geekhack

geekhack Community => Keyboards => Topic started by: redskull on Thu, 24 October 2013, 22:34:51

Title: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: redskull on Thu, 24 October 2013, 22:34:51
anyone seen this yet? oh my...

http://www.pcwaishe.cn/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=524282&extra=page%3D1%26filter%3Dauthor%26orderby%3Ddateline
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: ComradeSniper on Thu, 24 October 2013, 22:37:19
I really hope this becomes a widespread thing. I'd love to put MX sets on my Topre boards.
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: keymaster on Thu, 24 October 2013, 22:38:43
I can just imagine all those people "swearing" by MX jumping ship and buying these in droves to put their MX sets on.  :thumb:
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: Dubsgalore on Thu, 24 October 2013, 22:40:50
What's up with all these new bootleg stems??  :))

This one is actually really cool, maybe Kangaroo or Vesper should hit these up, and come back from the dark side
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: Cafeine on Thu, 24 October 2013, 22:41:57
Wow, google translate have a hard time but it seems you are right. 35g force... mmmmm  8)
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: redskull on Thu, 24 October 2013, 22:45:47
man, if the build quality is reliable, this is something i believe can go everywhere. but the 35g, ain't that a bit too light?
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: jonathanyu on Thu, 24 October 2013, 23:04:29
maybe one day there will be a adapter for mx keycaps and topre keycaps
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: rowdy on Thu, 24 October 2013, 23:06:33
An interesting hybrid, which would certainly go some way towards ameliorating the deplorable lack of custom Topre keycaps.
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: tp4tissue on Thu, 24 October 2013, 23:17:43
I've long come to realize that the the MOST IMPORTANT THING to keyboards is   ERGONOMICS....... NOT switches....
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: ComradeSniper on Thu, 24 October 2013, 23:21:08
I've long come to realize that the the MOST IMPORTANT THING to keyboards is   ERGONOMICS....... NOT switches....

As soon as a topre ergodox comes out i'll buy it
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: keymaster on Thu, 24 October 2013, 23:21:15
I've long come to realize that the the MOST IMPORTANT THING to keyboards is   ERGONOMICS....... NOT switches....

It's a good thing I do the whole home-row hand placement. As a result, my hands have naturally found the most ergonomic hand placement. I've never experienced fatigue or pain due to keyboard use.
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: tp4tissue on Thu, 24 October 2013, 23:26:06
I've long come to realize that the the MOST IMPORTANT THING to keyboards is   ERGONOMICS....... NOT switches....

It's a good thing I do the whole home-row hand placement. As a result, my hands have naturally found the most ergonomic hand placement. I've never experienced fatigue or pain due to keyboard use.

but what of the wrist/ shoulder and elbows...
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: eth0s on Thu, 24 October 2013, 23:26:36
This seems like such an obvious mod, I can't believe nobody thought of it before now, including me.  The Topre switch should be able to take any kind of stem. 

35g is extremely light in Topre.  35g Topre switch has almost no tactile bump at all.  If you like that, and you like Cherry double-shot keycaps, I guess this keyboard would be your ultimate keyboard.
 
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: redskull on Thu, 24 October 2013, 23:46:17
This seems like such an obvious mod, I can't believe nobody thought of it before now, including me.  The Topre switch should be able to take any kind of stem. 

35g is extremely light in Topre.  35g Topre switch has almost no tactile bump at all.  If you like that, and you like Cherry double-shot keycaps, I guess this keyboard would be your ultimate keyboard.
 
if they come out with something heavier, i might give them a try. i don't think that they would be too expensive originally coming from the China market.
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: Sniping on Thu, 24 October 2013, 23:50:33
Why is the cup rubber pink someone pls explain
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: tp4tissue on Fri, 25 October 2013, 00:01:58
Why is the cup rubber pink someone pls explain

OK, just a guess.. But it could be that it's the same silicone rubber supplier that supplies MANY different end products...   And the factory in question mostly supplies makers of adult male masturbatory aids...  and so.. their product is primarily Pink, and that's their cheapest most abundant supply..   

So.. the keyboard people goes and asks the supplier for cheap material, and they're like.. whateves,, it's going under the keyboard anyway.. I don't care if it's pink...

And there you have it...   
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: MKULTRA on Fri, 25 October 2013, 00:14:38
Why is the cup rubber pink someone pls explain

OK, just a guess.. But it could be that it's the same silicone rubber supplier that supplies MANY different end products...   And the factory in question mostly supplies makers of adult male masturbatory aids...  and so.. their product is primarily Pink, and that's their cheapest most abundant supply..   

So.. the keyboard people goes and asks the supplier for cheap material, and they're like.. whateves,, it's going under the keyboard anyway.. I don't care if it's pink...

And there you have it...
:)) Clever
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: MKULTRA on Fri, 25 October 2013, 00:19:32
On a more serious note, what is stopping us from 3d printing a MX version (similar to OP) of this thing

(http://i.imgur.com/sKmJ0Lv.jpg)
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: Michael on Fri, 25 October 2013, 00:22:47
makers of adult male masturbatory aids...


I think this is a subject we can all agree, that tp4 is the foremost expert on.
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: tp4tissue on Fri, 25 October 2013, 00:27:38
makers of adult male masturbatory aids...


I think this is a subject we can all agree, that tp4 is the foremost expert on.

I don't own one... and I wouldn't deny owning one if I did... I don't find it at all shameful... It's a HUGE business over in Japan with very-little input cost... The US market is also adopting quickly...

(http://www.cute-factor.com/images/smilies/onion/044.gif)
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: Linkbane on Fri, 25 October 2013, 00:34:23
Why is the cup rubber pink someone pls explain

OK, just a guess.. But it could be that it's the same silicone rubber supplier that supplies MANY different end products...   And the factory in question mostly supplies makers of adult male masturbatory aids...  and so.. their product is primarily Pink, and that's their cheapest most abundant supply..   

So.. the keyboard people goes and asks the supplier for cheap material, and they're like.. whateves,, it's going under the keyboard anyway.. I don't care if it's pink...

And there you have it...

CN
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: Linkbane on Fri, 25 October 2013, 00:34:45
Why is the cup rubber pink someone pls explain

OK, just a guess.. But it could be that it's the same silicone rubber supplier that supplies MANY different end products...   And the factory in question mostly supplies makers of adult male masturbatory aids...  and so.. their product is primarily Pink, and that's their cheapest most abundant supply..   

So.. the keyboard people goes and asks the supplier for cheap material, and they're like.. whateves,, it's going under the keyboard anyway.. I don't care if it's pink...

And there you have it...

Can't tell if I should say 'what is this I don't even' or laugh hard.
Probably a bit of both.
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: Michael on Fri, 25 October 2013, 00:36:28
In all seriousness, though... this is a great idea. As long as the caps can depress without any interference. It would be a lot of work replacing all the stems in a Realforce, just because of the massive amount of labor involved.


But if you get to use all of your MX cap sets, I would say it just might be worth it.
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: redskull on Fri, 25 October 2013, 00:55:10
In all seriousness, though... this is a great idea. As long as the caps can depress without any interference. It would be a lot of work replacing all the stems in a Realforce, just because of the massive amount of labor involved.


But if you get to use all of your MX cap sets, I would say it just might be worth it.
yeah. and also the plastic quality of the stem itself. wouldn't want them to be easily broken like some on those immitation cherry stems.
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: tp4tissue on Fri, 25 October 2013, 00:58:32
Why is the cup rubber pink someone pls explain

OK, just a guess.. But it could be that it's the same silicone rubber supplier that supplies MANY different end products...   And the factory in question mostly supplies makers of adult male masturbatory aids...  and so.. their product is primarily Pink, and that's their cheapest most abundant supply..   

So.. the keyboard people goes and asks the supplier for cheap material, and they're like.. whateves,, it's going under the keyboard anyway.. I don't care if it's pink...

And there you have it...

Can't tell if I should say 'what is this I don't even' or laugh hard.
Probably a bit of both.

Guys seriously Where Else have you seen "pink" silicone rubber material... (http://www.cute-factor.com/images/smilies/onion/efb50fe2.gif)
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: meiosis on Fri, 25 October 2013, 01:02:36
Why is the cup rubber pink someone pls explain

OK, just a guess.. But it could be that it's the same silicone rubber supplier that supplies MANY different end products...   And the factory in question mostly supplies makers of adult male masturbatory aids...  and so.. their product is primarily Pink, and that's their cheapest most abundant supply..   

So.. the keyboard people goes and asks the supplier for cheap material, and they're like.. whateves,, it's going under the keyboard anyway.. I don't care if it's pink...

And there you have it...

Can't tell if I should say 'what is this I don't even' or laugh hard.
Probably a bit of both.

Guys seriously Where Else have you seen "pink" silicone rubber material...
Show Image
(http://www.cute-factor.com/images/smilies/onion/efb50fe2.gif)


Erasers.
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: tp4tissue on Fri, 25 October 2013, 01:35:06
Why is the cup rubber pink someone pls explain

OK, just a guess.. But it could be that it's the same silicone rubber supplier that supplies MANY different end products...   And the factory in question mostly supplies makers of adult male masturbatory aids...  and so.. their product is primarily Pink, and that's their cheapest most abundant supply..   

So.. the keyboard people goes and asks the supplier for cheap material, and they're like.. whateves,, it's going under the keyboard anyway.. I don't care if it's pink...

And there you have it...

Can't tell if I should say 'what is this I don't even' or laugh hard.
Probably a bit of both.

Guys seriously Where Else have you seen "pink" silicone rubber material...
Show Image
(http://www.cute-factor.com/images/smilies/onion/efb50fe2.gif)


Erasers.

hmmmm...

i haven't seen the silicone erasers in pink..

i've only seen the white silicone kind.

I'm also pretty sure that it may not even be silicone rubber, it's probably vinyl
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: Moosecraft on Fri, 25 October 2013, 01:42:20
If someone 3d prints these I will buy them ;D
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: DamnDan on Fri, 25 October 2013, 02:15:12
<Sees topre with cherry compatibility. Secretly wishes someone made cherry compatibile alps stems>
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: FoxWolf1 on Fri, 25 October 2013, 02:55:45
Oh, a new version of the Noppoo capacitive switch?

The last batch of these that they did was with foil-and-foam rather than a spring, and never achieved much by way of popularity. Those were priced similarly to the MX versions, so these have some potential for a good value, assuming they do a good job on the switch itself.

Even with a spring, feel may differ from Topre switches if there are differences in the domes (which seems likely).
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: Findecanor on Fri, 25 October 2013, 03:08:44
I see several potential problems with these custom stems:
* Topre stems are made with high tolerances + lube. The high quality of the stems is part of the Topre's appeal.
* Topre keycaps are textured PBT. The high quality of the keycaps is part of Topre's appeal.
* The stems of wide Topre keys have stabilisers on the bottom, inside the key switch. These sizes would also have to be replicated for a full keyboard. It does not do to just replicate the stems for 1u keys.
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: Oobly on Fri, 25 October 2013, 03:30:30
I see several potential problems with these custom stems:
* Topre stems are made with high tolerances + lube. The high quality of the stems is part of the Topre's appeal.
* Topre keycaps are textured PBT. The high quality of the keycaps is part of Topre's appeal.
* The stems of wide Topre keys have stabilisers on the bottom, inside the key switch. These sizes would also have to be replicated for a full keyboard. It does not do to just replicate the stems for 1u keys.

If we could get hold of just a few of these stems it would be nice for some. Can put a few novelty or nice custom MX keycaps on just a couple of keys. That said, I'm not a Topre fan... yet.  ;) Still in my "OMFGZ! Dese MX browns and ergoclears are da totalshizzlewizzle compared to my old rubber dome bordzz" stage.
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: tp4tissue on Fri, 25 October 2013, 04:43:50
I see several potential problems with these custom stems:
* Topre stems are made with high tolerances + lube. The high quality of the stems is part of the Topre's appeal.
* Topre keycaps are textured PBT. The high quality of the keycaps is part of Topre's appeal.
* The stems of wide Topre keys have stabilisers on the bottom, inside the key switch. These sizes would also have to be replicated for a full keyboard. It does not do to just replicate the stems for 1u keys.


^^^  This is insane fanboism....

We're in 2013... anyone with the exception of iONE can make a quality plastic keyboard given the right price. (http://www.cute-factor.com/images/smilies/onion/th_113_.gif)

And I guarantee you that price is LESS than what those Topre jerks charge their n00b kiss-ass fanbois...
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: terran5992 on Fri, 25 October 2013, 04:47:41
Hmmmm, really cool idea. Finally nice keycaps available for topre boards
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: PointyFox on Fri, 25 October 2013, 04:50:12
Can't wait until Cherry stems achieve complete oneness with the cup rubber.
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: 002 on Fri, 25 October 2013, 05:00:15
I wonder if this has anything to do with China assembling boards (Leopold FC600C & Type HEAVEN) for Topre these days? :)
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: terran5992 on Fri, 25 October 2013, 05:00:37
I wonder if this has anything to do with China assembling boards (Leopold FC600C & Type HEAVEN) for Topre these days? :)

Theres no doubt
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: Findecanor on Fri, 25 October 2013, 08:03:38
^^^  This is insane fanboism....
Are you accusing me of being a Topre fanboy? ... You don't know me very well.
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: Linkbane on Fri, 25 October 2013, 08:17:20
^^^  This is insane fanboism....
Are you accusing me of being a Topre fanboy? ... You don't know me very well.

He doesn't need to know you well to judge you by how you act, and it did seem pretty fanboyish.
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: Danule on Fri, 25 October 2013, 08:33:00
i wonder if the keycap will be as secure on the stem as the original topre version.  The lack of wiggle is one of the pluses of topre.
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: esoomenona on Fri, 25 October 2013, 08:43:28
Lack of wiggle? I'm wiggling my HHKB caps right now, and they're definitely wiggling.
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: Danule on Fri, 25 October 2013, 08:49:18
Lack of wiggle? I'm wiggling my HHKB caps right now, and they're definitely wiggling.

compared to cherry.
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: keymaster on Fri, 25 October 2013, 08:51:48
The only switch I've noticed significant wiggle was with ALPS. The amount of wiggle Cherry and Topre stems don't negatively affect my experience. Still, the wiggle with ALPS switches isn't really bothersome unless you're being nitpicky.
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: frvrngn on Fri, 25 October 2013, 09:28:44
I think this is a great idea.  I love my new Topre board but wouldnt mind using some of the keycaps from my other boards on it to "liven" it up a bit! 
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: daerid on Fri, 25 October 2013, 09:45:18
I just want to see a self contained cherry-pinout compatible Topre switch. Is that too much to ask?
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: frvrngn on Fri, 25 October 2013, 09:57:14
I just want to see a self contained cherry-pinout compatible Topre switch. Is that too much to ask?

Want to make a Topre Ergodox??  That would be quite nice!
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: daerid on Fri, 25 October 2013, 10:01:21
Want to make a Topre Ergodox??  That would be quite nice!

Yup. It is my dream board. Clears are great, but they're no Topre.
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: MKULTRA on Fri, 25 October 2013, 12:29:56
I see several potential problems with these custom stems:
* Topre stems are made with high tolerances + lube. The high quality of the stems is part of the Topre's appeal.
* Topre keycaps are textured PBT. The high quality of the keycaps is part of Topre's appeal.
* The stems of wide Topre keys have stabilisers on the bottom, inside the key switch. These sizes would also have to be replicated for a full keyboard. It does not do to just replicate the stems for 1u keys.
1. You can lube Cherry stems, and they are about the same "quality"
2. You have a much wider variety of keycaps and keycaps of equal or greater "quality" with cherry style stems
3. So replicate them...?
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: dorkvader on Fri, 25 October 2013, 13:36:10
* Topre keycaps are textured PBT. The high quality of the keycaps is part of Topre's appeal.
Spacebar.

I should think that adding compatibility for cherry spacebars should be a priority, as PBT spacebars are easy to come by.


Also, those domes don't look as high quality as a realforce.
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: tp4tissue on Fri, 25 October 2013, 13:38:06
* Topre keycaps are textured PBT. The high quality of the keycaps is part of Topre's appeal.
Spacebar.

I should think that adding compatibility for cherry spacebars should be a priority, as PBT spacebars are easy to come by.


Also, those domes don't look as high quality as a realforce.

If they are readily replaceable for low cost... They may not need to be (as high quality)(http://www.cute-factor.com/images/smilies/onion/th_113_.gif)
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: esoomenona on Fri, 25 October 2013, 13:43:07
Spacebar.

I should think that adding compatibility for cherry spacebars should be a priority, as PBT spacebars are easy to come by.

This would require either creating a new Cherry PBT spacebar that has the same stabilizer support as Topre or changing the board somehow to accept Cherry stabilizers.

IMO, we'd be better served pooling money together to have SP build us a PBT Topre spacebar mold and starting shooting.
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: tp4tissue on Fri, 25 October 2013, 13:51:47
Spacebar.

I should think that adding compatibility for cherry spacebars should be a priority, as PBT spacebars are easy to come by.

This would require either creating a new Cherry PBT spacebar that has the same stabilizer support as Topre or changing the board somehow to accept Cherry stabilizers.

IMO, we'd be better served pooling money together to have SP build us a PBT Topre spacebar mold and starting shooting.

I don't think this is necessary.....

The new wave of topre-esque boards are incoming... you can bet they'll probably have costar stabilizers :D
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: Findecanor on Fri, 25 October 2013, 13:52:24
He doesn't need to know you well to judge you by how you act, and it did seem pretty fanboyish.
Really?  :confused: I was trying to be objective. If I was a fanboy, I would have claimed Topre's properties to be superior instead of saying that they "have appeal".

1. You can lube Cherry stems, and they are about the same "quality"
Besides smoothness, I was referring to lack of wiggle. :)

2. You have a much wider variety of keycaps and keycaps of equal or greater "quality" with cherry style stems
Not really. Only if you want a key set in US-ANSI for a Filco/Das/Ducky/QFR are there many new and exciting sets.
Far from all sets include the 1.5u and 1u modifiers that a Topre Realforce or HHKB has.
Cherry MX-compatible keycaps of dye-sub PBT were very rare until quite recently (very expensive vintage G80-xxx Sxx keyboards).
My one Topre keyboard (that I don't use very much because I prefer Cherry MX) is in Swedish layout, but it is practically impossible to find dye-sub PBT keys for Cherry MX in Swedish layout. It took me three years before I found a set of lasered PBT keys for Swedish, and then that set was still incomplete.

* Topre keycaps are textured PBT. The high quality of the keycaps is part of Topre's appeal.
Spacebar.

I should think that adding compatibility for cherry spacebars should be a priority, as PBT spacebars are easy to come by.
Valid point on space bar. However, Topre Realforce and HHKB have 6u Space bars.
I do not know of anyone who makes 6u Cherry space bars in PBT. 7bit offered 6u space bars in ABS, but only with offset key stem for Cherry G80-1800/11x00.

I'm starting to think that the keyboard in the picture is a custom model that copies Topre.
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: tp4tissue on Fri, 25 October 2013, 13:57:53
He doesn't need to know you well to judge you by how you act, and it did seem pretty fanboyish.
Really?  :confused: I was trying to be objective. If I was a fanboy, I would have claimed Topre's properties to be superior instead of saying that they "have appeal".

1. You can lube Cherry stems, and they are about the same "quality"
Besides smoothness, I was referring to lack of wiggle. :)

2. You have a much wider variety of keycaps and keycaps of equal or greater "quality" with cherry style stems
Not really. Only if you want a key set in US-ANSI for a Filco/Das/Ducky/QFR are there many new and exciting sets.
Far from all sets include the 1.5u and 1u modifiers that a Topre Realforce or HHKB has.
Cherry MX-compatible keycaps of dye-sub PBT were very rare until quite recently (very expensive vintage G80-xxx Sxx keyboards).
My one Topre keyboard (that I don't use very much because I prefer Cherry MX) is in Swedish layout, but it is practically impossible to find dye-sub PBT keys for Cherry MX in Swedish layout. It took me three years before I found a set of lasered PBT keys for Swedish, and then that set was still incomplete.

I found your post was fanboish because of all the capitalized Topre monikering/ name drop

My stance is.. the problems you listed are quite trivial for any modern engineering team.. I am not disagreeing that your emphasis on the potential problems may happen..

I merely want to say that Topre is not the only people who know how to engineer some keyboard parts... in fact I'd say the topre stabilizers are not as good as costars due to its requirement of higher tolerance parts like the cherry stabilizer..

Whereas the costar stab design can work even with a VERY mis-molded space bar.
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: esoomenona on Fri, 25 October 2013, 13:59:28
Spacebar.

I should think that adding compatibility for cherry spacebars should be a priority, as PBT spacebars are easy to come by.

This would require either creating a new Cherry PBT spacebar that has the same stabilizer support as Topre or changing the board somehow to accept Cherry stabilizers.

IMO, we'd be better served pooling money together to have SP build us a PBT Topre spacebar mold and starting shooting.

I don't think this is necessary.....

The new wave of topre-esque boards are incoming... you can bet they'll probably have costar stabilizers :D

Even then, the problem comes down to this: size and availability. There aren't many Cherry PBT spacebars to begin with, let alone those in 6x.
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: tp4tissue on Fri, 25 October 2013, 14:10:40
Spacebar.

I should think that adding compatibility for cherry spacebars should be a priority, as PBT spacebars are easy to come by.

This would require either creating a new Cherry PBT spacebar that has the same stabilizer support as Topre or changing the board somehow to accept Cherry stabilizers.

IMO, we'd be better served pooling money together to have SP build us a PBT Topre spacebar mold and starting shooting.

I don't think this is necessary.....

The new wave of topre-esque boards are incoming... you can bet they'll probably have costar stabilizers :D

Even then, the problem comes down to this: size and availability. There aren't many Cherry PBT spacebars to begin with, let alone those in 6x.

say wha.... there are plenty of pbt space bars..... i can go buy one right now...
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: Linkbane on Fri, 25 October 2013, 15:37:10
Even then, the problem comes down to this: size and availability. There aren't many Cherry PBT spacebars to begin with, let alone those in 6x.

say wha.... there are plenty of pbt space bars..... i can go buy one right now...

Not from Topre you can't.  :D
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: esoomenona on Fri, 25 October 2013, 15:39:28
We're talking about Cherry PBT spacebars. Where are these PBT spacebars you speak of, tp4?
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: Daniel Beardsmore on Sat, 26 October 2013, 12:50:48
Got a reference for that?

The only photos I've seen of the Noppoo capacitive switch show rubber domes over a double-sided PCB bearing diodes for every switch, suggesting conductive rubber domes, not capacitive. I've never seen the inside of the domes.
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: tp4tissue on Sat, 26 October 2013, 13:01:53
We're talking about Cherry PBT spacebars. Where are these PBT spacebars you speak of, tp4?

well, SP sells the space bars by itself.. But then there's all these ebay pbt sets.. and there's plenty of the original oem profile pbt sets that go for $35-45.... Cherry PBT ap-plenty.. (http://www.cute-factor.com/images/smilies/onion/sillyp1.gif)
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: ComradeSniper on Sat, 26 October 2013, 13:58:01
Spacebar.

I should think that adding compatibility for cherry spacebars should be a priority, as PBT spacebars are easy to come by.

This would require either creating a new Cherry PBT spacebar that has the same stabilizer support as Topre or changing the board somehow to accept Cherry stabilizers.

IMO, we'd be better served pooling money together to have SP build us a PBT Topre spacebar mold and starting shooting.

What's the cost of a new mold? Huge probably, but could we attain it through a gb?
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: dorkvader on Sat, 26 October 2013, 16:35:44
IMO, we'd be better served pooling money together to have SP build us a PBT Topre spacebar mold and starting shooting.
SP won't even do PBT spacebars for cherry MX, I doubt they'll be interested in spacebars for topre.

I think if you put smaller modifiers on it, and had a bit of a gap on one side, you could probably put a 6.25x spacebar on there, but it's not the optimal solution at all. I mean, i'd be fine with it for a PBT or metal spacebar, but I feel like most topre users want better quality (or at least a better-integrated solution) than that.


What's the cost of a new mold? Huge probably, but could we attain it through a gb?
At least $3,000.
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: tp4tissue on Sat, 26 October 2013, 16:39:43
IMO, we'd be better served pooling money together to have SP build us a PBT Topre spacebar mold and starting shooting.
SP won't even do PBT spacebars for cherry MX, I doubt they'll be interested in spacebars for topre.

I think if you put smaller modifiers on it, and had a bit of a gap on one side, you could probably put a 6.25x spacebar on there, but it's not the optimal solution at all. I mean, i'd be fine with it for a PBT or metal spacebar, but I feel like most topre users want better quality (or at least a better-integrated solution) than that.


What's the cost of a new mold? Huge probably, but could we attain it through a gb?
At least $3,000.

per key? is it "any key"  and can we get exclusive rights to it.. so that over time, if other people buy the space bar, they'd essentially refund us the money slowly...
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: kelske on Sat, 26 October 2013, 17:59:58
What do you think about the adapter idea I talked about in this thread? http://geekhack.org/index.php?topic=28983.0
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: 002 on Thu, 19 December 2013, 21:00:47
http://v.youku.com/v_show/id_XNjQyNDQ3NjM2.html

03:10 - Removes keycap
05:25 - Bag of spares showing sliders and housings of various colour etc
11:06 - Closeup from under the housing
11:21 - Closeup of slider and looks like silencing washer/band at the base of the slider
12:30 - Closeup of housing with slider
14:30 - Under the board
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: Linkbane on Thu, 19 December 2013, 21:17:15
http://v.youku.com/v_show/id_XNjQyNDQ3NjM2.html

03:10 - Removes keycap
05:25 - Bag of spares showing sliders and housings of various colour etc
11:06 - Closeup from under the housing
11:21 - Closeup of slider and looks like silencing washer/band at the base of the slider
12:30 - Closeup of housing with slider
14:30 - Under the board

!!
Whoa, where'd you find this?
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: demik on Thu, 19 December 2013, 21:18:23
so noppoo is going to be CM to the punch?

my biggest question is how will the stabs look. i dont think a full HHKB conversion will work out because of the spacebar

although i hope im wrong
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: Pacifist on Thu, 19 December 2013, 21:19:26
http://v.youku.com/v_show/id_XNjQyNDQ3NjM2.html

03:10 - Removes keycap
05:25 - Bag of spares showing sliders and housings of various colour etc
11:06 - Closeup from under the housing
11:21 - Closeup of slider and looks like silencing washer/band at the base of the slider
12:30 - Closeup of housing with slider
14:30 - Under the board

I got an ad for chinese pizza hut  :p

but noppo got topre now!?!?!
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: Linkbane on Thu, 19 December 2013, 21:21:23
Also would like to mention that the guy in the video mentioned that the keycaps were still POM, like all over Noppoo's other boards.
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: SpAmRaY on Thu, 19 December 2013, 21:24:56
Those are the fake topre switches that were posted a while ago.
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: bueller on Thu, 19 December 2013, 21:26:05
Those are the fake topre switches that were posted a while ago.

Could be good for harvesting though!
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: SpAmRaY on Thu, 19 December 2013, 21:28:01
Those are the fake topre switches that were posted a while ago.

Could be good for harvesting though!

On my phone atm ...but seems like these had an issue that wouldn't allow that...but I don't remember what.
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: bueller on Thu, 19 December 2013, 21:28:58
Those are the fake topre switches that were posted a while ago.

Could be good for harvesting though!

On my phone atm ...but seems like these had an issue that wouldn't allow that...but I don't remember what.

BLAST!
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: dorkvader on Thu, 19 December 2013, 21:32:05
Those are the fake topre switches that were posted a while ago.
This.

Noppoo capacitive (http://deskthority.net/wiki/Noppoo_capacitive) switches have been mentioned in literature for a while. This appears to be an upgraded or slightly modified version of that.
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: 002 on Thu, 19 December 2013, 21:36:51
Those are the fake topre switches that were posted a while ago.
This.

Noppoo capacitive (http://deskthority.net/wiki/Noppoo_capacitive) switches have been mentioned in literature for a while. This appears to be an upgraded or slightly modified version of that.

These old white slider switches aren't capacitive. I'll confirm it tonight and update the wiki. Im pretty sure they are conductive.
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: terran5992 on Thu, 19 December 2013, 22:07:34
Those are the fake topre switches that were posted a while ago.
This.

Noppoo capacitive (http://deskthority.net/wiki/Noppoo_capacitive) switches have been mentioned in literature for a while. This appears to be an upgraded or slightly modified version of that.

These old white slider switches aren't capacitive. I'll confirm it tonight and update the wiki. Im pretty sure they are conductive.

0.o but do they feel different?
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: Canious on Thu, 19 December 2013, 22:26:19
Meh seems like a fluke to me, but if its the real deal i don't think we'll get our hands on it any time soon
Title: Re: Topre capacitive BUT with CHERRY STEMS
Post by: Moosecraft on Sat, 21 December 2013, 10:13:25
Very nice, more mx stems for the one and only switch :D