geekhack
geekhack Marketplace => Interest Checks => Topic started by: ideus on Thu, 05 March 2015, 17:47:20
-
Disclaimer: These are 60% sets, not full size 100+ ones. For full sets you could check Photekqs Red, Blue, Beige sets, or TA one.
I have open a poll for BLACK, Beige and Dolch 60% sets at MD, compatible with Poker (ANSI US standard layout), and Infinity (HHKB layout support). These colors are awesome, and if it happens that you just get an Infinity, or have a Poker or other similar 60% keyboard this drop may interest you, so go and cast your vote.
Motivation: As a 60% percent user I always have a hard time justifying the investment in full sets, because of all these caps I will never have any use for, the function keys, the nine central pack, and the numbers pack.
You can also discuss some options that may interest you to get included in the final drop, and I will keep track of them as they reach some consensus, and I will discuss them with the MD guys to make sure to get them included in the final specifications of the set, or sets, if both reach 200+ votes.
The timing for this will be defined considering current GMK goodness pipeline of Elder's offers, if one or more of the colors reach 200+ casted votes, that I really doubt, I will take the community's input for the scheduling, and pass it to MD officials for consideration.
:thumb:
-
link to the poll?
-
link to the poll?
I am not sure if I can post it here. I will wait for a mod to enlighten me about it. But thank you for asking.
-
If your going for the classic beige you might as well add the classic white on black! :thumb:
-
I'm guessing you did not consider the beige GB I'm going to be starting shortly whatsoever when you did this?
It can't be put down as ignorance, because I know you've seen it. I can only put it down as very inconsiderate.
-
Wasn't the Massdrop link for the GMK Triumph Adler poll posted here?
-
I'm guessing you did not consider the beige GB I'm going to be starting shortly whatsoever when you did this?
Not really sir. These sets are not full sets, and have far less keys than yours. Does that make sense? They are something in between a modifiers set and the full size 100+ key sets. Thus they are not the same as either one.
-
I'd rather go through Photekq's simply because it's a full set. But have you reconsidered making all USA buyers pay a 20% EU tax? Plenty of trustworthy people offered to handle CONUS distribution in order to keep the cost reasonable.
-
Wasn't the Massdrop link for the GMK Triumph Adler poll posted here?
I think so, but I will wait either way.
-
I'm guessing you did not consider the beige GB I'm going to be starting shortly whatsoever when you did this?
Not really sir. These set are not full sets, and have far less keys than yours. Does that make sense?
I understand that. Regardless, do you not agree that if this were to run it would lower the order count of my GB, thus lowering the chances of it reaching MOQ?
@Keyzus
I'm working on that now. I want to get the price as low as possible to everyone, and thanks to a very generous offer from a certain Myster, this could happen.
Plenty of trustworthy people offered to handle CONUS distribution
We have different definitions of trustworthy :) There's only one person who's offered that I consider truly trustworthy, but luckily one is all we need.
-
Just my opinion, running a vote is fine, but please don't run the actual gb in the following 5-6 months. There are a lot of GMK gb right now already. Hyperfuse, Olivetti, Red Alert, Classic Beige, Blue mods, Triumph Adler... I think most people cannot afford all of them, so it maybe nice to give people a break time before you run the gb
-
Hoff offered to help and he's among the most trusted people here.
Massdrop is also an option. They'd handle everything and more would be sold so it would cost less.
-
Hoff offered to help and he's among the most trusted people here.
thanks to a very generous offer from a certain Myster, this could happen.
There's only one person who's offered that I consider truly trustworthy, but luckily one is all we need.
To be clear : I was talking about Hoffman :)
-
I'm guessing you did not consider the beige GB I'm going to be starting shortly whatsoever when you did this?
Not really sir. These set are not full sets, and have far less keys than yours. Does that make sense?
I understand that. Regardless, do you not agree that if this were to run it would lower the order count of my GB, thus lowering the chances of it reaching MOQ?
Your set already have the GH community interest, while 60% sets are more of a niche product, that may attract other users that in any case will not pay the cost for a full size keyboard set. Besides, as it has been discussed here many times, GMK are for actual keyboard aficionados, and I even doubt they reach the 200+ in the poll.
As Keyzus did, other people is waiting for your set, and your set only. I think the only ones that may be interested in the poll are some that just got the Infinity kit, and they are looking for a non so expensive decent set to dress it.
-
Plenty of trustworthy people offered to handle CONUS distribution
We have different definitions of trustworthy :) There's only one person who's offered that I consider truly trustworthy, but luckily one is all we need.
Well, I can always help too.
-
Just my opinion, running a vote is fine, but please don't run the actual gb in the following 5-6 months. There are a lot of GMK gb right now already. Hyperfuse, Olivetti, Red Alert, Classic Beige, Blue mods, Triumph Adler... I think most people cannot afford all of them, so it maybe nice to give people a break time before you run the gb
This is why I am not moving on anything regarding my HHKB kit interest check. There is just too much going on. I am probably just going to drop the idea and let the pros handle it. Honestly if people are smart, they will just go with Poteq's simply because of higher resale value and utility on multiple boards.
Going with a purely 60% layout seems so close minded.
-
Well, I can always help too.
LOL
I feel bad now! Make that two bro. I completely missed your post :'(
-
Just my opinion, running a vote is fine, but please don't run the actual gb in the following 5-6 months. There are a lot of GMK gb right now already. Hyperfuse, Olivetti, Red Alert, Classic Beige, Blue mods, Triumph Adler... I think most people cannot afford all of them, so it maybe nice to give people a break time before you run the gb
Worry not, as I wrote before, I have not seen much interest at MD for GMK made stuff, but for TA, it appears most people there are in the PBT madness train.
-
Plenty of trustworthy people offered to handle CONUS distribution
We have different definitions of trustworthy :) There's only one person who's offered that I consider truly trustworthy, but luckily one is all we need.
Well, I can always help too.
Yo Nubbs I guess Photekq doesn't think your to be trusted! :))
-
Well, I can always help too.
LOL
I feel bad now! Make that two bro. I completely missed your post :'(
rude as ****
-
Wait a minute, Bill did you say you'd help as well?
-
Just gonna deposit my $.02
I think this is a bad idea at this time. Photekq has put a lot of work into his beige gb and this would really undercut it and not benefit either of you. Maybe at a later time this would be better.
Wait a minute, Bill did you say you'd help as well?
yea, but I think Hoff or nubs might be better choices than me to help
-
There's lots of other designs to run there. Dolch wouldn't be stepping on anyones toes since Ivan already finished running his. Or you could run classic white on black.
-
Just gonna deposit my $.02
I think this is a bad idea at this time. Photekq has put a lot of work into his beige gb and this would really undercut it and not benefit either of you. Maybe at a later time this would be better.
Wait a minute, Bill did you say you'd help as well?
yea, but I think Hoff or nubs might be better choices than me to help
it is only a poll guys. People tend to hate ABS outside GH.
-
There's lots of other designs to run there. Dolch wouldn't be stepping on anyones toes since Ivan already finished running his. Or you could run classic white on black.
Great idea, standard white on black would not hurt anyone.
-
Plenty of trustworthy people offered to handle CONUS distribution
We have different definitions of trustworthy :) There's only one person who's offered that I consider truly trustworthy, but luckily one is all we need.
I stand by what I said though. Hoff, Nubbs and BillNye are three of the most trusted people on GH. Can't go wrong with having anyone of them help. Let's get that started.
-
This interest check is turning into a Photekq's beige set IC branch, LOL.
I told you guys, only we GHers want the GMK goodness.
:thumb:
-
I stand by what I said though. Hoff, Nubbs and BillNye are three of the most trusted people on GH. Can't go wrong with having anyone of them help. Let's get that started.
Hoff offered to help and he's among the most trusted people here.
thanks to a very generous offer from a certain Myster, this could happen.
There's only one person who's offered that I consider truly trustworthy, but luckily one is all we need.
To be clear : I was talking about Hoffman :)
-
Are you thinking about the same set of keys that billnye has in his upcoming buy?
I'm generally in favour of colourful 'booster packs.'
-
I would like this to add some value to current and upcoming GMK buys that our elders are working on right now. Thus, I would like some input to define an offer that complement but not compete with current designs under study.
For example, I have added the plain white on black to the poll. It may have some complements like a red enter and red escape only. There is no other offer like that, even Ivan's mod set will be a more complete design, and therefore they will not be in direct competition. As previously explained these are small sets, not full ones, therefore people in need of TKLs and beyond will be better served by Photekq's, HFs, and other full sets. Each one has its very own market.
As a 60% percent user I always have a hard time justifying the investment in full sets, because of all these caps I will never have any use for, the function keys, the nine central pack, and the numbers pack. This is the motivation for this IC.
-
This is going to step all over the MOQ of already established GB's. When are you planning on running it? Between Photekq's Classic Beige, billnye's mod set, Hyperfuse, Red Alert and Triumph Adler there is very little room to move. Not to mention the fact that some of these people have been actively waiting for a gap to run their GB's so as to not over-crowd the landscape, it would be pretty rude to just jump in.
-
This is going to step all over the MOQ of already established GB's. When are you planning on running it? Between Photekq's Classic Beige, billnye's mod set, Hyperfuse, Red Alert and Triumph Adler there is very little room to move. Not to mention the fact that some of these people have been actively waiting for a gap to run their GB's so as to not over-crowd the landscape, it would be pretty rude to just jump in.
I certainly will not. If the sets reach MoQ, that I doubt, I will consult the elders involved to get their input scheduling-wise.
-
This is going to step all over the MOQ of already established GB's. When are you planning on running it? Between Photekq's Classic Beige, billnye's mod set, Hyperfuse, Red Alert and Triumph Adler there is very little room to move. Not to mention the fact that some of these people have been actively waiting for a gap to run their GB's so as to not over-crowd the landscape, it would be pretty rude to just jump in.
I certainly will not. If the sets reach MoQ, that I doubt, I will consult the elders involved to get their input scheduling-wise.
You do realise that Massdrop doesn't care, right? If your poll gets plenty of votes and they decide to run it, they will run it when & how THEY want to.
-
This is going to step all over the MOQ of already established GB's. When are you planning on running it? Between Photekq's Classic Beige, billnye's mod set, Hyperfuse, Red Alert and Triumph Adler there is very little room to move. Not to mention the fact that some of these people have been actively waiting for a gap to run their GB's so as to not over-crowd the landscape, it would be pretty rude to just jump in.
I certainly will not. If the sets reach MoQ, that I doubt, I will consult the elders involved to get their input scheduling-wise.
You do realise that Massdrop doesn't care, right? If your poll gets plenty of votes and they decide to run it, they will run it when & how THEY want to.
Haata is a reasonable person, and I am pretty sure he can listen.
-
This is going to step all over the MOQ of already established GB's. When are you planning on running it? Between Photekq's Classic Beige, billnye's mod set, Hyperfuse, Red Alert and Triumph Adler there is very little room to move. Not to mention the fact that some of these people have been actively waiting for a gap to run their GB's so as to not over-crowd the landscape, it would be pretty rude to just jump in.
I certainly will not. If the sets reach MoQ, that I doubt, I will consult the elders involved to get their input scheduling-wise.
You do realise that Massdrop doesn't care, right? If your poll gets plenty of votes and they decide to run it, they will run it when & how THEY want to.
Haata is a reasonable person, and I am pretty sure he can listen.
What does he have to do with this? His only contribution is the actual Infinity? He has no say how things are run...
-
This is going to step all over the MOQ of already established GB's. When are you planning on running it? Between Photekq's Classic Beige, billnye's mod set, Hyperfuse, Red Alert and Triumph Adler there is very little room to move. Not to mention the fact that some of these people have been actively waiting for a gap to run their GB's so as to not over-crowd the landscape, it would be pretty rude to just jump in.
I certainly will not. If the sets reach MoQ, that I doubt, I will consult the elders involved to get their input scheduling-wise.
You do realise that Massdrop doesn't care, right? If your poll gets plenty of votes and they decide to run it, they will run it when & how THEY want to.
Haata is a reasonable person, and I am pretty sure he can listen.
What does he have to do with this? His only contribution is the actual Infinity? He has no say how things are run...
Have to contact them then.
-
This is going to step all over the MOQ of already established GB's. When are you planning on running it? Between Photekq's Classic Beige, billnye's mod set, Hyperfuse, Red Alert and Triumph Adler there is very little room to move. Not to mention the fact that some of these people have been actively waiting for a gap to run their GB's so as to not over-crowd the landscape, it would be pretty rude to just jump in.
I certainly will not. If the sets reach MoQ, that I doubt, I will consult the elders involved to get their input scheduling-wise.
You do realise that Massdrop doesn't care, right? If your poll gets plenty of votes and they decide to run it, they will run it when & how THEY want to.
Haata is a reasonable person, and I am pretty sure he can listen.
What does he have to do with this? His only contribution is the actual Infinity? He has no say how things are run...
Have to contact them then.
The guy you want to get in contact with is Andrew Lekashman if you want to work with MD on keyboard related things.
-
This is going to step all over the MOQ of already established GB's. When are you planning on running it? Between Photekq's Classic Beige, billnye's mod set, Hyperfuse, Red Alert and Triumph Adler there is very little room to move. Not to mention the fact that some of these people have been actively waiting for a gap to run their GB's so as to not over-crowd the landscape, it would be pretty rude to just jump in.
I certainly will not. If the sets reach MoQ, that I doubt, I will consult the elders involved to get their input scheduling-wise.
You do realise that Massdrop doesn't care, right? If your poll gets plenty of votes and they decide to run it, they will run it when & how THEY want to.
Haata is a reasonable person, and I am pretty sure he can listen.
What does he have to do with this? His only contribution is the actual Infinity? He has no say how things are run...
Have to contact them then.
The guy you want to get in contact with is Andrew Lekashman if you want to work with MD on keyboard related things.
This is correct. Haata has no affiliation with Massdrop.
-
overlap with others aside, i wouldn't join a GB where the organizer doesn't know 100% what he's doing
-
ideus, I really really like your idea (God I want HHKB Dolch) but I agree this will hurt upcoming GMK GBs. If I didn't have tremendous respect for Photekq I would look at this poll, decide that all three color schemes were great and just wait until MD launched their drop, even if I had to wait for some random community GB to end first.
Please don't get discouraged and let this idea die. Just...please get in line :D
-
This is going to step all over the MOQ of already established GB's. When are you planning on running it? Between Photekq's Classic Beige, billnye's mod set, Hyperfuse, Red Alert and Triumph Adler there is very little room to move. Not to mention the fact that some of these people have been actively waiting for a gap to run their GB's so as to not over-crowd the landscape, it would be pretty rude to just jump in.
I certainly will not. If the sets reach MoQ, that I doubt, I will consult the elders involved to get their input scheduling-wise.
You do realise that Massdrop doesn't care, right? If your poll gets plenty of votes and they decide to run it, they will run it when & how THEY want to.
Haata is a reasonable person, and I am pretty sure he can listen.
What does he have to do with this? His only contribution is the actual Infinity? He has no say how things are run...
Have to contact them then.
The guy you want to get in contact with is Andrew Lekashman if you want to work with MD on keyboard related things.
This is correct. Haata has no affiliation with Massdrop.
Thank you guys, I have sent an email to Andrew, and I will let you know the answer.
Again, the intention of this is not to get in the middle of anybody else plans. The people that may be interested in these sets are mostly newbies that are just getting into keyboards customization, while most of the people buying GH GBs are us long timers that know what we want already, thus we will not change our minds just because a partial set may be offered. Each set will have their demand, some already have theirs.
-
Again, the intention of this is not to get in the middle of anybody else plans. The people that may be interested in these sets are mostly newbies that are just getting into keyboards customization, while most of the people buying GH GBs are us long timers that know what we want already, thus we will not change our minds just because a partial set may be offered. Each set will have their demand, some already have theirs.
But there is overlap here, there's no denying it. There are a lot of people who exclusively use 60% boards that buy full sets and help support those that need the full set (whether they want to or not). This will definitely fragment buyers, and doesn't really benefit anyone (there likely will not be enough 60%-only buyers, much like there aren't enough full size-only buyers). GMK sets have a hard enough time reaching MOQ, I don't see how splitting this further would help anyone.
-
Again, the intention of this is not to get in the middle of anybody else plans. The people that may be interested in these sets are mostly newbies that are just getting into keyboards customization, while most of the people buying GH GBs are us long timers that know what we want already, thus we will not change our minds just because a partial set may be offered. Each set will have their demand, some already have theirs.
But there is overlap here, there's no denying it. There are a lot of people who exclusively use 60% boards that buy full sets and help support those that need the full set (whether they want to or not). This will definitely fragment buyers, and doesn't really benefit anyone (there likely will not be enough 60%-only buyers, much like there aren't enough full size-only buyers). GMK sets have a hard enough time reaching MOQ, I don't see how splitting this further would help anyone.
Fact is only the Dolch set is getting a few votes, and I think that does not fragment anything as there is no any other GMK Dolch in the horizon. I can hide the Beige option, that I see as the only one that may be in conflict with Photekq's.
-
Again, the intention of this is not to get in the middle of anybody else plans. The people that may be interested in these sets are mostly newbies that are just getting into keyboards customization, while most of the people buying GH GBs are us long timers that know what we want already, thus we will not change our minds just because a partial set may be offered. Each set will have their demand, some already have theirs.
But there is overlap here, there's no denying it. There are a lot of people who exclusively use 60% boards that buy full sets and help support those that need the full set (whether they want to or not). This will definitely fragment buyers, and doesn't really benefit anyone (there likely will not be enough 60%-only buyers, much like there aren't enough full size-only buyers). GMK sets have a hard enough time reaching MOQ, I don't see how splitting this further would help anyone.
I'm one of those people and I'm not alone. There are plenty of people here that will buy into whatever GMK sets are available, problem is we only have so much money. Running this in parallel with the already announced buys will hurt other people's GB's regardless of how you try to spin it.
-
Well guys, thank you for your feedback. I prefer to be in good standing with the community instead of keep my own ideas. It appears that this, even done with good intention, is deteriorating my reputation here.
I will ask Andrew to remove the poll at MD, if that is possible.
-
The poll is going to be removed at MD, and this thread locked. I hope that this settle this, with those who posted opinions against the proposal.
Just as a side note Andrew is a great guy, and he was ready to help.