Seems like we're pretty much done here then. I'm a little concerned that we don't seem to have settled much - knowing SP, this situation will repeat itself in the future
I see mistaken batches as cursed bonus extras... they wouldn't come about if it wasn't for the original group buy, and there's a
potential large profit, but it would take many months to realise, if ever, and the Org is in an awkward situation that they didn't intend.
So in that sense, I don't see it as purely orthogonal to the tiers/extras debate, just as another form of extras. It doesn't mean that anyone was ripped off in the original GB.
I launched into this debate because I think it's wrong to attack anyone without being able to back up the accusations with solid facts, that properly address the whole picture. It's not valid to highlight one part of someone's deal with SP, and use it to smear the rest of it. It's even less valid to use it to smear someone's character.
Above all, it's just fundamentally wrong for a small clique to try and hound anyone off the forum. If the moderators choose not to ban someone, then live with it - vendettas are bad for the community.