Author Topic: Illuminated keys vs Non-illuminated - Does one last longer than the other?  (Read 2018 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline ModusPwnens

  • Thread Starter
  • Posts: 14
Hi, I did a search on this but it yielded no results for me. Here is my question: Does an illuminated keyboard last as long as a non-illuminated? I imagine that you would have to use a special coating or something to let the light shine through, and I have even seen keys from illuminated keyboards that have some white surface on the underside of the key, which I assume lets the light through. Is there a chance of rubbing lettering off or light bleeding through the coating eventually?

Offline sixty

  • Posts: 984
    • http://deskthority.net
Illuminated keys vs Non-illuminated - Does one last longer than the other?
« Reply #1 on: Tue, 04 January 2011, 14:34:05 »
The wiki should be able to answer most of your questions, but I'll do it anyway:

Basically there are two common ways for illuminated keys.

The first: Make a clear/milky keycap and paint it black, leave out the letter when painting it. This is the most common method and will eventually wear off. Depending on the company and plastics use this can happen in a very short time. There have been several reports of Logitech and Razer illuminated keys wearing off extremely quick. Example:



The same goes for most Laptop keyboards that use the same method.

Second: Basically the same base idea as mentioned before, but instead of painting the black part is being "dyed" into the key under heat. This means that the paint will soak into the plastic and stay there. This method has been patented by TG3 for their illuminated keyboards. Since Deck is a daughter company of TG3, they use this method too. Its known to last for pretty much forever. You are more likely to spill something over your keyboards* before the keys wear off.

As for normal, non-illuminated keys there are various different materials and labeling methods and they all vary. Double-shot keycaps and dye-sublimated keycaps (same as the TG3 method described above) will basically last forever. Lasting forever is exactly what the problem of these technologies was. Lasting longer than the keyboards they are being used on is not optimal in terms of production costs, which is why these methods are nowadays only found on vintage keyboards or special equipment.

The most common labeling technology nowadays is laser-engraving. This means that the letters on the keycap are being "burned out" with a laser and then optionally filled with "paint" on black keyboards. This will also last very long but is known to have a much lower contrast than double-shot molding or dye-sublimation.

For more details, please check the "all about keys" entry in the wiki.

Offline Pylon

  • Posts: 852
Illuminated keys vs Non-illuminated - Does one last longer than the other?
« Reply #2 on: Tue, 04 January 2011, 14:51:57 »
The first one that Sixty mentioned is known as the "cell phone lettering" method around here, since almost all cell phones use this method for their backlit keypads, and is used on pretty much 99% of backlit keyboards. It basically involves coating a translucent white plastic key with black paint, and then burning the paint off with a laser (thus exposing the white plastic underneath) to form the letter. The printing is very crisp, which is one of its main advantages. Durability will vary. My Dell E6410 laptop uses this method for its backlit keyboard, and it's not doing too well. It's only about 2 months old (though I bought it refurbished, but the keyboard came practically new) and I'm not a particularly heavy typist, but the spacebar and some of the heavier used keys are already shiny, but no worn off lettering yet.

Read:
http://geekhack.org/showwiki.php?title=Das+S+Lasered+Keys+Versus+Filco+Pad+Printed+-+FIGHT#Overview+of+Different+Lasering+Techniques (scroll down a bit)

Also, do they make any backlit keyboards with double shot keys? It seems almost like the perfect tech for backlit keyboards.