It's not illegal to share in private groups, courts have upheld that since the first computers. If you join a private torrenting group, there's nothing illegal about it. You also won't get trojans or fake movie downloads. You also get to retain the movie, where if you go to a theater you're paying essentially for a service that's the same as burning money. You might as well wait for a dvd, where after watching it you still have something of value in hand.
Artists need to be able to make a living, but that doesn't mean that they have to stick some huge $20-40 fee to the end consumer. The truth of the matter is that the theaters are making money hand over fist, while the artists that make the film are getting paid practically nothing relative to the overall gross of a theater intake. Theaters still show ads and are ad supported but still stick it to customers by hideously overcharging at the counter. Movie theaters can suck it. I used to go to theaters every week for years. I decided I'd rather spend my money on a nice home theater.
Torrents are ONLY legal if they are sending non-copyrighted material, or, demos of software. Viruses
can be embedded in WMV files last time I checked.
Artists choose to work for a company or a publisher, it doesn't matter the price; often or not theatres themselves modify the price. If arists don't like it, they are free to work for someone else, get a different job, or start a company of their own.
The publishing industry, whether it be for music, film, or games, has a long history of ****ing over creative people/groups/companies and controlling and promoting a market where having the same repetitive **** dished out over and over again is seen as a good thing. On a $50 game in retail, the developer might make $5... In this day and age where I can make a game on my laptop and distribute it over a peer-to-peer network, what exactly is it that these publishing and retail companies do that justifies taking 90% of my potential income? Same with music, and film to a certain extent.
Now, I'm far to nihilistic to say that we all should pirate stuff to stick it to the man, rather, when I download something 'illegally', I feel absolutely no guilt and see no reason why I should. As far as I am concerned, I'm stealing from the thief.
Tear-jerkers do not change the issue. If you download software or movies from a company, it is stealing.
Furthermore, I know a hefty amount of independent developers who are indeed having their software being pirated. Sure it doesn't affect the big companies as much, but it DOES affect the little guys trying to make a living. Ever think of that?
The issue isn't the publishers, it's people becomming insane with pirating things, which adversely affects everything. You keep on pointing to big corporations and say stealing their products isn't harming, well let us deduct this:
#1 if everyone were to pirate movies and software, the big corporations would make no revenue whatsoever.
#2 there are a LOT of independent game developers and publishers who have their products pirated -- they are not big corporations so it really hurts their profits.
#3 it doesn't matter if people feel guilty or not, that's just an emotion! The issue is the economy, and the right to earn money when someone is utilizing your intellectual property.
#4 all of this pirating is pushing companies to develop anti-piracy techniques which are highly annoying... so everyone has to suffer, even those who don't pirate.