Hey geekhack,
I used to think people were crazy for spending more than $20 on keyboards. A few days ago, I got the chance to type on a mechanical keyboard myself (an Apple Extended Keyboard II, M3501, with ALPS non-click tactile according to the wiki) and it blew me away how much better it felt than my rubber domes, so now I'm looking to get one for myself.
First of all, what Cherry MX switch feels the most similar to the ALPS that I used? I'm assuming Browns or Clears (I couldn't find the actuation force of the ALPS switches anywhere, so I don't know which is closer) because they're marketed as tactile bump, but I could be wrong.
Next, what keyboard would be the best for me? I'm looking for a compact layout. I'm mainly considering the KBC Poker or the Noppoo Choc Mini, due to their nice layouts. I like the Poker's layout a bit more, but I'm not so sure about the build quality on it compared to the Choc's, with the PCB-mounted keys making it more susceptible to spills or damage, and I've read some people complain about the case being flimsy/wobbly. Is the difference in build that big between the two? I also like that the Choc has media controls on QWEASD, but I don't like the position of the Choc's Fn key compared to the Poker's (one key between the Choc's and the spacebar, Poker's directly next to the spacebar) as it's harder to reach with my thumb.
What do you guys think? Thanks in advance.