CE Pack 1 sounds really good. I'd absolutely need both the keycap puller and the keychain switch, and the keycap duh. CE Pack 2 sounds absolutely amazing too. Not sure what the themed wrist rest would be like, but I'd be interested to see. Sleeve is a must, and an absolutely amazing idea, and I really need stickers. Stickers are just my favorite addition to buying any keycap (except maybe the other stuff that you listed, but stickers are more ordinary and I can collect them more like from other artisans too). And CE Pack 3, oh boy! Mini Comic book would be perfect, that would be so amazing, although probably really hard to produce, same with the figure, although that is sooo cool. I'd love a figure so much, as for the pin and badge, I'm not sure if I'd use them, but they would serve the same goal as the figure for me.
If I were to suggest a mixed bag CE pack in order of desire, this is what it would look like:
CE Pack #1337
Keycap
3" Figure
Themed Keyboard Sleeve
Mini-Comic Book
Themed Keychain Switch
(Keypuller if space)