them.

How much money were you thinking of as insurance? I don't think that solution would work at all either way.

-If you did it to ensure that there was enough money to cover everyone, the GB organizer would be required to have a LARGE amount of money at hand to deposit for this. They would be taking the entire risk on themselves and essentially become a Vendor rather than a GB organizer.

-One could do it with a smaller amount of money that that of the entire GB. It is a bit naive to think that this would discourage a GB organizer from walking away with everyone's investments since they will still benefit from this transaction because the amount they put up as insurance is less than the total cost of the GB.

Both of these solutions negates the point of having a GB. People are allowed to get things without one person having to take all the risk and no one needs to have the investment required to begin with since everyone contributes. With this, you would essentially turn every GB into a sale where the GB organizer takes the entire risk etc.

This is correct. Everyone takes a risk when entering a GB. It really sucks that your money is gone, but you should have known this before entering the GB.

Yes but can't be "Geekhack: a great place for scammers!" and you know the more the users the more the risk.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: piraterice on Sat, 05 October 2013, 21:24:36
The host of this gb just dissappeared without any explanation or message left for us.After so many words we talked about him,i just want to know is here anybody can contact with him or make him say something about this gb?He just said that the gb is stopped by sherryton,and the bsper keeped all our money,then ,the end?
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Photoelectric on Sat, 05 October 2013, 21:44:29
Perhaps someone should contact BSP and see where they stand on the refund part--if they were paid.  See if they can return the money to someone else from the group buy, to be distributed among those who paid.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: IPT on Sun, 06 October 2013, 01:18:51
BSP can't authorize a return to someone else except for the person they did business with
think about it, how can you as a business owner take money that was paid by 1 individual and give it to another?
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Photoelectric on Sun, 06 October 2013, 01:24:56
BSP can't authorize a return to someone else except for the person they did business with
think about it, how can you as a business owner take money that was paid by 1 individual and give it to another?

You can still contact them and ask for the status.  Better than posting here, because nothing will get done here. 

In this case the person went MIA due to the situation I am sure they are aware of.  So they are still responsible for that money and can still be asked to give information about it.  He collected other people's money--not his own, so you have a right to ask.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: IPT on Sun, 06 October 2013, 05:10:15
Bsp has no clue who we(members) are. How can they give out information someone else ordered? I'd be pissed if a company gave out information. There's nothing that can be done, chalk it up to a learning experience. Not the 1st time a GB gone bad, and won't be the last time. Ive been in some as well that's gone bad (changdrew for example)
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Rabbit on Sun, 06 October 2013, 08:13:10
Bsp has no clue who we(members) are. How can they give out information someone else ordered? I'd be pissed if a company gave out information. There's nothing that can be done, chalk it up to a learning experience. Not the 1st time a GB gone bad, and won't be the last time. Ive been in some as well that's gone bad (changdrew for example)

It's not your money, it's not your ass which was on fire, so you don't give a ****.

But some of us did spent money on this GB, what do you think we should do ?
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Tym on Sun, 06 October 2013, 08:25:32
Any evidence of OP's address anywhere? Mods must have his IP? Worth tracing ? Demand Letter/Law suit? Even if its not worth it individually, pool a small amount of money together? Stop him doing it again?
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: mattics on Sun, 06 October 2013, 10:13:24
Any evidence of OP's address anywhere? Mods must have his IP? Worth tracing ? Demand Letter/Law suit? Even if its not worth it individually, pool a small amount of money together? Stop him doing it again?

After a little bit of Googling around the username, location and subject matter. It is relatively easy to find a 'business' which deals with keyboard items which I believe is related to the user. I have also found a similar domain name to the username, the who-is data shows the same address as a few local business listing sites as mentioned above but also with a name and number.

I won't post any info till I am off my phone and have PMd a mod, as while this info is in the public domain it is still personally identifiable info. But it was incredibly easy to find and most of it is probably already known to users here.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: tinlong117 on Sun, 06 October 2013, 11:59:49
After some googling, I know where he lives and I know a guy who lives pretty close to kbdvintage.

P.S. Suppose the address on whois is correct.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: mattics on Sun, 06 October 2013, 13:41:08
...But it was incredibly easy to find...

After some googling, I know where he lives and I know a guy who lives pretty close to kbdvintage.

P.S. Suppose the address on whois is correct.

Told you :)

The address on the who-is is the same as the address which shows on some listing sites if you just Google the username, and the country at least matches that on his profile here.

I think a simple letter stating the money owed is the first, correct step. Any attempt at threatening (not suggesting that anyone here would) would likely cause him to run and if it got to a legal setting in which the money was retrieved would be a mark in his favour.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: IPT on Sun, 06 October 2013, 14:04:48
Bsp has no clue who we(members) are. How can they give out information someone else ordered? I'd be pissed if a company gave out information. There's nothing that can be done, chalk it up to a learning experience. Not the 1st time a GB gone bad, and won't be the last time. Ive been in some as well that's gone bad (changdrew for example)

It's not your money, it's not your ass which was on fire, so you don't give a ****.

But some of us did spent money on this GB, what do you think we should do ?


im talking from a business standpoint.  Stop thinking with your emotions and consider this:  Would you want your supplier to randomly give money you paid them to someone else?
come on man, think rationally for a moment.

If BSP did this, how the hell can anyone in good faith do business with them in the future?
If they're willing to refund $$ to people based on hearsay?

Besides just read rule #1 in the forum:
Quote
1) Conflict resolution: CAVEAT EMPTOR. Moderators will not step in to mediate buys gone bad. BE CAREFUL WHEN BUYING/SELLING ON THIS FORUM! We accept no liability and will provide no services to buyers or sellers short of providing a forum for organizing group buys. We highly encourage buyers and sellers to reference their own feedback ratings (heatware, ebay, etc), and we highly encourage users to refrain from joining buys organized by anyone but senior members with a proven track record of organizing large group buys. CAVEAT EMPTOR: WE ACCEPT NO LIABILITY FOR LOSSES RELATED TO OR RESULTING FROM POSTING IN THIS FORUM OR FOR ANY TRANSACTION RESULTING FROM A POSTING IN THIS FORUM.

...But it was incredibly easy to find...

After some googling, I know where he lives and I know a guy who lives pretty close to kbdvintage.

P.S. Suppose the address on whois is correct.

Told you :)

The address on the who-is is the same as the address which shows on some listing sites if you just Google the username, and the country at least matches that on his profile here.

I think a simple letter stating the money owed is the first, correct step. Any attempt at threatening (not suggesting that anyone here would) would likely cause him to run and if it got to a legal setting in which the money was retrieved would be a mark in his favour.

Do you really think GH will condone vigilantism?  Or threats against bodily harm? lol
What if you guys are wrong about the address?  Are you willing to take responsibility for something that happens to an innocent party?
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Photoelectric on Sun, 06 October 2013, 14:12:49
stuff

What are you trying to say, in essence?  Don't do anything at all?  I don't see anyone talking about sending threats or anything like that--quite the opposite.  Why are you so against people getting a resolution to this situation?  Trying to get in touch with different parties to get information is a step toward resolving this.  Posting long negative replies here and doing nothing is not going to help in any way.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Rabbit on Sun, 06 October 2013, 15:03:42
Bsp has no clue who we(members) are. How can they give out information someone else ordered? I'd be pissed if a company gave out information. There's nothing that can be done, chalk it up to a learning experience. Not the 1st time a GB gone bad, and won't be the last time. Ive been in some as well that's gone bad (changdrew for example)

It's not your money, it's not your ass which was on fire, so you don't give a ****.

But some of us did spent money on this GB, what do you think we should do ?


im talking from a business standpoint.  Stop thinking with your emotions and consider this:  Would you want your supplier to randomly give money you paid them to someone else?
come on man, think rationally for a moment.

If BSP did this, how the hell can anyone in good faith do business with them in the future?
If they're willing to refund $$ to people based on hearsay?

Besides just read rule #1 in the forum:
Quote
1) Conflict resolution: CAVEAT EMPTOR. Moderators will not step in to mediate buys gone bad. BE CAREFUL WHEN BUYING/SELLING ON THIS FORUM! We accept no liability and will provide no services to buyers or sellers short of providing a forum for organizing group buys. We highly encourage buyers and sellers to reference their own feedback ratings (heatware, ebay, etc), and we highly encourage users to refrain from joining buys organized by anyone but senior members with a proven track record of organizing large group buys. CAVEAT EMPTOR: WE ACCEPT NO LIABILITY FOR LOSSES RELATED TO OR RESULTING FROM POSTING IN THIS FORUM OR FOR ANY TRANSACTION RESULTING FROM A POSTING IN THIS FORUM.

...But it was incredibly easy to find...

After some googling, I know where he lives and I know a guy who lives pretty close to kbdvintage.

P.S. Suppose the address on whois is correct.

Told you :)

The address on the who-is is the same as the address which shows on some listing sites if you just Google the username, and the country at least matches that on his profile here.

I think a simple letter stating the money owed is the first, correct step. Any attempt at threatening (not suggesting that anyone here would) would likely cause him to run and if it got to a legal setting in which the money was retrieved would be a mark in his favour.

Do you really think GH will condone vigilantism?  Or threats against bodily harm? lol
What if you guys are wrong about the address?  Are you willing to take responsibility for something that happens to an innocent party?



We are not asking any help from GH, we are just a bunch people who paid money for this GB , looking for a solution

Then,what are you doing? We can't even talk about this thing?
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: mattics on Sun, 06 October 2013, 16:25:26

I think a simple letter stating the money owed is the first, correct step. Any attempt at threatening (not suggesting that anyone here would) would likely cause him to run and if it got to a legal setting in which the money was retrieved would be a mark in his favour.

Do you really think GH will condone vigilantism?  Or threats against bodily harm? lol
What if you guys are wrong about the address?  Are you willing to take responsibility for something that happens to an innocent party?

I clearly stated a letter stating money owed is what should be done. If it goes to someone else they just ignore or say "sorry, not me". End of story.

Also in my first post on the matter I said I was not going to post any personal information. Tinlong didn't post anything either, it is freely publicly available for you to find it yourself so how have either of us condoned any sort of vigilante.

Edit: Just to clarify a few things here.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: sprit on Sun, 06 October 2013, 18:13:03
Sorry  for That!
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Neal on Sun, 06 October 2013, 18:16:56
I live >very< close by, I can be the sender of this letter if it comes to that if that were to happen.
Or if anything else requires a local, lmk.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: IPT on Sun, 06 October 2013, 21:26:24
stuff

What are you trying to say, in essence?  Don't do anything at all?  I don't see anyone talking about sending threats or anything like that--quite the opposite.  Why are you so against people getting a resolution to this situation?  Trying to get in touch with different parties to get information is a step toward resolving this.  Posting long negative replies here and doing nothing is not going to help in any way.

because you're setting the blame the wrong way
if you want to try to contact the OP, that's fine
contacting BSP is not the right way, nor is trying to get BSP to give you $$.  Not to mention as i said b4, they'd just ignore you.

Unfortunately, the fact of the matter is like many other GBs that organizers just "disappear" from GH, if you can do chargeback with your Credit Card, you do it.  If you can chargeback through paypal, you do it.
Other than that, there's really nothing you can do except chalk it up as a learning experience and deal with people who you personally think is "safe"

The whole GB system relies on a trust between all parties.  If you're not willing to assume the risks of the GB, you're better off buying it from Venders/suppliers.  AT least that way you're guaranteed $$ back if anything goes wrong.

That being said, good luck to you guys who have your $$ stuck in this horrible situation.  Hopefully you get better luck than I did on previous GBs and Sales where people just disappear.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: zenuty on Mon, 07 October 2013, 10:57:18
Please serch to him.  :blank:

Its not small money.
Many user lost a huge of money.

Unbelivable....


I live >very< close by, I can be the sender of this letter if it comes to that if that were to happen.
Or if anything else requires a local, lmk.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Photoelectric on Mon, 07 October 2013, 11:31:27
stuff

What are you trying to say, in essence?  Don't do anything at all?  I don't see anyone talking about sending threats or anything like that--quite the opposite.  Why are you so against people getting a resolution to this situation?  Trying to get in touch with different parties to get information is a step toward resolving this.  Posting long negative replies here and doing nothing is not going to help in any way.

because you're setting the blame the wrong way
if you want to try to contact the OP, that's fine
contacting BSP is not the right way, nor is trying to get BSP to give you $$.  Not to mention as i said b4, they'd just ignore you.

Unfortunately, the fact of the matter is like many other GBs that organizers just "disappear" from GH, if you can do chargeback with your Credit Card, you do it.  If you can chargeback through paypal, you do it.
Other than that, there's really nothing you can do except chalk it up as a learning experience and deal with people who you personally think is "safe"

The whole GB system relies on a trust between all parties.  If you're not willing to assume the risks of the GB, you're better off buying it from Venders/suppliers.  AT least that way you're guaranteed $$ back if anything goes wrong.

That being said, good luck to you guys who have your $$ stuck in this horrible situation.  Hopefully you get better luck than I did on previous GBs and Sales where people just disappear.

I'm pretty sure that interested parties are not as naive as you keep making them out to be.  It's not like all of them don't know good business practices.  Your resolution is to accept the loss and do nothing, and you were not involved into this group buy, so your money is not on the line.  The people who were involved do want some answers, and I don't see any harm in them trying to get them.  Once again, it doesn't hurt to ask.  It appears that the organizer will not be back if nothing is done.

And finally, if one person scams another person, that's a certain amount of money owed to that one person.  In this case, we're talking about a LOT of people effectively scammed out of a lot of money.  So acceptance comes with greater difficulty.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: demik on Mon, 07 October 2013, 11:48:11
None of you are about that life so stfu. Call your cc companies and get it sorted. Or walk the walk and stop pretending like you're going to do something.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: IPT on Mon, 07 October 2013, 12:18:37
stuff

What are you trying to say, in essence?  Don't do anything at all?  I don't see anyone talking about sending threats or anything like that--quite the opposite.  Why are you so against people getting a resolution to this situation?  Trying to get in touch with different parties to get information is a step toward resolving this.  Posting long negative replies here and doing nothing is not going to help in any way.

because you're setting the blame the wrong way
if you want to try to contact the OP, that's fine
contacting BSP is not the right way, nor is trying to get BSP to give you $$.  Not to mention as i said b4, they'd just ignore you.

Unfortunately, the fact of the matter is like many other GBs that organizers just "disappear" from GH, if you can do chargeback with your Credit Card, you do it.  If you can chargeback through paypal, you do it.
Other than that, there's really nothing you can do except chalk it up as a learning experience and deal with people who you personally think is "safe"

The whole GB system relies on a trust between all parties.  If you're not willing to assume the risks of the GB, you're better off buying it from Venders/suppliers.  AT least that way you're guaranteed $$ back if anything goes wrong.

That being said, good luck to you guys who have your $$ stuck in this horrible situation.  Hopefully you get better luck than I did on previous GBs and Sales where people just disappear.

I'm pretty sure that interested parties are not as naive as you keep making them out to be.  It's not like all of them don't know good business practices.  Your resolution is to accept the loss and do nothing, and you were not involved into this group buy, so your money is not on the line.  The people who were involved do want some answers, and I don't see any harm in them trying to get them.  Once again, it doesn't hurt to ask.  It appears that the organizer will not be back if nothing is done.

And finally, if one person scams another person, that's a certain amount of money owed to that one person.  In this case, we're talking about a LOT of people effectively scammed out of a lot of money.  So acceptance comes with greater difficulty.

you're making it seem like this is the only time this ever happened here on GH
I assure you, this wasn't the 1st, and it won't be the last.
Also why do you think you guys that are involved in this GB had it worse than anyone else who had a GB go wrong??

I don't think this GB is any smaller than the Changdrew nonsense that happened last year (or was it 2 years), or the countless other GBs that ended up having organizers run off.  Lets be honest, unless you're gonna be able to serve him in small claims court (which i don't even know the jurisdictions in Europe for that), its just a bunch of saber rattling.  He's not gonna reply to you, BSP isn't gonna give you the $$.

Maybe you'll get lucky to get someone to walk over to his address and talk to him.  I doubt it'll accomplish anything.  What else is it?  Gonna call the cops on him?  Gonna beat him down for the $$?  I keep asking as I didn't bother looking up this guy's details:  What if the whois info is wrong?  What if its an innocent person?  What if it goes the same way as Spike Lee tweeting out an address that was allegedly george zimmerman's address, but instead ended up being an innocent elderly couple who got death threats/bomb threats to their home that they had to flee?

None of you are about that life so stfu. Call your cc companies and get it sorted. Or walk the walk and stop pretending like you're going to do something.

this basically.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: piraterice on Tue, 08 October 2013, 06:44:45
Any evidence of OP's address anywhere? Mods must have his IP? Worth tracing ? Demand Letter/Law suit? Even if its not worth it individually, pool a small amount of money together? Stop him doing it again?
+1
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: piraterice on Tue, 08 October 2013, 06:46:40
Bsp has no clue who we(members) are. How can they give out information someone else ordered? I'd be pissed if a company gave out information. There's nothing that can be done, chalk it up to a learning experience. Not the 1st time a GB gone bad, and won't be the last time. Ive been in some as well that's gone bad (changdrew for example)

It's not your money, it's not your ass which was on fire, so you don't give a ****.

But some of us did spent money on this GB, what do you think we should do ?
agree!
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: demik on Tue, 08 October 2013, 12:08:25
Bsp has no clue who we(members) are. How can they give out information someone else ordered? I'd be pissed if a company gave out information. There's nothing that can be done, chalk it up to a learning experience. Not the 1st time a GB gone bad, and won't be the last time. Ive been in some as well that's gone bad (changdrew for example)

It's not your money, it's not your ass which was on fire, so you don't give a ****.

But some of us did spent money on this GB, what do you think we should do ?
agree!

Do you guys not have banks/cc companies to call? Most will fight fraud for you. But really, blame the people that had an itchy trigger finger and filed a dispute before OP fixed the problem and paypal shut his account. Dudes didn't even let him fix it.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: dr/owned on Wed, 09 October 2013, 04:29:01
(no dog in this fight)

3 months later...this dude is either dead, in the hospital, or never coming back.

At least 2 ways to weed out wimpy GB leaders:

a)Organizer != Purchaser .  Example: I had to order a $700 transformer for a project.  I'm the one on the phone speaking to company reps making sure it aligns with specs, etc.  They send me invoice, I sent invoice to my purchaser who pays it directly to the company.

b) Organizer has to go through same rules needed to get a PO Box in the US.  2 forms of ID on file tied to a physical address, on file with an Admin.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: dr/owned on Wed, 09 October 2013, 04:29:56
Double post.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Rabbit on Wed, 09 October 2013, 16:12:11
I live >very< close by, I can be the sender of this letter if it comes to that if that were to happen.
Or if anything else requires a local, lmk.

I just wanna know how this thing is going.Would you please contact him and ask whatever this is going?

We are not blamming him. We just wanna know if he still working on this thing or not.

And do let him updata something in this topic,please.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Neal on Wed, 09 October 2013, 16:50:50
I live >very< close by, I can be the sender of this letter if it comes to that if that were to happen.
Or if anything else requires a local, lmk.

I just wanna know how this thing is going.Would you please contact him and ask whatever this is going?

We are not blamming him. We just wanna know if he still working on this thing or not.

And do let him updata something in this topic,please.
What do you expect me to do?

There is a domain that is the exact same as his username, and its the same country.
That's all we have, if I were to step by. What do I ask, if he's who we think he is? He could just say no, same thing with a letter.
Sure I could go step by, but we're not even 100% sure if this guy is the same guy.

I'd like to not take initiative on this, but if the communnity would like to write a letter or of something requires a local I can do that.
I guess I could go and ask if he's kboardvintage.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Rabbit on Wed, 09 October 2013, 20:27:55
I live >very< close by, I can be the sender of this letter if it comes to that if that were to happen.
Or if anything else requires a local, lmk.

I just wanna know how this thing is going.Would you please contact him and ask whatever this is going?

We are not blamming him. We just wanna know if he still working on this thing or not.

And do let him updata something in this topic,please.
What do you expect me to do?

There is a domain that is the exact same as his username, and its the same country.
That's all we have, if I were to step by. What do I ask, if he's who we think he is? He could just say no, same thing with a letter.
Sure I could go step by, but we're not even 100% sure if this guy is the same guy.

I'd like to not take initiative on this, but if the communnity would like to write a letter or of something requires a local I can do that.
I guess I could go and ask if he's kboardvintage.

You are right. I have nothing former to say. Let's just hope this thing won't go that bad way.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: zenuty on Mon, 21 October 2013, 07:45:43
I can directly request to BSP about refund ?

Where is my $ 350 USD...  :-X  :-X  :-X  :-X  :-X  :-X  :-X
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: mattics on Mon, 21 October 2013, 17:48:42
Did you pay via PayPal, zenuty? I believe there is a time frame for refunds with PayPal of around 3 months(?) but it might be worth contacting them anyway. If possible I would try to call PayPal as you will get the best response from them, emails seem to get no where judging by others experience.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: keymaster on Mon, 21 October 2013, 17:59:17
I'm glad I haven't participated in this GB, but I feel terrible for those have. Have the admins anything to say about this?

This is pretty bogus. kboardvintage has not logged into GH since July 5th, 2013. Unless OP is dead or in a coma, there is NO EXCUSE for him to not update everyone who participated in the GB on the situation. It's almost November now and nothing has changed. OP still basically has hundreds (maybe thousands) of dollars floating around. It doesn't matter if BSP "has the money" or not -- he is still the one responsible. What a shame...
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: sleepy916 on Mon, 21 October 2013, 18:09:34
Did you pay via PayPal, zenuty? I believe there is a time frame for refunds with PayPal of around 3 months(?) but it might be worth contacting them anyway. If possible I would try to call PayPal as you will get the best response from them, emails seem to get no where judging by others experience.

The time frame is 45 days and it was well past that when things started to get a bit complicated. Paypal won't even look into it if it is past the 45 days.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: acidtrip69 on Mon, 21 October 2013, 23:38:31
So did the Op rip off people ?
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: mattics on Tue, 22 October 2013, 01:51:49
Did you pay via PayPal, zenuty? I believe there is a time frame for refunds with PayPal of around 3 months(?) but it might be worth contacting them anyway. If possible I would try to call PayPal as you will get the best response from them, emails seem to get no where judging by others experience.

The time frame is 45 days and it was well past that when things started to get a bit complicated. Paypal won't even look into it if it is past the 45 days.

That is a real shame. I had hoped that maybe because others had got their money back from the same purchase PayPal might have some common sense.

@acid I don't think kboard set out to rip anyone off, it just ended that way. I think he just didn't/couldn't handle the situation for whatever reason. And then didn't/couldn't stick around to handle the mess.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: zenuty on Sat, 26 October 2013, 09:09:25
I was paid through paypal invoice
and i was tried dispute to paypal.

But Still not found any answer.

Im very sick and headache How i can resolve this problems...
I just flow tears from my eyes... ㅠ_ㅠ

I cant speak to english as well and im live in korea
I cant call to paypal call center.

I need to help.

I hope G.B Organizer come back to here and start refund.....
But He was gone a long long time ago.

Did you pay via PayPal, zenuty? I believe there is a time frame for refunds with PayPal of around 3 months(?) but it might be worth contacting them anyway. If possible I would try to call PayPal as you will get the best response from them, emails seem to get no where judging by others experience.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: nullstring on Sat, 26 October 2013, 09:52:26
For the record, I think BSP has the right to sell it's product however they like. They have the right to give deals to some people and selectively enforce their MOQ.
Further, I think that if BSP committed to doing this and money was already paid, they do not have the right to simply cancel the agreement to keep in good faith with another customer.

Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: zenuty on Sat, 26 October 2013, 19:12:46
I was tried dispute to paypal resolution center.

But Failed. Paypal is not accepted dispute...
I was too lated..  :-[

Non-receipt - Claim - #PP-002-615-479-806
 
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: zenuty on Sat, 02 November 2013, 13:53:52
I need to water gun...
I would fill pee and shot to irresponsibility man....  >:D

Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Puddsy on Sat, 02 November 2013, 15:42:50
I need to water gun...
I would fill pee and shot to irresponsibility man....  >:D

You know you have a problem when zenuty gets mad.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: demik on Sat, 02 November 2013, 18:30:43
I need to water gun...
I would fill pee and shot to irresponsibility man....  >:D



petrol + lighter would give a bigger statement
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: terran5992 on Sun, 03 November 2013, 00:27:07
So its official,

this guy ran off with the money
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Photekq on Sun, 03 November 2013, 00:28:45
I need to water gun...
I would fill pee and shot to irresponsibility man....  >:D
I think we all do, zenuty :'(

I'm just glad I didn't join this GB when kbdvintage tried to persuade me to do so.. What he's done is just terrible. I hope it gets sorted in the end.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: zenuty on Sun, 03 November 2013, 00:58:18
Yes How i can do it now...

im very fever and sick... 
im very regret join to this g.b
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: feng on Sun, 03 November 2013, 01:20:20
You're not along zenuty, I put over $500 on this GB. :(
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: alixinhzai on Sun, 03 November 2013, 01:19:44
same me for 4 sets :v
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Puddsy on Sun, 03 November 2013, 16:05:00
same me for 4 sets :v

Ouch :(
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Patchwrks on Mon, 04 November 2013, 12:55:29
So did anybody else besides me get a set of these keys?
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Dianoda on Mon, 04 November 2013, 13:03:24
So did anybody else besides me get a set of these keys?

I got a set... from sherryton - but not the keys I paid for as a part of this GB.

Interestingly enough, kboardvintage has logged into GH in the past 24hrs - account last active: Mon, 04 November 2013, 03:12:58
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Acanthophis on Mon, 04 November 2013, 18:26:04
I don't know if it helps, but I made my bank wire transfer via SEPA to:

Mod edit: Posting personal information is NOT allowed.


So, somebody can work with that?



(yes, this is personal information, but frankly I don't care and she/he deserves it)
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Puddsy on Mon, 04 November 2013, 21:09:33
I don't know if it helps, but I made my bank wire transfer via SEPA to:

[snip]


So, somebody can work with that?



(yes, this is personal information, but frankly I don't care and she/he deserves it)

Doesn't matter if they "deserve" it. That's not cool in any context.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: sleepy916 on Tue, 05 November 2013, 01:26:49
He finally logged in, shot him a pm but I bet it goes nowhere.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: piraterice on Tue, 05 November 2013, 07:36:31
He finally logged in, shot him a pm but I bet it goes nowhere.
i think we should pm him more and more till he come to update!
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: piraterice on Tue, 05 November 2013, 09:09:38
So did anybody else besides me get a set of these keys?

I got a set... from sherryton - but not the keys I paid for as a part of this GB.

Interestingly enough, kboardvintage has logged into GH in the past 24hrs - account last active: Mon, 04 November 2013, 03:12:58
i am going to buy a BSP set from sherryton too....The money of this GB seems to be lost for me ...
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: zenuty on Thu, 07 November 2013, 07:10:13
You're not along zenuty, I put over $500 on this GB. :(

same me for 4 sets :v

Oh my god...
I cant more countinue comment ...  :'(  :'(
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: zenuty on Tue, 03 December 2013, 21:41:33
Hmm.......

Last Active: Mon, 04 November 2013, 03:12:58
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: piraterice on Thu, 05 December 2013, 22:32:10
Hmm.......

Last Active: Mon, 04 November 2013, 03:12:58
The starter of this gb may be laughing behind all of us,with all our money on his hand~
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Neal on Thu, 05 December 2013, 22:51:32
Hmm.......

Last Active: Mon, 04 November 2013, 03:12:58
The starter of this gb may be laughing behind all of us,with all our money on his hand~
Please don't take assumptions and start a witch hunt, no one has all the information and can know what has happened.
Details about the GB organizer and what BSP had said/done or even Paypal are unclear.

However its definitely NOT ok for the organizer to just leave and leave people out in the blue.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: sleepy916 on Thu, 05 December 2013, 23:07:46
I've emailed the op numerous times with his paypal email. No reply and pmed him many times. I am sure this guy scum. No way to change my mind about it. It's been a long time and not a word.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: piraterice on Fri, 20 December 2013, 08:46:59
Hmm.......

Last Active: Mon, 04 November 2013, 03:12:58
The starter of this gb may be laughing behind all of us,with all our money on his hand~
Please don't take assumptions and start a witch hunt, no one has all the information and can know what has happened.
Details about the GB organizer and what BSP had said/done or even Paypal are unclear.

However its definitely NOT ok for the organizer to just leave and leave people out in the blue.
What i say was that he just logged in before,without any update for all of us~
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Rabbit on Wed, 08 January 2014, 15:41:49
Any progress?
I'm furious.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Puddsy on Wed, 08 January 2014, 17:40:40
Looks like nothing.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: synerr on Sat, 11 January 2014, 07:17:19
I was not part of this GB, but skimping over it I think there are valuable lessons to be learnt.

Am I correct in my conclusions that what happened was that this sherry dude ordered a bunch of keycaps from bsp and then the kboardvintage guy tried to opportunistically buy direct from bsp additional keysets by asking bsp to extend the run and provide a limited quantity at a favourable price?  Then kboardvintage collected money from users, handed over the money to BSP, then Sherry got upset and strong armed BSP to default on the keysets promised to kboardvintage?

Besides the initials in the bsp sku, does Sherry have any intellectual property rights over those specific keysets that gave him the right to block others from acquiring the same product?

Or did he simply strong arm BSP to kill kboardvintage's gb wth the muscle of a 400 keyset purchase order + possibility of future business?

What happened to the money kboardvintage had collected?  BSP do not owe anyone other than kboardvintage any explanation as far as I can see.  And no one other than kboardvintage owes any of those hurt by the failed GB any explanation.

What however I find most disturbing in interest groups such as gh however is how some players are held in veneration as righteous and the go to people even when their actions speak otherwise.  In this case there have been comments where keyboard enthusiasts have not only lost money on this gb and defended the person who ultimately knifed the gb and put their money in jeopardy but went scurrying back to that user handing over more money for the same keysets.

As the saying goes "Fool me once, shame on you; fool me twice, shame on me."

Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: IPT on Sat, 11 January 2014, 19:43:53
I was not part of this GB, but skimping over it I think there are valuable lessons to be learnt.

Am I correct in my conclusions that what happened was that this sherry dude ordered a bunch of keycaps from bsp and then the kboardvintage guy tried to opportunistically buy direct from bsp additional keysets by asking bsp to extend the run and provide a limited quantity at a favourable price?  Then kboardvintage collected money from users, handed over the money to BSP, then Sherry got upset and strong armed BSP to default on the keysets promised to kboardvintage?

Besides the initials in the bsp sku, does Sherry have any intellectual property rights over those specific keysets that gave him the right to block others from acquiring the same product?

Or did he simply strong arm BSP to kill kboardvintage's gb wth the muscle of a 400 keyset purchase order + possibility of future business?

What happened to the money kboardvintage had collected?  BSP do not owe anyone other than kboardvintage any explanation as far as I can see.  And no one other than kboardvintage owes any of those hurt by the failed GB any explanation.

What however I find most disturbing in interest groups such as gh however is how some players are held in veneration as righteous and the go to people even when their actions speak otherwise.  In this case there have been comments where keyboard enthusiasts have not only lost money on this gb and defended the person who ultimately knifed the gb and put their money in jeopardy but went scurrying back to that user handing over more money for the same keysets.

As the saying goes "Fool me once, shame on you; fool me twice, shame on me."



1st part of the problem:
BSP's MOQ is 400 pieces
without sherry's order, this keyset was not gonna get through

explain to me how its fair for kboardvintage to come and piggy back on sherry's order?
Sherry's order involved him paying for the whole order out of pocket, without starting up a GB.
KB offered the keyset at a similar low price after the 400MOQ was agreed to on sherry's order.

Let me ask you, if you've invested over $20,000 in a product, then someone comes along and piggybacks on your investment for the product with the goal of distributing to your potential customers, how would you feel?

This isn't about someone being thought of as righteous or what not.  Its quite simply very simple business.

BSP made the mistake of trying to profit off an order that one of their customers placed.  The argument that sherry's order of 400 was in, so they should just sell the extra orders to anyone else is ridiculous.
If they conducted their business like this, they would lose a ton of customers.  You don't see SP allowing people to buy our GB keysets or produce more than our GB amounts do you?

Part 2 of the problem:
Instead of trying to workout some way with sherry, say move the orders to sherry instead of trying to proceed with the gb.  Or contacting sherry and offering to buy out at his price these pieces, KB instead believes he's entitled to his product order and tries to get BSP to continue with his order.  i personally don't see how a company refunding the $$ for an order is a breach of contract, maybe its different in london?  As long as $$ was returned how is there a breach?

Anyway so KB decides to nag sherry, not refund the $$ to the groupbuy members, and basically then disappears off of GH.  So you can say sherry's "wrong" for stopping 19 sets from being processed in this GB.
But frankly speaking, KB shows he's just a coward for disappearing and not coming back.  He claims paypal's claimed over 2 grand from his accounts, but i'm pretty sure the order cost more than 2 grand so in the end he still profits and goes away, screwing all the people who tried to participate in this gb.
So say what you want about sherry, he's still around GH and running his store.  Kboardvantage has disappeared from GH and ran off with $.  You decide who's the bigger douchebag.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: sleepy916 on Sun, 12 January 2014, 01:05:28
I was not part of this GB, but skimping over it I think there are valuable lessons to be learnt.

Am I correct in my conclusions that what happened was that this sherry dude ordered a bunch of keycaps from bsp and then the kboardvintage guy tried to opportunistically buy direct from bsp additional keysets by asking bsp to extend the run and provide a limited quantity at a favourable price?  Then kboardvintage collected money from users, handed over the money to BSP, then Sherry got upset and strong armed BSP to default on the keysets promised to kboardvintage?

Besides the initials in the bsp sku, does Sherry have any intellectual property rights over those specific keysets that gave him the right to block others from acquiring the same product?

Or did he simply strong arm BSP to kill kboardvintage's gb wth the muscle of a 400 keyset purchase order + possibility of future business?

What happened to the money kboardvintage had collected?  BSP do not owe anyone other than kboardvintage any explanation as far as I can see.  And no one other than kboardvintage owes any of those hurt by the failed GB any explanation.

What however I find most disturbing in interest groups such as gh however is how some players are held in veneration as righteous and the go to people even when their actions speak otherwise.  In this case there have been comments where keyboard enthusiasts have not only lost money on this gb and defended the person who ultimately knifed the gb and put their money in jeopardy but went scurrying back to that user handing over more money for the same keysets.

As the saying goes "Fool me once, shame on you; fool me twice, shame on me."



1st part of the problem:
BSP's MOQ is 400 pieces
without sherry's order, this keyset was not gonna get through

explain to me how its fair for kboardvintage to come and piggy back on sherry's order?
Sherry's order involved him paying for the whole order out of pocket, without starting up a GB.
KB offered the keyset at a similar low price after the 400MOQ was agreed to on sherry's order.

Let me ask you, if you've invested over $20,000 in a product, then someone comes along and piggybacks on your investment for the product with the goal of distributing to your potential customers, how would you feel?

This isn't about someone being thought of as righteous or what not.  Its quite simply very simple business.

BSP made the mistake of trying to profit off an order that one of their customers placed.  The argument that sherry's order of 400 was in, so they should just sell the extra orders to anyone else is ridiculous.
If they conducted their business like this, they would lose a ton of customers.  You don't see SP allowing people to buy our GB keysets or produce more than our GB amounts do you?

Part 2 of the problem:
Instead of trying to workout some way with sherry, say move the orders to sherry instead of trying to proceed with the gb.  Or contacting sherry and offering to buy out at his price these pieces, KB instead believes he's entitled to his product order and tries to get BSP to continue with his order.  i personally don't see how a company refunding the $$ for an order is a breach of contract, maybe its different in london?  As long as $$ was returned how is there a breach?

Anyway so KB decides to nag sherry, not refund the $$ to the groupbuy members, and basically then disappears off of GH.  So you can say sherry's "wrong" for stopping 19 sets from being processed in this GB.
But frankly speaking, KB shows he's just a coward for disappearing and not coming back.  He claims paypal's claimed over 2 grand from his accounts, but i'm pretty sure the order cost more than 2 grand so in the end he still profits and goes away, screwing all the people who tried to participate in this gb.
So say what you want about sherry, he's still around GH and running his store.  Kboardvantage has disappeared from GH and ran off with $.  You decide who's the bigger douchebag.

Thanks for saving me the trouble of writing something like this.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Photoelectric on Sun, 12 January 2014, 01:12:51
But frankly speaking, KB shows he's just a coward for disappearing and not coming back.  He claims paypal's claimed over 2 grand from his accounts, but i'm pretty sure the order cost more than 2 grand so in the end he still profits and goes away, screwing all the people who tried to participate in this gb.
So say what you want about sherry, he's still around GH and running his store.  Kboardvantage has disappeared from GH and ran off with $.  You decide who's the bigger douchebag.

This is pretty much the conclusion of this thread.  This is really what happened.  Despite any circumstances short of Kboardvintage being in a hospital this whole time or unable to access the internet (and even then, he could have had someone post for him), he simply disappeared and stopped updating--and for all we can see, completely dropped any attempts to recover the money for those who paid.  In the grand scheme, that's all that really matters here.  Even if he was in the right initially, which he wasn't, there's no excuse to simply vanish with other people's money.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: tbc on Sun, 12 January 2014, 01:27:12
I'm confused, where did the extra money go?  did kbd keep it?  or did kbd actually send the money to BSP and BSP kept it?  or did kbd send the money to BSP, they refunded the money to kbd, and then kbd kept what was left after paypal handled it?
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Photoelectric on Sun, 12 January 2014, 01:30:33
Seeing as it's up to KBDvintage to tell us what happened, and he's not here--there's really no way to know what the latest status is.  I think he paid BSP, and he said that extra sets were already produced.  What happened with those extra sets and the money is uncertain.

P.S.: the last detailed update:
http://geekhack.org/index.php?topic=43104.msg933104#msg933104

And from the update in the OP:

"I read a lot of comments in the GB. My apologies to all those who feel frustrated with the actual situation. Most of you guys have file a complain via paypal and so far paypal is already taking care of those (I ll be consider as a "scammer" in the paypal system so, again, THANKS).
About BSP, the people responsible of dealing with my order are now on holidays (as they just told me via phone) and will be back somewhere end of July. I have already request a full refund, but apparently within the "backup" team left, no accountant is present...so SURPRISE, your money is still at BSP's hands, at least until August."

Seeing as it's January now, I'd hope he should have gotten something back.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: damorgue on Sun, 12 January 2014, 01:34:49
You always have to pay extra for exclusivity and I don't think Sherry did that, which is why it was fully within BSP's right to also sell to someone else. Then Sherry went to BSP and complained, and BSP decided to side with Sherry and then turned down keyboardvintage's order. That is my conclusion at least.

Sherry messed up, BSP covered for him by breaking another order even though they had no responsibility to do so which is how they messed up. BSP ought to have refunded keyboardvintage though, and he hasn't returned with this money which is where he messed up. Although Sherry was the first to make a mistake, they all did something wrong in my eyes.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Photoelectric on Sun, 12 January 2014, 01:40:57
Don't you think though that BSP could have said no to Sherry's request for exclusivity after Sherry inquired about the extra sets?  It wasn't very wrong to express outrage that BSP would produce extra sets at lower price per set based on Sherry's purchase from Sherry's perspective--wouldn't you agree?  I mean wouldn't you feel similarly if you'd invested your own money into something for your store and someone else jumped in to effectively steal some of your customers?  That's his perspective.  It's not like he MADE BSP offer extra sets to others and then made them deny those extra sets.  The fault is 1. with BSP for shady dealings, and 2. with Kboardvintage for not updating anymore and disappearing.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: sleepy916 on Sun, 12 January 2014, 01:46:53
In the end what matters is that Kboardvintage must have got the money back. I don't think BSP as a company wouldn't refund him the money if he did not get a product. He could have just refunded everyone and try again at another time. No harm, no foul. But nothing from him at all for months now.

So to summarize Sherry still got his sets, Kboardvintage probably got the GB money back from BSP, and the people who participated got the shaft.

The end.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: damorgue on Sun, 12 January 2014, 01:55:46
Don't you think though that BSP could have said no to Sherry's request for exclusivity after Sherry inquired about the extra sets?  It wasn't very wrong to express outrage that BSP would produce extra sets at lower price per set based on Sherry's purchase from Sherry's perspective--wouldn't you agree?  I mean wouldn't you feel similarly if you'd invested your own money into something for your store and someone else jumped in to effectively steal some of your customers?  That's his perspective.  It's not like he MADE BSP offer extra sets to others and then made them deny those extra sets.  The fault is 1. with BSP for shady dealings, and 2. with Kboardvintage for not updating anymore and disappearing.

I don't agree. If it wasn't mentioned in the contract, BSP had no liability to ensure exclusivity. This is in my experience always added to contracts, but since BSP didn't honour any such thing, I suspect it was left out. Had it been included, BSP would never have accepted keyboardvintage's order in the first place. I absolutely see why Sherry was upset, I would have been so too if I had realized I had forgotten such an important aspect, but that does not make it BSP's fault. They even helped Sherry even though they didn't have too, by breaking another established order. There is where BSP made their mistake in my opinion.

Edit: This is usually written in relation to the NDA section. If nothing like this has been specified, neither party can just assume that there is an NDA or exlusitivy agreement.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Photoelectric on Sun, 12 January 2014, 02:04:10
You said it was Sherry's fault too, but my reply was explaining how it doesn't look like Sherry's fault.  It was more BSP's fault for allowing it all to happen as it did.  They should not have made extra sets and should not have offered them to another customer.  What does Sherry have to do with that part?  So he didn't sign the exclusivity part, and in that case, BSP could have just said "well, you didn't sign an exclusivity contract, so we have the legal right to keep both sets of orders at the original terms".  It was BSP's choice to change the terms on Kboardvintage. 

We don't know all the exact details anyway.  This is just what we've been told.

And regardless, this group buy is really in a rut more because of Kboardvintage's disappearance with the rest of the money from those who did not get theirs back via PayPal disputes.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: damorgue on Sun, 12 January 2014, 02:16:38
You said it was Sherry's fault too, but my reply was explaining how it doesn't look like Sherry's fault.  It was more BSP's fault for allowing it all to happen as it did.  They should not have made extra sets and should not have offered them to another customer.  What does Sherry have to do with that part?
They on the other hand had no reason not to not accept the second order and make extra sets. Why shouldn't they make them if someone else orders them and there is nothing preventing them to? Sherry has to do with it in that he first made the mistake of not specifying that BSP wasn't allowed to do this, and secondly conveyed BSP to honour an agreement which was never there in the first place. I assume there was no such agreement beforehand simply because BSP being a large company would have honoured such an agreement if there was one.

So he didn't sign the exclusivity part, and in that case, BSP could have just said "well, you didn't sign an exclusivity contract, so we have the legal right to keep both sets of orders at the original terms".  It was BSP's choice to change the terms on Kboardvintage. 

Precisely, it was again wrong of Sherry to convince the company to break off another order, and wrong of BSP to agree to this.

Anyway, our opinions differ and lets leave it at that. My understanding is that Sherry made a mistake, then tried to cover his ass by converying BSP, which led to BSP accepting that request and cancelling an order, and then keyboardvintage stopped communicating and did not refund people.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: IPT on Sun, 12 January 2014, 02:45:44
You said it was Sherry's fault too, but my reply was explaining how it doesn't look like Sherry's fault.  It was more BSP's fault for allowing it all to happen as it did.  They should not have made extra sets and should not have offered them to another customer.  What does Sherry have to do with that part?  So he didn't sign the exclusivity part, and in that case, BSP could have just said "well, you didn't sign an exclusivity contract, so we have the legal right to keep both sets of orders at the original terms".  It was BSP's choice to change the terms on Kboardvintage. 

We don't know all the exact details anyway.  This is just what we've been told.

And regardless, this group buy is really in a rut more because of Kboardvintage's disappearance with the rest of the money from those who did not get theirs back via PayPal disputes.

frankly the main fault lies with BSP with the way they tried to conduct business.
Without sherry's 400MOQ order, they would not have produced the keycaps.
To come around and try to sell to someone else this initial order is dishonest.

You can say all you want about exclusivity and what not, the fact of the matter is this keyset would not exist without sherry's order.
not to mention during the time this was all getting sorted out, full production had not occurred i don't believe.

this is what would've happened if BSP continued with this order:
Sherry would cancel his order with BSP, probably stop doing business with them in the future, wouldn't surprise me if he'd spread his experience about how BSP takes advantage of MOQ orders to make a little extra on the side.

I don't see BSP continuing with the order for KB, they'd prob contact him and cancel the order or tell him he has to come up with the 400MOQ now to run the production.
which since he sold 19 sets here, i doubt he would be successful.  Just look at all the GMK sets we've tried to start here on GH (and please don't bring up toxic in this one, until that GB's restarted the "order list" is just letters.

Either way, the fault now 100% lies with KBvintage because frankly he went MIA and ran off with everyone's $$.

*EDIT*
You said it was Sherry's fault too, but my reply was explaining how it doesn't look like Sherry's fault.  It was more BSP's fault for allowing it all to happen as it did.  They should not have made extra sets and should not have offered them to another customer.  What does Sherry have to do with that part?
They on the other hand had no reason not to not accept the second order and make extra sets. Why shouldn't they make them if someone else orders them and there is nothing preventing them to? Sherry has to do with it in that he first made the mistake of not specifying that BSP wasn't allowed to do this, and secondly conveyed BSP to honour an agreement which was never there in the first place. I assume there was no such agreement beforehand simply because BSP being a large company would have honoured such an agreement if there was one.

So he didn't sign the exclusivity part, and in that case, BSP could have just said "well, you didn't sign an exclusivity contract, so we have the legal right to keep both sets of orders at the original terms".  It was BSP's choice to change the terms on Kboardvintage. 

Precisely, it was again wrong of Sherry to convince the company to break off another order, and wrong of BSP to agree to this.

Anyway, our opinions differ and lets leave it at that. My understanding is that Sherry made a mistake, then tried to cover his ass by converying BSP, which led to BSP accepting that request and cancelling an order, and then keyboardvintage stopped communicating and did not refund people.

because its bad business to do this.
Do you see SP selling extra sets that we do GB's on?
Why can't i contact SP and tell them to run another Red Alert set with OG legends?  Its already been done, the tooling is done, why is it wrong for them to sell me a few sets of that?
How about telling them to run another set of the graphite set that some have sold for $200+?
Or a Soware set that sells for $200?

Only person I see selling sets he produces for GBs is IMSTO but we all know how business is done in China so meh.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: piraterice on Sun, 12 January 2014, 03:02:46
Till now,i think that the problem of this gb had no business with sherry.The attitude of kboardvintage to this gb made us disappointed  a lot------just disappear with out any updating,made all the money we paid disappeared without a trace.I thought what u have argued about this gb made  no sense,u just have to find somebody of ghers who can contact with him,and tell him to come out to explain all of it, that is the way so solve the problem of this gb!
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: nubbinator on Sun, 12 January 2014, 03:04:29
They on the other hand had no reason not to not accept the second order and make extra sets. Why shouldn't they make them if someone else orders them and there is nothing preventing them to? Sherry has to do with it in that he first made the mistake of not specifying that BSP wasn't allowed to do this, and secondly conveyed BSP to honour an agreement which was never there in the first place. I assume there was no such agreement beforehand simply because BSP being a large company would have honoured such an agreement if there was one.

Precisely, it was again wrong of Sherry to convince the company to break off another order, and wrong of BSP to agree to this.

This GB was only possible because they were piggybacking on Sherry's purchase and thus circumventing the MOQ.  There would have been no issue if they had done a full order at BSP's MOQ.  Sherry was rightfully upset when some potential customers were being sold his product without having to meet the same MOQ requirements that he did. 

For all intents and purposes, this group buy was like the authentic knock offs that are made in China.  They're made on the same line with the same materials as the real stuff, but after the official hours and are sold as fakes.  The manufacturer is stealing from the customer and reducing the potential customer base.

The initial fault was with BSP and I'd say it stayed with them and not sherry.  However, once BSP offered a refund and OP refused it and tried to coerce them into making the set anyways, well, the blame transferred to them.


How about telling them to run another set of the graphite set that some have sold for $200+?
Or a Soware set that sells for $200?

Someone could set up a GB for those if they wanted to.  The problem would only exist if the original group buy had custom tooling or had some sort of copyright on the colors.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: damorgue on Sun, 12 January 2014, 03:46:56
because its bad business to do this.
Do you see SP selling extra sets that we do GB's on?
Yes, I bought some Red Alert from them after the GB for instance.

Why can't i contact SP and tell them to run another Red Alert set with OG legends?  Its already been done, the tooling is done, why is it wrong for them to sell me a few sets of that?
You can. Some sets have been made several times. Sometimes you can't make a replica because some legends and colours are copyrighted. In the case of klaxxon Red Alert, they could be bought from SP outside of the GB.

How about telling them to run another set of the graphite set that some have sold for $200+?
Graphite is one of the sets where an agreement was made to not sell outside. This is also true for the tooling of the Cherry replica fonts which not just anyone can use.

I stand by my point that unless you agree on NDAs and exclusivity agreements beforehand, you can not expect the other party to adhere to any of your expectations on such matters. I stand by that Sherry is to blame for messing this all up by convincing BSP to cancel this order. BSP is to blame for agreeing to such a request, and keyboardvintage is to blame for not refunding people.

#blamestorming, the new brainstorming method

Depending on keyboardvintage's agreement with BSP, it might not be possible for him to get his money back. It might be the case that he has paid part of a large MOQ order, which has gone into production, and will need to pay the rest to have it delivered, and can't get it back because it has already been produced. This of course depends on the contracts, but if that is the case then keyboardvintage can do nothing about it.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: IPT on Sun, 12 January 2014, 04:33:56
Kbv already said his order is 19 sets. Also I can't get red alert custom legends made for me from sp so yeah I guess my point stands
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: synerr on Sun, 12 January 2014, 04:41:28

1st part of the problem:
BSP's MOQ is 400 pieces
without sherry's order, this keyset was not gonna get through

explain to me how its fair for kboardvintage to come and piggy back on sherry's order?
Sherry's order involved him paying for the whole order out of pocket, without starting up a GB.
KB offered the keyset at a similar low price after the 400MOQ was agreed to on sherry's order.

Let me ask you, if you've invested over $20,000 in a product, then someone comes along and piggybacks on your investment for the product with the goal of distributing to your potential customers, how would you feel?

This isn't about someone being thought of as righteous or what not.  Its quite simply very simple business.

BSP made the mistake of trying to profit off an order that one of their customers placed.  The argument that sherry's order of 400 was in, so they should just sell the extra orders to anyone else is ridiculous.
If they conducted their business like this, they would lose a ton of customers.  You don't see SP allowing people to buy our GB keysets or produce more than our GB amounts do you?

Part 2 of the problem:
Instead of trying to workout some way with sherry, say move the orders to sherry instead of trying to proceed with the gb.  Or contacting sherry and offering to buy out at his price these pieces, KB instead believes he's entitled to his product order and tries to get BSP to continue with his order.  i personally don't see how a company refunding the $$ for an order is a breach of contract, maybe its different in london?  As long as $$ was returned how is there a breach?

Anyway so KB decides to nag sherry, not refund the $$ to the groupbuy members, and basically then disappears off of GH.  So you can say sherry's "wrong" for stopping 19 sets from being processed in this GB.
But frankly speaking, KB shows he's just a coward for disappearing and not coming back.  He claims paypal's claimed over 2 grand from his accounts, but i'm pretty sure the order cost more than 2 grand so in the end he still profits and goes away, screwing all the people who tried to participate in this gb.
So say what you want about sherry, he's still around GH and running his store.  Kboardvantage has disappeared from GH and ran off with $.  You decide who's the bigger douchebag.

Thanks for saving me the trouble of writing something like this.

MOQ by itself means nothing.  If I were a manufacturer of, say plastic screws, I may put an MOQ of 5000 to cover the tooling, overheads, and opportunity cost for using that time and shop floor space to do something else.    If I have the opportunity that once set up I can extend the run and sell some more screws over the original order so be it.  If the original purchaser who had to meet the MOQ wanted an exclusive product then he should either own the rights to that product, or pay an additional premium to guarantee an exclusive run.  It's all in the terms and conditions.

How I would feel if I found myself in Sherry's position?  It's not about feelings.  It is about terms and conditions.

We don't know who breached what contracts and what moneys have exchanged hands between whom.  It has nothing to do with London but again it is down to the terms and conditions.  When I was contracting I used to charge a fixed amount for a project.  However I very often could not just walk away from a project and I had penalties for breaking a contract.  If say, someone paid me 10k to install a network, and I agreed to do it within a week, and then I just say ... sorry can't do it here's your money back ... I'd be bound by a break clause of probably at least half as much and would still leave the customer in deep trouble because time has passed and they still have no network.

In his thread sherry asked people not to be misled that this is his product.  I do not know that other than those being his initials on a SKU.  Whether he had the legal right to kill BSP's extended run or he was just throwing toys out of the pram I do not know.  I do find it distasteful though that any reputable supplier of a very specialist product would wilfully contribute to doing something that harms members of a friendly community, some lost hundreds of dollars, and while a few hundred quid mean nothing to some, they could be 6 months savings to other.

II just cannot believe the blind naivety of a lot of users when it comes to vendors ... it is the closest I've seen to Stockholm syndrome.    If you feel so strongly about a vendor's meeting the MOQ of an unprivileged product being taken advantage of by an opportunistic buyer whilst the manufacturer's tooling is still in place, then how do you feel about group buys set up by vendors where effectively they are only getting a community to co-sponsor their for-profit stock piling of an item they would otherwise not afford?

Meh
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: Photoelectric on Sun, 12 January 2014, 10:33:00
Depending on keyboardvintage's agreement with BSP, it might not be possible for him to get his money back. It might be the case that he has paid part of a large MOQ order, which has gone into production, and will need to pay the rest to have it delivered, and can't get it back because it has already been produced. This of course depends on the contracts, but if that is the case then keyboardvintage can do nothing about it.
You seriously think that? It would be called Extortion, which should be illegal in most civilized countries.  If the agreement was to buy x sets for y price, a vendor can't suddenly increase the price and hold your money hostage.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: damorgue on Sun, 12 January 2014, 10:43:19
Depending on keyboardvintage's agreement with BSP, it might not be possible for him to get his money back. It might be the case that he has paid part of a large MOQ order, which has gone into production, and will need to pay the rest to have it delivered, and can't get it back because it has already been produced. This of course depends on the contracts, but if that is the case then keyboardvintage can do nothing about it.
You seriously think that? It would be called Extortion, which should be illegal in most civilized countries.  If the agreement was to buy x sets for y price, a vendor can't suddenly increase the price and hold your money hostage.

Of course. But if the agreement was to buy enough parts to satisfy the MOQ, and keyboardvintage was led to believe that this MOQ was low when it later became far higher, if BSP didn't ever state that this low MOQ was permanent to him he could have entered into an agreement without realizing that the MOQ had changed. He might have begun payment and production and then have been told that the MOQ was far higher than he had anticipated. Again, this all depends on communication, how the specifics were formulated, contract was worded and agreements which we are unaware of and currently just speculating in. What I am stating is that under certain circumstances, keyboardvintage comes of as perfectly innocent other than his lack of communication. He might be stuck in a situation where he is out some money as well, and not that he has been refunded and left with the money.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: IPT on Sun, 12 January 2014, 11:36:53
Depending on keyboardvintage's agreement with BSP, it might not be possible for him to get his money back. It might be the case that he has paid part of a large MOQ order, which has gone into production, and will need to pay the rest to have it delivered, and can't get it back because it has already been produced. This of course depends on the contracts, but if that is the case then keyboardvintage can do nothing about it.
You seriously think that? It would be called Extortion, which should be illegal in most civilized countries.  If the agreement was to buy x sets for y price, a vendor can't suddenly increase the price and hold your money hostage.

Of course. But if the agreement was to buy enough parts to satisfy the MOQ, and keyboardvintage was led to believe that this MOQ was low when it later became far higher, if BSP didn't ever state that this low MOQ was permanent to him he could have entered into an agreement without realizing that the MOQ had changed. He might have begun payment and production and then have been told that the MOQ was far higher than he had anticipated. Again, this all depends on communication, how the specifics were formulated, contract was worded and agreements which we are unaware of and currently just speculating in. What I am stating is that under certain circumstances, keyboardvintage comes of as perfectly innocent other than his lack of communication. He might be stuck in a situation where he is out some money as well, and not that he has been refunded and left with the money.

he posted BSP was going to process his refund, he instead wanted them to go through with his purchase.
So there's no MOQ agreement or whatever nonsense speculation you're thinking of.  So he's not out of money, i can assure you.
\
Fact of the matter is BSP was caught double dipping.  They were going to give the $$ back to KBV.  He didn't want the $$ back, he wanted the product.  I dunno why you seem to think KBV is absolutely innocent in this situation.
Do you have a personal vendetta against sherry?  You act like we're all blindly supporting sherry because we love him or idolize his ability to get keycaps.  I assure you that isn't the case considering i've only made 1 purchase from sherry and i still haven't gotten it yet.  But to defend KBV?  Im sorry but running off shows his true colors.  There's nothing innocent about that.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: sleepy916 on Sun, 12 January 2014, 12:10:35
As a person who was in this GB, I don't care about MOQs at this point, I would just like my money back. Only Kboardvintage can refund the money. If he was truly innocent he would write something, anything, as an explanation within the past few months.

After this GB I still have not bought any of the BSP keysets that were offered on Sherry's website.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: piraterice on Mon, 10 February 2014, 11:10:20
Whoever start the GB must be responsible for all the GHers who took part in the GB,till now, me and my friends just believe that our money had lost~I must say that if this GB was started by me and came to this situation ,i will take my own money to pay back all the GBer who took part in,after that i will talk with the BSP company to ask my money back!
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: feng on Tue, 11 February 2014, 10:47:02
Oh well, things happened. I have no hope to get my money back.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: ApocalypseMaow on Wed, 12 February 2014, 22:50:25
KBV has been gone for over a year... Money is long gone! :/
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: piraterice on Thu, 10 April 2014, 05:27:13
KBV has been gone for over a year... Money is long gone! :/
:-[ALMOST 150 DOLLARS GONE!
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: pbtforever on Tue, 04 November 2014, 12:23:34
Did this Group Buy ever happen?  Are ther other BSP group buys going on?
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: SpAmRaY on Tue, 04 November 2014, 12:24:54
:facepalm:
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: pbtforever on Tue, 04 November 2014, 12:26:46
What is the problem?  I am looking for thick PBT keys and these BSP ones look good.
Title: Re: [GB (almost) CANCELLED] BSP DYE SUB
Post by: IvanIvanovich on Tue, 04 November 2014, 12:29:21
See this thread for a current BSP offerings (http://geekhack.org/index.php?topic=64188.0).

I am locking this thread.