I got mine in early last week. It's pretty clean, but has been thoroughly used, as evidenced by the more frequently used keys taking on a nice sheen. This is my first (known) experience with black Alps, and while they feel better than rubber dome by a long shot, my overall impression is still kinda "meh." But for 12 + shipping it was a worthy experiment, and I now have another keyboard to add to the pile. Now I just need to locate a cheap white alps board so I can see what the fuss is about.