geekhack
geekhack Community => Keyboards => Topic started by: Rainman on Mon, 04 January 2016, 15:03:45
-
Hi all,
I'm playing with a thought to exchange my mx clears with tactile grays. I sometimes bottom out on clears and have a general feeling that I might go with heavier switch but I'm kinda reluctant whether I should really take the risk and splash $ for new switch only to find out that they are too heavy and would tire out on prolonged typing. I know they actuate at 80g but are there really that much heavier compared the clears in a "real life typing scenario"?
Besides, is there any reason there aren't more mx tactile grey keyboards being sold? RSI anyone? Hope I get more input from you guys that use (or have been using) mx tactile greys as a daily driver.
Cheers
-
It's not a very common switch to have a whole board 'full of them, I think there's 1 or 2 boards that have them elsewhere besides the spacebar?
but my GH60 has lubed/stickered Tactile Greys and I really love it. It's heavier than clears by a bit, but I am heavy handed. If it weren't lubed I don't think I could really do it, but to me it's smooth enough to make up for how heavy it is; I think it's the only MX switch I don't regularly bottom out on. I don't think I would recommend stock tactile greys, only lubed.
-
I've got a full size coolermaster XT with tactile grays. To me they ping by default, or maybe have a springier sound.
To me they are almost too heavy, I used to think I liked heavy switches but anymore I lean towards lighter switches.
Also I thought tactile grays would be more tactile but to me they felt less tactile which I guess makes sense since they are heavier.
-
I've got a full size coolermaster XT with tactile grays. To me they ping by default, or maybe have a springier sound.
To me they are almost too heavy, I used to think I liked heavy switches but anymore I lean towards lighter switches.
Also I thought tactile grays would be more tactile but to me they felt less tactile which I guess makes sense since they are heavier.
Yeah, they feel less tactile to me as well, and are indeed quite heavy.
-
I sometimes wonder about these stiffer switches. I bottom out most of the time on clears, which have a final force of something like 95g (according to DT). Greys have about 80g, so I have a feeling I might bottom out all the time.
-
I sometimes wonder about these stiffer switches. I bottom out most of the time on clears, which have a final force of something like 95g (according to DT). Greys have about 80g, so I have a feeling I might bottom out all the time.
Other than being heavier, they felt a lot like clears. I have found that it is really worth having a 60% with a plate that allows for switches to be opened without desoldering just for experimenting with things like this. Instead of buying a board with Greys, you could pretty much just swap springs in clears for something heavier 110g/120g!? and go from there. Way cheaper way to experiment.
-
I sometimes wonder about these stiffer switches. I bottom out most of the time on clears, which have a final force of something like 95g (according to DT). Greys have about 80g, so I have a feeling I might bottom out all the time.
The grays are definitely heavier and more fatiguing compared to clears.
-
I sometimes wonder about these stiffer switches. I bottom out most of the time on clears, which have a final force of something like 95g (according to DT). Greys have about 80g, so I have a feeling I might bottom out all the time.
The grays are definitely heavier and more fatiguing compared to clears.
Oh yeah, i like heavy switches, still, but these just weren't.....great to me. I generally use Buckling Springs as my ideal switch weight. For Cherry switches, I pretty much only have Greens, Clears, Zealio 67s on boards I actually use. Greys just seemed too heavy to me even, and didn't really feel like a "refined" switch, as I felt like they were slightly uneven in feel and sound, similar to how Whites usually are.
-
I sometimes wonder about these stiffer switches. I bottom out most of the time on clears, which have a final force of something like 95g (according to DT). Greys have about 80g, so I have a feeling I might bottom out all the time.
The grays are definitely heavier and more fatiguing compared to clears.
Oh yeah, i like heavy switches, still, but these just weren't.....great to me. I generally use Buckling Springs as my ideal switch weight. For Cherry switches, I pretty much only have Greens, Clears, Zealio 67s on boards I actually use. Greys just seemed too heavy to me even, and didn't really feel like a "refined" switch, as I felt like they were slightly uneven in feel and sound, similar to how Whites usually are.
Did you think grays has a very springy sound? It's kind of like when you get on an old mattress and it creeks.
-
I sometimes wonder about these stiffer switches. I bottom out most of the time on clears, which have a final force of something like 95g (according to DT). Greys have about 80g, so I have a feeling I might bottom out all the time.
The grays are definitely heavier and more fatiguing compared to clears.
Oh yeah, i like heavy switches, still, but these just weren't.....great to me. I generally use Buckling Springs as my ideal switch weight. For Cherry switches, I pretty much only have Greens, Clears, Zealio 67s on boards I actually use. Greys just seemed too heavy to me even, and didn't really feel like a "refined" switch, as I felt like they were slightly uneven in feel and sound, similar to how Whites usually are.
Greens feel way lighter than clears to me.
And I do bottom out most of the time on clears, which makes me wonder what a full keyboard of grays would feel like.
-
I sometimes wonder about these stiffer switches. I bottom out most of the time on clears, which have a final force of something like 95g (according to DT). Greys have about 80g, so I have a feeling I might bottom out all the time.
The grays are definitely heavier and more fatiguing compared to clears.
Oh yeah, i like heavy switches, still, but these just weren't.....great to me. I generally use Buckling Springs as my ideal switch weight. For Cherry switches, I pretty much only have Greens, Clears, Zealio 67s on boards I actually use. Greys just seemed too heavy to me even, and didn't really feel like a "refined" switch, as I felt like they were slightly uneven in feel and sound, similar to how Whites usually are.
Greens feel way lighter than clears to me.
And I do bottom out most of the time on clears, which makes me wonder what a full keyboard of grays would feel like.
Greens seem to "buckle" after the actuation/bump, where the Clears actuation curve don't just fall off making them feel heavier and harder to bottom out on. Greys were a lot like the clears in that regard, but the bump was less noticeable when typing at speed.
-
I sometimes wonder about these stiffer switches. I bottom out most of the time on clears, which have a final force of something like 95g (according to DT). Greys have about 80g, so I have a feeling I might bottom out all the time.
The grays are definitely heavier and more fatiguing compared to clears.
Oh yeah, i like heavy switches, still, but these just weren't.....great to me. I generally use Buckling Springs as my ideal switch weight. For Cherry switches, I pretty much only have Greens, Clears, Zealio 67s on boards I actually use. Greys just seemed too heavy to me even, and didn't really feel like a "refined" switch, as I felt like they were slightly uneven in feel and sound, similar to how Whites usually are.
Greens feel way lighter than clears to me.
And I do bottom out most of the time on clears, which makes me wonder what a full keyboard of grays would feel like.
Greens seem to "buckle" after the actuation/bump, where the Clears actuation curve don't just fall off making them feel heavier and harder to bottom out on. Greys were a lot like the clears in that regard, but the bump was less noticeable when typing at speed.
I don't notice the bump on clears when typing at speed.
-
I sometimes wonder about these stiffer switches. I bottom out most of the time on clears, which have a final force of something like 95g (according to DT). Greys have about 80g, so I have a feeling I might bottom out all the time.
The grays are definitely heavier and more fatiguing compared to clears.
Oh yeah, i like heavy switches, still, but these just weren't.....great to me. I generally use Buckling Springs as my ideal switch weight. For Cherry switches, I pretty much only have Greens, Clears, Zealio 67s on boards I actually use. Greys just seemed too heavy to me even, and didn't really feel like a "refined" switch, as I felt like they were slightly uneven in feel and sound, similar to how Whites usually are.
Greens feel way lighter than clears to me.
And I do bottom out most of the time on clears, which makes me wonder what a full keyboard of grays would feel like.
Greens seem to "buckle" after the actuation/bump, where the Clears actuation curve don't just fall off making them feel heavier and harder to bottom out on. Greys were a lot like the clears in that regard, but the bump was less noticeable when typing at speed.
I don't notice the bump on clears when typing at speed.
Compared to Greys, you will haha. The heaviness makes they feel even more linear than Clears can tend to feel.
-
So after reading all of your comments I can assume that greys aren't that good of a switch for everyday use because:
1. They are very fatiguing for prolonged use
2. They tend to squeek (ping) much more because of heavier spring
3. The tactile bump is a lot less pronounced compared to clears
Hm... Maybe it's me or my curiosity that drives me to use heavier switches.. I know this might sound stupid but I always felt heavier switch tend to be/feel "more mechanical".
Maybe greys would be a miss, and I should look for 67g springs to swap for the stock clear spring.
-
1. Man up and do some pushups on your fingertips.
2. Enjoy the oneness with ping.
3. Who needs a tactile bump when you're going to bottom out as much as possible?
-
go for it, i love my tactile greys over clears any day. my fingers do not fatigue. i am on the keyboard all day. mine do not squeek. i bottom out and no sounds other then the solid clack of the keycap. The tactile feels just like clears, but more intentional and solid/strong.
-
So after reading all of your comments I can assume that greys aren't that good of a switch for everyday use because:
1. They are very fatiguing for prolonged use
2. They tend to squeek (ping) much more because of heavier spring
3. The tactile bump is a lot less pronounced compared to clears
Hm... Maybe it's me or my curiosity that drives me to use heavier switches.. I know this might sound stupid but I always felt heavier switch tend to be/feel "more mechanical".
Maybe greys would be a miss, and I should look for 67g springs to swap for the stock clear spring.
I will say this. After years of trying keyboards, and trying to describe them or learn about them via text, the translation is never fully accurate. You really gotta just try it out yourself and see what you like. When trying out Greys you may think "oh, i see what they were talking about with that comment" but actually like them, or vice versa.
-
Yeah I agree.
With all the hate running around about MX blues being bad for gaming and MX greens being even WORSE for gaming, until I got my ducky shine 5 nature white, and my YOTG (Browns), I used my Shine fire 69 edition 24/7 for GAMING with *MX GREENS* and absolutely loved it.
If there was a RGB MX green switch that actually existed, there would be no need for any other switch.
I'd much rather buy a Shine 5 with MX greens than blues :(:(