Bakelite is brown or black, this should be some early plastic.
Well, Bakelite IS an early plastic. In fact it is the first synthetic plastic (celluloid is earlier, but it is organically based), dating from around 1910 for commercial production. Of course sawdust, cotton, paper, linen or carbon black were often used as a filler, so only the resin part of it is always truly synthetic.
Because of the fillers used, most real Bakelite (made using the original process) is opaque black or brown, but other colors like white, yellow, red and green could be made; however, an essentially identical phenolic resin that was made by a different process not needing binders was made under the brand name Catalin. Most of the really colorful "Bakelite" was actually Catalin as it was made without fillers and was essentially transparent to begin with, so could be dyed in manufacturing into almost any color, even translucent and marbled.
Bakelite, however, has become the generic name for all phenol-formaldehyde plastics despite it originally being a brand name, like Kleenex for tissues, etc.
Most very early typewriter keys were either wood or celluloid, often with surrounding rings and mountings of metal and tops of glass or early translucent plastic. In the 40s and 50s they started making the high-profile double-shot keys like those on the HH, probably out of "Bakelite", but not positive. If it is VERY heat resistant, it's "Bakelite". If it melts anywhere near the temp of boiling water it is one of the newer plastics developed during or after WWII (PVC, Styrene, etc.) There are ways of testing other than heating, however.
I make no warranty about the following test for "Bakelite", so use at your own risk:
"Formula 409 - Test on a small area, preferably on the back side of a piece or the inside of a bracelet. Put a small amount on a swab and rub on the test area for a few seconds. If it is bakelite, the swab develops a yellowish residue no matter what color the plastic is. After testing, be sure to immediately wash the area with a mild dishwashing soap and warm water and towel dry immediately. Formula 409 is superior to other methods, as it does not strip the finish."