The smaller "SSK" keyboards are more rare and desirable and cost 2x-3x what the full-sized boards do, as do the "industrial" models with an olive-gray-green case.
Otherwise, early-1990s models probably carry a $10 premium over late-1990s models, late-1980s are probably $10 more than 1990s, and square metal badge models perhaps $10 more than that. If the low end of the range is $50 + shipping in the US, the high end is probably just over $100.
With new Unicomps going for ~$80 + shipping, used IBMs will generally cluster around that. And remember, if you need replacement keys from Unicomp because something is missing, that is likely to be at least another $10 order.
While I'm no means a expert on the model M, I started out by posting a wanted ad on Craigslist which netted me two decent Model Ms for free. I bought another at a Hamfest (Amateur radio fleamarket) for $15 and two more on ebay for around $30 each. I've bolt modded all but one which isn't that hard if you take your time. But my post here is really about UniComp.
I've only bought 1 original keycap from them and I wish I didn't, the pad printing is heavier then the OEM and it stands out like a sore thumb.
The springs they sell are quietier so keep that in mind if re-building a keyboard.
I'm happy with the RGB keycaps they sell, again the printing is heavier but its not a noticeable since the key is R,G,B.
I purchased two new barrel frames from them as my OEM we're beyond repair. They worked well but they're not an exact match. There's an extra post so you need to remember not to drill it and bolt it other wise you will damage your keyboard.
Personally I prefer full-size keyboards because I use the number-pad but I see the appeal of the smaller form factor but not so much the price.
Phosphorglow makes a nice USB controller and Orhalicon stocks converter cables that work well also.
Mine range from late 80's to late 90's they all work equally well and unless you're looking for a square badge to add to a collection I'd go with a late 90's as a daily 'driver' if only for the fact that they barrel frame has a spill channel in it.
The one thing I'll leave you with is don't believe the Auctions saying they have a 1984 Model M. That's a copyright date not a manufacture date and I've seen some people try and grab premium money for a late 90's keyboard trying to say it's a rare first generation. Always get a picture of the build label on the back.