Edgar Matias maintains that all Cherry mx switches are inherently linear; some claim to be tactile by grafting a bump onto the slider and others achieve clickiness by adding a clicker. I tend to agree with him, so that for me, the best Cherry switches are the ones that are billed as linear, unfettered with tactile or clicky add-ons. However, I find contemporary linear Cherry switches lack smoothness. Gateron seems to have addressed this, and if I were going to use a linear mx switch, I would choose Gateron yellow for a good blend of actuation and bottoming-out weights along with smooth operation.
I've tried Matias linear switches, and they had two problems for me. First, they were too light. Second, they were linear! They lacked the excellent tactile feedback of the Matias Click or Matias Quiet switches.
Although I like Matias Click and Matias Quiet switches, they aren't as refined as Alps switches in good to excellent condition. At the moment, I favor SKCM blue and SKCM white Alps switches. These have just the right amount of tactile feedback and a relatively subtle click. I still have high hopes for Matias. I hope they will iron out the kinks in their switches and perhaps eventually introduce improved versions that could rival vintage Alps.
As for damped vs. undamped Alps or Alps clones, I prefer undamped. However, I have swapped out the sliders on some of my Alps boards with damped sliders from Matias Quiet switches, but I've kept all of the other parts of the Alps switches, including the return spring and tactile/click leaf. I thought that I might like a hemi-damped slider with damping only on the return stroke, but when I clipped the bottom dampers on some Matias Quiet switches, I was not pleased with the result.
In general, I prefer tactile or tactile/clicky switches to linear switches, but based on what I've read and tried, if I were to use a linear switch, it would most likely be Alps. At the moment, I have two boards with linear Alps waiting in the wings for refurbishing -- one has SKCL green and the other has SKCL yellow. When I eventually get around to making these boards fully operational, I will post my impressions.