geekhack
geekhack Projects => Making Stuff Together! => DIY Discussions ARCHIVE => Topic started by: lam47 on Thu, 09 April 2009, 04:26:17
-
Im de soldering the switches from a dell 101 and putting them in the macally. That's all there is to it.
I will have a load of simplified clicky alps spare if anyone wants them.
Space saver with black alps?
Yes please.
-
go man, go. I did the same with a dell at101w and a filco tenless. It turned out real well too.
-
If I like the feel I might have to get the filco to do it to.
I do like the blacks rather a lot.
-
The black alps are very nice. I kind of put them in the same class as the cherry browns and Topres. Relatively quiet and relatively soft.
-
I would take the white alps, but I can't think of what I'd put them in.
I personally love the white alps much more than the black. I am thinking of getting a Filco with them if EliteKeyboards.com starts carrying them. I'm a bit nervous that the "white XM" switches in the Filco won't be the same as in the Macally.
I was going to buy a Unicomp for work, but I like the Macally so much now that I am keeping it at work, for now.
GL on the project. I can't wait to hear and see more!
-
Here we go.
Two and a half de soldering wicks later and I have some switches.
Now I have to do it all over again in another board.
I think it will be worth it though.
(http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v331/laurie47/DSC00536.jpg)
(http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v331/laurie47/DSC00538.jpg)
I agree too. They are very much in the same class as the topre and browns with the feel.
Nice and soft with a subtle and pleasing tactile response.
I'm looking forward to trying them on a board that will fit on my desk :)
If its very nice I may do as you have and make a Filco with them.
If you don't mind that is ;)
-
I think the black alps switches in the Filco tenless are an excellent combination.
I use that keyboard at work, its the one that replaced the 4100 in my laptop bag. When I use it I am struck at how nice it actually is.
-
So, besides the heavier springs in the black alps, what's the order of tactile event magnitude (TM): from big to small: black alps, browns, topre?
-
hmmm, i tried this and most of my black alps were destroyed in the soldering process. I hope you have better luck than me!
-
What happened to them Welly?
-
So, besides the heavier springs in the black alps, what's the order of tactile event magnitude (TM): from big to small: black alps, browns, topre?
I'd agree to that order.
-
To me, it sounds like black Alps, Topre then Cherry browns.
-
Hey lam,
Just curious...are you using the MK96 with a Mac or PC? If you are using it with a PC, are you changing any mapping for the keys? I ended up changing 10 keys to get it how I like it, and I'm still getting used to it.
Thanks.
-
I have not re mapped anything yet. However I have never used the board for very long.
I am using it on a PC with a imate thingy.
Its all done.
It was pretty simple really. The only tedious part is de soldering the tabs from both boards. I dont mind using the braid to suck up the solder but then you need to make sure the pin is not still attached to the PCB. I had to heat the pin and prise it up with a knife.
Once they were all out I straightened the pins and popped them into the metal plate.
Pushed the PCB on the back and re soldered each one. This only took a few minuets as I am used to much smaller jobs.
I will use the board for a while and see what I think.
So far it feels very nice. Like Browns the most I would say but a lot louder.
Any questions please ask.
Laurie.
Oh I have a load of simplified noisy alps if anyone wants them.
(http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v331/laurie47/six.jpg)
(http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v331/laurie47/five.jpg)
(http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v331/laurie47/four.jpg)
(http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v331/laurie47/three.jpg)
(http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v331/laurie47/two.jpg)
(http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v331/laurie47/one.jpg)
-
Nice! I am planning on trying to dye some of the Esc key and other keys as well.
I also drew the comparison between the black alps and brown cherries. They are different, but I find them to be very similar (blacks are definitely louder...)
I had no idea the HHKB was that small. I just figure it was normal size from LShift to Enter (or however you want to say that...).
-
I had no idea the HHKB was that small. I just figure it was normal size from LShift to Enter (or however you want to say that...).
It might be a little smaller, but I think the perspective in the photo makes it look much smaller than it actually is. There are some other photos in the Keyboard pics thread that would suggest that the HHKB is about the same size as an average keyboard in the "letter region."
EDIT: Thinking a little more about this, it would make the HHKB hard to type on since the keys would have to be smaller to get the overall size down.
-
Yeah, the perspective may be part of it. I would think it would be hard to type on if they were very much smaller keys, though..
I just saw you also switched the F & D and J & K keys. I had to do that as well to get the bumps in the "right" places.
-
The width of the keys from shift to enter is exactly the same as on the macally. Its just the photo that makes it look small.
I have to have the nipples in the right place or it slows me right down.
I never look at the keyboard so its not an issue.
And now Ella has her laptop It does not matter what kind of crazy configuration I have :)
Just like to add be very careful if you try and rit dye the keys.
They do not take it very well and the escape on mine is slightly warped. It had to be dyed 3 times to get the colour you see there.
Last edit I promise.
What happened to your switches during soldering Welly? I managed to snap the pins of a couple but otherwise they were fine.
Good job the Dell was 101 and this is 96 :)