Author Topic: What Good Keyboards are For  (Read 5940 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline quadibloc

  • Thread Starter
  • Posts: 770
  • Location: Edmonton, Alberta, Canada
  • Layout Fanatic
    • John Savard's Home Page
What Good Keyboards are For
« on: Wed, 04 August 2010, 13:03:51 »
Mechanical keyboards with linear switches are occasionally offered to enthusiastic computer gamers.

But if that's one application for a quality computer keyboard that ought to generate sales, one would have thought that it would be data entry typing. If one expects one's secretaries to type stuff in at 60 to 80 words per minute... you need to give them a decent keyboard.

Of course the beam spring keyboard in a Displaywriter added to its price. So did the buckling spring keyboards in the original PC. They might not feel precisely like the keys in a Selectric - and, in fact, the way an electric typewriter operates is constrained by its mechanical operation. Tactile feedback is, to some extent, just a happy consequence, not something that could easily be optimized in design.

So IBM - and other companies that made computer terminals or keyboards for them - considered it was worth making an effort to provide tactile feedback in a computer keyboard.

The goal wasn't to mimic a typewriter exactly, just to give the typist something she could work with.

Some advertisements for Topre keyboards note their use in airport ticket counters, because fast, accurate entry is important there.

I presume this is an element in Unicomp's continued sales as well. But in a small web search, at least initially, it doesn't seem as though anyone out there is using that sort of thing as a sales pitch these days.

Offline spolia optima

  • Posts: 580
  • Location: On the shores of the cosmic ocean...
What Good Keyboards are For
« Reply #1 on: Wed, 04 August 2010, 13:19:59 »
I'd love to know more about the results of 30-some years of ergonomics research going into keyboard design. I imagine there are plenty of differing professional opinions on what is "ergonomic".
Damn, someone should wirte a book about keyboards.
keyboards!

Offline washuai

  • Posts: 410
  • Location: SF
    • http://home.earthlink.net/~haruai/
What Good Keyboards are For
« Reply #2 on: Wed, 04 August 2010, 13:53:06 »
An HR working for a company that hasn't already realized the cost and productivity benefits of mechanicals isn't going to have an issue of finding people that can type 60-80 wpm on a crap keyboard.  People that can't type 60 on a crap keyboard, aren't generally going to to type 60 on a mechanical keyboard that they've never typed on before in their life.
I know average typing speed for people in general according to some studies is like 40-50.  Most employers accept 50-60.

The low bar for 911 dispatcher is apparently 40 wpm - random google search.  

Court reporting and live transcription are where fast typists are cared about and that's the 120-300 wpm crowd.
⌨(home)Realforce 87U ⌨(backup) Filco Majestouch 104 Brown ⌨(backup)Cherry G80-8200LPDUS ⌨(work)Leopold FC200RT/AB
☛CST L-Trac-X ☛Logitech Wireless Optical Trackman ☛ Razer 3500 dpi ☛MS Explorer DeathAdder

Lay-a-bouts:  ⌨Full 109 Key Virtually Indestructable  Keyboard ⌨Compaq Radio Quack GYUR84SK
Wishlist: ⌨KBDmania Pure ⌨Déck 82 ice/frost/toxic/royal ⌨Ricercar spos G86-62410EUAGSA ☠ ✞⌨miniGuru(s) ☠
 ✐Intuos or Cintiq

Offline keyboardlover

  • Posts: 4022
  • Hey Paul Walker, Click It or Ticket!
    • http://www.keyboardlover.com
What Good Keyboards are For
« Reply #3 on: Wed, 04 August 2010, 14:02:46 »
Quote from: spolia optima;209107
I'd love to know more about the results of 30-some years of ergonomics research going into keyboard design. I imagine there are plenty of differing professional opinions on what is "ergonomic".
Damn, someone should wirte a book about keyboards.


I agree with that. I know someone who would write that book (if they got paid to do it and a publisher was lined up).

Offline hyperlinked

  • Posts: 924
What Good Keyboards are For
« Reply #4 on: Wed, 04 August 2010, 14:03:04 »
Quote from: spolia optima;209107
I'd love to know more about the results of 30-some years of ergonomics research going into keyboard design. I imagine there are plenty of differing professional opinions on what is "ergonomic".
Damn, someone should wirte a book about keyboards.


I doubt there's anything conclusive because ergonomics is such a dirty field of study. By that I mean that it's hard to isolate a cause and an effect and some of the causes and effects take years to materialize.

The best you can hope for is a study that shows that people do indeed make fewer mistakes per day or work faster overall when they have good keyboards. Ergonomics is about how a person interacts with his working environment and it boils down to two key areas: 1) health and safety and  2) performance. The health part is near impossible to nail down conclusively. The performance part is easier, but still leaves a lot up for debate.
-

Topre: Realforce 103U Cherry: Filco Majestouch 104 (Brown), Ione Scorpius M10 (Blue)
Buckling Spring: IBM Model M1391401 ALPS: Apple Extended Keyboard II (Cream), ABS M1 (Fukka/Black), MicroConnectors Flavored USB (Black)
Domes: Matias Optimizer, Kensington ComfortType, Microsoft Internet Keyboard
Scissors: Apple Full Sized Aluminum
Pointy Stuff: Razer Imperator, Razer Copperhead, DT225 Trackball, Apple Magic Mouse, Logitech MX1000, Apple Mighty Mouse
Systems: MacPro, MacBook Pro, ASUS eeePC netbook, Dell D600 laptop, a small cluster of Linux Web servers
Displays: Apple Cinema Display 30", Apple Cinema Display 23"
Ergo Devices: Zody Chair, Nightingale CXO, Somaform, Theraball, 3M AKT180LE Keyboard Tray

Offline ch_123

  • * Exalted Elder
  • Posts: 5860
What Good Keyboards are For
« Reply #5 on: Wed, 04 August 2010, 14:59:10 »
Quote from: washuai;209109
An HR working for a company that hasn't already realized the cost and productivity benefits of mechanicals isn't going to have an issue of finding people that can type 60-80 wpm on a crap keyboard.  People that can't type 60 on a crap keyboard, aren't generally going to to type 60 on a mechanical keyboard that they've never typed on before in their life.
I know average typing speed for people in general according to some studies is like 40-50.  Most employers accept 50-60.

The low bar for 911 dispatcher is apparently 40 wpm - random google search.  

Court reporting and live transcription are where fast typists are cared about and that's the 120-300 wpm crowd.


I think the speed boost from mechanical keyboards is a largely misinterpreted. To name a few examples from recent experiences, I can type almost as fast on a decent laptop keyboard, an Apple Aluminium keyboard, and even some Dell rubber domes as I can type on a top-notch mechanical keyboard. Given that I can type at about 80-100WPM, and even above that some times, I figure that relatively basic keyboards are good enough for about 99% of the population.

Of course, there are dire keyboards are that slow down my typing noticeably, but I think the main benefit comes from having a usable keyboard over a **** keyboard, rather than having an excellent one over a usable one.

Offline patrickgeekhack

  • Posts: 1460
What Good Keyboards are For
« Reply #6 on: Wed, 04 August 2010, 15:29:37 »
If anything, most companies are trying to cut cost. So, I don't see them investing into mechanical keyboards. Moreover, most would say that mechanical keyboards are too loud. Besides the Topre, most are indeed quite noisy, even the Filco with Cherry brown can get noisy if someone bottoms out heavily.
Cherry MX Blue: Cherry G80-3000, Das Keyboard Model S Ultimate
Cherry MX Brown: Filco Majestouch, Compaq MX11800
ALPS: AEK, AEK II, Northgate Omnikey Ultra, Matias Tactile Pro 4
Topre: Realforce 103UB
Buckling Spring: IBM Model M 1390120
Previous owned: Unicomp Customizer 104, IBM Model M 1390141, ABS M1

Offline wellington1869

  • Posts: 2885
What Good Keyboards are For
« Reply #7 on: Wed, 04 August 2010, 15:30:27 »
didnt we have an infamous thread once where, after some dozen pages, we couldnt find one single verifiable advantage of using mechanical keyboards?

maybe its simply an aesthetic rather than functional choice.

"Blah blah blah grade school blah blah blah IBM PS/2s blah blah blah I like Model Ms." -- Kishy

using: ms 7000/Das 3

Offline patrickgeekhack

  • Posts: 1460
What Good Keyboards are For
« Reply #8 on: Wed, 04 August 2010, 15:39:04 »
Quote from: kishy;209137
It is for me. I don't claim to prefer mechanicals for ergonomic reasons, I just happen to like them (particularly the noise and feel of buckling springs). I think that's the case for a lot of people but they need further justification than "I just happen to like them" to spend the money.


I like the feel. If the feel is too mushy, then it's not pleasant to me. When I'm stressed trying to complete an assignment, a mushy keyboard can increase my frustration. Before my mechanical keyboards, in such cases, I would prefer to type directly on my MacBook keyboard.
Cherry MX Blue: Cherry G80-3000, Das Keyboard Model S Ultimate
Cherry MX Brown: Filco Majestouch, Compaq MX11800
ALPS: AEK, AEK II, Northgate Omnikey Ultra, Matias Tactile Pro 4
Topre: Realforce 103UB
Buckling Spring: IBM Model M 1390120
Previous owned: Unicomp Customizer 104, IBM Model M 1390141, ABS M1

Offline wellington1869

  • Posts: 2885
What Good Keyboards are For
« Reply #9 on: Wed, 04 August 2010, 15:45:22 »
Quote from: kishy;209137
It is for me. I don't claim to prefer mechanicals for ergonomic reasons, I just happen to like them (particularly the noise and feel of buckling springs).

ya me too. Once i accepted that its merely aesthetic, I even went back to some domes i liked. :)

Quote

I think that's the case for a lot of people but they need further justification than "I just happen to like them" to spend the money.

ya that happens a lot.

"Blah blah blah grade school blah blah blah IBM PS/2s blah blah blah I like Model Ms." -- Kishy

using: ms 7000/Das 3

Offline quadibloc

  • Thread Starter
  • Posts: 770
  • Location: Edmonton, Alberta, Canada
  • Layout Fanatic
    • John Savard's Home Page
What Good Keyboards are For
« Reply #10 on: Wed, 04 August 2010, 15:48:56 »
I guess I was figuring that mechanicals had enough real benefit for quick typing that they were being bought by companies - but I just couldn't find the references, not looking in the right place.

But then, old-style Hall effect keyboards and the like had no tactile feel at all, whereas rubber dome keyboards may indeed have enough. Which is why it was a concern then, but not now.

Offline ch_123

  • * Exalted Elder
  • Posts: 5860
What Good Keyboards are For
« Reply #11 on: Wed, 04 August 2010, 15:56:22 »
Quote from: wellington1869;209133
didnt we have an infamous thread once where, after some dozen pages, we couldnt find one single verifiable advantage of using mechanical keyboards?

maybe its simply an aesthetic rather than functional choice.


Reliability.

If a keyboard is being used in a mission critical and/or extreme (as in temperature, humidity, continuous abuse) environment, you are going to see some sort of mechanical switch. Mainly linear, granted. But mechanical nonetheless.

And no, the fact that Keytronics have a lifetime warranty does not mean that they are as reliable as mechanicals. Spare us.

Offline wellington1869

  • Posts: 2885
What Good Keyboards are For
« Reply #12 on: Wed, 04 August 2010, 16:15:28 »
Quote from: ch_123;209154
Reliability.

If a keyboard is being used in a mission critical and/or extreme (as in temperature, humidity, continuous abuse) environment, you are going to see some sort of mechanical switch. Mainly linear, granted. But mechanical nonetheless.

And no, the fact that Keytronics have a lifetime warranty does not mean that they are as reliable as mechanicals. Spare us.


lol, yea, mechanicals are so reliable that half the posts on this forum are about how they're not working and how to fix them :)

"Blah blah blah grade school blah blah blah IBM PS/2s blah blah blah I like Model Ms." -- Kishy

using: ms 7000/Das 3

Offline ch_123

  • * Exalted Elder
  • Posts: 5860
What Good Keyboards are For
« Reply #13 on: Wed, 04 August 2010, 16:19:01 »
In fairness, that seems to be concentrated between Filcos, and keyboards that were made about 20 years ago. I don't think that's exactly a meaningful sample size, do you?

Furthermore, given that people don't really talk about the failing of their Logi****e or whatever, we don't really have a control group.

Offline wellington1869

  • Posts: 2885
What Good Keyboards are For
« Reply #14 on: Wed, 04 August 2010, 16:20:19 »
Quote from: ch_123;209167
In fairness, that seems to be concentrated between Filcos, and keyboards that were made about 20 years ago. I don't think that's exactly a meaningful sample size, do you?


you're right, filcos suck ;)

"Blah blah blah grade school blah blah blah IBM PS/2s blah blah blah I like Model Ms." -- Kishy

using: ms 7000/Das 3

Offline gr1m

  • Posts: 439
What Good Keyboards are For
« Reply #15 on: Wed, 04 August 2010, 16:50:39 »
Quote from: ch_123;209167
In fairness, that seems to be concentrated between Filcos, and keyboards that were made about 20 years ago. I don't think that's exactly a meaningful sample size, do you?

Furthermore, given that people don't really talk about the failing of their Logi****e or whatever, we don't really have a control group.


It's the nature of mechanical keyboards. 104 individual mechanical (read: made up of tiny parts that can stop working) switches might display more problems than a membrane keyboard simply because there's so much that can go wrong.

Offline quadibloc

  • Thread Starter
  • Posts: 770
  • Location: Edmonton, Alberta, Canada
  • Layout Fanatic
    • John Savard's Home Page
What Good Keyboards are For
« Reply #16 on: Thu, 05 August 2010, 08:03:26 »
Quote from: wellington1869;209165
lol, yea, mechanicals are so reliable that half the posts on this forum are about how they're not working and how to fix them :)
But that might be because you fix a rubber dome by throwing it away and buying a new one.

Offline instantkamera

  • Posts: 617
What Good Keyboards are For
« Reply #17 on: Thu, 05 August 2010, 08:54:03 »
Quote from: gr1m;209211
It's the nature of mechanical keyboards. 104 individual mechanical (read: made up of tiny parts that can stop working) switches might display more problems than a membrane keyboard simply because there's so much that can go wrong.


I think you have a point, where, with mechs, the likely-hood of one of the many working parts being DOA could be higher, but maybe not.

I think the large advantage comes when you have a 100% tested and working mech board, they will last longer than your standard rubber dome POS.
Realforce 86UB - Razer Blackwidow - Dell AT101W - IBM model MCST  LtracX - Kensington Orbit - Logitech Trackman wheel opticalAMD PhenomII x6 - 16GB RAM - SSD - RAIDDell U2211H - Spyder3 - Eye One Display 2

Offline microsoft windows

  • Blue Troll of Death
  • * Exalted Elder
  • Posts: 3621
  • President of geekhack.org
    • Get Internet Explorer 6
What Good Keyboards are For
« Reply #18 on: Thu, 05 August 2010, 08:58:10 »
A good rubber domer would probably be the best choice for something like that.
CLICK HERE!     OFFICIAL PRESIDENT OF GEEKHACK.ORG    MAKE AMERICA GREAT AGAIN MERRY CHRISTMAS

Offline ch_123

  • * Exalted Elder
  • Posts: 5860
What Good Keyboards are For
« Reply #19 on: Thu, 05 August 2010, 09:03:06 »
Quote from: gr1m;209211
It's the nature of mechanical keyboards. 104 individual mechanical (read: made up of tiny parts that can stop working) switches might display more problems than a membrane keyboard simply because there's so much that can go wrong.


Apparently the reason why Diatec didn't make Blue Cherry keyboards is that they are so prone to failure. They're not the most elegant design of switch around.

Offline microsoft windows

  • Blue Troll of Death
  • * Exalted Elder
  • Posts: 3621
  • President of geekhack.org
    • Get Internet Explorer 6
What Good Keyboards are For
« Reply #20 on: Thu, 05 August 2010, 09:07:01 »
You got to admit that the old IBM's are reliable.
CLICK HERE!     OFFICIAL PRESIDENT OF GEEKHACK.ORG    MAKE AMERICA GREAT AGAIN MERRY CHRISTMAS

Offline Phaedrus2129

  • Posts: 1131
What Good Keyboards are For
« Reply #21 on: Thu, 05 August 2010, 10:21:35 »
Until all the rivets fall out.
Daily Driver: Noppoo Choc Mini
Currently own: IBM Model M 1391401 1988,  XArmor U9 prototype
Previously owned: Ricercar SPOS, IBM M13 92G7461 1994, XArmor U9BL, XArmor U9W prototype, Cherry G80-8200LPDUS, Cherry G84-4100, Compaq MX-11800, Chicony KB-5181 (SMK Monterey), Reveal KB-7061, Cirque Wave Keyboard (ergonomic rubber domes), NMB RT101 (rubber dome), Dell AT101W

Offline ch_123

  • * Exalted Elder
  • Posts: 5860
What Good Keyboards are For
« Reply #22 on: Thu, 05 August 2010, 10:25:27 »
Model Fs don't have rivets.

Offline Phaedrus2129

  • Posts: 1131
What Good Keyboards are For
« Reply #23 on: Thu, 05 August 2010, 10:42:20 »
Yeah, but 90% of them are XT and don't work with anything but 1980s IBM workstations, and no one uses those but EIBM.
Daily Driver: Noppoo Choc Mini
Currently own: IBM Model M 1391401 1988,  XArmor U9 prototype
Previously owned: Ricercar SPOS, IBM M13 92G7461 1994, XArmor U9BL, XArmor U9W prototype, Cherry G80-8200LPDUS, Cherry G84-4100, Compaq MX-11800, Chicony KB-5181 (SMK Monterey), Reveal KB-7061, Cirque Wave Keyboard (ergonomic rubber domes), NMB RT101 (rubber dome), Dell AT101W

Offline ch_123

  • * Exalted Elder
  • Posts: 5860
What Good Keyboards are For
« Reply #24 on: Thu, 05 August 2010, 10:43:37 »
Actually, there's quite a good few people here who use Model Fs. Myself included.

Situational awareness is situational.

Offline Phaedrus2129

  • Posts: 1131
What Good Keyboards are For
« Reply #25 on: Thu, 05 August 2010, 10:46:44 »
I'd love to have a Model F, but every single one that I've found for sale was XT. Every single one, of the dozens I've looked at.

I get the feeling that most of the Model F ATs have already been found and are in use.
Daily Driver: Noppoo Choc Mini
Currently own: IBM Model M 1391401 1988,  XArmor U9 prototype
Previously owned: Ricercar SPOS, IBM M13 92G7461 1994, XArmor U9BL, XArmor U9W prototype, Cherry G80-8200LPDUS, Cherry G84-4100, Compaq MX-11800, Chicony KB-5181 (SMK Monterey), Reveal KB-7061, Cirque Wave Keyboard (ergonomic rubber domes), NMB RT101 (rubber dome), Dell AT101W

Offline didjamatic

  • Posts: 1352
What Good Keyboards are For
« Reply #26 on: Thu, 05 August 2010, 11:42:12 »
Unfortunately most have been trashed or recycled.  To the uneducated it's not worth saving so they get scrapped like most vintage keyboards.
IBM F :: IBM M :: Northgate :: Cherry G80 :: Realforce :: DAS 4

Offline JBert

  • Posts: 764
What Good Keyboards are For
« Reply #27 on: Sat, 07 August 2010, 18:29:01 »
ncbound regularly puts one up for sale on Ebay. Expect $80 though.
IBM Model F XT + Soarer's USB Converter || Cherry G80-3000/Clears

The storage list:
IBM Model F AT || Cherry G80-3000/Blues || Compaq MX11800 (Cherry brown, bizarre layout) || IBM KB-8923 (model M-style RD) || G81-3010 Hxx || BTC 5100C || G81-3000 Sxx || Atari keyboard (?)


Currently ignored by: nobody?

Disclaimer: we don\'t help you save money on [strike]keyboards[/strike] hardware, rather we make you feel less bad about your expense.
[/SIZE]

Offline ch_123

  • * Exalted Elder
  • Posts: 5860
What Good Keyboards are For
« Reply #28 on: Sat, 07 August 2010, 18:29:51 »
Not as common from him as they used to be... He used to have one every second month at $60. That's how I got mine.

Offline JBert

  • Posts: 764
What Good Keyboards are For
« Reply #29 on: Sat, 07 August 2010, 18:31:15 »
Well, you could still have some luck and look for wrongly-listed model F's...
Got mine at $50 by such a one-in-hundred chance.
IBM Model F XT + Soarer's USB Converter || Cherry G80-3000/Clears

The storage list:
IBM Model F AT || Cherry G80-3000/Blues || Compaq MX11800 (Cherry brown, bizarre layout) || IBM KB-8923 (model M-style RD) || G81-3010 Hxx || BTC 5100C || G81-3000 Sxx || Atari keyboard (?)


Currently ignored by: nobody?

Disclaimer: we don\'t help you save money on [strike]keyboards[/strike] hardware, rather we make you feel less bad about your expense.
[/SIZE]