Yeah, I also like the kb0316 better. Unfortunately, I got the UK version with small left shift-knob. I can't adapt using UK layouts. So, I just modded it onto the HP tkl.
At Leiden University (Holland) major library, I saw there were about 100's of kb0316 installed for use. And they get beaten for about 8-10 hours each day. They still work. But the tactility is gone, and just feels mushy..too bad. I think rubberdomes are just nice in the beginning.