Oh - yeah, it doesn't take much to change the dynamics of a buckling spring. Anyway Welly you seem skeptical of everybody else's tests. Why not buy a Model F and try to mod it? If you can beat the IBM engineers I'd be impressed.
well, first, I'm not sceptical, what i'm pointing out is that friction and other factors make a difference, and what all of your tests show is the spring cant account for everything.
second, as far as the spring goes, I'd like nothing more than to buy an F and get to work on hacking it into an M (which is why I posted this thread to begin with). This is a long term interest for me though since I dont have decent workspace (or time) to do it in the timeframe i'd like while i'm still in student housing
BUt yes, absolutely, this is something i'm going to do at some point cuz I'm very curious about the question of how to lighten a BS.
I doubt I can 'beat ibm engineers' (my dad was one, and believe me, there are some things, like engineering stuff, on which I'd rather not compete with him); however, ibm engineers in the '80s were, I think, shooting for a relatively heavy switch compared to the switches we use today, so it may be that they never seriously tried to 'lighten' it. (They would have had no need to do so). So its worth tweaking and experimenting with the basic BS design today to see if that can be done. I dont consider that competing with ibm engineers, I guess, since I dont believe they ever were shooting for that same goal. Since unicomp wont step up to the plate with keeping up with the times, I guess its up to hackers to see whats possible.