geekhack
geekhack Community => Keyboards => Topic started by: aquatic on Tue, 14 May 2013, 19:58:42
-
I just bought a Filco Majestouch 2 with blue switches. I love the feel of the keys, but I'm not so fond of the noise. So I read on this forum that you can use o-ring switch dampeners to quiet them down a bit. My question is: does dampeners make the keys heavier to actuate?
Also are there any online stores in europe selling them?
-
The o-rings don't add weight. They just dampen the noise slightly and shorten the travel distance.
-
Like CPTBadAss said, they don't change the actuation point. They do change the feel of the key if you bottom out. To me, it adds a little mush to the bottom
-
O-rings won't do anything for that infernal tactile click, I don't think. :confused:
-
Good news, thanks.
Now I just have to find someplace to buy them.
-
O-rings won't do anything for that infernal tactile click, I don't think. :confused:
They won't do anything for the click but they may significantly impact the noise of the keyboard overall. I haven't used a Filco like the OP's but I added WASD's red o-rings to my MX blue WASD V1 and the keyboard is substantially quieter. IME there are three noises:
1) The key click (depending on switch type)
2) The bottom-out clack
3) The "top-out" clack on release
The o-rings get rid of (2). My perception is that my keyboard is much quieter due to this, because (again, on my keyboard at least) (1) and (3) are quieter than (2). Noises (2) and (3) are also why Kinesis Advantage boards (with MX browns) have a reputation around my office for being loud/clacky, even through browns are technically a silent switch.
Hope this helps... FWIW I really like the feel of my keyboard with WASD's lower travel-reduction o-rings, and it still sounds good as well IMO.
-
imsto
buy multiple sets to spread out the shipping
get the thinnest and softest ones, the 40L
-
Blues have a part that causes click, the only way to stop that is a different switch, or Jailhouse Blues. Both require de-soldering every switch.
O-rings help in two ways, the first is bottoming out, O-rings stop you from bottoming out as hard, decreasing noise and finger impact. The second is that keycaps can amplify any noise from the switch, o-rings dampen them.
And no, they do not increase the force required to activate, they actually lower it an imperceptible amount by adding weight to the keycap.