Author Topic: [IC] KAT Atlantis | UPDATE #11: Final Mats 2/17  (Read 56426 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline slxdegrees

  • Posts: 241
  • Location: Oriath
  • i write nice things to make people buy stuff
Re: [IC] KAT Atlantis | UPDATE #2: Deskmat added & more kit changes!
« Reply #150 on: Thu, 31 October 2019, 20:37:03 »
Wew what a huge update indeed! Every tatse seems to have been catered for sans the Ortho/40s bit. And that deskmat, it's gorgeous! I mean it when I say I can't wait for this to run.

Sent from my LYA-L29 using Tapatalk


Offline psxndc

  • Posts: 198
Re: [IC] KAT Atlantis | HUGE UPDATE: New kits/Changes!
« Reply #151 on: Fri, 01 November 2019, 13:04:13 »
-Added Deskmat

I like the Deskmat. What size will it be?

Offline Rensuya

  • Thread Starter
  • Posts: 345
  • Location: NC
  • Blue is my spirit animal
    • Link to the discord!
Re: [IC] KAT Atlantis | HUGE UPDATE: New kits/Changes!
« Reply #152 on: Fri, 01 November 2019, 14:29:40 »

Offline LightenS

  • Posts: 4
Re: [IC] KAT Atlantis | UPDATE #2: Deskmat added & more kit changes!
« Reply #153 on: Fri, 01 November 2019, 19:06:52 »
Love <3.

Now I am in with Ergo and Colemak!

Offline ref

  • Posts: 20
  • Location: China,Xi'an
Re: [IC] KAT Atlantis | UPDATE #2: Deskmat added & more kit changes!
« Reply #154 on: Sun, 03 November 2019, 11:53:22 »
For the 3u, for the minila..

Offline Hell-es

  • Posts: 197
  • Location: Bavaria
Re: [IC] KAT Atlantis | UPDATE #2: Deskmat added & more kit changes!
« Reply #155 on: Sun, 03 November 2019, 12:01:59 »
Argh, i‘m crazy for different country layouts ... now i have to buy greek and korean .... normal alphas have to go ;) .... this will end up as expensive as milkshake.

Offline Adelscott

  • Posts: 130
  • Location: ISO-FR
Re: [IC] KAT Atlantis | UPDATE #2: Deskmat added & more kit changes!
« Reply #156 on: Sun, 03 November 2019, 15:00:24 »
Argh, i‘m crazy for different country layouts ... now i have to buy greek and korean .... normal alphas have to go ;) .... this will end up as expensive as milkshake.
Along with french you mean ?

Offline depletedvespene

  • Posts: 519
  • Location: Chile
  • Old, used-up vespene geyser.
    • Keyboard-related resources.
Re: [IC] KAT Atlantis | UPDATE #2: Deskmat added & more kit changes!
« Reply #157 on: Mon, 04 November 2019, 05:51:24 »
Argh, i‘m crazy for different country layouts ... now i have to buy greek and korean .... normal alphas have to go ;) .... this will end up as expensive as milkshake.

You just wait until I popularize the Iberoamerican layout among the masses. ;)

Offline harlekein

  • Posts: 242
Re: [IC] KAT Atlantis | UPDATE #2: Deskmat added & more kit changes!
« Reply #158 on: Mon, 04 November 2019, 08:40:53 »
Can we get some Korean/Greek renders? Wondering what that will look like with the mods.

Offline SomeGreekGuy

  • Posts: 3
  • Location: Greece
Re: [IC] KAT Atlantis | UPDATE #2: Deskmat added & more kit changes!
« Reply #159 on: Mon, 04 November 2019, 10:16:38 »
As a Greek, the Greek letters seem off. And the lack of ;/: in the "Q" position def kills it for me, I'm sorry.

Offline Hell-es

  • Posts: 197
  • Location: Bavaria
Re: [IC] KAT Atlantis | UPDATE #2: Deskmat added & more kit changes!
« Reply #160 on: Mon, 04 November 2019, 12:16:09 »
Argh, i‘m crazy for different country layouts ... now i have to buy greek and korean .... normal alphas have to go ;) .... this will end up as expensive as milkshake.
Along with french you mean ?

Gladly for me, this are the normal letters, just in different rows .... oh moment ... didn‘t realize the top row with cedille ;) ok... but at least thats affordable


Argh, i‘m crazy for different country layouts ... now i have to buy greek and korean .... normal alphas have to go ;) .... this will end up as expensive as milkshake.

You just wait until I popularize the Iberoamerican layout among the masses. ;)
Yeah and maya letters, nordic runes, klingon, elvish ...

Offline MdotMaxson

  • Posts: 217
Re: [IC] KAT Atlantis | UPDATE #2: Deskmat added & more kit changes!
« Reply #161 on: Fri, 08 November 2019, 20:13:01 »
Nice. The icon mods got finished. And even the ergo set has all custom icons. Ok dammit I can’t pass up anything that has an ergo offering. Although I like this set and won’t be buying it just purely to increase demand and popularity of ergo kits. I’ll be getting it to possibly use it or give to gf

Offline MdotMaxson

  • Posts: 217
Re: [IC] KAT Atlantis | UPDATE #2: Deskmat added & more kit changes!
« Reply #162 on: Fri, 08 November 2019, 20:15:39 »
Oh and great job. Also looking forward to the Greek alphas. I love any kinda foreign alphabet that makes it mono instead of as sub legends. I try to get most all of them like weirdos, MT3 Elven, dsa force awakens, etc

Offline MadBinton

  • Posts: 6
  • Location: Europe
  • Settled linear 65/75% user
Re: [IC] KAT Atlantis | UPDATE #2: Deskmat added & more kit changes!
« Reply #163 on: Sat, 09 November 2019, 12:56:23 »
Just noticed how this could actually "naturally" fill a Race 3.

Guess I'll move my Eternal set over to a to be build 65% and move this over to the Race.

No GB just yet? So probably around Q2 2020?

Anyway, + 1 Alpha's + Mods + Creatures from me. If you could supply that through an European supplier that would be awesome.

Offline unicorn855

  • Posts: 1
  • Location: Germany
Re: [IC] KAT Atlantis | UPDATE #2: Deskmat added & more kit changes!
« Reply #164 on: Sat, 09 November 2019, 14:39:33 »
If you could supply that through an European supplier that would be awesome.

I think the plan is for  mykeyboard.eu to proxy it <3

Offline Senor Coconut

  • Posts: 74
  • Location: EU
  • FR (ISO or not)
Re: [IC] KAT Atlantis | UPDATE #2: Deskmat added & more kit changes!
« Reply #165 on: Sun, 10 November 2019, 07:21:23 »
French ISO ? Count me in!
,,,

Offline shoujoA

  • Posts: 3
Re: [IC] KAT Atlantis | UPDATE #2: Deskmat added & more kit changes!
« Reply #166 on: Thu, 21 November 2019, 05:22:33 »
Would it be possible to add R3 and R2 1u keys (2 each) to the ergo kit, for boards that support 1u inner mod columns like the Sol 2/Boardwalk?

Other than that, gotta say I'm really glad there are custom icons for the kits!

Offline Rensuya

  • Thread Starter
  • Posts: 345
  • Location: NC
  • Blue is my spirit animal
    • Link to the discord!
Re: [IC] KAT Atlantis | UPDATE #2: Deskmat added & more kit changes!
« Reply #167 on: Thu, 21 November 2019, 10:29:34 »
Would it be possible to add R3 and R2 1u keys (2 each) to the ergo kit, for boards that support 1u inner mod columns like the Sol 2/Boardwalk?

Other than that, gotta say I'm really glad there are custom icons for the kits!
I'll look into it. Can you provide me with an example?

Offline shoujoA

  • Posts: 3
Re: [IC] KAT Atlantis | UPDATE #2: Deskmat added & more kit changes!
« Reply #168 on: Thu, 21 November 2019, 23:35:57 »
Would it be possible to add R3 and R2 1u keys (2 each) to the ergo kit, for boards that support 1u inner mod columns like the Sol 2/Boardwalk?

Other than that, gotta say I'm really glad there are custom icons for the kits!
I'll look into it. Can you provide me with an example?

Here you go! Thanks for considering!

Offline Rensuya

  • Thread Starter
  • Posts: 345
  • Location: NC
  • Blue is my spirit animal
    • Link to the discord!
Re: [IC] KAT Atlantis | UPDATE #2: Deskmat added & more kit changes!
« Reply #169 on: Fri, 22 November 2019, 18:45:46 »
Would it be possible to add R3 and R2 1u keys (2 each) to the ergo kit, for boards that support 1u inner mod columns like the Sol 2/Boardwalk?

Other than that, gotta say I'm really glad there are custom icons for the kits!
I'll look into it. Can you provide me with an example?

Here you go! Thanks for considering!
Thanks, I'll look these over and update the kit!

Offline Rensuya

  • Thread Starter
  • Posts: 345
  • Location: NC
  • Blue is my spirit animal
    • Link to the discord!
Re: [IC] KAT Atlantis | UPDATE #2: Deskmat added & more kit changes!
« Reply #170 on: Mon, 25 November 2019, 14:07:08 »
Would it be possible to add R3 and R2 1u keys (2 each) to the ergo kit, for boards that support 1u inner mod columns like the Sol 2/Boardwalk?

Other than that, gotta say I'm really glad there are custom icons for the kits!
I'll look into it. Can you provide me with an example?

Here you go! Thanks for considering!

I updated the kit!


Offline Rensuya

  • Thread Starter
  • Posts: 345
  • Location: NC
  • Blue is my spirit animal
    • Link to the discord!
Re: [IC] KAT Atlantis | UPDATE #2: Deskmat added & more kit changes!
« Reply #171 on: Mon, 25 November 2019, 16:38:21 »
Update #3: I hope everyone has a good thanksgiving!

Today I just have some more changes/additions I have been meaning to make. You can find these and others in the "UPDATES" at bottom of main most.

As of 11/25/19
-Removed extra mod tilde & pipe keys in alphas, greek alphas, korean alphas
-Removed Extra 5 in numpad (no homing in KAT)
-Removed Additional tab key from alt alphas (better used in GMK)
-Added 1.5 backspace to icon/text mods
-Added Missing convex labeling for 40s/ortho
-Added Missing convex labeling for spacebars kit
-Added Additional pgup/pgdn and bracket keys for ergo kit (for Sol 2/Boardwalk)
-Added Single bracket key to R2 of Colvrak kit (request of Dvorcol)

*All changes are reflected in updated kit images on main most

Offline piit79

  • Posts: 262
Re: [IC] KAT Atlantis | UPDATE #2: Deskmat added & more kit changes!
« Reply #172 on: Mon, 25 November 2019, 16:42:19 »
-Removed Extra 5 in numpad (no homing in KAT)

No homing keys in KAT at all? Not even F/J? Or am I misunderstanding?

Offline Rensuya

  • Thread Starter
  • Posts: 345
  • Location: NC
  • Blue is my spirit animal
    • Link to the discord!
Re: [IC] KAT Atlantis | UPDATE #2: Deskmat added & more kit changes!
« Reply #173 on: Mon, 25 November 2019, 16:55:02 »
-Removed Extra 5 in numpad (no homing in KAT)

No homing keys in KAT at all? Not even F/J? Or am I misunderstanding?

KAT only has barred no scoop. So bar is standard.

Offline harlekein

  • Posts: 242
Re: [IC] KAT Atlantis | UPDATE #3: More kit changes 11/25/19
« Reply #174 on: Tue, 26 November 2019, 04:53:58 »
If you aren't going to split 40s and ortho, can you add two 1.5u space bars to the kit?

Offline Rensuya

  • Thread Starter
  • Posts: 345
  • Location: NC
  • Blue is my spirit animal
    • Link to the discord!
Re: [IC] KAT Atlantis | UPDATE #3: More kit changes 11/25/19
« Reply #175 on: Tue, 26 November 2019, 10:04:59 »
If you aren't going to split 40s and ortho, can you add two 1.5u space bars to the kit?
What board/boards use 1.5 bars?

Offline shoujoA

  • Posts: 3
Re: [IC] KAT Atlantis | UPDATE #2: Deskmat added & more kit changes!
« Reply #176 on: Tue, 26 November 2019, 10:08:28 »
Would it be possible to add R3 and R2 1u keys (2 each) to the ergo kit, for boards that support 1u inner mod columns like the Sol 2/Boardwalk?

Other than that, gotta say I'm really glad there are custom icons for the kits!
I'll look into it. Can you provide me with an example?

Here you go! Thanks for considering!

I updated the kit!

Show Image


Once again, thank you for being so receptive! Q2 can't come soon enough :)

Offline harlekein

  • Posts: 242
Re: [IC] KAT Atlantis | UPDATE #3: More kit changes 11/25/19
« Reply #177 on: Tue, 26 November 2019, 10:18:07 »
If you aren't going to split 40s and ortho, can you add two 1.5u space bars to the kit?
What board/boards use 1.5 bars?
Corne, Atreus, Minidox and the like.

Stand alone ortho kits usually have them, but whenever they get thrown in with 40s they are lost.

Offline Rensuya

  • Thread Starter
  • Posts: 345
  • Location: NC
  • Blue is my spirit animal
    • Link to the discord!
Re: [IC] KAT Atlantis | UPDATE #3: More kit changes 11/25/19
« Reply #178 on: Tue, 26 November 2019, 10:55:13 »
If you aren't going to split 40s and ortho, can you add two 1.5u space bars to the kit?
What board/boards use 1.5 bars?
Corne, Atreus, Minidox and the like.

Stand alone ortho kits usually have them, but whenever they get thrown in with 40s they are lost.

Ok, currently looking into it  :thumb:

Offline Rensuya

  • Thread Starter
  • Posts: 345
  • Location: NC
  • Blue is my spirit animal
    • Link to the discord!
Re: [IC] KAT Atlantis | UPDATE #3: More kit changes 11/25/19
« Reply #179 on: Tue, 26 November 2019, 12:08:27 »
If you aren't going to split 40s and ortho, can you add two 1.5u space bars to the kit?
What board/boards use 1.5 bars?
Corne, Atreus, Minidox and the like.

Stand alone ortho kits usually have them, but whenever they get thrown in with 40s they are lost.

I was meaning to make some changes I'd forgotten about to the 40s anyway so I went ahead and did those and added those bars  ;)

Offline bliss

  • Posts: 44
Re: [IC] KAT Atlantis | UPDATE #3: More kit changes 11/26/19
« Reply #180 on: Wed, 27 November 2019, 09:44:49 »
Thanks very much for giving us an ISO kit, especially with those novelty keys :D

I would definitely top it off with an R2 \| so that, with one swift stroke(tm), two ISO variants are supported (US + UK).

For your consideration... thank you!

Offline Rensuya

  • Thread Starter
  • Posts: 345
  • Location: NC
  • Blue is my spirit animal
    • Link to the discord!
Re: [IC] KAT Atlantis | UPDATE #3: More kit changes 11/26/19
« Reply #181 on: Wed, 27 November 2019, 21:10:10 »
Thanks very much for giving us an ISO kit, especially with those novelty keys :D

I would definitely top it off with an R2 \| so that, with one swift stroke(tm), two ISO variants are supported (US + UK).

For your consideration... thank you!

It's there  :thumb:

Offline bliss

  • Posts: 44
Re: [IC] KAT Atlantis | UPDATE #3: More kit changes 11/26/19
« Reply #182 on: Thu, 28 November 2019, 08:55:10 »
Thanks very much for giving us an ISO kit, especially with those novelty keys :D

I would definitely top it off with an R2 \| so that, with one swift stroke(tm), two ISO variants are supported (US + UK).

For your consideration... thank you!

It's there  :thumb:

 :) You're the best!

Offline Jignoni

  • Posts: 10
Re: [IC] KAT Atlantis | UPDATE #3: More kit changes 11/26/19
« Reply #183 on: Mon, 02 December 2019, 21:02:58 »
loving the kits (yay for IS support  :thumb:)
can't wait for this to go live

Offline MdotMaxson

  • Posts: 217
Re: [IC] KAT Atlantis | UPDATE #3: More kit changes 11/26/19
« Reply #184 on: Wed, 04 December 2019, 01:52:54 »
So damn excited for that ergo kit

Offline harlekein

  • Posts: 242
Re: [IC] KAT Atlantis | UPDATE #3: More kit changes 11/26/19
« Reply #185 on: Wed, 04 December 2019, 03:51:38 »
I know this is superlate to say something like this. I was pondering which alphas would be a great match with the icons. While I have been asking for Hangul monolegend in other sets, but in this set I don't think it's a great fit.

I think this kit would really be amazing with an alpha kit in the same style as the mod icons. Just putting this out there. I know it's late and probably not realistic to expect a complete new alpha design at this point.

Offline Kettu

  • Posts: 1
Re: [IC] KAT Atlantis | UPDATE #3: More kit changes 11/26/19
« Reply #186 on: Wed, 04 December 2019, 07:05:46 »
Have you considered separating the ortho/40s? Shouldn't be a problem with KAT MOQ and people using either layout won't end up with half of the keys being unused.

Offline Rensuya

  • Thread Starter
  • Posts: 345
  • Location: NC
  • Blue is my spirit animal
    • Link to the discord!
Re: [IC] KAT Atlantis | UPDATE #3: More kit changes 11/26/19
« Reply #187 on: Wed, 04 December 2019, 16:59:56 »
I know this is superlate to say something like this. I was pondering which alphas would be a great match with the icons. While I have been asking for Hangul monolegend in other sets, but in this set I don't think it's a great fit.

I think this kit would really be amazing with an alpha kit in the same style as the mod icons. Just putting this out there. I know it's late and probably not realistic to expect a complete new alpha design at this point.

When you say in the same style as the mods, do you mean like make custom alphas that are "Atlantean" themed?

Offline harlekein

  • Posts: 242
Re: [IC] KAT Atlantis | UPDATE #3: More kit changes 11/26/19
« Reply #188 on: Thu, 05 December 2019, 03:57:14 »
I know this is superlate to say something like this. I was pondering which alphas would be a great match with the icons. While I have been asking for Hangul monolegend in other sets, but in this set I don't think it's a great fit.

I think this kit would really be amazing with an alpha kit in the same style as the mod icons. Just putting this out there. I know it's late and probably not realistic to expect a complete new alpha design at this point.

When you say in the same style as the mods, do you mean like make custom alphas that are "Atlantean" themed?

Yes indeed.

Offline MadBinton

  • Posts: 6
  • Location: Europe
  • Settled linear 65/75% user
Re: [IC] KAT Atlantis | UPDATE #3: More kit changes 11/26/19
« Reply #189 on: Tue, 10 December 2019, 15:25:53 »
While I don't really read the alpha's anyway, I'm not sure going full custom atlantean symbols on a custom alpha set would be all that appealing. It might be cool looking and fitting the icon mods very well, I'm not sure I'd buy that.

As with a elven language alphabet or Star Wars Empire signing on alpha's they tend to give a board a pretty weird vibe and make it unusable to others in a household. And it's a lot of work do design for no other reason than a cool look.

I might love it if they are done, but I'm also having strong reservations against buying them.

Offline harlekein

  • Posts: 242
Re: [IC] KAT Atlantis | UPDATE #3: More kit changes 11/26/19
« Reply #190 on: Wed, 11 December 2019, 04:19:18 »
And it's a lot of work do design for no other reason than a cool look.

To be fair, that's 99% of all keycaps.

Offline dgooglr

  • Posts: 2
Re: [IC] KAT Atlantis | UPDATE #3: More kit changes 11/26/19
« Reply #191 on: Wed, 18 December 2019, 04:58:18 »
Registered to geekhack, just to say. Wow this looks amazing!

Offline SighKenny

  • Posts: 11
Re: [IC] KAT Atlantis | UPDATE #3: More kit changes 11/26/19
« Reply #192 on: Thu, 19 December 2019, 21:58:00 »
Please come out with this haha! I've been looking for a sea/marine themed key set

Offline Rensuya

  • Thread Starter
  • Posts: 345
  • Location: NC
  • Blue is my spirit animal
    • Link to the discord!
Re: [IC] KAT Atlantis | UPDATE #3: More kit changes 11/26/19
« Reply #193 on: Sun, 22 December 2019, 16:47:48 »
Please come out with this haha! I've been looking for a sea/marine themed key set
Don't worry it's coming Q1 2020. More renders coming as well

Offline Bleddyn

  • Posts: 55
  • Location: United Kingdom
Re: [IC] KAT Atlantis | UPDATE #3: More kit changes 11/26/19
« Reply #194 on: Sat, 28 December 2019, 19:18:21 »
Greek Alphas with the icon mods is a perfect combo i feel, shame the coolest novelty is on ISO enter as even as a UK based person i tend to use ANSI, all in all though this is fantastic.

Offline Symbiote

  • Posts: 14
  • Location: Denmark
Re: [IC] KAT Atlantis | UPDATE #2: Deskmat added & more kit changes!
« Reply #195 on: Wed, 08 January 2020, 07:13:56 »
Greek

As a Greek, the Greek letters seem off. And the lack of ;/: in the "Q" position def kills it for me, I'm sorry.

I think this has been missed, so I'll emphasize it (maybe SomeGreekGuy will confirm) -- the current Greek kit is only 99% the Greek layout. The confusion might be because many Greek keyboards include Qwerty symbols as well.

The letter "Q" doesn't exist in Greek, so the Q key should instead be ; : (semicolon bottom, colon top).

The key to the right of Λ should be ´ ¨ (acute accent bottom, diaresis accent top -- should line up with ' and " on the next key).  This is used in combination with vowels to type άέήίόύώ, ϊϋ and even ΐΰ (e.g. for ΐ, by pressing ´ then ¨ then ι).

I think by "seem off", SomeGreekGuy might also mean the font -- are the letters hand drawn? Capital theta needs to have space between the "-" part and the "O" part, it shouldn't touch like a lowercase theta: θ but have a gap as in Θ.

Similarly, the capital psi should be like a U crossed with an I; it shouldn't be like a rounded W with a tail -- one curve, not two: Ψ.

I'm less sure about this, but the omega should probably have less or no vertical "legs": Ω.

Finally, I think the "final sigma"  is probably slightly misaligned, as it's actually a lowercase letter. (Uppercase sigma is Σ, lowercase σ is used within words and ς used if it's the last letter of a word: Ὀδυσσεύς = Odysseus.) The "tail" belongs below the line, and the "C" part should be a little smaller than "Ε" or any other capital.  I realize this might look slightly odd, but presumably doesn't look any more odd to a Greek than resulting alignment of "_" or "°" keys on other layouts. 

Θ Ψ Ω ς 

https://www.123rf.com/photo_120615365_greek-keyboard-top-view-of-keys-from-a-black-classic-desktop-keyboard-isolated-on-white-full-alphabe.html is the best picture I can find of a Modern Greek only keyboard (as opposed to Ancient Greek, used by classical historians, or a 2000s+-keyboard, which includes English letters too.)

(If this all seems pedantic, bear in mind that even "tiny" errors like an upside-down capital S would be noticeable.)

French

I'll also strongly suggest replacing * M with * µ on the French layout. In this case, µ isn't a lowercase letter: it's the micro symbol, as in "a hair is about 75µm thick", which could only be capitalized as "75µm THICK", since "75MM" is at best undefined, and at worst might be read as 75mm, 1000× larger,. (Or consider that I can't capitalize "the download runs at 10Mb/s" as "10MB/s", since 10MB/s = 80Mb/s.)

But I don't want either of these kits anyway...

Ergo

I'm interested in either the Orth or Ergo kit -- probably the Ergo kit, as it has many more 1U R1 keys, and lots of 1U thumb keys on my Ergodash (70 keys total).

The current Ergo render shows some duplicates amongst the 1U R1 keys, namely:
- three Alt/Option keys (if that's the wavy line with a dot below and above)
- three Sys keys (diamond with a centre dot)
- three of the ones with three horizontal lines
- two home (swishy up arrow)
- two end (swishy down arrow)

Pairs of icon mod keys are excellent (I can have Alt, Ctrl, Sys on each side, or use them alone for pretty much anything), but three of the same seems a bit excessive, so I think this is five redundant keys.

Personally, I'd prefer:
- two 1U R1 shift keys
- a 1UC R1 space key
- a 1U R1 enter key
- a 1U R1 backspace key
That still leaves the normal four arrows, three arrow pairs (PgUp/Down, Home/End, maybe that's Raise/Lower), four modifier pairs and delete. That gives plenty of flexibility for larger orth, split, or 3D keyboards.

Hopefully this is useful feedback, it's an excellent design, even if on a board with entirely 1U keys I can't make use of the best novelties.

Offline vudu

  • Posts: 2
Re: [IC] KAT Atlantis | UPDATE #3: More kit changes 11/26/19
« Reply #196 on: Thu, 09 January 2020, 10:58:21 »
SO IN!!!

Offline Rensuya

  • Thread Starter
  • Posts: 345
  • Location: NC
  • Blue is my spirit animal
    • Link to the discord!
Re: [IC] KAT Atlantis | UPDATE #2: Deskmat added & more kit changes!
« Reply #197 on: Thu, 09 January 2020, 11:28:34 »
Greek

As a Greek, the Greek letters seem off. And the lack of ;/: in the "Q" position def kills it for me, I'm sorry.

I think this has been missed, so I'll emphasize it (maybe SomeGreekGuy will confirm) -- the current Greek kit is only 99% the Greek layout. The confusion might be because many Greek keyboards include Qwerty symbols as well.

The letter "Q" doesn't exist in Greek, so the Q key should instead be ; : (semicolon bottom, colon top).

The key to the right of Λ should be ´ ¨ (acute accent bottom, diaresis accent top -- should line up with ' and " on the next key).  This is used in combination with vowels to type άέήίόύώ, ϊϋ and even ΐΰ (e.g. for ΐ, by pressing ´ then ¨ then ι).

I think by "seem off", SomeGreekGuy might also mean the font -- are the letters hand drawn? Capital theta needs to have space between the "-" part and the "O" part, it shouldn't touch like a lowercase theta: θ but have a gap as in Θ.

Similarly, the capital psi should be like a U crossed with an I; it shouldn't be like a rounded W with a tail -- one curve, not two: Ψ.

I'm less sure about this, but the omega should probably have less or no vertical "legs": Ω.

Finally, I think the "final sigma"  is probably slightly misaligned, as it's actually a lowercase letter. (Uppercase sigma is Σ, lowercase σ is used within words and ς used if it's the last letter of a word: Ὀδυσσεύς = Odysseus.) The "tail" belongs below the line, and the "C" part should be a little smaller than "Ε" or any other capital.  I realize this might look slightly odd, but presumably doesn't look any more odd to a Greek than resulting alignment of "_" or "°" keys on other layouts. 

Θ Ψ Ω ς 

https://www.123rf.com/photo_120615365_greek-keyboard-top-view-of-keys-from-a-black-classic-desktop-keyboard-isolated-on-white-full-alphabe.html is the best picture I can find of a Modern Greek only keyboard (as opposed to Ancient Greek, used by classical historians, or a 2000s+-keyboard, which includes English letters too.)

(If this all seems pedantic, bear in mind that even "tiny" errors like an upside-down capital S would be noticeable.)

French

I'll also strongly suggest replacing * M with * µ on the French layout. In this case, µ isn't a lowercase letter: it's the micro symbol, as in "a hair is about 75µm thick", which could only be capitalized as "75µm THICK", since "75MM" is at best undefined, and at worst might be read as 75mm, 1000× larger,. (Or consider that I can't capitalize "the download runs at 10Mb/s" as "10MB/s", since 10MB/s = 80Mb/s.)

But I don't want either of these kits anyway...

Ergo

I'm interested in either the Orth or Ergo kit -- probably the Ergo kit, as it has many more 1U R1 keys, and lots of 1U thumb keys on my Ergodash (70 keys total).

The current Ergo render shows some duplicates amongst the 1U R1 keys, namely:
- three Alt/Option keys (if that's the wavy line with a dot below and above)
- three Sys keys (diamond with a centre dot)
- three of the ones with three horizontal lines
- two home (swishy up arrow)
- two end (swishy down arrow)

Pairs of icon mod keys are excellent (I can have Alt, Ctrl, Sys on each side, or use them alone for pretty much anything), but three of the same seems a bit excessive, so I think this is five redundant keys.

Personally, I'd prefer:
- two 1U R1 shift keys
- a 1UC R1 space key
- a 1U R1 enter key
- a 1U R1 backspace key
That still leaves the normal four arrows, three arrow pairs (PgUp/Down, Home/End, maybe that's Raise/Lower), four modifier pairs and delete. That gives plenty of flexibility for larger orth, split, or 3D keyboards.

Hopefully this is useful feedback, it's an excellent design, even if on a board with entirely 1U keys I can't make use of the best novelties.

I appreciate the feedback and interest in interest in my set! I will look into updating the ergo kit. The French kit key you pointed out was an error I forgot to fix.

Offline rewke

  • Posts: 3
Re: [IC] KAT Atlantis | UPDATE #3: More kit changes 11/26/19
« Reply #198 on: Wed, 15 January 2020, 16:37:34 »
Like others, I'm registering just to say I love this keycap set!

Do you have a rough idea on when the group buy would go live?

Offline kingh271

  • Posts: 3
Re: [IC] KAT Atlantis | UPDATE #3: More kit changes 11/26/19
« Reply #199 on: Wed, 15 January 2020, 18:11:19 »
Like others, I'm registering just to say I love this keycap set!

Do you have a rough idea on when the group buy would go live?

Q1 2020 according to a couple comments up.