Author Topic: Switch testing question  (Read 1165 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline Isl1ngt0n

  • Thread Starter
  • Posts: 3
Switch testing question
« on: Sat, 09 May 2020, 20:15:07 »
I'm pretty new to the hobby, I just got my first couple sets of switches and I'm looking for a few recommendations on approaches to switch testing. My first real mechanical board is the Drevo BladeMaster Pro with browns, that I picked up as an early bird on kickstarter, It had a lot of features I thought wanted at the time. During a trip to Europe I did some damage to one of the stabs and the "C" key, I repaired the issues easily enough, but it got me thinking about modding the board, the switches feel loose and dry now that I've acclimated to the feel of a mechanical board, also they're barely tactile to my fingers at this point(particularly the repaired "C"); I started lurking here after that and now I have a full custom on order and went and picked up a couple different sets of tactile switches. I was thinking I could replace a region of keys on the BladeMaster as test to see what I liked or didn't like about the switches I purchased before building a complete board with them. So how misguided am I in my approach? is there a particular region I should replace or is it better to just do the whole board at once? Should i just leave it and take advantage of the fact the cherry browns can be opened and lube them and live with what it is? Professionally I service and calibrate electro-mechanical equipment, so this isn't about technique or the work involved, really its about methodology and approach to learning about my taste so that I waste too much time spinning my wheels on bad ideas and get to build a couple of boards for work and home I can enjoy in all the ways that this board has been disappointing.

 

Offline cari66ean

  • Posts: 26
Re: Switch testing question
« Reply #1 on: Sun, 10 May 2020, 14:20:27 »
Yeah you could order a switch tester (though be sure to also get some smooth linears in there just in case you get to realize that you actually do prefer smoothness over tactility). From then on you can sort out which switches you seem to like and which are a no go (in that instance I should mention that springs can always be swapped if you don't like the weight and that lube makes a hell of a difference too!).

Well and then I recommend using at least 4 switches (which you can place on the home row) to see how it feels under the whole hand. Sometimes switches tend to feel "light" when you are just pressing on a single one in a switch tester, whereas they can actually feel much heavier when actually typing with multiple fingers. Trying 4 switches on the home row will give you a very very close to "real usage" experience, while still being relatively affordable if you want to make sure they fit your taste.

Offline Isl1ngt0n

  • Thread Starter
  • Posts: 3
Re: Switch testing question
« Reply #2 on: Wed, 13 May 2020, 19:52:28 »
Awesome thanks! I'm thinking I will switch out right hand home row then. I wasn't sure if that was actually a reasonable approach, or which keys being swapped would be the most appropriate for that kind of test. Your point about living with the keys for a minute is exactly why I thought this might be the right approach for me.