would love to see comparisons to dev tty. Stepped caps are looking cool though
This looks really similar to MT3 profile aside from the exotic keys
Interested, do you have any idea about manu costs or even what manu to go through?I do. Let me put it to you this way, if I was personally going to produce them (and I'm not), I wouldn't do it with anything less than $200k of cash on hand.
would love to see comparisons to dev tty. Stepped caps are looking cool thoughThis looks really similar to MT3 profile aside from the exotic keys
Perhaps stylistically, but I would consider that a compliment. Profile wise, it's actually far closer to Cherry and Filco (OEM) Profile.Show Image(https://i.imgur.com/9K08VGj.png)
SSS is superimposed in blue over the corresponding profile in red. From the top down is SA, MIX, Filco (OEM), and Cherry.Interested, do you have any idea about manu costs or even what manu to go through?I do. Let me put it to you this way, if I was personally going to produce them (and I'm not), I wouldn't do it with anything less than $200k of cash on hand.
But who is actually going to manufacture it?
So it's like a more aggressively sculpted spherical Cherry? I like.There are a couple of parties interested, but I can't say one way or another. Nine times out of ten these things fall through.
But who is actually going to manufacture it?
Pricing wise for a set of these would they be comparable to anything like a GMK set, or is that too far off to give a rough estimate?That would depend on so many factors, but I would say it is unlikely they would cost less for a comparable set.
had me at topre compatibility.
The question it has to answer is "what are you bringing to the table that's better?" The marketplace is getting a lot more crowded.I couldn't agree with you more. With exciting new profiles and vendors popping up (seemingly) every few months, it takes an awful lot to stand out these days.
Two or three years ago, just saying "we've got sphericals and can ship something in less than Signature Plastics' 18-month turnaround time" would be enough.
But now you've got vendors like Maxkey saying "here's a complete set, $100 out the door, in several popular colours right now". And I'm even seeing some no-name places offering PBT sphericals
I have several switches that I have also been working on, and they are all Topre mount. These caps, while compatible with Cherry MX mounts, are ultimately intended to be used with those switches, so if the caps happen, they will be Topre native, and Cherry MX compatible.had me at topre compatibility.
^this. very interested if this comes true
[It] takes an awful lot to stand out these days.
To my mind, the true value proposition of any profile comes down to the aesthetic options made available to designers, and the calibre of the designers drawn to the profile. In other words, how many colors will be available? How easy will it be to request/make custom legends? Will triple shot be available? Will lens shots be available? Will front legends be possible? Will dye-sub PBT be an option? What surface textures will be available?This is one of the meta type questions that I can answer with surety. I am not a vendor. I am a designer. Everything about the design of this product is designer-biased. I have designed the dishes to be universally compatible across rows (sans convex), and I have designed the molds to allow for complex flow paths on the legend plates. These caps could be triple, even quadruple shot. As far a touch surface textures go, I think something like semi-matte would have to be standard, because otherwise differences in texturing between the legend plates and the dishes will lead to bleeding issues. Yes, textures have depth.
A compelling keycap profile is of little value if custom sets can't be designed with attractive colors, clean legend fonts and creative novelties, all at reasonable prices. Moreover, the fewer design options available to designers, the less likely the profile will attract the more skilled designers. And without them, your profile will struggle mightily for marketplace exposure and relevance.
Currently typing on Mt3, and I can confirm, dye sub quality for everything but the cyrillics is ****. I love the look of SA, but personally I find it a terrible profile to actually type on. That said, many people love them, and the lead times are INSANE.[It] takes an awful lot to stand out these days.
Honestly it really doesn’t, it’s still very much a seller's market.
MT3 has had one complete pre‐order and they dropped the ball in a few ways (piss‐poor legend alignment, poor color QC, legend ****‐ups in a few kits, big ass delay...). All Chinese manufacturers of high profile caps are inflexible or have quality issues. Lead times are universally high. Sure, plenty of IC’s, but not very many shipped products.
SP SA is basically the only guaranteed product that is accessible, flexible, and quality — but it isn’t totally unproblematic (sprue on sides, middling QC as to color, etc.) and takes close to a year to ship. On
top of that, the profile itself is unspectacular (doubly so for the Chinese PBT sets with the inferior 2‐3‐3‐3‐3 sculpt) and most people prefer something with more of a sculpt along the lines of what you have here (hence the chomping at the bit for /dev/tty).
I don’t think it’s fair to say that the market for high profile spherical sets is ‘getting crowded’ when:
- topre sets go for hundreds of percent markups and they don’t even fit the boards people are putting them on
- alps sets are all rare, vintage, yellowed, esoteric in layout, unobtainable, or some combination thereof
- blanks barely exist
- SA makes up a huge majority of enthusiast sets and much of the increase in options are manufacturers retreading that ground and failing to improve
- ALL lead times of pre‐orders are counted in months
- SA sets STILL (despite the perception of the community’s interest explosion having slowed) get flipped immediately after shipping with hundreds of sets sold
I'm watching this thread for Topre compatibility. And from your comparison pic, I still can't quite make out how different it is to MT3. However, that is a pretty good place to start with since there isn't really a market for custom Topre keysets. Personally I have to use Topre MX sliders to use MT3. People who are sworn by the ONLY stock-Topre keycaps gospel can sod off, surely more options is always better.I have a few Topre boards and I think aftermarket sliders are ****. I think that's most people's hangup, not necessarily that the caps aren't OEM. I think the best designers will designers will design for the best profile, and a few have already expressed interest.
Pricing can be relatively high at the very beginning as the average Topre owners are used to spending more money than MX-users counterparts to get what they want, but naturally other profiles will get cheaper and begs the question: slider swap + MX sets are much better value?
The first set can be the classic beige, similar to how MT3 went, but I also agree with zslane that you really need to get big designers to either bring their signature designs or come up with new attractive ones for the profile to stay relevant for a long time. And they will only come if your profile can support their wildest and craziest ideas.
...Everything about the design of this product is designer-biased.
Anyway, my point is, I'm with you.
I guess we are at odds on your first point. I am not at all satisfied with any of the current spherical offerings. As a matter of fact, my preference is Cherry, SS2, and OEM, in that order. Notice there are no spherical options in my preferences. I find them all very compromised. Hence, why I am developing this profile. If you are satisfied with the current offerings, this profile might not be for you....Everything about the design of this product is designer-biased.
Anyway, my point is, I'm with you.
That's great to hear.
I guess my ultimate point is that I have many spherical sets already (SA, DSA, and MT3) that I really love. At this point, a new spherical profile in and of itself is of little interest to me as I already have that base well and truly covered. The only thing that will make me part with my money is a set design that I find irresistible. That's why I say this profile's value proposition (for me) all comes down to the set designs that are made with it, not the fact that it is uniquely sculpted.
I will say that the possibility of getting Topre-compatible sets is intriguing, but again, I would probably only get excited by that if a set design came along that I simply couldn't pass up (e.g., Space Cadet).
I guess we are at odds on your first point. I am not at all satisfied with any of the current spherical offerings. As a matter of fact, my preference is Cherry, SS2, and OEM, in that order. Notice there are no spherical options in my preferences. I find them all very compromised. Hence, why I am developing this profile. If you are satisfied with the current offerings, this profile might not be for you.
Well, the problem with injected molded plastics is the cost barrier of entry is really high, and once that barrier is cleared, the operating costs are really low. That said, premium quality caps are still really hard to come by, the only options in the market being GMK, SP-SA, and Gateron-ePBT.I guess we are at odds on your first point. I am not at all satisfied with any of the current spherical offerings. As a matter of fact, my preference is Cherry, SS2, and OEM, in that order. Notice there are no spherical options in my preferences. I find them all very compromised. Hence, why I am developing this profile. If you are satisfied with the current offerings, this profile might not be for you.
Just want to say that I completely agree with you on this point and I don't think you're alone. Existing options for spherical keycaps are pretty mediocre, which is probably why there has been so much interest in new profiles lately. For actual typing my favorite spherical would probably be Mix (though the dishes on those are so shallow they're barely even spherical...), but the current design options for that are...limited to say the least. It's funny that while I say I like spherical keycaps I probably own more GMK sets than anything...
At the same time if all the new profiles that are being worked on actually make it to market it could be a little overwhelming. I mean SP is working on DSS, there's Hub, Novelkeys has something in the works, etc. We're also finally starting to see new sets in Mix profile and maybe we'll see some more MT3s as well. While more choice is certainly a good thing I wonder if there is actually a big enough market for all of these...