Former Evo "fanatic" here. When I grew up, the Evo was my dream car but I recently got to drive the X and, to be honest, I felt a bit disappointed. Yes, it pulls quite well. (Granted, I've only driven/ridden sub-200 hp cars so the Evo's near 300 felt fast.) The SST transmission seems to read minds. And it handles well on the track. But, sitting inside, it doesn't feel engaging or inviting. Many have said that the interior is bad, and I have to agree. The steering wheel is a bit obnoxious with its huge center and thick cross-members. The center console is very plain with flat, shallow buttons that feel like they don't work when you press them. Crispy is the feeling. The spacious interior also adds to the heavy feeling of the Evo. Would I still want one? Yes, but only for the performance and probably not the X.
And on that note, I'd like to have a go in the STi. At least the interiors of Subarus are much better than the Evo's. I've always had the impression that Subarus are more outgoing whereas the Evos are more hardcore tryhard. In the end, a Subaru just might suit me better.