Thank you all for your input! I suppose the "whatever is in front of me" answer inspired me to just have a go using my New Model F62.
In the past I used a K95 Platinum with Cherry MX Browns for quite some time, and then I stopped using it about a year ago. I was using my Unicomp Model M Classic at work, and it took about a year before my boss said it was too loud for some people in the office and that I had to take it home. So even though it only had 2-key roll over, I actually enjoyed it quite a bit for gaming.
I decided to try out a Dell board I have with Black Alps switches, but I found for quick and subtle key-presses, it was a bit difficult to perform well on. The F62 actually handled quite well though. I type on it all day for work (at home currently) so let's see if it doesn't wake up my whole house at night

Cheers!