This holds the following assumptions:
1. The item is going to stay in demand.
Trying to grasp a future price of something not in production is very hard (consider the variety/price of keyboards from IBM).
I would add something to do with demand. Demand cant be a constant here since once the people who gets a hold of the product the demand will decrease unless there are more people somehow introduced to the product that is not marketed/produced at the exact same rate... Demand can increase or decrease depending on competitors reaction/trend changes/new introductions/etc. Its been a while since I learned econ but hope that helps. Knowing what the product is might bring some more input from people knowledgeable about the industry.
Ah yes I should clarify. The main ones I'm considering are hobbyist items sold as limited editions. Audio technica comes out with limited edition headphones now and then. The products generally are unique from other offerings and can't be easily replicated. It should also be noted that regardless of the likeness to the regular versions, they still sell for a premium (but they also sell some that are completely unique to other offerings).
Trends changing is definitely a big factor.
The IBM keyboards weren't sold as limited edition hobbyist items so I wouldn't count those in this. I would however count something like the limited edition breast cancer awareness Unicomp keyboard that was sold.
Supply and demand would probably be the biggest factor.
If the item is truly limited in a hobbyist community that wants the product I would think that there will always be people who don't have it that want it.
The following assumption would then have to be stated: There were fewer released than demanded by the community purchasing the item.