Author Topic: Gateron black too light?  (Read 9676 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline nogoodnames444

  • Thread Starter
  • Posts: 115
  • Location: Alamo California
  • I like keyboards
Gateron black too light?
« on: Fri, 26 January 2018, 13:15:44 »
I'm using on a keyswitch tester right now and it does not feel as heavy as the modern mx black that I tried

Offline jdcarpe

  • * Curator
  • Posts: 8852
  • Location: Odessa, TX
  • Live long, and prosper.
Re: Gateron black too light?
« Reply #1 on: Fri, 26 January 2018, 14:11:06 »
I'm using on a keyswitch tester right now and it does not feel as heavy as the modern mx black that I tried

Supposedly Gateron black have the same compression force on the spring, but I'm sure they have a different force curve, so they feel lighter to me. They are also much smoother than modern MX blacks. They seem lighter, but definitely not too light.

I bought about 1300 Gateron blacks for keyboard builds, if that tells you anything. I swapped out the switches on a full size Filco (and installed my replacement plate - see link in my sig) to Gateron blacks because I like them so much.
KMAC :: LZ-GH :: WASD CODE :: WASD v2 :: GH60 :: Alps64 :: JD45 :: IBM Model M :: IBM 4704 "Pingmaster"

http://jd40.info :: http://jd45.info


in memoriam

"When I was a kid, I used to take things apart and never put them back together."

Offline Hyde

  • Posts: 2643
  • Location: Toronto, Canada
  • White Tofu Extraordinaire
Re: Gateron black too light?
« Reply #2 on: Fri, 26 January 2018, 14:23:24 »
Yes they are different:

MX Black:  Actuate at 60g, bottom out at 80g.
Gateron Black:  Actuate at 50g, bottom out at 70g.

So they are about 10g lighter.  For people who want inbetween MX Red and MX Black feel some people suggest:

Gateron Yellow:  Actuate at 50g, bottom out at 60g.

Not sure what you're looking for but yes the switches were designed to be different.  :)

Archiss ProgresTouch Retro - Gateron Yellow  |  Topre Realforce 104UW - 45g Silent  |  Topre Type Heaven  |  Beige Filco Ninja 104 - MX Red  |  Das Keyboard - MX Brown  |  Poker II - MX Red  |  Race II - MX Brown  |  Matias Quiet Pro - Matias Dampened ALPS  |  Logitech K840 - Romer G  |  Cherry MX Board 2.0 - MX Red  |  Cherry G84-4100 - ML  |  IBM Model M
Roccat Kone Pure  |  Logitech G203  |  Logitech G303  |  Logitech G302  |  Razer Naga  |  CM Storm Xornet  |  Razer Goliathus Mobile Stealth  |  Razer Goliathus Control  |  Artisan Hien  |  Artisan Hayate  |  Artisan Shiden

Offline Rob27shred

  • Posts: 1538
  • Location: Pittsburgh, PA
  • Insane in the Membrane! 👻
Re: Gateron black too light?
« Reply #3 on: Fri, 26 January 2018, 16:22:03 »
Yeah, I find the Gateron blacks to feel noticeably lighter than Cherry blacks as well. I prefer heavy switches & Cherry blacks are just heavy enough for me with their stock spring, while Gateron blacks are definitely too light for my liking with their stock spring. I believe Hyde is correct with his weighting info. Although there are pros & cons for both brands, weight isn't a huge consideration considering you can get aftermarket springs to make either as heavy or light as you like. 

The Gateron blacks are smoother than Cherry blacks, but Cherry has retooled their production line & now the difference in smoothness is much less of an issue. The new Cherry blacks are very smooth compared to pre retooling blacks. Then Gateron switches have more wobble than Cherry switches which can be pretty apparent if you're using higher profile caps like SA or even OEM due to how tall they are. This is due to Gateron having slightly looser tolerances than Cherry. Basically all the parts in a Cherry switch fit tighter together causing more friction with key presses hence them feeling scratchier. While all the parts in Gateron switches have a tiny bit more room with each other, which causes a smoother key press feel, but also a noticeable wobble of the key cap on off center presses.

This carries across the whole regular Gateron line up when comparing to their Cherry equivalent. Gaterons will be smoother, a bit lighter weighted, & more wobbly than their Cherry equivalents. This doesn't carry over into Gateron silent switches apparently though, as they have been reported to be pretty scratchy & haven't reviewed to well AFAIK. No personal experience with them yet so YMMV with them.
« Last Edit: Fri, 26 January 2018, 16:29:27 by Rob27shred »

Offline rich1051414

  • Posts: 353
  • Location: Decaturville, TN
Re: Gateron black too light?
« Reply #4 on: Fri, 26 January 2018, 16:44:46 »
Much of the 'lighter' feel I attribute to the smoother sliders and looser enclosure. I think it has more of an affect of feeling lighter than the slightly lighter spring. That does make them feel 'wobbly', but it also makes the switch feel less restrictive when pushing them off axis. It makes them feel even smoother and lighter. Personally, I think linear switches are better off in a loose enclosure, while tactile and clicky are better off in a tight enclosure, but this is all subjective opinion.
« Last Edit: Fri, 26 January 2018, 16:48:15 by rich1051414 »
Siig Minitouch with Orange Alps, Whitefox 60% Zealios 67g, Realforce 87U 55g Topre, LFK SMK/Alps TKL With SMK 2nd Gen Cherry MX mount switches, NEC APC-H412 NEC Blue Ovals, Unicomp Model-M Spacesaver, XMIT Hall Effect, WASD Code Cherry MX Clear, KBDFans75 Lubed Gateron Greens, Azio MGK L80 Kailh Brown, XD84 Pale Blue Box Kailh, NIB Pingmaster TMK Converted, KPrepublic XD96 Blue aluminum case with Jade Box Kailh

Offline nogoodnames444

  • Thread Starter
  • Posts: 115
  • Location: Alamo California
  • I like keyboards
Re: Gateron black too light?
« Reply #5 on: Fri, 26 January 2018, 22:19:07 »
Thanks for all of the responses. I have heard that smoother switches do feel lighter but it sounds like they are just physically smoother

Offline Hyde

  • Posts: 2643
  • Location: Toronto, Canada
  • White Tofu Extraordinaire
Re: Gateron black too light?
« Reply #6 on: Sat, 27 January 2018, 08:35:45 »
Alternatively you can try Kailh Box Black switch it's suppose to be same weight as MX Black but super smooth and no wobble.

Only trade off is 3.6 mm key travel vs the usual 4.0 mm in Cherry.

:)

Archiss ProgresTouch Retro - Gateron Yellow  |  Topre Realforce 104UW - 45g Silent  |  Topre Type Heaven  |  Beige Filco Ninja 104 - MX Red  |  Das Keyboard - MX Brown  |  Poker II - MX Red  |  Race II - MX Brown  |  Matias Quiet Pro - Matias Dampened ALPS  |  Logitech K840 - Romer G  |  Cherry MX Board 2.0 - MX Red  |  Cherry G84-4100 - ML  |  IBM Model M
Roccat Kone Pure  |  Logitech G203  |  Logitech G303  |  Logitech G302  |  Razer Naga  |  CM Storm Xornet  |  Razer Goliathus Mobile Stealth  |  Razer Goliathus Control  |  Artisan Hien  |  Artisan Hayate  |  Artisan Shiden

Offline nogoodnames444

  • Thread Starter
  • Posts: 115
  • Location: Alamo California
  • I like keyboards
Re: Gateron black too light?
« Reply #7 on: Sat, 27 January 2018, 12:27:34 »
Alternatively you can try Kailh Box Black switch it's suppose to be same weight as MX Black but super smooth and no wobble.

Only trade off is 3.6 mm key travel vs the usual 4.0 mm in Cherry.

:)
Yeah I will have to try that switch I'm probably going to get the keyswitch tester for box switches of kbd fans

Offline Puddsy

  • nice
  • * Elated Elder
  • Posts: 12277
  • Location: RSTLN E
  • "Do you shovel to survive, or survive to shovel?"
Re: Gateron black too light?
« Reply #8 on: Sat, 27 January 2018, 13:07:09 »
Alternatively you can try Kailh Box Black switch it's suppose to be same weight as MX Black but super smooth and no wobble.

Only trade off is 3.6 mm key travel vs the usual 4.0 mm in Cherry.

:)

+1

there are a few other minor issues with them but it doesn't really matter unless you're doing some really esoteric stuff
QFR | MJ2 TKL | "Bulgogiboard" (Keycon 104) | ctrl.alt x GON 60% | TGR Alice | Mira SE #29 | Mira SE #34 | Revo One | z | Keycult No. 1 | First CW87 prototype | Mech27v1 | Camp C225 | Duck Orion V1 | LZ CLS sxh | Geon Frog TKL | Hiney TKL One | Geon Glare TKL



"Everything is worse, but in a barely perceptible and indefinable way" -dollartacos, after I came back from a break | "Is Linkshine our Nixon?" -NAV | "Puddsy is the Puddsy of keebs" -ns90

Offline klennkellon

  • Posts: 1278
  • Location: Southern California
  • I like bottoming out
Re: Gateron black too light?
« Reply #9 on: Sat, 27 January 2018, 13:58:38 »
Alternatively you can try Kailh Box Black switch it's suppose to be same weight as MX Black but super smooth and no wobble.

Only trade off is 3.6 mm key travel vs the usual 4.0 mm in Cherry.

:)
Yeah I will have to try that switch I'm probably going to get the keyswitch tester for box switches of kbd fans
Box Black is also lighter than MX Black from my experience. You will want the "Heavy Dark Yellow" ones for something more similar to MX Black.

Offline ander

  • * Esteemed Elder
  • Posts: 1186
  • Location: Vancouver, BC
  • I type, therefore I am
Re: Gateron black too light?
« Reply #10 on: Sun, 28 January 2018, 04:58:48 »
They may be too light, but as a jazz musician, I can't consider any switch "too black".
We are not chasing wildly after beauty with fear at our backs. – Natalie Goldberg

Offline Hyde

  • Posts: 2643
  • Location: Toronto, Canada
  • White Tofu Extraordinaire
Re: Gateron black too light?
« Reply #11 on: Thu, 01 February 2018, 17:17:12 »
Alternatively you can try Kailh Box Black switch it's suppose to be same weight as MX Black but super smooth and no wobble.

Only trade off is 3.6 mm key travel vs the usual 4.0 mm in Cherry.

:)
Yeah I will have to try that switch I'm probably going to get the keyswitch tester for box switches of kbd fans

Actually definitely try out the tester first.  After using Box Red for a few days the shortened travel distance start to bug me a little, I think I prefer full travel (4.0 mm as oppose to 3.6 mm).

I was like mah what can 0.4 mm difference make?  But you actually do notice it.

Archiss ProgresTouch Retro - Gateron Yellow  |  Topre Realforce 104UW - 45g Silent  |  Topre Type Heaven  |  Beige Filco Ninja 104 - MX Red  |  Das Keyboard - MX Brown  |  Poker II - MX Red  |  Race II - MX Brown  |  Matias Quiet Pro - Matias Dampened ALPS  |  Logitech K840 - Romer G  |  Cherry MX Board 2.0 - MX Red  |  Cherry G84-4100 - ML  |  IBM Model M
Roccat Kone Pure  |  Logitech G203  |  Logitech G303  |  Logitech G302  |  Razer Naga  |  CM Storm Xornet  |  Razer Goliathus Mobile Stealth  |  Razer Goliathus Control  |  Artisan Hien  |  Artisan Hayate  |  Artisan Shiden