Well I can't specifically address your point as I don't have one, but I have good things about them. For me, I've been fine with the ubiquitous 3M gel types when it comes to keyboards with traditional layout. But I have to say this is one area where I miss my MS Ergo 4k, the integrated wrist rest with the angled hand position is a very comfortable typing position. Unfortunately your fingers suffer from mushy rubber domes in the process. Perhaps someday someone will integrate the best of both worlds.