I like the free scrolling myself. It's a lot less jarring on the index/middle finger than a standard mechanical scroll. So if I'm scrolling web pages or documents for say 3-4 hours straight (I've done this on many occasions...), the free scrolling definitely saves your finger some pain.
In games however, I much prefer the mechanical scroll.
and no it does not take away the "third mouse button" click.
Show Image(http://www.ergonomictouchpad.com/images/ergonomictouchpadscroll.gif)
There is a reason why it is not being used. :)
I'd agree on it being a nice piece of mechanical engineering, but I do not really like using the free scroll. On top of that, it takes away the standard middle click, replacing it with the mechanical scroll mode switch. On this particular mouse (RX1500), there is a dedicated middle click button, but the position makes it unusable.
Anyhow, I feel the free scroll is usable mainly when you want to scroll directly to the bottom of some document/webpage. In such case I'd rather just grab the scroll bar, and drag it down. I'm sorry, Logitech.
RX1500 is the way to go for Contour mod. Press scroll wheel to change modes.
A quick scrolling mod would be to add this velcro stick on touchpad.
(http://www.ergonomictouchpad.com/ergonomic_touchpad.php)Show Image(http://www.ergonomictouchpad.com/images/ergonomictouchpadscroll.gif)
Haven't tried it. Waiting for someone else to go first.
I am talking about the mice & trackballs like DT225, ExpertMouse & CST, all have a little resistance that helps when you are nearing the click area and need to decelerate.
??
Posting here mainly to keep track of the progress and any people who might be interested in getting rid of their scroll wheel assemblies eventually. I too am looking for one to use in a project. I got to visit a store and try out the scrolls. Unfortunately, some of the ones people appear very fond of are no longer made and I have to get a second hand one to even try out the wheel.
So I guess HyperScroll didn't catch on…just a marketing gig for a couple years? Too bad because it's really neat. I have the scroll wheel that you press to change function. Doesn't work the way I would like and so I want to get the wheel that has a button to press to change the HyperScroll back and forth from clicky to smooooooth spinnnnning…. dang, AND I need to get some model numbers too. Crap. A lot changed the last 2 years while I hibernated.
"So I guess HyperScroll didn't catch on…just a marketing gig for a couple years? Too bad because it's really neat. "
I disagree. I think it is a good feature not implemented correctly. Also the overall scroll mechanism is out of favor due to being somewhat jarring, and flimsy (I think!!!) after few hours use. So a lot of guys may be using the arrow cluster/page navigation keys instead.
Some model numbers from my notes:
hyperscroll models: logitech Marathon M705, vx revolution (portable), mx revolution, performance mx,
m500,G500,G9 (low tracking rate cap),g9x,MX620,M555b bluetooth(portable) Anywhere Mouse MX,
RX1500-push wheel to change modes, middle click is button behind wheel.
Another interesting find MX1100...
Is there even more variant to this mechanism? I read somewhere that there is something called hyper scrolling and the newer term is hyper-fast scrolling. In hyper-srolling they had an additional control that could disable the hyper mode via software; this mode is different than what we are getting now a days (the extra button thing), i.e. when you spin the wheel really hard (above a set threshold), free spins and scrolls extremely quickly. Before the threshold it works as a regular scroll wheel.
This definitely is another different mechanism. What model can this be? There is vx nano that allows disabling of the hyperscroll from software. Some hint at mx revolution also does that.
Elrick... Does yours do this?
Summary of Logitech Performance MX and MX Revolution after having taken them apart and examined the scrolling mechanisms. I might look into the others with similar functionality.
MX Revolution:
-Electronically engaged free spin-function. It can thus be toggled both through software and by pressing a button when on, but on the other hand requires power to toggle this functionality. It can also toggle when you are scrolling above a certain speed for instance. Mine almost sounds like the shutter of a camera when it engages.
-The side scrolling is discrete. It clicks from side to side which makes it far easier to click the scroll wheel without accidentally scrolling horizontally.
Although with my version I hear no switching as you select a setting. It just clicks instantly when anything is selected, unfortunately doesn't sound anything like a camera shutter.