geekhack

geekhack Community => Keyboards => Topic started by: y11971alex on Tue, 04 October 2016, 15:26:13

Title: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: y11971alex on Tue, 04 October 2016, 15:26:13
As stated in topic, should I invest in a Topre?  I heard it's highly recommended, but not quite sure about it :p
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: DALExSNAIL on Tue, 04 October 2016, 15:29:05
If you only want one topre, I highly suggest spacebar topre. Very nice.  :thumb:
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: y11971alex on Tue, 04 October 2016, 15:43:21
If you only want one topre, I highly suggest spacebar topre. Very nice.  :thumb:
I think I'm looking for an entire board :p
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: Jesse36m3 on Tue, 04 October 2016, 15:51:08
I wasn't sure about it either, but I jumped straight into a Realforce and I find it to be what I use the most for day to day typing because it's so comfortable.
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: Beanhead on Tue, 04 October 2016, 15:52:58
I've posted this a few times, but I switched from a V60 with MX Cherry Clears to a Leopold FC660C and could not be happier. Topre keys are wonderful to type on and I can't suggest them enough.
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: jonathanyu on Tue, 04 October 2016, 15:53:44
no
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: xtrafrood on Tue, 04 October 2016, 15:54:27
Yup
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: Moistgun on Tue, 04 October 2016, 15:55:45
Why not?

Whats the hesitation?
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: Bucake on Tue, 04 October 2016, 15:58:33
yo i'll trade one of mine for ya beam spring ^-^


edit: Honeywell rubber domes IBM 09F4230 <- if you like this keyboard, topre has a good chance of being liked (more).
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: Vagabond on Tue, 04 October 2016, 15:59:32
Realforce > HHKB
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: 1391406 on Tue, 04 October 2016, 17:52:57
Everyone who likes Topre will say yes. Those who don't will say no. Personally, I like Topre and would recommend the Realforce 104U if you prefer full sized boards, but that's me.
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: Erikdayo on Tue, 04 October 2016, 20:29:42
I think Topre is worth trying provided you don't mind selling for near retail value if you don't like what you got. When I first got a Realforce 45g I ended up getting rid of it soon after. Even though it was the nicest keyboard I had ever owned up to that point. I just felt the switches wouldn't be the best for me for gaming. And I think that's still true now.

 I recently picked up a FC660C that I love and have no plans to sell. When I had to do a lot of extended gaming recently I just busted out of the FC660M instead because I think it's less fatiguing for extended periods of gaming. And the linear feel of the Reds is just nicer for gaming, imo. For typing I prefer the Topre feel. I feel more precise and confident in my typing when I'm using a Topre compared to my Cherry MX Red. Currently I'm using my Topre for both typing and gaming because I can't be bothered to swap constantly. But if I'm playing for hours on end I'll probably swap in the FC660M again.

Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: y11971alex on Tue, 04 October 2016, 20:49:02
What's the difference between Realforce and Type Heaven?
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: Dyaems on Tue, 04 October 2016, 20:51:54
If you already tried a Topre board and liked it, go buy. Otherwise, don't :thumb:


What's the difference between Realforce and Type Heaven?

Type Heaven uses ABS keycaps AFAIK and probably lower build quality on the externals maybe? compared to Realforce.
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: y11971alex on Tue, 04 October 2016, 20:58:34
If you already tried a Topre board and liked it, go buy. Otherwise, don't :thumb:


What's the difference between Realforce and Type Heaven?

Type Heaven uses ABS keycaps AFAIK and probably lower build quality on the externals maybe? compared to Realforce.
The whole problem is that I haven't tried a Topre before.  Nobody does tours in Canada. :p
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: pesky brat on Tue, 04 October 2016, 21:02:17
What's the difference between Realforce and Type Heaven?

Type Heaven is Topre's budget keyboard; cheaper caps (pad printed ABS vs. dyesub PBT on a Realforce), less weight/heft to the board, and just an overall less premium experience. In my opinion, and I think others will agree, it's worth the extra $60 or so to get the Realforce. Also, I personally prefer 55g which is only available on the Realforce.
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: Dyaems on Tue, 04 October 2016, 21:17:34
If you already tried a Topre board and liked it, go buy. Otherwise, don't :thumb:


What's the difference between Realforce and Type Heaven?

Type Heaven uses ABS keycaps AFAIK and probably lower build quality on the externals maybe? compared to Realforce.
The whole problem is that I haven't tried a Topre before.  Nobody does tours in Canada. :p

Even someone you know who owns a Topre board? haha. What I did with my Topre purchase is through... blind buy  :cool:
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: y11971alex on Tue, 04 October 2016, 21:25:58
Yeah, nobody near Toronto has reached out to me :p
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: y11971alex on Tue, 04 October 2016, 21:39:54
Is it just me or is RF SSK cheaper than full size?  :eek:
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: Dyaems on Tue, 04 October 2016, 21:44:42
full size is generally more expensive then TKL simply because it has more keys/pcb parts/springs/domes/etc..
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: y11971alex on Tue, 04 October 2016, 21:46:25
full size is generally more expensive then TKL simply because it has more keys/pcb parts/springs/domes/etc..
I guess it's only on Model M that SSK is more expensive by severalfold.
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: E3E on Tue, 04 October 2016, 21:55:41
I prefer the way the fullsize looks, probably just because I'm accustomed to full-size vintages and the bulky case styling is reminiscent of that to me. The TKL design is a little more clumsy, imo. Space-wise, I definitely understand it though.

Topre's interesting. If I had jumped into Topre before Cherry MX (what I started with) and Alps (one true love), I probably would've absolutely adored it as the feel is similar to a rubber dome (and reminds me of the scissor switches I was used to typing on). There is something about the feel that is charming, but the clack of traditional mechanical switches is something I enjoy a bit too much.
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: y11971alex on Tue, 04 October 2016, 22:06:39
I prefer the way the fullsize looks, probably just because I'm accustomed to full-size vintages and the bulky case styling is reminiscent of that to me. The TKL design is a little more clumsy, imo. Space-wise, I definitely understand it though.

Topre's interesting. If I had jumped into Topre before Cherry MX (what I started with) and Alps (one true love), I probably would've absolutely adored it as the feel is similar to a rubber dome (and reminds me of the scissor switches I was used to typing on). There is something about the feel that is charming, but the clack of traditional mechanical switches is something I enjoy a bit too much.
How do they compare with other rubber domes?
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: Dyaems on Tue, 04 October 2016, 22:08:26
full size is generally more expensive then TKL simply because it has more keys/pcb parts/springs/domes/etc..
I guess it's only on Model M that SSK is more expensive by severalfold.

oh you are talking about model M SSK, i thought realforce TKL. SSK is i think harder to get, this is why it is so expensive!
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: 1391406 on Tue, 04 October 2016, 22:09:51
full size is generally more expensive then TKL simply because it has more keys/pcb parts/springs/domes/etc..
I guess it's only on Model M that SSK is more expensive by severalfold.

Namely because SSK Model M's are far more rare, whereas Realforce TKL's are just as prevalent as their full sized counterparts.
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: y11971alex on Tue, 04 October 2016, 22:11:09
full size is generally more expensive then TKL simply because it has more keys/pcb parts/springs/domes/etc..
I guess it's only on Model M that SSK is more expensive by severalfold.

oh you are talking about model M SSK, i thought realforce TKL. SSK is i think harder to get, this is why it is so expensive!
No.  I thought Topre SSK would be the same situation between 1401/1472.
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: E3E on Tue, 04 October 2016, 22:16:09
How do they compare with other rubber domes?

Compared to something run-of-the-mill full-travel rubber dome, its eons ahead.

It reminds me of what I'd imagine a full-travel scissor switch would feel like. It's snappy and has a pleasant rubbery thock to it.

I've heard it compared to some BTC slider over dome switches before:


It's definitely got a feel that's similar to a rubber dome, but it's just a more refined feel because of the slider and quality of the dome sheet, I think. Someone with more Topre or rubber dome experience might want to chime in.

It also reminds me of Alps SKCM Green and Alps SKCM Brown if you're familiar with those switches.
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: 1391406 on Tue, 04 October 2016, 22:22:09
What's the difference between Realforce and Type Heaven?

Type Heaven is Topre's budget keyboard; cheaper caps (pad printed ABS vs. dyesub PBT on a Realforce), less weight/heft to the board, and just an overall less premium experience. In my opinion, and I think others will agree, it's worth the extra $60 or so to get the Realforce. Also, I personally prefer 55g which is only available on the Realforce.

I own both and the Type Heaven actually weighs slightly more than my Realforce 104U. Personally, I prefer the look of my 104U / 87U, but after having swapped the domes from my Type Heaven with the domes in my 87U, I can tell you that the internals of the Type Heaven are qualitatively indistinguishable from the standard Realforce boards, at least as far as I can tell. Aesthetics aside though, the biggest difference comes down to the key caps(ABS vs. PBT), in my opinion.
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: 1391406 on Tue, 04 October 2016, 22:57:16
I prefer the way the fullsize looks, probably just because I'm accustomed to full-size vintages and the bulky case styling is reminiscent of that to me. The TKL design is a little more clumsy, imo. Space-wise, I definitely understand it though.

Topre's interesting. If I had jumped into Topre before Cherry MX (what I started with) and Alps (one true love), I probably would've absolutely adored it as the feel is similar to a rubber dome (and reminds me of the scissor switches I was used to typing on). There is something about the feel that is charming, but the clack of traditional mechanical switches is something I enjoy a bit too much.
How do they compare with other rubber domes?

I've owned my share of rubber domes boards, and while I think the feel of Topre is a bit similar to one of my favorite rubber domes, it's not as mushy, and thanks to the capacitive nature of Topre, I don't have to worry about keys not registering. In a typical rubber dome over membrane board, the dome has to make physical contact with the underlying sheets (pressing them together) to actuate a key. Thus, it's necessary to bottom out on every keystroke. That's not the case with Topre.

In my opinion, the way Topre domes are shaped lends itself to a feel that's unlike any rubber dome board I've ever used, the typing experience of which is extremely gratifying. Most rubber dome boards I've owned or used feel downright sloppy by comparison. The closest thing I can compare it to would be the Orange Alps switches in my Apple Extended Keyboard. It feels closer to a linear mechanical switch than a rubber dome, though 45g Topre switches have a softer bottom out than MX Brown switches, in my opinion.

That said, out of all the switches I've tried(see my signature), Topre is my favorite.
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: y11971alex on Tue, 04 October 2016, 22:59:59
Is it really different from Honeywell rubber domes?

(https://i.imgur.com/a3FhRfl.jpg)
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: 1391406 on Tue, 04 October 2016, 23:09:21
I've never used a Honeywell, but Topre keys definitely aren't stiff nor require as much actuation force as Buckling Springs.
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: rowdy on Wed, 05 October 2016, 04:19:35
Yes, or you will be forever wondering.

Or maybe one of those Top[re clone boards?  I believe they should have a feel similar to genuine Topre, and if you really like it then get a RealForce.
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: aaron6301 on Wed, 05 October 2016, 10:05:26
Sure, it might just be you're favorite switch. And like others have said, you will never know until you try.

When I received my first Topre board, a HHKB Type-S, I was a bit underwhelmed. After all the hype I've been reading about Topre being the end-all-be-all, I didn't quite understand. Perhaps it was the fact that I built it up so much in my head that it would be impossible for this keyboard to meet my expectations. In fact, the first time I typed on it, I actually disliked it quite a bit. Although, after putting in a little time, I now see why everyone was harping about the buttery smooth tactility that is Topre.

All that being said, it's worth the investment to try out. Worst comes to worst, you can always sell it and recoup all or nearly all of your funds.
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: Geroximo on Wed, 05 October 2016, 14:16:12
Get one as soon as possible.
The fact that you opened this thread already tells me that you're going to try out Topre sooner or later, so the sooner the better.
Try it out for at least a month.
Worst case: You sell it, you lose a bit of money, but at least you then know if Topre is for you or not.
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: xtrafrood on Wed, 05 October 2016, 14:27:06
Is it really different from Honeywell rubber domes?

Show Image
(https://i.imgur.com/a3FhRfl.jpg)


Does your Quiet Touch have rubber domes with springs? Sliders over dome right? Sliders over dome over membrane?
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: y11971alex on Wed, 05 October 2016, 14:27:50
Where's a good place to buy it?
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: y11971alex on Wed, 05 October 2016, 14:29:18
Is it really different from Honeywell rubber domes?

Show Image
(https://i.imgur.com/a3FhRfl.jpg)


Does your Quiet Touch have rubber domes with springs? Sliders over dome right? Sliders over dome over membrane?
Slider over spring over membrane.
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: zslane on Wed, 05 October 2016, 14:36:21
As modern tactile switches go, I don't see how you can get much better than Topre to be honest. So to my mind the question isn't whether or not you'll like Topre, but whether or not you'll like tactile switches.

There are really only three kinds of tactile switches made today:

1. MX Brown/Clear (and their clones)
2. Topre (and its clones)
3. Matias "Quiet Click"

I will have a chance to try out the Matias switch tomorrow when my KBP-60 arrives, but between MX and Topre there's simply no contest in my view. MX Browns just feel like broken MX Reds to me. The tactile experience of a Topre switch is really nice, and quite addictive.
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: dgneo on Wed, 05 October 2016, 14:41:19
Topre is always a sound investment!
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: y11971alex on Wed, 05 October 2016, 15:14:05
Topre is always a sound investment!
But where should I get one to avoid being ripped off by eBay?
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: HoffmanMyster on Wed, 05 October 2016, 15:19:44
Topre is always a sound investment!
But where should I get one to avoid being ripped off by eBay?

Elite Keyboards (http://www.elitekeyboards.com/) is a great place to buy Realforce (http://elitekeyboards.com/products.php?sub=topre_keyboards) and HHKB (http://www.elitekeyboards.com/products.php?sub=pfu_keyboards) boards, and they do ship to Canada.
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: xtrafrood on Wed, 05 October 2016, 15:25:38
Is it really different from Honeywell rubber domes?

Show Image
(https://i.imgur.com/a3FhRfl.jpg)


Does your Quiet Touch have rubber domes with springs? Sliders over dome right? Sliders over dome over membrane?
Slider over spring over membrane.

Wait what? IBM 73x3832? Yours is a different model? Not the same as the one with the Micro Switch ST & or Bud 115ST?

https://deskthority.net/wiki/IBM_73x3832_Quiet_Touch (https://deskthority.net/wiki/IBM_73x3832_Quiet_Touch)

(https://deskthority.net/w/images/thumb/0/0d/Bud-115ST-Black-Switch-1.jpg/800px-Bud-115ST-Black-Switch-1.jpg)
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: y11971alex on Wed, 05 October 2016, 15:28:02
Mine looks identical and has blue sliders.
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: HoffmanMyster on Wed, 05 October 2016, 15:29:18
Get out of this thread and buy a Topre board already.  ;)  Preferably a 55g Realforce or an HHKB, depending on your layout preference.
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: y11971alex on Wed, 05 October 2016, 15:38:07
Get out of this thread and buy a Topre board already.  ;)  Preferably a 55g Realforce or an HHKB, depending on your layout preference.
I also hear that the 55g version is highly praised, but I can't find a 55g Realforce in pearl/pebble, so I don't know where to begin.  Elitekeyboards.com is apparently out of them, and eBay sellers are charging a ridiculous premium above that.
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: HoffmanMyster on Wed, 05 October 2016, 15:40:36
Get out of this thread and buy a Topre board already.  ;)  Preferably a 55g Realforce or an HHKB, depending on your layout preference.
I also hear that the 55g version is highly praised, but I can't find a 55g Realforce in pearl/pebble, so I don't know where to begin.  Elitekeyboards.com is apparently out of them, and eBay sellers are charging a ridiculous premium above that.

EK says the ETA for a re-stock is Sept 2016.  Obviously that's come and gone, but it may be worth emailing EK to ask for an updated estimate on timing.  It's possible that they'll be coming back in stock very soon.  I personally wouldn't pay a premium for those boards, they always sell out and come back in stock (someone correct me if this trend has changed recently).
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: 1391406 on Wed, 05 October 2016, 16:35:49
Get out of this thread and buy a Topre board already.  ;)  Preferably a 55g Realforce or an HHKB, depending on your layout preference.
I also hear that the 55g version is highly praised, but I can't find a 55g Realforce in pearl/pebble, so I don't know where to begin.  Elitekeyboards.com is apparently out of them, and eBay sellers are charging a ridiculous premium above that.

The Keyboard Company (http://www.keyboardco.com/keyboard/usa-topre-realforce-87uw-55g-mini-black-on-beige-keyboard.asp) sells them, and given the shipping estimate based on my location in the states, it would cost about the same as EK for me.
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: yuppie on Thu, 06 October 2016, 04:50:16
As stated in topic, should I invest in a Topre?  I heard it's highly recommended, but not quite sure about it :p

yes
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: moh18one on Sun, 09 October 2016, 09:12:31
Yes and buy a Leopold FC980C https://geekhack.org/Smileys/solosmileys/wink.gif
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: xtrafrood on Sun, 09 October 2016, 09:55:14
Yes and buy a Leopold FC980C https://geekhack.org/Smileys/solosmileys/wink.gif

OR, silent cherry mx switch version. AND THEN, add some landing pads :cool:
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: Laurel on Sun, 09 October 2016, 10:07:27
When is the Leopold fc980 available?
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: xtrafrood on Sun, 09 October 2016, 10:11:31
When is the Leopold fc980 available?

Mechanicalkeyboards.com has an ETA of 11/10/2016 but I've noticed quite a few reviews on youtube. Maybe Leopold shipped to some mainland shops first?
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: mushman on Sun, 09 October 2016, 16:36:05
I've tried all the Topre keyboards and concluded that I prefer Plum (clones) better.

After 30 minutes to an hour of continuous typing on Topre my hands/wrists start to feel pain.  I don't know if this is because Topre is using a thicker more rigid metal backplate but I have absolutely no troubles whatsoever on Plum boards.

In addition Plum opens up options that Topre doesn't want to explore (ie: fullsize 55g/62g, tenkeyless 35g, etc...)

Topre may in fact be "higher quality" but for typing I can't go the distance on them.
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: iamtootallforthis on Sun, 09 October 2016, 16:44:37
I really enjoy Topre. I have a 55g Type-S HHKB. Looking forward to getting a hold of the FC980C and I also want to get a Silenced 55g UB.
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: Hypersphere on Sun, 09 October 2016, 17:03:44
Before buying my first Topre-switch keyboard, I read countless reviews and watched a number of videos. I was intrigued by the HHKB, but initially afraid of the layout. So, at first, I went with a compromise -- the Leopold FC660C. I liked the sound and feel of the Leopold, but at the time the keycap choices for this keyboard were limited to the stock brown and gold caps, and I didn't particularly like the layout. So, I gave the Leopold away and got a RF87UB45.

I wanted to try a heavier switch, so I got an RF87UB55. Finally, after agonizing over the seemingly alien layout, I went for a HHKB Pro 2. I liked it instantly -- the 60% form factor, the design and styling, the excellent dye-sublimated PBT keycaps, and especially the layout.

Since then, my keyboard collection has grown exponentially, and I have just about every form factor, layout, and switch type imaginable. I have an active keyboard rotation that includes quite a few boards, but I always come back to my all-time favorite, the HHKB.

All my Topre-switch boards are now lubed and silenced with my own Silencing Rings, which I think makes them even better, but the stock boards are quite nice to use as well. I have modded one of my HHKB boards to 55g domes -- it is fine, but I slightly prefer the stock 45g. I also have a Novatouch, but I prefer the RF87UB45 or RF87UB55. I have never tried a Type Heaven.

The RF87 boards provide a refined typing experience, but the HHKB is more fun. The difference between the two is sort of like driving a luxury sedan vs. a sports car.

If you happen not to like your Topre board, they have excellent resale value. You could then go for other premium switches, such as IBM Model F, IBM Model M, or various flavors of Alps and Alps clones. My own current ranking is approximately as follows:

Topre 45g ~ Topre 55g ~ IBM Model F > SKCM blue Alps ~ SKCM white Alps >  IBM Model M > Matias Click > Matias Quiet> SKCM brown Alps > >> Gateron yellow >> Cherry mx red

Good luck!
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: E3E on Sun, 09 October 2016, 17:16:25
Topre 45g ~ Topre 55g ~ IBM Model F > SKCM blue Alps ~ SKCM white Alps >  IBM Model M > Matias Click > Matias Quiet> SKCM brown Alps > >> Gateron yellow >> Cherry mx red

Good luck!

Hypersphere:

What causes Alps SKCM Brown to be placed so low on the list for you? I ask because many people consider it to be very reminiscent of Topre and enjoy it for the similarities they share. Is it simply too stiff for your liking?

It's certainly a lot louder, but I do feel they are similar. It's funny how preferences form for switch types. I much prefer Alps over Topre, though I do enjoy Topre. I think if I had found Topre first, I might've liked it more.
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: y11971alex on Sun, 09 October 2016, 17:46:00
Hypersphere, I already have both buckling spring switches and some experience with Alps :P
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: Hypersphere on Sun, 09 October 2016, 18:07:45
@E3E: I probably shouldn't attempt to rank-order my switch preferences! The difference in preference among some of them is very slight, and the order frequently changes, depending upon the phase of the moon and the relative humidity. ;)

Sometimes I really relish typing on my brown Alps board. There's a lot to like about it, including my favorite form factor (60%) and layout (HHKB). The brown Alps switches are a lot of fun -- the tactility is amazing. However, with a small unyielding stainless steel plate, the board gets fatiguing after a while.

@y11971alex: My apologies for telling you what you already knew. I sometimes go overboard with providing a full context for my explanations. If you try Topre, let us know how you like it compared to other switches.

It is really difficult to compare switches per se. So much depends upon the particular keyboard in which they are installed and, particularly with Alps, the history of the switches including how much dirt and wear they might have accumulated. Indeed, today I have been comparing two Leading Edge DC-3014 keyboards. Both boards have SKCM blue Alps switches. The only differences are that one case has been painted and the keycaps are different, yet I find that the boards have noticeable differences in feel and sound. Doing a side by side comparison, I can choose a favorite. Yes, I like the blue Alps better than the blue Alps!

Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: Bucake on Sun, 09 October 2016, 20:25:14
i enjoy your posts hypersphere :D
always nicely written sentences and sound formatting, just great to read
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: E3E on Sun, 09 October 2016, 20:38:09
@E3E: I probably shouldn't attempt to rank-order my switch preferences! The difference in preference among some of them is very slight, and the order frequently changes, depending upon the phase of the moon and the relative humidity. ;)

Sometimes I really relish typing on my brown Alps board. There's a lot to like about it, including my favorite form factor (60%) and layout (HHKB). The brown Alps switches are a lot of fun -- the tactility is amazing. However, with a small unyielding stainless steel plate, the board gets fatiguing after a while.

@y11971alex: My apologies for telling you what you already knew. I sometimes go overboard with providing a full context for my explanations. If you try Topre, let us know how you like it compared to other switches.

It is really difficult to compare switches per se. So much depends upon the particular keyboard in which they are installed and, particularly with Alps, the history of the switches including how much dirt and wear they might have accumulated. Indeed, today I have been comparing two Leading Edge DC-3014 keyboards. Both boards have SKCM blue Alps switches. The only differences are that one case has been painted and the keycaps are different, yet I find that the boards have noticeable differences in feel and sound. Doing a side by side comparison, I can choose a favorite. Yes, I like the blue Alps better than the blue Alps!

Oh wow, do you mean your Leading Edge DC-2014 or did you actually pick up a second Leading Edge DC-3014?

Yes, I completely agree, Hypersphere, it is very difficult to compare switches outright. There are objective differences between each kind of switch which can lead to a more general preference, but keyboards are always more than just a sum of their parts. :P Echoing how you feel about Alps SKCM Browns in a stiff plate, I felt very much the same way with Alps SKCM Amber when I used them in a keyboard with a carbon fiber plate and just felt they were way too harsh for my fingers. 
 
Alps seem to have a more delicate relation with case and plate material other switches. I can at least say that I've never felt that Cherry MX Clears were too harsh depending on plate material. Alps, however... Yeah, very sensitive to plate material and case.
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: Hypersphere on Mon, 10 October 2016, 08:09:37
Thanks, Bucake!

@E3E: Yes, I was very lucky in being able to find a second DC-3014 soon after the first. I will post some pics and impressions soon.
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: moh18one on Tue, 11 October 2016, 10:19:10
Leopold FC980C all day all night ! The layout is quite impressive. Wow can't wait more to get this keyboard
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: E3E on Tue, 11 October 2016, 11:35:36
Using my Ducky Realforce and it's always nice to type on. I see it as a board I can use to take a break from my other mechanical keyboards, kind of like a palate cleanser.

I don't like Topre more than Alps, but there is something luxurious-feeling about it. Probably influenced a bit by the price tag and the premium quality that surrounds Topre. I just think it's got a refined feel for a dome with slider board. It's a blend of interesting tech to come together into something that does have a luxurious feel.

I think Topre, for me, is a bit nostalgic but also a foil to rubber dome boards I grew up with. I love scissor switches, still, and these remind me of those, but they also make me conscious of the fact that a rubber dome can be great if designed well. Topre's design is pretty clever in how it imbues the characteristics of a traditional mechanical switch (slider, actuation that doesn't require full travel, etc) into a slider with dome design.
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: y11971alex on Sun, 12 February 2017, 19:21:29
Elitekeyboards.com remains out of stock at February.  It looks like I'll be going for a Type Heaven

http://www.ebay.ca/itm/172486403870
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: happylacquer on Sun, 12 February 2017, 21:26:32
Elitekeyboards.com remains out of stock at February.  It looks like I'll be going for a Type Heaven

http://www.ebay.ca/itm/172486403870

Despite what everyone says complaining about the Type Heaven, it seems perfectly fine to me. I plan to get one soon to complement my HHKB.
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: zslane on Sun, 12 February 2017, 21:48:58
I wouldn't exactly call a Type Heaven an investment. But it is certainly a decent way to dip one's toes into the Topre waters.
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: y11971alex on Sun, 12 February 2017, 21:54:56
I wouldn't exactly call a Type Heaven an investment. But it is certainly a decent way to dip one's toes into the Topre waters.
In case I don't like the Realforce, I can sell it for around 80% of its purchase value, right?
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: 1391406 on Sun, 12 February 2017, 22:14:13
I wouldn't exactly call a Type Heaven an investment. But it is certainly a decent way to dip one's toes into the Topre waters.
In case I don't like the Realforce, I can sell it for around 80% of its purchase value, right?

You should know fairly rapidly whether you like it. If you use it for a day or two and don't like it, sell it. 75% - 80% of the original cost isn't unreasonable assuming you package it up neatly in the original box and sell it as a like new item.

Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: 1391406 on Sun, 12 February 2017, 22:17:05
By the way, all of the 104U's on EK are listed as in stock.
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: y11971alex on Sun, 12 February 2017, 22:52:28
By the way, all of the 104U's on EK are listed as in stock.
But I don't want to buy the variable weight ones  :eek:
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: happylacquer on Sun, 12 February 2017, 23:01:11
I wouldn't exactly call a Type Heaven an investment. But it is certainly a decent way to dip one's toes into the Topre waters.
 


Even for some of us keyboard fans 120 is a decent chunk of change
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: y11971alex on Sun, 12 February 2017, 23:04:07
I wouldn't exactly call a Type Heaven an investment. But it is certainly a decent way to dip one's toes into the Topre waters.
 


Even for some of us keyboard fans 120 is a decent chunk of change
Well, the keyboard hobby for me is auto-financing.  Which means I do, as a matter of fact, by some keyboards as investments.
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: happylacquer on Sun, 12 February 2017, 23:14:12
I wouldn't exactly call a Type Heaven an investment. But it is certainly a decent way to dip one's toes into the Topre waters.
 


Even for some of us keyboard fans 120 is a decent chunk of change
Well, the keyboard hobby for me is auto-financing.  Which means I do, as a matter of fact, by some keyboards as investments.

Nice I do that with headphones. I have been selling headphone mods for years and it has paid off nicely.
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: zslane on Sun, 12 February 2017, 23:36:16
I wouldn't exactly call a Type Heaven an investment. But it is certainly a decent way to dip one's toes into the Topre waters.
 


Even for some of us keyboard fans 120 is a decent chunk of change
Well, the keyboard hobby for me is auto-financing.  Which means I do, as a matter of fact, by some keyboards as investments.

Sure. I just wouldn't expect a Type Heaven to qualify as one. It is unlikely to ever fetch more than you paid for it, adjusting for inflation.
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: 1391406 on Sun, 12 February 2017, 23:44:05
By the way, all of the 104U's on EK are listed as in stock.
But I don't want to buy the variable weight ones  :eek:

You can always buy one from Taobao with the help of a purchasing agent such as taobaofocus.com (http://taobaofocus.com).
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: happylacquer on Sun, 12 February 2017, 23:45:16
By the way, all of the 104U's on EK are listed as in stock.
But I don't want to buy the variable weight ones  :eek:

You can always buy one from Taobao with the help of a purchasing agent such as taobaofocus.com (http://taobaofocus.com).

This and whatever you do, don't use mistertao. They're a bunch of ****ers.
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: y11971alex on Sun, 12 February 2017, 23:47:31
I am quite able to deal in Chinese, so I don't need a proxy.  In fact, I'd be happy to be a proxy for anyone here.   :D
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: ArchDill on Sun, 12 February 2017, 23:53:54
By the way, all of the 104U's on EK are listed as in stock.
But I don't want to buy the variable weight ones  :eek:

You can always buy one from Taobao with the help of a purchasing agent such as taobaofocus.com (http://taobaofocus.com).

I just looked into this... So you pay the first price and then do you pay something again when it is delivered to the Proxy?
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: y11971alex on Mon, 13 February 2017, 00:17:09
Many of the Topre listings on Taobao are in fact proxy purchases.  So if you use a proxy on these items, they'll be imported from Japan to China and then shipped to wherever you live.  Shipping and handling will take time.

Generally speaking, I expect shipments to arrive from China in around 8 working days.
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: happylacquer on Mon, 13 February 2017, 01:03:46
By the way, all of the 104U's on EK are listed as in stock.
But I don't want to buy the variable weight ones  :eek:

You can always buy one from Taobao with the help of a purchasing agent such as taobaofocus.com (http://taobaofocus.com).

I just looked into this... So you pay the first price and then do you pay something again when it is delivered to the Proxy?

in my experience you pay for the items and domestic shipping, when they get everything, they figure out shipping rates to you and tell you what you owe for shipping to you.
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: MperorM on Mon, 13 February 2017, 01:37:13
as someone who just bought a leopold fc890c from a shop in korea, I would say that you should do everything in your power to try it out first. Topre really is a unique keyboard feeling. My daily driver is a stiff alps keyboard, so usually I lean towards heavy, stiff and clicky switches that make a lot of noise when you press them. However I went into the store without any intention of buying anything and the   45 g topre switches completely won me over. They feel absolutely amazing to type on, fantastic sound, amazing feel. I would describe them like this: Imagine a rubber dome keyboard if it felt good to type on.

However I can absolutely imagine that someone might hate topres, and I think that a lot of people who buy them feel complied to love them after shelling out 200-300 dollar for them. I would never blindly buy a topre board, and I would never have bought them if I didn't have a chance to try them out first. I did not expect to like them at all, since they are pretty much the opposite of the usual switches I prefer, but I made a 180 on them.
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: 1391406 on Mon, 13 February 2017, 02:52:09
I think that a lot of people who buy them feel complied to love them after shelling out 200-300 dollar for them.

I can see that being the case for something you can't recoup most of your money on, but that's not true for Topre.

Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: y11971alex on Mon, 13 February 2017, 02:53:47
I have something along the lines of a 87-key model with 55g domes incoming. 
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: Hypersphere on Mon, 13 February 2017, 08:23:04
as someone who just bought a leopold fc890c from a shop in korea, I would say that you should do everything in your power to try it out first. Topre really is a unique keyboard feeling. My daily driver is a stiff alps keyboard, so usually I lean towards heavy, stiff and clicky switches that make a lot of noise when you press them. However I went into the store without any intention of buying anything and the   45 g topre switches completely won me over. They feel absolutely amazing to type on, fantastic sound, amazing feel. I would describe them like this: Imagine a rubber dome keyboard if it felt good to type on.

However I can absolutely imagine that someone might hate topres, and I think that a lot of people who buy them feel complied to love them after shelling out 200-300 dollar for them. I would never blindly buy a topre board, and I would never have bought them if I didn't have a chance to try them out first. I did not expect to like them at all, since they are pretty much the opposite of the usual switches I prefer, but I made a 180 on them.
This doesn't seem strange to me at all. In my own case, my favorite switches before I started using Topre on a regular basis were IBM membrane buckling spring (Model M) and IBM capacitive buckling spring (Model F). After trying Topre, I added Topre 45g and 55g to my favorites list. More recently, I have added clicky Alps (blue, white, and clicky hybrids) to the list. The common thread among these seemingly disparate switch types appears to be a similar sort of tactility.

Topre didn't cause me to abandon other tactile switches, but now I spend most of my typing time on my HHKB Pro 2. The others are in my keyboard rotation, but I always gladly return to Topre in general and the HHKB in particular.

Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: evilpacket on Mon, 13 February 2017, 09:27:17
topres are worth it.
usually considered pleasant to type on by most people, or at least before they see the pricetag...
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: 1391406 on Mon, 13 February 2017, 13:26:11
You can see a small sampling of the keyboards I've tried in my signature, and of all the ones I've used I ended up settling on Topre.
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: y11971alex on Wed, 22 February 2017, 13:57:01
(http://i.imgur.com/IWnhL78.jpg)
(http://i.imgur.com/M4GzIJh.jpg)
(http://i.imgur.com/tdqzuRs.jpg)
(http://i.imgur.com/Cb8fdDi.jpg)
(http://i.imgur.com/bJi6hlP.jpg)
(http://i.imgur.com/Qeh0TDh.jpg)
(http://i.imgur.com/VCBudlB.jpg)
(http://i.imgur.com/xkOcL7r.jpg)
(http://i.imgur.com/juSQgmT.jpg)
(http://i.imgur.com/UIdC1n8.jpg)
(http://i.imgur.com/4QSPeUr.jpg)
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: kmba on Sat, 25 February 2017, 00:53:42
You did it!  :thumb:

Hope you're enjoying it. 

I fully disagree with the notion that people hype topre boards, or are prone to "like them" just because they shell out over $200.  My modded fc660c is my least costly board aside from the Model Ms I've owned for 30 years!!!  And yet it's my daily driver.  thock.


thock.
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: yuppie on Mon, 27 February 2017, 14:21:57
Answer is still: yes
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: 1391406 on Mon, 27 February 2017, 19:38:51
Now that you have one, what do you think?
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: y11971alex on Mon, 27 February 2017, 20:50:13
I'll quote my post on Deskthority.

It's not the smoothest, the most tactile, or the best built keyboard, but it scores very high on all these aspects.  IMO, it combines almost all keyboard virtues in an unassuming, convenient package.  It is a very well-rounded keyboard.

I think we can all name keyboards that score higher than the Realforce in any one or more than one of these aspects, but to name one that beats the Realforce squarely on all these aspects, it would be a challenge.  In terms of switch feel, beam springs are definitely smoother, more tactile, more pleasant to type on, and (much) better build quality, but you make sacrifices on layout and ergonomics (or lack thereof) with beam springs. 
Title: Re: Should I invest in a Topre
Post by: E3E on Mon, 27 February 2017, 23:03:39
I've always enjoyed Realforce as a palate cleanser to my Alps collection, especially since mine is the silenced variant, so the contrast in loudness is much more noticeable. I have to say though, my NCR Alps board is very quiet for using standard (not dampened) Alps switches. It's probably as quiet as a stock Realforce. I think it's a mixture of the case and the thick ABS caps that do it. 
 
But the Realforce is nice. The mysticism built around Topre made me imagine something much greater than it really is (which is why I sold my variable Topre board almost right after receiving it), but it is a good switch. It's high quality in contrast to its contemporaries, essentially one of the few OEM keyboards that bring the build quality of premium keyboards from the '80s into the present.

Despite using rubber domes, I don't find them to be the most comfortable switch out there. I'd say Alps Plate Spring is the most comfortable switch I've ever used. I agree with Alex that the Realforce is just very well-rounded, which makes for a pleasant experience.