geekhack

geekhack Community => Keyboards => Topic started by: phruitpie on Tue, 01 December 2015, 13:18:17

Title: HHKB Silencing
Post by: phruitpie on Tue, 01 December 2015, 13:18:17
Looking to silence my HHKB.

Do I go with dental bands, EK landing pads, or hypersphere's rings (if they ever restock)? I'm leaning towards landing pads since they're relatively cheap and I've heard they do a great job. Just looking for some opinions, thanks!!
Title: Re: HHKB Silencing
Post by: user 18 on Tue, 01 December 2015, 20:28:29
Split this topic by request, as asking for an opinion doesn't fall into the bounds of a simple question.

I haven't silenced any topre boards myself, but I hear that the landing pads do the best job of silencing the board while preserving its original feel.
Title: Re: HHKB Silencing
Post by: raymogi on Tue, 01 December 2015, 20:34:28
Hypersphere's is the best but if you wanna do it right now then go with the landing pads.
Title: Re: HHKB Silencing
Post by: bocahgundul on Tue, 01 December 2015, 20:40:52
Hypersphere my friend they will restock 2016 january
Title: Re: HHKB Silencing
Post by: phruitpie on Tue, 01 December 2015, 21:12:23
Split this topic by request, as asking for an opinion doesn't fall into the bounds of a simple question.

I haven't silenced any topre boards myself, but I hear that the landing pads do the best job of silencing the board while preserving its original feel.

Oops my bad, thanks for moving! I appreciate the input :)

Hypersphere's is the best but if you wanna do it right now then go with the landing pads.

Looks like I'll be going with landing pads, I want this thing silenced asap :p Thanks!

Hypersphere my friend they will restock 2016 january

But I wanna silence it nowwwwwwww lol :( good to know though ty
Title: Re: HHKB Silencing
Post by: Latin00032 on Tue, 01 December 2015, 22:29:15
I thought the dental bands were good to use. Is hyper's rings better?
Title: Re: HHKB Silencing
Post by: raymogi on Tue, 01 December 2015, 22:30:47
I thought the dental bands were good to use. Is hyper's rings better?

It will give you the same result as a stock Type-S silencing, which means no travel reduction.
Title: Re: HHKB Silencing
Post by: Latin00032 on Tue, 01 December 2015, 22:40:12
I thought the dental bands were good to use. Is hyper's rings better?

It will give you the same result as a stock Type-S silencing, which means no travel reduction.
So, I might as well get some dental bands, right?

Is there something I'm missing. I want to try a silencing mod but I want to do a good job.
Title: Re: HHKB Silencing
Post by: SpAmRaY on Tue, 01 December 2015, 22:41:49
I thought the dental bands were good to use. Is hyper's rings better?

It will give you the same result as a stock Type-S silencing, which means no travel reduction.
So, I might as well get some dental bands, right?

Is there something I'm missing. I want to try a silencing mod but I want to do a good job.

He meant hypersphere's rings not the dental bands. The dental bands reduce the travel.
Title: Re: HHKB Silencing
Post by: raymogi on Tue, 01 December 2015, 22:42:05
Every method works if all you want is just to silence it. What I'm saying is Hyper's ring will give the best result compared to a stock silencing method.

The easiest method I suppose is the dental band as you just have to stick in in there without doing any extra work.
Title: Re: HHKB Silencing
Post by: captaineleven on Tue, 01 December 2015, 23:01:30
Every method works if all you want is just to silence it. What I'm saying is Hyper's ring will give the best result compared to a stock silencing method.

The easiest method I suppose is the dental band as you just have to stick in in there without doing any extra work.

The dental band mod took me no more than an hour to do the first day I got my hhkb (which was yesterday lol) so I'd agree with that comment about it being the easiest.

I've otherwise heard good things about the other options. I think it's a matter of how just how silent you want your kb to be. Because the dental bands on mine took out a lot of the higher pitch "rain" patter sound from before the mod and it does silence it but I feel like it could be even quieter than it is now. But I could be wrong as I have only seen videos and other people's notes on the other silencing methods.

Good luck with figuring out what to do with yours, though!
Title: Re: HHKB Silencing
Post by: phruitpie on Tue, 01 December 2015, 23:18:21
I thought the dental bands were good to use. Is hyper's rings better?

It will give you the same result as a stock Type-S silencing, which means no travel reduction.
So, I might as well get some dental bands, right?

Is there something I'm missing. I want to try a silencing mod but I want to do a good job.

Dental bands are quick and easy, but I'm leaning more towards landing pads because they will apparently do a better silencing job - all the while not reducing travel as much.
In my opinion ironing some landing pads is well worth the extra time. I'd gladly put in some extra work if it means more permanence, rather than just slapping on some dental bands that I'll probably end up replacing down the road.
Title: Re: HHKB Silencing
Post by: phruitpie on Tue, 01 December 2015, 23:24:52
Every method works if all you want is just to silence it. What I'm saying is Hyper's ring will give the best result compared to a stock silencing method.

The easiest method I suppose is the dental band as you just have to stick in in there without doing any extra work.

The dental band mod took me no more than an hour to do the first day I got my hhkb (which was yesterday lol) so I'd agree with that comment about it being the easiest.

I've otherwise heard good things about the other options. I think it's a matter of how just how silent you want your kb to be. Because the dental bands on mine took out a lot of the higher pitch "rain" patter sound from before the mod and it does silence it but I feel like it could be even quieter than it is now. But I could be wrong as I have only seen videos and other people's notes on the other silencing methods.

Good luck with figuring out what to do with yours, though!

Curious as to what size bands you used, also by "'rain' patter sound" do you mean the click sound on the upstroke? Hows adjusting to the backspace going? :p
Title: Re: HHKB Silencing
Post by: crj3012 on Wed, 30 December 2015, 13:54:39
Ironed landing pads are a bit more of a pain than hyperspheres, but they'll suffice if you want to do it ASAP. They have less key travel issues than dental bands.