Welcome to Geekhack!
I have three Ducky Shine - all LEDs work perfectly.
I also have a CM Trigger which is broken (functionality wise), but all LEDs work there too.
I think you were just unlucky. It does happen occasionally, where you get one faulty keyboard, swap it over the the second keyboard has the same fault. During the last couple of days someone had a similar situation with MX blue switches not clicking on three successive keyboards.